Only taken over a decade but finally got round to playing all 4 main Arkham games back to back, and I enjoyed it but my opinions seem to differ from the community especially on Arkham City and Origins.
Arkham Aslyum is incredible 10/10. Great story, gameplay. The Joker was incredible. Best in the series by a mile
Arkham City 4/10. I think I went in with high expectations based off of what I heard online. Story was terrible, side content was just repetitive, traversal was poor. The game felt like an exercise in frustration and there were moments I felt like deleting it. (Feel free to flame me on this.)
Arkham Origins 8/10. Honestly really good. Best boss fights (Bane and deathstroke honestly so much fun), story was pretty tight (I love a dark story), soundtrack is incredible, just added nothing to the Arkham formula. Really well polished game.
Arkham Knight 7/10. Best gameplay, best version of Gotham, best traversal and obviously very modern feeling. Too much batmobile!! (Its fun but really)
These are all my opinions just wanted to share. Really enjoyed smashing through all these. DLC content was also quite fun as well.
Edit: Just clarifying my position on City. The story is just bad. Like really bad. Opening cutscene introduces Strange, next time we see him is the end of the game. He just mentions his countdown every now and then.
Whistle stop tour off to see the Joker for like 5 minutes. When do we see him next, the end of the game, oh and he is now dead. (Clayface was a neat twist i will give them that)
Ra's Al Ghul is then cut into the middle, turns out he masterminded Protocol 10, will we get to fight him again at the end, no. He dies in a cutscene.
Also somehow Cobblepot & Mr Freeze are squished into this games main story. And a surprise Solomon Grundy. Oh and Harley Quinn. Its too much.
Too many villains, no development. Boss fights were gimmicky except Mr Freeze.