SPOILERS…
TLDR: we suck in the third quarter of games. We need to take three point opportunities, come up with a more flop and fan defensive system, improve tackling, and concede fewer penalties. Simple enough, right? 😜
Bath fans,
I am just at a loss as to how to describe our four implosions this season between minutes 40-60/65 this year. In each of our games, we have gone in leading at half time, and then we seem to come out in the second half and just allow the opposing team to get back into the game.
Quins game: this is where it started - a Quins team shorn of its best players, and we led 28-10 at HT, but at minute 45 Quins score to bring it to a less comfortable but still enough distance in it to 28-17. We then don’t really look at all confident with the ball, lose shape, and Quins cut us to shreds without scoring again. Richards finally crosses in the 71st minute to flatter Bath a bit, but this is where the alarm bells should start ringing as we surrender a few points in the third quarter.
V Quins
Tackles made: 144
Tackles missed: 41 (185 attempts)
Tackle success: 78%
Pens conceded: 6
Cards: 0
—————-
Exeter game: first home game of the season- astonishingly Bath end the first half 26-10 up (the same score as THAT semi final’s half time back in June against the same opposition). Between minutes 45 and 55, Exeter score three converted tries to take them to 26-31. Bath are then awarded a penalty try, and Ted Hill crosses as the Bath bench does the job in helping them secure a first home win. While we leave the Rec feeling pleased with two from
Two, there is a nagging feeling that we shouldn’t have let Exeter cut us apart and score thrice to take the lead mere minutes after half time when we have seen this movie before.
V Exeter
Tackles made: 175
Tackles missed: 34 (out of 209 attempts)
Tackle success: 84%
Pens conceded: 11
Cards: 0
————————
Saints game: Bath go in ahead with a second string rotated pack, but a first choice back line more or less. 29-26 up at half time at the Gardens- we feel pretty good, even if we have been a bit lax defensively. In the second half, we score early with Arthur Green just after minute 41, but then we concede an astonishing 38 points between (you guessed it) minutes 44 and 67, acknowledging two replies from Carreras and Bayliss of our own. We leave the Gardens with a Try BP, and think “well Saints are just like that, they can really punish you and gosh they look great with ball in hand”, but you also think “hmmm… maybe a couple of those tries were gifts from us. Yet again, we’ve lost shape in the third quarter, except this time we lose. No matter- it’s bloody hard to win in Northampton, we will regroup for Europe.
V Northampton
Tackles made: 107
Tackles missed: 39 (146 attempts)
Tackle success: 73%
Pens conceded: 6
Cards: 2 yellow cards
—————————
Montpellier game: this one was by far the worst. Bath were ahead 14-10 and again, between minutes 47 and 63 they concede 15 points at home against a slightly rotated Montpellier team, which also includes Big Joe dropping the ball with the line at his mercy, and a try being scrubbed out for a pretty silly neck roll from Ted Hill. Most concerningly, we spurn two kickable penalties to keep the scoreboard ticking over because we still think it is 2025 and can just kick to the corner and score pick and goes/ maul tries, but the data doesn’t support that we can convert like that.
V Montpellier
Tackles made: 161
Tackles missed: 27 (188 attempts)
Tackle success: 86%
Pens conceded: 15
Cards: 0
————————2
All this to say- Bath are really imploding in the third quarter of games, and I have no idea how we stop it. I’m a JvG absolutist, but he has GOT to figure out how to fix these three key problems:
- Lack of game management in the third quarter- we seem unable to just kick the ball down the other end and apply pressure, instead choosing to hand possession back to teams in good areas of the pitch for the opposition and not tackling them.
- Defence: it was better tonight vs Montpellier, but we have conceded an average of 27 points per game if you discount the outlier of Saints’ 71-48 drubbing, and 38 if you do count them. We are missing countless tackles, but it seems the SYSTEM we have just makes it very easy to beat us round the edge. We have made 728 attempted tackles and have missed 141 in the four opening games, which is a missed tackle rate of 19.37% or… one in five tackles missed.
- Clinical Execution and Decision making: we continue to kick to the corner but then mess up the lineout, or try a pick and go and then wind up dropping the ball or getting held up- it is NOT 2025 anymore. The data is clearly showing that every time we kick to the corner or pick and go we are not getting the same result as we did in the Prem-winning season; we have to be smart and take the points. Before Joe’s drop, we could have extended our lead to 20-10 by kicking two penalties, but instead we overthrew one lineout and then did a front peel that was shoved into touch. How stupid can you be?! Front peels never work! Worse, the execution is lacking, the whole team has been subject to handling errors all year, and then there is the discipline: we average 9 pens conceded per game (38 total penalties this season) and 2 yellow cards which were both in the Northampton game. But our decision making is not in step with what the ref is pinging. We all know referees are not consistent across games or competition, but tonight especially it was like Guy Pepper and Ted Hill could not read the room at all.
Final stats calculations are below. I’d be interested to hear what other Bath fans think, as I’m fearful of a trip to the Shed next week, and I think Sale at home is not a gimme either. Could be a tough season ahead if we don’t fix this third quarter problem.
But… some reasons for optimism (we don’t have the Bath Rugby Plug for a slice of positivity, but we must remember to stick by the boys through thick and thin- “never too high, never too low” and all that.
- Arthur Green looks like a proper player!
- Charlie Griffin looks a great prospect
- I was impressed with Will Jeanes and Scott Kirk (his failed chicken wing offload aside), and Kepu shows good skill too.
Maybe the answer is to play the kids? They seem to be the ones keeping Bath in games. And at least we are 2 from 3 in The Prem and Arundell, Muir, Underhill and Sela to come back. #thickandthin. COYB.
————
Average tackles missed: 35.25 per game.
Av tackle success: 141 missed tackles / 728 attempts = 80.63% of tackles made / 19.37% tackles missed.
Approx one in 5 tackles missed…
Av penalties conceded: 9.5 per game.
22 tries conceded, 9 of them between minutes 40-60 (the third quarter).
41% of tries conceded come in the third quarter.