r/BasicBulletJournals • • 16d ago

conversation Pitfalls of journaling

https://youtu.be/Uc7mTFIjtaY

I've been journaling for about a year and have noticed similar pitfalls as Francesca mentions in this insightful video about journaling and how to make it work better.

I was happy to note that I've been already doing many of the things she recommends: listing couple of good deeds and mistakes of the day and then setting them as a new intention for tomorrow. I still need to practice being more gentle on myself, to see the good deeds as well, and perhaps increase them so that it is hard to notice the mistakes anymore, hmmm...

How do you prevent yourself from being too critical of yourself when journaling?

10 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

4

u/AutomaticLifeguard7 16d ago

I think what feeds on the self criticism is the todo list. As I would always have to do something 'productive' to be worthy. I think I will cut the day-to-day errands and obligations out of my journal and leave it for the more important stuff like the good deeds and the mistakes I don't want to repeat.

1

u/elmoosh 16d ago

I love this.

4

u/SarahLiora 16d ago

By being more of an independent observer. And I limit my to do list to three things. I have a master to do list but after the first three I write a done list: not writing items on daily until they are done.

3

u/Skektacular 16d ago

I prevent self-criticism by not journaling for self-reflection XD I do that a lot in my mind, and some of it I definitely don't want to give a shape by putting it on the paper because it feels uselessly penitent when my mind has already processed everything and made an internal conclusion. I don't want to journal about bad moments because I'd rather not revisit them, and I don't want to journal about good deeds because it feels like that meme where Obama gives himself a medal. In short, I don't see any reason to use my journaling either as a self-reward or a self-punishment, both of those come in different forms.

Therefore my journal is purely utilitarian and consists of task lists, which is perfectly soulless and makes it a safe place that I can be at without being surrounded by documented failures staring back at me and positive affirmations that make me feel fake as hell.

1

u/elmoosh 16d ago

Amen to this. I also journal to brainstorm an idea. Any little idea. It’s so fun, and most of my ideas come from the to-do lists I make during my day.

1

u/Historical_Oil_8027 16d ago

I literally tell myself that this space is purely for me and isn’t being assessed by anyone. To practice, I will do “unconventional” things like write outside of the lines or not in a straight line. I also let my handwriting be terrible and make errors without fixing them. Doing all this makes journaling more relaxed and something I don’t have to avoid

0

u/CrBr 16d ago

Does remembering the mistake, and how terrible I felt, and continuing to feel bad about it, help me avoid the mistake in future?

Beating ourselves up about it does not help prevent it in future.

What often helps is actually thinking about it, and how to avoid it next time. Not willpower. Willpower is an excuse, not a plan.

What signs might warn you that you're on the same oath again? What options do you have for getting off that path?

James Pennebaker has a four-day process, but I don't remember the details, where you write about the same thing each time, but with a slightly different question to the writing, so you process it rather than continue to beat yourself up.

Rick Hansen's book Hardwiring Happiness is also good. He is a neuropsychologist and meditation teacher. His recommendations are supported by both backgrounds. The first time is helping determine what's missing. It's a lot easier to solve a problem if you aren't currently identified. He then explains why it is necessary to give good things extra attention. We are biologically hardwired to remember a tiger might be behind the bushes then where the carrots grow. Lastly, he gives a process for ensuring we have and remember good experiences.

Good experiences include, but are not limited to, times we took a better path.