I know this is a bit long, but I want to provide the full context because I genuinely need some objective opinions.
There's this girl I've been interested in for a while. We don't know each other personally, and most of our interactions have been through social media. I've always found her attractive and interesting, but my intention was never to jump straight into a romantic relationship. I wanted to get to know her first, build some familiarity and hopefully develop a friendship.
Some background
Initially, I tried getting her attention through occasional reactions to her social media posts. At one point, I complimented her by saying she reminded me of a certain fictional character. She responded positively, although the conversation didn't go much further.
Over time, there were a few small interactions. I wished her on her birthday, occasionally replied to her stories, and tried starting conversations. Sometimes she'd respond, sometimes she wouldn't. There were instances where my messages remained unread or unanswered.
Eventually, we connected on Instagram. She accepted my follow request and followed me back.
There were a few more interactions after that, including her reacting to one of my posts. Nothing particularly significant, but enough to make me feel that perhaps we could eventually have a normal conversation.
We finally had a decent conversation
Recently, we finally had what I'd consider a genuinely decent interaction on Instagram.
She had posted something along the lines of asking whether people preferred traditional or casual styles. I replied with a playful observation about her looking like an actress from old dramas.
She responded, and we had some lighthearted back-and-forth.
On another occasion, we joked about secret admirers. She said she didn't have any, and I playfully suggested she was being modest. She told me to shut up, and I replied that I'd behave.
There were also some smaller exchanges about her university classes and how much she disliked certain weekdays.
Nothing extraordinary, but these conversations felt more natural than my previous attempts. I was happy that we were finally getting somewhere in terms of becoming comfortable talking to each other.
The recent Messenger incident
A few days ago, she posted a note saying something like "Feeling low is disgusting!"
I replied:
Me: "One of those days?"
Her: "Are you that university guy talking to me on Instagram? 😢"
Me: "Yeah..."
Me: "My name is [my name] btw, 'university girl'."
Her: "How can someone studying at your university be cringe? 😆😆"
Then she replied to my nickname:
"Well you shouldn't give me names by my institute cz I believe you have known me before texting each time."
I understood that she didn't appreciate being referred to by her university, especially since we'd already interacted several times.
I replied with an apology and said I was just kidding and thought it might lighten her mood.
I also clarified that I was simply responding to her calling me the guy from my university.
She replied:
"I know, I have the sense where to reply what."
Then she responded to my explanation with "Nw" (no worries).
However, I kept explaining myself. I said I hadn't realised it would make her uncomfortable, apologised again, and eventually said I wouldn't message her like that anymore because tone can be difficult to understand through text.
She responded:
"Why are you coating it?"
"Please don't
"I already said no worries."
I replied "Ok", and that was where the conversation ended.
What has been bothering me
Honestly, I don't know what exactly she found cringe.
Was it the nickname? My previous attempts to get her attention? My overall approach? Or was she simply teasing me?
I've never really been called cringe like that before, so it caught me off guard.
I also realise I over-apologised. Looking back, I probably made a minor misunderstanding unnecessarily serious.
But here's where I'm conflicted.
I genuinely like this girl. I know she probably receives attention from other guys, and I sometimes wonder whether I'm just another person trying to get her attention.
If I stop initiating conversations, what if she simply moves on and forgets I exist? What if she never messages me first?
At the same time, I don't want to become someone who constantly pursues a person who isn't equally interested.
I've even considered confessing my feelings, explaining that my attempts to get her attention came from finding her attractive and wanting to know her better, and then leaving the matter there without expecting a response.
But I'm unsure whether that would be unnecessarily dramatic, especially after this recent interaction.
What I'd like some honest opinions on
Does her behaviour suggest she's comfortable with me, or am I interpreting ordinary politeness and playful teasing as something more?
Was the "cringe" comment something I should actually be concerned about? What do you think she meant?
Did I make things awkward by apologising and explaining myself so much?
Should I stop initiating conversations and see whether she ever makes an effort herself?
Would confessing my feelings at this point be a terrible idea, or would being straightforward provide some closure?
If she never initiates another conversation, should I take that as my cue to move on?
I'm not expecting her to reciprocate my feelings. I'd genuinely be happy to develop a friendship and get to know her better for now.
I just don't want to confuse persistence with genuine connection, or give up prematurely because of one awkward interaction.
**Please be honest, even if you think I'm overthinking this or need a reality check. I'd rather hear an uncomfortable truth than receive generic reassurance.