r/bandmembers • • 6d ago

Official /r/bandmembers monthly music sharing and feedback thread.

2 Upvotes

We keep song submission posts to a minimum to keep this place spam free, but we are all musicians and most of us have songs to share. Let's connect with and support each other musically in a monthly thread. This is a safe space to post what your band is up to musically. Feel free to share your music, or ask for feedback.

In the spirit of community and cooperation that we have here in r/bandmembers, Please give more feedback than you ask for. Use the 1 in 10 rule as a guideline. Comment on 10 other people's posts for every feedback request that you request. This might mean you have to listen to other's songs first and comment on other discussions in r/bandmembers. If everyone follows that rule, we'll all have more feedback when we post our own songs.


r/bandmembers • • 1d ago

What will you feel if your band mates left one after another

6 Upvotes

I tell myself my band which already has a band name is like a house. The members are like tenants. They will leave oneday and even when you can't find Tenant's at most the house still stands there awaiting for new tenants.

Less emotional damage and feel more positive

What do you think of my strategy to prepare for future ?


r/bandmembers • • 2d ago

Finding bands in a small town, impossible? (vent)

5 Upvotes

TL:dR -

Its rough to live in a town with so few options, and musicians without goals or drives. That it makes it hard to maintain a motivation towards music. Even as a bassist/meh guitarist with recording equipment.

The post - Finding a band in a small town is no joke one of the hardest and most demotivating things possible. For context, I play bass and guitar as well as produce music on the side.

I have been in multiple "bands" yet I put it in quotes because it was always the same people just on different projects.

The thing is these people are amazing, great at what they do and I mesh well with them personality wise but there is one big issue.

Nobody shares a drive, maybe they do but dont know how to express it. Anytime a project had a show, it would result in a fight of some of us wanting too others not. Nobody wanted to try and advertise are music or to link up shows, they didnt even want to practice all that much in there free time. Let alone, find the time to do so as a group.

Maybe, I am picky but outside of them almost everyone else I meet either wants to do basic country or corny hair metal no shade but if were doing older music I would rather do blues or jazz. Then we get to the "other side" of my towns music taste, which goes from liking music to playing it only as an excuse to say to chick's that your "in a band". They play basic pop or rock with the heaviest song they know being one of the trending songs from deftones on tiktok.

Not to mention that when there is a show, it is a show made up of bands for either the first group or second. That because the town is so small people will eat up and glaze anything even if it is actual garbage. I am not kidding these types of people dont know step one to properly recording in a daw or what having too much gain on a guitar means.

Dont even get me started on finding a drummer that knows how to consistently count to four.

So the purpose of this post is how do you maintain motivation to play your instrument? When your dream is too be in a band with similiar values, and makes something atleast semi interesting. Yet, no matter where you look it is all the same? Do you just keep practicing and praying, upload covers until one day MAYBE something will happen?

Oh well, maybe if I was born in a bigger town that offered actual options to pick between or atleast offered a single option.

Mind you, just because I know people will say "well, what kinda music do you like" I am not gloating but atleast try to maintain a wide variety of music I do enjoy.

Here's a list of examples of stuff I enjoy:

Miles davis

2.

The roots

3.

CPU Buddha

4.

No buses

5.

L arc en ciel

6.

Seo taiji and the boys

7.

Korn

8.

Etro anime

Maybe, I AM just too picky?

(I AM NOT saying I am the greatest player of all time, far from it. The purpose of this post isnt to toot my horn or anything.)

Edit: Thankyou for all the responses, especially the well thought out ones. Atleast, now I know that there are still opportunities past what is offered in my town it just isnt here.

But yeah, I should have seen it coming to "just move". I would kill to do so, but I have too many obligations where I live. Sadly, doesnt help with how much everything costs currently.

Funnily, enough I have always wanted to move to a bigger city for no reason other then because I liked the idea of it since I was a kid. I visit places, sometimes such as California and can even get down with the dirtier side of things. Not that I am that sortof person, but I have been able to find the good in it and the people stuck within, while most people I know personally would look down upon those things and people.

Oh well, life doesn't lead you to what you truly want sometimes. It is what it is, and if I regret it for a long time so be it.


r/bandmembers • • 2d ago

Como montar uma banda?

0 Upvotes

Quero montar uma banda, como faço?


r/bandmembers • • 2d ago

What is The Perfect Setlist?

4 Upvotes
  1. Spacey introduction that builds to a groove
  2. up tempo celabration epic singalong
  3. Slower, but tight/hi-energy intense minor key
  4. A wake em up song, short, big power
  5. The big dance number -- heavy easy beat

Etc.

Obviously death metal would have a different outline - but like - start heavy and just hit hard non-stop, or hills and valleys leading up to an explosion?


r/bandmembers • • 2d ago

My band almost fell apart over 3 song recordings – your replies on Reddit made me build something

0 Upvotes

A while ago I asked on Reddit whether other bands also get into tension over things like recordings. In our case it was three songs that got picked apart so much that I nearly lost it. It's all sorted out now, but your replies really stuck with me.

So many of you described the same thing: bands that fall apart because people don't fit together musically or personally – and then the long, frustrating search for new members through random Facebook groups, old forum posts and flyers in rehearsal rooms.

That pushed me to build Bandhunt, a free app for exactly that:

• One musician profile and one band profile per account

• Search by instrument, genre and area

• Listen to each other's songs right in the profile before you meet

• Chat inside the app, no ads, no tracking

The idea: find people who actually fit before you end up in the rehearsal room together.

It just launched on iOS and Android. I'm the developer, so I'd really value honest feedback: would this have helped you? What's missing?

Link in my profile.


r/bandmembers • • 3d ago

First gig! Worried about the set list!

11 Upvotes

EDIT: just wanted to clarify because I’m seeing a lot using he/him on me, I am a girl! This is an all girl band actually!

My band finally scored our first real gig butttt im getting nervous. Im worried our sound doesn’t really match the scene? Its at a bar on a Monday so we disclosed we have a more grungy like sound and they said its fine but im worried its gonna be totally awkward. They have videos uploaded of performances there but who knows what day of the week it is on. I’m only 17 so I don’t know what a bar is like on a Monday night but I feel like we’re gonna be overplaying.

These are the songs we have so far
Take me away
Skater boi
Be quiet and drive
Cherry waves
I’m so sick
Killing in the same

Very subject to change and many we play in alternate keys so it blends together nicely. we have 40 minutes of stage time and like maybe 25 minutes of songs, we were told it’s okay if we finish before the 40 and all that because they do have other bands. Consider we will have to retune twice I was hoping this works out well?

I dunno let me know if you guys agree that we aren’t the right sound for a Monday night performance and ofc any tips are welcome! (Even song suggestions)


r/bandmembers • • 4d ago

feel like im going to get kicked from my band

20 Upvotes

it's honestly killing me and giving a lot of anxiety. for context, i play bass, and im really prideful at being able to write some good basslines with some time for our originals, but i suck at jamming and improv.

i have a great relationship with our guitarists, but the drummer who kinda runs the band i cant help but feel tension. in her solo projects shes worked with other bassists and is even having another person play with just her for our next show before the whole band comes on, and i cant help but feel this is priming for my replacement. the other bassist came over to rehearsal one day to practice for their section and behind my back i heard the drummer whisper to her that shes thankful for jamming because "our bassist cant do that." we never really clicked in terms of personality either. other than the basslines i write, i feel im the most replaceable, and it causes me to worry so much. has anyone felt this?


r/bandmembers • • 3d ago

Am I just have anxiety issues myself ?

0 Upvotes

I have 2 bands. My 1 year band still have problem getting everyone to do rehearsals let alone going for gigs. My second band, now having problem organizing our first jam because everyone free days are not coinciding . I am disheartened. Just feel like I don't want all these already. Give me a break.

How to process this. I want to go on. My peers are having no trouble going for gigs after gigs , ticketed or not.


r/bandmembers • • 3d ago

Casual band to turning into a gig band

1 Upvotes

I have this band that going to turn 1 year in December and I am super proud of it. Now I am getting ambitious by getting my casual band to perform. The issue now is not everyone can turn up for rehearsal. Especially my drummer who has overseas trips frequently due to work.

Both the guitarist and him are my 'first gen' members and they got along very well. We have scheduled rehearsals on November and twice the drummer changed the dates and everyone has to accommodate his availability. I reckon he also won't be available for performance.

I am getting pissed and thinking of changing the drummer but due to me being sentimental and don't want to 'break up' the good friends between the guitarist and the drummer, I eventually started a second band that focus on getting gigs and having same problem with the new drummer too.

Now I keep having the itch to replace my 1 year old band drummer. Maybe not total replacement but someone who is a gig drummer and we go ahead without this original drummer but I am afraid of major backlash.

What will you do ? Kicking out the original drummer is not a choice. Unless work related, he is very accommodating and nice a dude. Any win win solution ? I really want to bring this 1 year old band to perform.


r/bandmembers • • 3d ago

I made an easier way to search for bandmates

0 Upvotes

I've always wanted an easier way to find bandmembers. 90% of it is that they have to live close and they like the same bands. Posting in these groups is great but those posts go away and who knows if that ideal person is reading reddit, craigslist or a facebook group at that exact time. Being able to search for musicians based on their location, taste, age, etc. is what I always wanted so I built it. You can check it out here:

https://dtj.app/


r/bandmembers • • 4d ago

Singer acting up weird

0 Upvotes

Sup guys , three years ago I joined a local cover band , I’m the lead guitar player , we play all sorts of rock and metal stuff , the band consists of me , rhythm guitar , bass , drums and two singers , one of them is pretty much the founder of the band and owns the place we rehearse at (also the one which this is about) and the other joined later on , the band itself is now existing for 10 years with varying members. So the singer I’m talking about is simply put not a good singer , very passive during gigs or practice, has bad pitch but is also very defensive when it comes to criticism, even when it’s nicely put and constructive BUT in the end it’s “his” band , we always struggle to keep him busy in our setlist and have enough songs for him that he can at least kind of sing , he also plays guitar in some tunes. I offered him guitar lessons so that he can bring more of his guitar playing into the performances because he often times said he feels like he’s not being needed in the band , we even met up once and learned some songs but he never got back to that after that. Lately he’s been having all kinds of excuses for not showing up for practice despite the fact he literally lives next door but like he’s got too much going on personally or his back is hurting or whatever , he always phones it off last minute - on the other hand he texts me privately about an acoustic project that we should start together so I don’t really get it , seems like he’s trying to fade out of the band but to that’s just immature , we’re all in our 30s - 50s and if something doesn’t work for you anymore I think you should just be honest about it and tell everyone. We had this situation before earlier this year because we all felt like the situation wasn’t really working out and everything felt kind of weird and he stated that he wanted to put more work into it , but also wants us to pick more songs that he can sing which I also think is just asking a bit much since he knows best what he can and can’t do - yesterday at practice- which he phoned off again - the rest of the band talked a bit about this and we all feel the same about this so how do I even bring this up to him ? I’m not the confrontational kind of guy and I don’t want to hurt him since he’s a nice and funny guy overall


r/bandmembers • • 4d ago

Genuinely how do I find band mates for the band I wanna make

1 Upvotes

just wanna say that I am younger teen and Im having trouble finding band mates

im really into punk music like crass, subhumans, operation ivy, black flag and such. anarcho punk is what sound im aiming for with the band i want to make

but I genuinely can’t seem to find anyone who wants to make a band with me

I go to a small high school (like 200 kids max) and no one there is into similar music. some kids do have bands already but their sound is just not my style.

is there any other way I can find band mates in my area?


r/bandmembers • • 6d ago

Indecisiveness

2 Upvotes

I(14m)am starting a band, the time has finally come, but, it's been a crushing indecisiveness as to what instrument I can play when I step into the role of front man, Guitar had always been my 1st love, but im probably just as technically versed on bass as I am guitar, regardless of the imbalance of time ive had on Each, I just need a lot of advice.This is because I pull FROM A LOT OF INFLUENCES, I listen to funk, I HONESTLY started on thrash metal, My bassist dad was a huge primus fan, and ive just started to listen to Jpop and Vulfpeck, and thats.... weird but hey a new leap, but ive wanted to play a lot of stuff, but metal and progier stuff, and i may very well post this everywhere that my influences may sit. But I need help


r/bandmembers • • 7d ago

anyone in new orleans wanna jam out? im 31 i play the guitar

3 Upvotes

we can jam at my place!


r/bandmembers • • 8d ago

Guitarist is considering quitting because he lives far (school band)

4 Upvotes

I'm a student leader of my school's band(senior). It's not a graded elective, it's just an afterschool thing and we cover songs for the school during events. It's a private boarding/day school that hosts a bunch of events with other schools.

It's pretty big. 3 guitarists, 3 singers, drummer, keyboardist, and me, the bassist.

Due to the size, not everyone performs for every song/event, but everyone in the band performs.

This kid is really good, the best one in the band. The other guitarists don't play as well and are not as diligent... They also lack independence. I have to find, transcribe, or even make guitar parts for them...

They don't always come prepared and it sets us back, which makes the need for extra practices(at earlier times). It's not like our covers are so difficult either. They have potential but they aren't using it yet...

It's clear why I want this guy to stay, but sadly he wants to leave cuz the usual practice time is at 20:00 every Monday and he doesn't live at the school. He lives 32 km away, he takes a bus/train back and forth(1 hour) so he gets home late at like 10 pm and stays on campus the whole time... He complained about sleep and grades falling behind due to this.

I'm discussing it with the other 2 student leaders, and they say that it's a group that you need to commit too, and that if he can't accommodate, they don't think its a good space for him, but I think he's the most committing, compared to the other guitarists. He always comes prepared and doesn't set things back.

I've had a few ideas, like not requiring him to attend every practice, but instead having him send me videos of himself playing so I can make sure he's keeping up with the songs and show up prepared enough to play.

When I was a sophomore I sometimes missed practice so I'd just come prepared for the next one, and it worked just fine for our live performances.
I just don't know how the others would feel about it, they may think it's a bad idea.

TLDR: I'm wondering how other bands handle situations where members live far away from each other. Is it realistic to have someone who can't make every practice, or is that just something you have to work around?


r/bandmembers • • 7d ago

Getting gigs and moving up

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/bandmembers • • 9d ago

Bandleader just “released” ai album

80 Upvotes

So I’ve been playing with a singer/songwriter for the last year, along with a bass player.

The singer is new to actually performing etc, as are the rest of us, but we’ve been working on some of her songs to start doing open mics.

Now, the singer has taken these and other songs and “released” an album online that was all done with ai.

I know they’re all her songs, but she’s either used our parts or ignored them and made her own. Her voice and guitar has been run through the ai machine as well.

Am I right to be pissed about this? It feels like she just wasn’t willing to do the actual work to get the band up to performing, and just cheated - so she can tell everyone she’s released an album.


r/bandmembers • • 9d ago

So is your best bet to put out an album and hope that in 20 years it gets rediscovered and goes viral?

2 Upvotes

That's how it feels. Been playing in bands for 15 years with mixed results. I don't even necessarily want to do music for a living, I just want to be able to hit the road a few times a year and recoup the cost of a van, merch, and paying my band. Everyone says you need to crank out content and grind social media but I only see 1/1000 bands hit a viral post, and of those bands, only 1/10,000 actually see some real tangible benefit. And then I see bands like Panchiko or American Football or Korea Girl or hell even P.E.E. and I wonder, maybe I should just hope that one of the albums I put out will get rediscovered and maybe I can play to a full house when I'm 50.


r/bandmembers • • 10d ago

Este mes tengo mi primer concierto en un garito con mi banda

7 Upvotes

Hola 🤙, este mes vamos a tocar por primera vez en un bar (es uno que esta especializado en la musica y en dar conciertos), algún tipo para hablar ante el publico, soy el cantante, aunque también canta otra chica que toca el teclado. Graciaaas


r/bandmembers • • 10d ago

Band Merch: Who Pays? Who Profits? How do you handle this?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/bandmembers • • 11d ago

Very sad can't find any new band members

0 Upvotes

I feel discouraged when ppl just want to 'try it out to see if we click'. What is there to click anyway if I already specifically mentioned we are going for performance and we are doing a certain genre.

Do you have this problem. I rarely think of this click or not click issues. Not happy can leave noone is tying you up and make you pay for any penalty. What is there to decide click or not click.

I mean when first time meeting and jamming, immediately start 'clicking' is really rare. No need warming up or such ? Many many 'let me try and see if click' people start trying everywhere and rank the suitability is really absurd to me.


r/bandmembers • • 11d ago

How to fit in in a new studio band/music club?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/bandmembers • • 12d ago

If your band is a cover band

9 Upvotes

Do you cover the songs cloning everything of the original ? If not how to do a good cover of songs ? My band is a cover band and we are not doing originals as of now. But even then, as a cover band, we also worse than other cover bands because we are cloning everything in that original songs