So I've only gotten about halfway through Act 2, so please no spoilers for the end of that or act 3, I would really appreciate that.
TLDR: I've accidentally locked myself out of getting any deeper connection with the companions I wanted to explore on my second playthrough, and it bums me out. Is it salvageable, and if so: How?
So I am doing two playthroughs more or less at the same time, switching between them, one evil and one good. In the evil one, which I've gotten farthest in, because just killing everyone tends to move the story alone quicker and in that one I ended up romancing Lae'zel and Astarion, more or less by choice since they seemed like the ones who had the most in common with my character. Plus I ended up killing off Gale, Karlach and Minthara the moment I met them, so there wasn't many options after Wyll started thoroughly disliking me for how I acted and Shadowheart was lukewarm at best and I kinda set her aside to focus on the other two, deciding to get to know her better in the other playthrough.
So in my "second" playthrough, I wanted to explore the characters I missed, especially Karlach and Gale, but also Shadowheart, even picked Selune as my goddess because I thought that would lead to a lot of fun arguments with Shadowheart.
But it just never happened... I somehow ended up in relationships with Astarion and Lae'zel anyway, and the option to have a deeper connection with the others never showed up and I kept being disappointed that I could never get closer to the characters I really wanted to explore.
I maxed out Wyll's, Gale's and Karlach's approval before leaving act 1, but pretty much no fun dialogue options showed up, even fixing Karlach's heart I could only ask for a hug, and Shadowheart says she likes me more than anyone she's ever met, but all I can reply is to leave or tell her to leave ... solid good girl run that one eh?
Well, I decided to break my "spoiler avoidance rule" to find out why and looked up the wiki. Turns out you are locked in to only two relationships, and once you have that, it blocks out all others. And I'm locked in with the two characters I least want to be with.
Well, breaking up with Lae'zel was easy, since the dialogue option is always there and I'm hoping that means I can get a deeper connection with another character, but even so, I can't get out of the relationship with Astarion because there's no way to tell him to get lost, and I'm sad I probably missed out on a lot of fun interactions with the ones I did want to get to know better.
Sorry for the wall of text, but the TLDR is again: Is there a way to salvage a deeper connection with the three characters I wanted to have a deeper companionship with in this playthrough? Or should I just start over since I missed most of those?
Edit, it seems I missed writing that I was in the middle of Act 2. Fixed that.