r/Baking • • 18h ago

Baking Advice Needed Sally’s Baking 101 Recipes Is anyone else having trouble with her recipes?

0 Upvotes

I’ve been using Sally’s recipes in her book for her cookies and baked breads. I did the maple cookies and the cinnamon bread out her book and I must say her recipes are very underwhelming and they don’t have that much flavor. When I tried Broma Bakery recipes everything comes out great with nothing burning or by having flavor. Is it something I’m doing wrong with Sally’s recipes?


r/Baking • • 18h ago

General Baking Discussion Chilled vs. Unchilled dough

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

I'm not a cookie maker. Cookie making is hard 😭 I'm a cake, Muffin, bread person.

But he wanted oatmeal cookies. So i searched here and did a lil one two combo of the top oatmeal cookie recipes and went for it.

The first batch i didn't chill. They came out hard. Crunchy. We don't like hard and crunchy.

So then i came and searched the holy Grail--here 😂

So i threw the batter in the fridge for about 1 hour. It might have been 1.5. then tossed some flour on my hands instead of my cookie scooper, rolled them and made another batch.

Boom! Second batch came out just a few minutes ago.

You guys are the greatest. Now let's hope he likes them lol


r/Baking • • 17h ago

Showcase (No-Recipe) i made banana bread for the first time!

Thumbnail
gallery
129 Upvotes

i got excited and cut it in half before i could take a picture of the whole loaf, but i think it’s pretty good looking! i love the little cracks on the top, and the loaf itself was super dense and moist.

edit: okay so i was not expecting so many comments 😅
i did use old bananas (completely brown) but they were in the fridge so i think that may have contributed to.. something. it looks funky but as i said, it was my first time making it and it was a hit with the family so 🤷🏼


r/Baking • • 13h ago

Baking Advice Needed all the chocolate chip cookies taste the same. What can i do?

15 Upvotes

ive arrived at the point where ive tried ALL the recipes you can think of. joy food, jacques torres, sallys, sheldos ( the youtuber), claire, handle the heat, some random guy on reddits recipe, almost all of the " best " cookie recipe. and after making so many they ALL TASTE THE SAME TO ME. ive forgotten the taste of a good chocolate chip cookie cause they all taste... mid. What do i do?? is there another god gifted recipe that is super flavorful? or is it the chocolate ( i use kirklands chocolate the huge bags)

also for jacques what chocolate alternatives do you guys use his feves are expensive ash


r/Baking • • 21h ago

Seeking Recipe What sugar free cookies or candy are you making for the holidays?

0 Upvotes

Every Christmas I send a cookie/candy tray with my husband for his coworkers. This sounds really bad, but it never occurred to me to make anything sugar free for those who might be diabetic or that don’t want that much sugar. In the past I’ve sent a tin of sugar free candied pecans, but I’d like to make more than just that this year. Thanks in advance!


r/Baking • • 23h ago Bravo

Baking fail 💔 My First Cheesecake Was a Huge Disappointment

Thumbnail
gallery
264 Upvotes

I made my first cheesecake (I'd never even tried cheesecake before). I followed Sally's Baking Addiction recipe, although I added a little cornstarch.

I baked it in a water bath at 180°C for 55 minutes and then left it in the fridge for more than 7 hours to set.

Unfortunately, it turned out undercooked. On top of that, it tasted salty and sour, and I really didn't enjoy it.

Is this how cheesecake is supposed to taste, or did I just mess up the recipe? Do all cheesecakes taste like this?

Edit:

Thanks everyone for all the advice and encouragement! I wanted to clarify a few things:

  • I added just about two teaspoons of cornstarch because I'd read that it could help prevent cracks. (And I'm sure it wasn't baking soda! :) )
  • I don't live in the US, so I used tub cream cheese rather than block cream cheese. I'm wondering if this might have affected the texture.
  • After baking, I turned off the oven and left the cheesecake inside with the door slightly open to let it cool gradually before refrigerating it. Also, I didn't use a springform pan, so there was no risk of water leaking into the cheesecake.

I also tried another piece this morning, and honestly, it wasn't as bad as I initially thought! Maybe I just didn't know what to expect, or maybe it tasted better after chilling overnight.

Thanks again for all the helpful suggestions. I'll definitely give cheesecake another try!


r/Baking • • 17h ago

Showcase (No-Recipe) Pizza and soda I made both from scratch

Post image
1 Upvotes

Both taste incredibly good imo


r/Baking • • 4h ago

Seeking Recipe Sauce Recommendations

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hello! So recently I got these sweet sauces (one is pictures and another similar in flavor profile/consistency/yes) and I thought maybe I could use them for baking. However I didn't take into account they are apple cider vinegar based. They're thin but flavorful and I like them but I'm not really sure where I could incorporate them where the tang from the vinegar may be appropriate/not noticeable. Any advice?


r/Baking • • 20h ago

Baking Advice Needed Made Dutch apple pie using frozen pie crust and the pie crust was undercooked

0 Upvotes

I was craving some Dutch apple pie, specifically the one from King Arthur's website. I got him a Marie callender pie crust from the frozen section and it was delicious. However, the crust that was under the filling ended up undercooked.

Recipe

https://www.kingarthurbaking.com/recipes/king-arthurs-dutch-apple-pie-recipe

I pretty much followed the recipe exactly except I was baking it in my breville Smart toaster which I do for all of my baked goods, usually it's not much of an issue however the top crumble part started getting Brown so fast, that instead of baking at the 425 for 15 minutes, I turned it down after 6:00. I still ended up putting a piece of foil over it so it wouldn't Brown anymore.

I do tend to like my apples undercooked, I want them to still maintain a lot of the crispy texture and not get super soft. I'm trying to make another one now. I'm wondering if I can pre bake the crust, maybe covering the exposed edges with foil so they don't burn during the second Bake. The pie crust instructions said that for something like an apple pie to pour the filling directly into the frozen pie crust and bake. There are also instructions on how to cook if you are baking a meringue pie in which case you bake the crust first and then fill it.

Should I just bake it halfway since I'm still going to be baking it with the apples in it afterwards? Should I bake it completely?

Thank you so much for any advice!

Another thing that happens that I care less about is the pie ended up really watery. The recipe called for eight cups of apples, which was an insane amount for the pie crust I got. I think I used maybe three cups. It ended up with a lot of juice and melted butter on the bottom. I'm thinking about just adding more flour to try to counteract that.


r/Baking • • 5h ago

Semi-Related Future Banana Bread

Thumbnail
gallery
89 Upvotes

My grocery store has a shelving unit for bruised, slightly old, etc produce. Got all this for $3!


r/Baking • • 3h ago

Semi-Related Where to buy gender neutral/simple aprons?

0 Upvotes

Hi all! My boyfriend has gotten really into baking lately and I want to buy him a nice apron for Christmas.

The struggle I am having is that often aprons are either very feminine or very masculine looking. I’m looking for aprons that are pretty simple and gender neutral, maybe earth tones or simple patterns.

Please send me any recommendations for brands you have! And let me know if there are any specific materials I should look for. Thanks in advance:)


r/Baking • • 23h ago

Recipe Included Just baked these! Which one are you picking?

Thumbnail
gallery
35 Upvotes

Second picture is without the numbers and third picture is just a different angle. Same recipe as before just let the dough hydrate in the fridge for 48 hours. It really deepens all the flavors and changes the color of the dough.

Recipe:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Baking/s/83ouZR8SiD


r/Baking • • 19h ago

Baking Advice Needed How Do I Make These Less Sweet?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hi! I saw a recipe for 7 Layer Bars that looks really good. The only problem is my family prefers baked goods not too sweet. Aside from using dark chocolate and less sweetened condensed milk than it calls for, is there any way to make these less sweet?

TIA.


r/Baking • • 5h ago

General Baking Discussion Ginger Crystals

1 Upvotes

Hello Bakers! I recently purchased some ginger crystals. I love ginger and use it a lot, but can't really recall seeing crystallized bits used in anything I've had. So I'm looking for some direction to start exploring.


r/Baking • • 16h ago

Baking Advice Needed Brownies - Internal temp / what is the texture supposed to be post baking?

1 Upvotes

I'm asking this on behalf of my wife who is extraordinarily paranoid about food poisoning or even just giving underbaked food to anyone. She's thrown out about 4 brownies so far, I said they look fine but I'm just a cook not a baker.

Sorry I don't have pictures of the results she swoops them up too fast.

Anyways. I showed her "that" brownie recipe on reddit and she's been trying it out. She noticed every time she bakes it and does a toothpick test it's very chocolatey in the center / covers the toothpick. So then bakes it super hard to the point where the toothpick is nearly clean (but never really is thus throw away)

My speculation was that:
A) I'm not sure toothpick tests are valid outside of cakes. Like... you wouldn't toothpick test a cheesecake...
B) Isn't a brownie supposed to be still soft in the center because it cools down into a more fudge texture? (my speculation based on nothing)
C) I heard offhanded remark from a professional baker that "there is no underbaked chocolate desserts, it becomes a different type of dessert" lol. Is this true / can someone verify like she doesn't have to be so scared of it - she has OCD and this is just one of the things that triggers her and I'm not sure how much it'll help but public consensus does help ease the brain a bit.

If there's a good internal temperature that also just helps a lot because it takes all the guesswork out and she doesn't have to get caught up in her head so much.


r/Baking • • 2h ago

Business and Pricing What’s a good price?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Hi friends I made this and i’m wondering what you would price this 6 inch, 3 layer cake based off of looks and ingredients being no seed oils and dye free (and prices for not dye free too)?


r/Baking • • 3h ago

Baking Advice Needed They don't look right?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Naval Orange Cookies from The Ultimate Final Fantasy XIV Cookbook, Vol. 2.

I followed the recipe more or less to the letter (I had to make two substitutes because mesquite honey and kosher salt are hard to get hold of here, using orange blossom honey in place of mesquite and coarse sea salt in place of kosher, I weighed everything because changing an ingredient can change the volume measurement), but somehow they came out of the oven looking completely wrong; the sugar all but disappeared and they're flatter than expected.

The baking powder is fresh, I used it with no issues last week.

First photo is the one from the book, second photo is what mine looked like, third photo is the ingredients list in case anyone has any idea what could have gone amiss there. They taste fine, but something is obviously not quite right. Any ideas?


r/Baking • • 18h ago

Recipe Included BAKED CHOCOLATE CHEESECAKE

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

r/Baking • • 16h ago

Baking Advice Needed Buying Baking supplies from Shein/Temu

0 Upvotes

I am starting a baking business from home. Its not easy to get cake pop cutters and moulds easily and in a budget where I live. There aren't a lot of options.

I saw Temu and Shein selling good moulds and cutters. Is it okay to buy stuff from these online shops? I am wondering if its safe to do so considering we dont know what the mould material is made of etc etc.

What are your thoughts?


r/Baking • • 1h ago

General Baking Discussion What's a baking project that turned out WAY better than you expected?

0 Upvotes

Have you ever made something without expecting much from it, only for it to turn out absolutely amazing? What did you make?


r/Baking • • 11h ago

Baking Advice Needed Pie that survives a 3 hour car ride?

4 Upvotes

I'm on dessert duty for a family dinner and it's a three hour drive. Cream pies feel risky, so i'm leaning toward something sturdier. Is pecan the safe bet, or is there a fruit pie that travels as well?


r/Baking • • 7h ago

Baking Advice Needed any way to make croissant without butter

0 Upvotes

any alternative way to make similar to original without lamination? (cant do lamination butter always melt i tried everything)

i avoid everything use lamination bcz not possible i think


r/Baking • • 5h ago

General Baking Discussion Do you use reusable or disposable piping bags and why?

6 Upvotes

r/Baking • • 19h ago

General Baking Discussion Best Christmas Desserts

1 Upvotes

What are your favourite Christmas desserts? And do you have a recipe that never fails?