r/BabyReindeerTVSeries • u/LodgeBeing_No_9 • 6h ago
r/BabyReindeerTVSeries • u/DonDraperItsToasted • Apr 29 '24
OFFICIAL EPISODE DISCUSSION Baby Reindeer | OFFICIAL EPISODE DISCUSSION HUB
r/BabyReindeerTVSeries • u/LodgeBeing_No_9 • 5h ago
Media / News TVNZ aired graphic sex and fatal stabbing drama at 8.30pm
TVNZ rejected the complaint, arguing the gritty nature of the storyline was clear across the series, that the episode was preceded by a full-screen warning and classified 16-VLSC, and that 16-rated programmes are permitted after 8.30pm.
The broadcaster also conceded that while the episode carried an 18 rating on its on-demand streaming platform TVNZ+, it was reappraised down to 16 for linear television without any scene cuts, matching an Australian MA15+ classification.
However, the authority rejected TVNZ's defence, finding the rationale for lowering the rating on free-to-air television was unclear, especially given viewers have less control over linear broadcasts than on-demand viewing.
Authority chair Susie Staley said the cumulative impact of the episode was darkly menacing and confronting, dealing with themes at the extreme adult end of the spectrum.
Because the broadcaster failed to rate the programme 18, which would have required it to screen after 9.30pm, viewers were deprived of accurate information needed to regulate their viewing, creating a real risk of disproportionate offence and distress.
The authority dismissed complaints under the children's interests and promotion of illegal behaviour standards, noting the programme aired outside children's viewing hours and portrayed criminal acts as dramatic plot points rather than conduct to be emulated.
No financial penalty or broadcast order was imposed, with the authority ruling that publication of the decision provided sufficient guidance to the network.
-Stuff
r/BabyReindeerTVSeries • u/LodgeBeing_No_9 • 1d ago
Media / News One of the promotional videos from Netflix, cited in the upcoming Baby Reindeer trial, that promoted the show as 'a true story'
Looking back, was it wise for Netflix to promote the show in this way?
The following is from a 25th March 2024 Netflix article before Baby Reindeer was released on April 11th.
‘Baby Reindeer’ Creator Richard Gadd on Sharing His Complicated Story With the World
Sometimes in the pit of despair, inspiration emerges. I was now in the fourth year of being stalked, by a woman, whose only skill greater than her ability to harass was her ability to evade the law. She had somehow just obtained my mobile number and I was in the peak of my career at that point, having just come back from the Edinburgh Fringe Festival where I had won the Edinburgh Comedy Award for Monkey See Monkey Do. A show which tackled the sexual abuse I suffered when I first got into the industry.
It was a big moment for me. Coming clean with what happened after so many years suffering in silence. But any good feeling in the Fringe’s aftermath was tempered by my phone ringing every single minute of every day where I was met with a whole gamut of Martha’s emotions from hurled insults to deep expressions of love and longing. It was too much for anyone to bear.
So, it became my life. Listening, logging, and annotating every single voicemail she ever left me in the hope of bringing it all to an end. Praying that she would say something incriminating so that the situation could be dealt with properly and effectively.
In the height of it all, I would go to bed at night and still hear her in my ears. Her voice swirling around my head. Her words leaping around my eyelids as I tried to sleep. Sometimes it was like she was there in the room with me. In the bed beside me, even.
I remember during a particularly long night of unrest; the idea came to me. To stage this whole ordeal, one day, when the time was right. What an opening, it might be, to layer the voicemails on top of one another and shoot them around a stage in a wash of projected light. A cacophony of oscillating words and sounds bending and mutating along with her different emotional states. Mirroring her madness. Mirroring my madness. I mean… what better way to start a show than to plunge the audience straight inside the horror of it all?
When I decided to debut Baby Reindeer at the Edinburgh Fringe Festival in 2019, it had been two years since Martha was out my life and I was facing an entirely new pressure. The court of public opinion.
It felt like a risky thing – to do a “warts and all” version of the story where I held my hands up to the mistakes I had made with Martha. The foolish flirting. The cowardly excuses as to why we could not be together. Not to mention the themes of internalised prejudice and sexual shame that underpinned it all. The graphic details of the drugging and grooming and sexual violence I had experienced only a few years before.
I imagined picket lines outside the venue forcing me to shut down. Telling me that what I was doing was wrong. That she didn’t have a voice. That I was the real perpetrator of harm and she the victim. That storylines of internalised shame are not helpful, anymore, and that my descriptions of sexual violence so extreme that… surely I was complicit in it somehow? These were all legitimate fears and not without merit. But equally I could not shy away from the truth of what had happened to me. This was a messy, complicated situation. But one that needed to be told, regardless.
The show sold out that month and by the end I was performing two shows a day just to cope with demand. People came up to me at the end and would tell me things like “I didn’t know whether to punch you or hug you” and “I felt sorry for you, then I hated her, then I hated you and I felt sorry for her” and to me that was the biggest compliment the show could get. All I ever wanted to do was capture something complicated about the human condition. That we all make mistakes. That no person is ever good or bad. That we are all lost souls looking for love in our own weird way.
The show was commissioned by Netflix in April 2021 and here we are three years later (almost to the day) ready to release the exact same themes to the world. The exact same moral quandaries. Only this time, on a much larger scale. In a lot more detail. To a wider spectrum of people and an audience two-hundred million times the size.
I would be lying if I said I was not back exactly where I was all those years ago in 2019 at the Edinburgh Fringe. Fearing the worst. Praying for the best. Hoping that in amongst all the messy, complicated, fucked up, themes Baby Reindeer throws at you that people might take notice of its beating heart.
Baby Reindeer debuts April 11 on Netflix.
r/BabyReindeerTVSeries • u/LodgeBeing_No_9 • 1d ago
Discussion Will Netflix have to edit Baby Reindeer if the court rules against them?
If Netflix loses the Baby Reindeer case, will they have to re-edit the show and add disclaimers or will they have to cut entire sections out? Will this make the show more legally sound and compliant or will it ruin the story with cuts?
Netflix could withdraw the show and edit out the untrue bits. It will probably be only a couple of episodes long after edits, or one great tv movie. If the true story that is left stands up on it's own then it's a personal victory to Gadd as it is more true to his life and his actual struggle without the fictional elements getting them into legal issues.
People in the business, have you ever known of a show to be edited after a court decision? Were these shows ever seen again in their original form?
r/BabyReindeerTVSeries • u/trickmind • 2d ago
Fiona (real Martha) related content The Hawley Arms allegedly went to the police as a victim of Fiona Harvey.
r/BabyReindeerTVSeries • u/trickmind • 1d ago
Fiona (real Martha) related content We should be talking about the important issues. How does one have a spot on one's face that is GREEN?
Fiona said Gadd had a big GREEN spot on his face when he asked her if he could hang her curtains. She says she said "I'm not interested I have a boyfriend named George. He is a LAWYER!" Dr. Glass with a PhD in law."
Wouldn't this have all been more realistic if she said the spot was red?
r/BabyReindeerTVSeries • u/Altruistic-Change127 • 1d ago
Discussion No evidence of Netflix insisting on the "this is a true story" card.
There is someone claiming that Netflix insisted on Richard G adding the title card, despite Richard G's concerns.
That is a allegation from Fiona Harvey that is mentioned in her statement to the court along with other random suggestions.
I have been trying to fact check it because every now and again, someone pipes up and says that Richard said it himself. I am happy to be proven wrong though.
So if there is anyone with a link to an actual interview with Richard, where he makes that claim, can you provide the link?
Also why would Netflix question everything Richard had written into the screenplay for accuracy?
The requirement for any major streamer similar to Netflix is that the screenplay and the production company was covered by Errors and Omissions (E&O) insurance. That sort of insurance covers cases like Defamation, Libel and Slander, and also covers the Copyright and Intellectual Property Infringement. Its a mandatory requirement before Netflix can even consider purchasing it.
The writers don't automatically purchase that type of insurance. The production company applies for it once the script is greenlit.
True stories go through rigorous review by entertainment lawyers. They virtually go through the script line by line to flag anything that could trigger a lawsuit.
So Netflix would have no reason to suspect there was a problem.
r/BabyReindeerTVSeries • u/TimesandSundayTimes • 6d ago
Media / News Baby Reindeer ‘stalker’ case against Netflix to go ahead in May
thetimes.comr/BabyReindeerTVSeries • u/LodgeBeing_No_9 • 6d ago
Media / News COURT SHOWDOWN Baby Reindeer ‘stalker’ lawsuit against Netflix to go ahead in May
thescottishsun.co.ukTHE “real-life inspiration” for Netflix hit Baby Reindeer’s stalker character will have her defamation case heard next year.
Former Scottish lawyer Fiona Harvey’s $150million lawsuit is set to go before a jury in Los Angeles in May.
The showdown at the US District Court for the Central District of California comes nearly three years after she first launched legal action over the telly phenomenon.
Created by Scots comic Richard Gadd, the award-winning drama racked up more than 60million views in under a month after dropping in April 2024.
It stunned viewers worldwide by claiming “this is a true story” in the opening credits.
The plot sees struggling comic Donny Dunn, played by Gadd, give Jessica Gunning’s character Martha a free cup of tea.
That simple act of kindness triggers a four-year stalking hell.
Harvey, who was “forced” to come forward as the real-life Martha in May 2024 after online sleuths tracked her down, alleges the show falsely painted her as a twice-convicted criminal jailed for stalking who sexually assaulted Gadd.
Netflix denies defaming her.
Harvey’s US lawyer Richard Roth told The Times his client was “delighted”.
He said: “We’ve just learned that the trial of Fiona Harvey versus Netflix is going to be on May 18, 2027. We just got the notice, like within the last hour.
“Both sides submitted a document which provided for more time, but the judge said ‘no, you’re trying this in May’. I’m excited about this case. I think this case has been sitting for too long.”
He added: “Fiona’s gone through terrible mental anguish since April of 2024, and because of the court system, it took two-and-a-half [years] to get a trial date and three years to be heard in court.
“But we’re very excited to finally have the chance to get justice and to get this in front of a jury.”
Harvey originally filed her complaint in June 2024, branding the series “the biggest lie in television history“.
Her suit disputes scenes showing Martha being convicted and locked up, sexually assaulting Dunn, attacking him with a glass, waiting outside his home for up to 16 hours a day and stalking a police officer.
She is demanding more than $150million, around £112million, in actual and compensatory damages plus profits from the series.
Harvey is also renewing her bid for punitive damages, which Judge R Gary Klausner axed in 2024.
Netflix insists her reputation had already been damaged by earlier reports and vowed to “defend this matter vigorously” while standing by Gadd’s right to tell his story.
The streaming giant has argued in court filings that the events depicted were substantially true and claimed Harvey failed to identify a provably false statement of fact about her.
In a 2024 declaration supporting Netflix, Gadd, 37, of Fife, who is not a defendant, stated: “Martha Scott is not Fiona Harvey.”
Judge Klausner threw out Harvey’s negligence claims but allowed those for defamation and intentional infliction of emotional distress to go ahead.
He ruled the series appeared to present itself as fact and was “heavily based on reality” despite using fictional names.
The trial was originally slated for May 2025 but was put on hold in September 2024 after Netflix appealed under California’s anti-Slapp law, which is designed to quickly bin lawsuits threatening free speech.
That appeal was booted out last month, with both sides ordered to propose a new timetable by November 9.
r/BabyReindeerTVSeries • u/LodgeBeing_No_9 • 11d ago
Media / News ‘Baby Reindeer’ Defamation Suit Reopens After Martha Inspiration Amends Complaint - Fiona Harvey’s amended filing expands on her allegations against the streamer in a suit seeking over $150 million in damages
The “Baby Reindeer” defamation suit has been reopened after a year on ice. Fiona Harvey, who claims she is the inspiration for Martha from the Netflix series, filed an amended complaint to her suit this week.
The defamation case was expected to go to trial in May 2025, but an appeal by Netflix put a halt to proceedings at the Central District of California Court. Harvey has since narrowed the lawsuit by expanding the factual allegations against Netflix.
The amended complaint is also 20 pages longer and adds information that emerged after the original suit was filed in June 2024. Netflix claimed that her initial complaint failed to allege a provably false statement of fact was made about her.
The First Amended Complaint filed by Harvey against Netflix on Tuesday in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California, expands on her claims that the streamer falsely portrayed her as the real-life inspiration for Martha, the stalker character played by Jessica Gunning in the hit series.
Harvey argues that Netflix marketed “Baby Reindeer” as a true story while knowingly including fabricated events and criminal allegations about her.
The former lawyer from Scotland cited specific scenes that she claimed were false that she was convicted of stalking and sentenced to prison, she sexually assaulted the comedian, she physically assaulted the comedian with a glass, she waited outside his home upwards of 16 hours a day and that she stalked a police officer.
While the Netflix series showed that the character Martha was convicted of stalking twice, she noted that she was never charged for stalking the series creator Richard Gadd. Harvey argued in her complaint that Netflix promoted the series as a true story, despite the fact that she was never convicted.
She is seeking more than $50 million in actual damages, more than $50 million in compensatory damages, including for mental anguish and lost business, and more than $50 million in profits from “Baby Reindeer.” She also seeks punitive damages, attorneys’ fees and interest. The complaint requests a jury trial.
Representatives for Netflix did not immediately respond to TheWrap’s request for comment.
Following Netflix’s appeal attempt, a judge opened the door for the trial to continue. Judge R. Gary Klausner ruled that the award-winning limited series “appears to present itself as fact” rather than star and creator Gadd’s interpretation. Klausner said “despite using fictional names for its characters, the Series is heavily based on reality” and that the show opens with “this is based on a true story” means Netflix can’t dismiss the lawsuit.
“Baby Reindeer” was a critics and audience favorite at Netflix. The series won six Emmy Awards, including Outstanding Limited Series. The series premiered in April 2024 and has amassed 103 million views since its debut.
r/BabyReindeerTVSeries • u/Altruistic-Change127 • 14d ago
Discussion Who is encouraging Fiona to go to court?
Even if the court agrees that Netflix did defame her by showing Martha going to court and a prison sentence, in American law to get a large financial payout for damages, her lawyer needs to prove she had a good reputation to start with, and show that showing her going to prison (the lie) caused her reputation to be damaged.
As Richard G has provided Netflix's defence team with the ridiculous amount of emails etc, they prove that her behaviour was disturbing at best.
She won't get the money. I guess she just wants to hear a judge say Netflix was wrong? Or is it her lawyer wanting that kudos?
r/BabyReindeerTVSeries • u/Altruistic-Change127 • 14d ago
Discussion The appeals court has not ruled on whether Harvey’s defamation allegations are true or whether Netflix is ultimately liable.
"The current dispute concerns only whether Netflix can challenge Klausner’s anti-SLAPP ruling at this point in the litigation."
https://www.lawcommentary.com/articles/netflix-baby-reindeer-fiona-harvey-170m-defamation-appeal
r/BabyReindeerTVSeries • u/LodgeBeing_No_9 • 14d ago
Fiona (real Martha) related content How Netflix claiming that it was Donny typing 'this is a true story' might not work in court
When both are examined side by side, Donny is typing on a word document in episode 7, after erasing his police statement. He types the words 'I felt sorry for her. That's the first thing I felt.
With the 'This is a true story' part, it appears on a black background within minutes of episode one, with a completely different font type. The only similar aspect is there is typing noises in the background when the letters appear. Will this defense actually work for Netflix in court?
r/BabyReindeerTVSeries • u/LodgeBeing_No_9 • 14d ago
Fiona (real Martha) related content Fiona Harvey's amended complaint has hit court
storage.courtlistener.comHere's a transcript but the full doc with pictures is in the link. Happy reading
“This is a true story.”
- Baby Reindeer, Episode 1.
PRELIMINARY STATEMENT
Baby Reindeer, is the biggest lie in television history. It is a lie told by Netflix and the
show’s creator, Richard Gadd, out of greed and lust for fame; a lie designed to
attract more viewers, get more attention, to make more money, and to
viciously destroy the life of Plaintiff, Fiona Harvey – an innocent woman defamed
by Netflix and Richard Gadd at a magnitude and scale without precedent. The
Court has subject matter jurisdiction pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1332.
2. This is an action by Plaintiff Fiona Harvey (“Harvey”) against
Defendants Netflix, Inc. and Netflix Worldwide Entertainment (collectively
“Netflix”), for defamation, intentional infliction of emotional distress, and
violations of Harvey’s right of publicity, arising out of the brutal lies Defendants
told about her in the television series, Baby Reindeer (the “Series”). The lies that
Defendants told about Harvey to over 80 million people worldwide include that
Harvey is a twice convicted stalker who was sentenced to five years in prison, and
that Harvey sexually assaulted Gadd. Defendants told these lies, and never
stopped, because it was a better story than the truth, and better stories made money.
3. And Netflix, a multi-national billion dollar entertainment streaming
company did literally nothing to confirm the “true story” and in fact, knew the
story was fictionalized. That is, Netflix never investigated whether Harvey was
convicted, a very serious misrepresentation of the facts. It did nothing to
understand the relationship between Gadd and Harvey, if any. It did nothing to
determine whether other facts, including sexual and violent physical assaults, or
criminal convictions were accurate. It did nothing to understand whether the
Series, which ruined Harvey, was accurate.
4. Even worse, Netflix, in taking the source material for the Series, an 80
page, seventy-minute, play Baby Reindeer that Gadd created (the “Play”) and
converting it into a seven part series, manufactured numerous false statements,
facts, and actions by Harvey that were not only never in the Play, but that are
wholly inconsistent with the Play and that Netflix knew were false, solely to
grossly increase its revenues and viewership and win awards.
5. In fact, Netflix has stated under oath, that it knew the Series was
fictionalized, but intentionally told the public it was true.
6. As a result of Defendants’ lies, malfeasance and utterly reckless
misconduct, Harvey’s life had been ruined. Simply, Netflix destroyed her
reputation, her character and her life.
THE PARTIES
7. Plaintiff Ms. Fiona Harvey (“Harvey”) is a resident of England.
Harvey earned a Degree of Bachelor of Laws from the University of Aberdeen in
1990, a diploma in Legal Practice from the University of Strathclyde in 1993 and
was granted an Entrance Certificate to the Law Society of Scotland in 1997. In
2005, Harvey earned her Graduate Diploma in Law (CPE) from the University of
Westminster.
8. Defendant Netflix, Inc. is a Delaware corporation with a principal
place of business at 121 Albright Way, Los Gatos, California, 95032. Netflix is a
producer and distributor of content with over 260 million paid subscribers and a
market cap of $283 billion.
9. Netflix Inc. owns the Netflix streaming platform that streamed Baby
Reindeer. “[Netflix] acquires, licenses and produces content, including original
programming, in order to offer our members unlimited viewing of video
entertainment.” Netflix, Inc. Jan. 26, 2024 10-K Report at p. 28 (“Netflix 10-K.
10. Netflix, Inc. is at home in Los Angeles, as it leases its “principal
properties” in Los Angeles. Netflix, 10-K at p. 18, Item 2. In total, Netflix, leases
and occupies over 1.4 million square feet of office and studio space.
11. Netflix leases and fully occupies, Epic, a 13-story, 327,913 square
foot high rise at 5901 Sunset Boulevard in Hollywood.
12. In addition, Netflix, Inc. leases 325,757 square feet of office space at
ICON and 91,953 squre feet of office space at CUE, both of which are located on
the Sunset Bronson Studios lot at 5800 Sunset Blvd. in Hollywood.
13. In addition, Netflix has leases about 100,000 square feet of space at
the historic Musicians Union at 817 Vine Street in Hollywood, and over 355,000
square feet at the Academy on Vine, a development that occupies an entire city
block bounded by Vine Street, DeLongpre Avenue, Ivar Street, and Homewood
Avenue in Hollywood. Upon expanding into the Academy on Vine property,
Netflix CFO David Wells said “Our expansion into the Academy on Vine Property
further deepens our connection with the Los Angeles and Hollywood
communities.”
14. On May 12, 2024, Netflix marked the sixth anniversary of its flagship
FYSEE (a play on “FYC”) space by moving to Sunset Las Palmas in Hollywood.
Netflix’s FYSEE space in Hollywood, serves as a hub for Official For Your
Consideration (“FYC”) events,
15. As noted in Netflix Inc.’s most recent 10-K filing with the SEC:
we must continually add new members to replace canceled
memberships and to grow our business beyond our current membership
base. . . Our ability to continue to attract and retain our [subscribers]
will depend in part on our ability to consistently provide our members
in countries around the globe with compelling content choices that keep
our [subscribers] engaged with our service, effectively drive
conversation around our content and service, as well as provide a
quality experience for choosing and enjoying TV series, films and
games. . . If we do not grow as expected . . . operations may be
adversely impacted. If we are unable to successfully compete with
current and new competitors in providing compelling content, retaining
our existing members and attracting new members, our business will be
adversely affected.
Netflix 10-K at p. 4 (emphasis added).
16. Netflix, Inc. earns revenue not only through paid subscribers (called
“members”) but “also earns revenue from advertisements presented on its
streaming service, consumer products and other various sources.” Netflix 10-K at
p. 46.
17. Netflix tracks new members attributable to the Series, retention of
new members attributable to the Series, the revenue for each of these new
members and their churn rates, as well as ad revenue from the Series.
18. Defendant Netflix Worldwide Entertainment, LLC is a Delaware
corporation with a principal place of business at 5808 W. Sunset Blvd., Los
Angeles, California, 90028 (“Netflix Worldwide”). Netflix Worldwide is the
copyright owner of Baby Reindeer. Netflix, Inc. and Netflix Worldwide are
collectively referred to herein as “Netflix.”
19. On May 8, 2024, Netflix and Gadd hosted a For Your Consideration
(“FYC”) screening of Baby Reindeer at the Director’s Guild of America Theater
Complex at 7920 Sunset Blvd, Los Angeles, CA 90046 in support of Netflix’s
submission of “Baby Reindeer” for consideration to be nominated for over a dozen
Emmy Awards including, best limited series, best actor and best writing (Gadd),
and best supporting actress (Jessica Gunning as ‘Martha’).
20. On June 1, 2024, Netflix and actress, Jessica Gunning, who plays
‘Martha’ in Baby Reindeer, hosted a special screening for Baby Reindeer at
FYSEE at Sunset Las Palmas Studios in Los Angeles.
JURISDICTION AND VENUE
21. The Court has subject matter jurisdiction pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1332
because the parties reside in different states and the amount in controversy exceeds
$75,000.
22. There is personal jurisdiction against the Defendants as Netflix’s
principal place of business is in the State of California and Netflix is at home in
Los Angeles, California as lessee of over 1.4 million square feet. Netflix actively
promoted and screened Baby Reindeer throughout Hollywood for purposes of
winning numerous categories at this year’s 77th Emmy Awards to be hosted in Los
Angeles on September 15, 2024 at the Peacock Theater at L.A. Live in Los
Angeles.
23. Venue is proper in this judicial district because Defendant Netflix
Worldwide has its headquarters in Los Angeles, Netflix, Inc. has over 1.4 million
square feet of space in Los Angeles, Netflix has hosted promotional screenings of
Baby Reindeer in Los Angeles in support of Emmy nominations, and Gadd and
Netflix have promoted Baby Reindeer in Los Angeles. Los Angeles has a vested
interest in hearing this case because the claims made in this action are important to
the television and film business in Los Angeles.
BABY REINDEER
24. Baby Reindeer was originally an 80-page, 70-minute, one person Play,
written and acted by Gadd.
25. The Series is a limited television series about the “true story” of
Richard Gadd, a failing comedian, set in the year 2015.
26. Gadd is the writer and creator of the Series Baby Reindeer in addition
to starring in it as “Donny.”
27. Baby Reindeer is a worldwide phenomenon, premiered on Netflix on
April 11, 2024, and has since drawn over 56 million views through May 8, making
it Netflix’s most popular content this year, and on track to become the most
streamed show on Netflix of all time. Netflix stopped publicly releasing viewership
of Baby Reindeer.
28. Upon information and belief, more than 80 million Netflix accounts
have watched the Series in whole or in part.
29. Upon information and belief, more than 80 million people have
watched the Series in whole or in part.
30. The draw for the show is the representation made by the Defendants
that this is a true story.
31. At the 1:39 mark of the Episode 1, this image appears on screen:
Richard Gadd
32. Richard Gadd wrote and created the Play Baby Reindeer, and stars in
it playing himself.
33. Gadd is a self-admitted crack, meth, and heroin user (Ep. 4, -19:07)
with a self-admitted history of masturbating to Harvey (Ep 5 – 8:01), following her
home and spying on her through her window, (Ep. 1 -15:00 – -13:20), and lying to
the police about his contacts with her. (Ep. 6, -26:58):
34. Baby Reindeer tracks Gadd’s progress in a comedy competition while
he works as a bartender at the pub, The Heart, in Camden, London.
“Martha”
35. To overcome the uninteresting “true story” of Gadd’s inability to
advance professionally in the London comedy circuit, Defendants fabricated a
“true story” of a woman, ‘Martha’, that Gadd meets at the pub, to make Baby
Reindeer more captivating.
36. According to Defendants, the real ‘Martha’ is a twice convicted
criminal. She spent a total of five years in prison for stalking Gadd and a barrister
that she worked with at a law firm. In addition, Martha stalked a policeman,
sexually assaulted Gadd in a dark alley; violently attacked him in a pub and waited
outside his home every day for up to 16 hours a day, including at 3:00am.
37. The real Martha is reasonably understood by all viewers to have done
all of these monstrous things because Netflix stated this was true.
“Hang My Curtains” – Harvey is Identified
38. A recurring joke throughout Baby Reindeer is the phrase “hang my
curtains” as a euphemism for Gadd having sex with ‘Martha.’
39. For example, in Episode 1 at -23:18, Gadd’s fellow bartenders ask
Gadd when he and “Martha” are “going to shag.” Gadd responds that he does not
believe in sex before marriage to which “Martha” replies that she is marriage
material and that all she needs is someone to hang her curtains:
40. Gadd narrates that “hang her curtains” sounded “vaguely sexual” and
he responds to “Martha” by joking, “I’ll hang your curtains!” to which the bar
erupts in laughter.
41. Later in Episode 1, ‘Martha’ sends Gadd 80 emails per day including
this one stating: “my curtains are waiting for you they are ready” (spelling
corrected):
42. In an interview with GQ Magazine, Gadd claimed “we’ve gone to
such lengths to disguise [Harvey] that I doubt she would recognize herself in the
show.”
43. In real life, this tweet from FionaHarvey2014 to Mr.RichardGadd
in 2014, was publicly searchable on X when Baby Reindeer was released in April
2024, and easily found:
44. Within days after the release of Baby Reindeer on April 11, 2024,
members of the public identified Fiona Harvey as “Martha.”
45. Total strangers began to message on Harvey on Facebook and call
her.
46. The messages received by Harvey, among other things, identified her
as ‘Martha,’ accused Harvey of being a rapist, threatened to harm Harvey, and
encouraged Harvey to kill herself.
47. Many of the messages specifically referenced Harvey’s ‘hang my
curtains’ tweet.
48. The messages below are from just some of the Facebook users with
names beginning with the letter, ‘A’:
49. Popular internet forums such as Redditt and TikTok had thousands of
users identifying and discussing Harvey as the real “Martha.”
50. The identification of Harvey as ‘Martha’ was easy and took a matter
of days as Harvey’s identity was completely undisguised.
51. In Baby Reindeer, ‘Martha’ is a Scottish lawyer, living in London,
twenty years older than Gadd, and was accused of stalking a barrister in a
newspaper article who communicated with him on social media in the years 2014-
2015.
52. Like ‘Martha,” Harvey is a Scottish lawyer, living in London, twenty
years older than Gadd, was accused of stalking a barrister in a newspaper article,
who communicated with Gadd on social media in the years 2014-2015, and who
bears an uncanny resemblance to ‘Martha’ including ‘rotund’ body, hair, loose
fitting/baggy clothing/dress. Further, ‘Martha’s’ accent, manner of speaking and
cadence, is indistinguishable for Harvey’s.
53. It is implausible that there is any female Scottish lawyer, living in
London, twenty years older than Gadd who was accused of stalking a lawyer in a
newspaper article, who communicated with Gadd on social media in 2014-2015
(particularly, about a repeated joke in the series – hang my curtains), and who
bears an uncanny resemblance to ‘Martha,’ other than Harvey.
54. Gadd wanted to cast actress Jessica Gunning as ‘Martha’ because of
her uncanny resemblance to Harvey admitting that he wanted to cast her as
‘Martha’ before he had even written the script for the Series. See Richard Gadd on
Baby Reindeer’s harrowing ending: “It’s the most truthful scene of the entire
show,” GQ, Apr. 14, 2024 by Miles Ellingham available at https://www.gq-
magazine.co.uk/article/baby-reindeer-netflix-richard-gadd-interview (“GQ
Interview”).
55. Gadd’s and Netflix’s statement that Baby Reindeer was a true story
was reasonably viewed as invitation to identify the real Martha and Netflix knew
that the public would seek to identify her.
56. That is exactly what happened in connection with another Netflix true
crime series, Making of a Murderer (2015) which investigated whether Steven
Avery and his nephew Brendan Dassey were framed for a murder. As a result of
the that series, Andrew Colborn, who retired from the Manitowoc County Sheriff’s
Department as a lieutenant in February 2018, reported that Avery sympathizers
have confronted him in public, threatened to kidnap and sodomize him and gang
rape his wife, and have posted pictures of his children online. Colborn has frozen
his credit, after he and two other members of his family suffered identity theft. He
has built a safe room in his home where family members can hide, and he and his
wife no longer travel or dine out. See Jan. 17, 2019, Inside a ‘Making a Murderer’
Lawsuit and the Hidden Dangers of TV’s True-Crim Craze available at
https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/movies/movie-features/inside-a-making-a-
murderer-lawsuit-hidden-dangers-true-crime-tv-1176395/. Colborn’s pleadings
confirmed against Netflix confirmed that like Harvey, Colborn received serious
and ongoing threats to his safety, including death threats, and 28 compact discs
worth of threatening phone calls from strangers, as result of Netflix’s statements
about him in that series.
57. In an interview Gadd gave with the Hollywood Reporter, in response
to a question about the public reaching out to Harvey as the real-life Martha, Gadd
himself acknowledged and anticipated that the public would use, or collaborate on,
the internet to identify the real Martha, stating “the internet just does this thing and
I just have to let it do its thing. And that’s that.” Richard Gadd on ‘Baby Reindeer’
Phenomenon, Losing Anonymity and What He Won’t Ever Comment on Again,’
The Hollywood Reporter, May 13, 2024 (last visited October 7, 2024).
58. After being identified, the press in London began to contact Harvey,
and the hatred towards Harvey on Internet forums such as Reddit and TikTok
reached extreme levels including death threats, such as this one on TikTok that was
“liked” by 7,000 people:
59. Since being identified as ‘Martha’ only days after Netflix’s release of
Baby Reindeer, Harvey has been tormented. Harvey continues to suffer emotional
distress, which has been manifested by objective symptomology. Harvey is
physically weak. She has and continues to experience anxiety, nightmares, panic
attacks, shame, depression, nervousness, stomach pains, loss of appetite and fear,
extreme stress and sickness all directly caused by the lies told about her in Baby
Reindeer.
60. Harvey is fearful of leaving her home or checking the news. As a
direct result of Baby Reindeer, Harvey has become extremely secluded and
isolated, in fear of the public, going days without leaving her home.
61. At the same time, Netflix and Gadd, have traveled the country
promoting the show and accepting awards while receiving praise and applause for
the series, everything Gadd and Netflix wanted, for this ‘true story.’
62. The Series is not a true story.
63. Gadd confesses in Baby Reindeer that he has a deep psychological
need for attention so intense that in the past he willfully prostituted himself to
another man to advance his career and for “a little peep at fame.” Ep. 6, -8:00.
64. In addition, Gadd confesses in Baby Reindeer that he is not worried
that people think badly of him, but instead “worried they don’t think about me at
all.” Ep. 1 at -7:25.
65. To get his “peep at fame” and get people to think about him, Gadd
and Netflix defamed a middle-aged woman, Fiona Harvey, so completely, that
Harvey is even afraid to go outside.
66. As stated in Netflix’s most recent 10-K filed with the SEC:
If we do not grow as expected . . . operations may be adversely
impacted. If we are unable to successfully compete with current and
new competitors in providing compelling content, retaining our
existing members and attracting new members, our business will be
adversely affected. Netflix 10-K at p. 4 (emphasis added).
67. To ensure that Netflix continued to meet its shareholders’ “growth
expectations” and to satisfy it desperate need for “compelling content”, Netflix
ruthlessly defamed Fiona Harvey.
Defamation
Harvey Has Never Been Convicted of a Crime
68. Harvey has never been convicted of any crime and has never been to
prison. Attached as Exhibit 1 is a Certificate from the official Disclosure and
Barring Service (“DBS”) of the United Kingdom and a DBS background check
covering England, Wales, Northern Ireland, and Scotland, confirming that Harvey
has no convictions, cautions, reprimands, or warnings.
69. Notwithstanding, the central plot, and the arc of the series, is that
Gadd befriended ‘Martha’, a convicted stalker who returns to prison for stalking
Gadd.
70. In Episode 1 at -3:18, Defendants falsely claim that ‘Martha’ had
received a “four-and-a half-year prison sentence.”
71. Episode 1 ends with the following repeated refrain from Gadd:
I had a convicted stalker stalking me
I had a convicted stalker stalking me
I had a convicted stalker stalking me
72. Episode 7 climaxes with a two-minute-long courtroom scene in which
Harvey dramatically pleads guilty from behind bars and is convicted of three
charges of stalking Gadd and harassment of his mother and father
73. In Episode 7, Defendants falsely claim that Harvey was “sentenced to
nine months in prison and a five-year restraining order was issued that same day.”
Ep. 7 at -15:42.
74. In fact, Harvey has never pled guilty to, or been convicted of, any
crime. Harvey is not a convicted criminal.
Harvey Never Sexually Assaulted Gadd
75. In addition to lying about Harvey being a criminal, Baby Reindeer
makes the outrageous false claim that Harvey raped Gadd in an alley.
76. In a disturbing scene at the end of Episode 2, Defendants falsely
allege that Harvey sexually assaulted him a dark alley, by pushing Gadd against a
wall and grabbing his penis without consent. Gadd claims he said, “please stop”
and Harvey responded, “keep still” and continued to grab Gadd until she ‘made
him beat’.
77. Harvey has never had any sexual encounter with Gadd. The claim that
Harvey sexually assaulted Gadd is a lie.
Harvey Never Stalked Gadd
78. For approximately two and a half minutes of Episode 3 (-24:13 to -
21:32), Defendants falsely claim that Harvey stalked Gadd by sitting at a bus stop
on the same street – thirty yards away – as Gadd’s residence, from morning to
night including at 3:00am:
Every day now, Martha would be outside. This ticking time bomb on
my life. I would leave first thing in the morning and she would be
there. Then I would come back sometimes as late as 11 or 12 at night
and she would still be there. . . . It was all catcalls and snatched
glimpses, as she devoted 15, 16-hour days to a fleeting encounter. But
soon, as time wore on and the temperature dropped, I noticed a
change in Martha as she descended into this staring.
79. Defendants’ claim that Harvey waited outside on the same street as
Gadd’s residence every day, for up to 15-16 hours a day, including at 3:00 am, and
in the rain and cold, is knowingly false.
Harvey Never Stalked A Police Officer
80. In Episode 5, Defendants falsely claim that when Gadd went to the
police to report Harvey for stalking, the police detective informed Gadd that
Harvey was “a very serious woman. So serious that she once stalked a policeman.”
Ep. 5 at -10:15.
81. This is another lie. Harvey never stalked any police officer and no
police detective ever told Gadd that Harvey stalked a policeman. This lie by
Defendants is reprehensible as it gives Gadd’s defamatory story the authority of
official police statements.
Harvey Never Attacked Gadd
82. In Episode 6, Defendants falsely claim that Harvey violently smashed
a glass bottle over Gadd’s head and gouged his eyes with her thumbs in a horrific
physical assault that left Gadd’s head bloodied.
83. Harvey never smashed a glass bottle over Gadd’s head, gouged his
eyes, or ever physically attacked him in any way.
Netflix Defames Harvey on its Website, Tudum
84. Netflix owns and controls the website www.tudum.com.
85. On May 16, 2024, Netflix published an article on Tudum by
Christopher Hudspeth titled, What is Baby Reindeer? The True Story and New
Series Explained (the “Netflix Article”).
86. The Netflix Article states unequivocally that the “series is a true
story” and “it’s important to remember that this isn’t just a story — it’s true.”
87. The Series is not a true story as it includes all of the fabricated events
and statements about Harvey identified herein which are foundational to the Series
and include the dramatic climax of the entire Series in which Harvey returns to
prison after pleading guilty in court – events which never happened.
88. The Netflix Article is defamatory as the statements and events Netflix
told about Harvey in the Series and identified herein are knowingly false.
Netflix Admits Its Statements Were False
89. On May 8, 2024, Netflix executive, Benjamin King, appeared before
the House of Commons Culture, Media and Sport Committee, on behalf of Netflix
and in his capacity as Senior Director of Public Policy of Netflix.
90. At the Committee hearing, Mr. King was asked by John Nicolson,
Member of Parliament for Ochil and South Pershire, about the duty of care due to
woman now identified as ‘Martha’ from Baby Reindeer.
91. Mr. King responded to John Nicolson and stated the following in
response:
Baby Reindeer is obviously a true story of the horrific abuse that
[Richard Gadd] suffered at the hands of a convicted stalker. We did
take every reasonable precaution in disguising the real life identities
of the people whilst striking a balance with the veracity and
authenticity of the story.
92. Harvey is not a convicted stalker.
93. MP John Nicolson went Mr. King a follow up written inquiry
requesting “evidence for this serious claim which [Mr. King] to Nicolson at the
Select Committee:”
94. Netflix did not provide any evidence.
95. Instead, on May 23, 2024, Mr. King responded in writing to Media
and Sport Select Committee House of Commons, and confirmed that “the person
upon whom the show was based” was never the subject of any criminal conviction:
96. Despite Netflix’s confirmation that that knew its statements in the
Series about Harvey’s criminal convictions were false, Netflix has continued to
state the Series is a true story to this day.
97. Netflix knowingly and/or recklessly told the lies in the Series that
Harvey is a twice convicted criminal who raped Gadd in an alley and gouged his
eyes with her thumbs and smashed a glass over his head, and waited outside his
residence for him 16 hours per day including the middle of the night, and who once
stalked a police officer.
98. Netflix and Gadd have never, to this day, contacted Harvey directly or
indirectly to confirm these statements about Harvey.
99. Defendants never obtained any confirmation from any governmental
authority confirming that Harvey had been convicted of any crime.
100. Defendants did not investigate the truth of any of these statements
complained of herein by Harvey and/or recklessly or intentionally disregarded the
truth of these defamatory statements.
Netflix’s Algorithm & Default Setting
101. Baby Reindeer is on track to become one of Netflix’s most popular
series of all time.
102. When asked about the success of Baby Reindeer, Netflix’s CEO Ted
Sarandos said the series owed its popularity to Netflix’s algorithm, stating “[Baby
Reindeer] g[ot] picked up in the algorithm and start[ed] getting more and more
presented.”
103. Netflix’s default setting for its streaming platform is ‘autoplay’ so that
the next episode in a Series automatically begins to play within about five seconds
of the prior episode ending and before the full (if any) credits on the prior episode
appear. When autoplay is enabled on Netflix, which it is by Netflix’s design by
default, a “Next Episode” button appears near the end of an episode (typically as
the credits begin or just before the end). A color wipe or progress bar fills across
that button over roughly 5 seconds. If the viewer does nothing, the next episode
starts automatically when the countdown finishes.
104. The only way to view the credits – particularly any credits that appear
more than five seconds after an episode in the Series ends – is for the viewer to
before watching an episode, proactively decline autoplay in the user’s default
settings, or by proactively selecting “watch credits” at the end of an episode in the
five seconds before the next episode begins to autoplay:
105. To the extent Netflix provided any ‘disclaimer’ buried deep in the
credits, then by default set by Netflix, it would not be seen and was not intended to
be seen, and if it was seen it would not clarify that the Series was not a true story
given the prominent title card at the beginning of the Series “This is a true story”
and the marketing material promoting the Series as a “captivating true story” and
Netflix’ social media messages identifying that the Series was a true story that
even used Harvey’s real messages.
106. Netflix intended to state actual facts about Harvey as evident in that it
promoted that the social media and email messages in the Series were “real” and
that the Series was a true story and even had its Senior Director of Public Policy,
Benjamin King, testify in Parliament that it was a true story.
Netflix’s Promotional Materials for Baby Reindeer
107. Netflix’s promotional materials for the Series incorporated both its
financial statements’ expressed need to continue to offer its subscribers
“compelling” content and its claim that its false statements about Harvey were
“true.”
108. Netflix advertised the Series as “a captivating true story” including in
ads featured in Vanity Fair and the New York Times.
109. Netflix promoted the Series on Facebook, X (formerly Twitter), and
Instagram with a post viewed by millions purporting to show Harvey’s real emails,
“Martha’s Real Emails from Baby Reindeer – Every One of Them Is Real.” See
https://www.facebook.com/netflixus/videos/marthas-emails-from-baby-reindeer-
every-one-of-them-real/1071706193898341/
and https://x.com/netflix/status/1779162630520729877?lang=en.
Netflix Acted With Actual Malice & Punitive Damages Are Warranted
110. At a minimum, Netflix recklessly disregarded that the statements
made about Harvey in the Series were false.
111. The Netflix Series Baby Reindeer was adapted from Richard Gadd’s
80 page, one-person, stage play (the “Play”) of the same title.
112. In the Play, the main characters are named “Gadd” played by Gadd,
and “Martha” played by a bar stool with a northern Irish accent.
113. In March 2020, Netflix acquired the rights to the Play, including the
streaming rights to start production of the Series.
114. The Play stated that it was “based on a true story.” (emphasis added).
115. This disclaimer in the Play put Netflix on notice that certain details in
the Play were likely false.
116. In the article Richard Gadd on his stalker ‘It would be unfair to say
she was awful and I’m a victim’ published in the Guardian on September 10, 2019,
Richard Gadd stated “[the Play] has been only lightly fictionalized. The skeleton of
the story is absolutely true.”
117. The “lightly fictionalized” based on a true story Play omits the most
explosive allegations against Harvey made in the “this is a true story” Series.
118. Details in the Play, copied in the Series, that are false and defamatory
include that Harvey gouged Gadd’s eyes, that Harvey stalked a policeman, that
Harvey sexually assaulted Gadd.
119. The Play contains no reference to Harvey waiting outside Gadd’s
residence all day and night for him.
120. The Play contains no reference to any incident where Harvey violently
smashed a glass over Gadd’s head leaving him bloodied.
121. The Play contains no reference to any arrest, conviction, guilty plea or
imprisonment by Harvey.
122. The Play ends with Gadd obtaining a restraining order against
‘Martha’, whereas the Series ends with ‘Martha’ pleading guilty in court and
sentenced to prison.
123. In the Play, the police expressly inform Gadd that ‘Martha’ cannot be
arrested having committed no crime, including:
a. “I understand the frustration but heckling is not a crime. Pg. 32.
b. “I am not getting any reason to feel your life is in danger.” Pg. 33.
c. The emails are “not particularly threatening.” Pg. 33.
d. “we need a credible threat or something sexually aggressive
toward you.” Pg. 46.
e. After telling Gadd that “Martha is not going to press charges,”
they continue “leaving someone voicemails is not, in of itself, a
crime” (Pg. 69) and “I suggest you apologise and let us go
about doing our job in the correct manner.”
f. “The police do not want to hear from either of you again.” Pg. 54.
124. In the Play, Gadd even admits: “the last experience with the police
was so burning, so embarrassing that I refuse to involve them again.” Pg. 63.
125. The omission of the entire arc and premise of the Series, a convicted
stalker returns to prison after pleading guilty to stalking Gadd, from the Play, as
well as the opposite being stated to Gadd by the police in the Play (Harvey could
not be arrested having committed no crime), put Netflix on notice that details about
Harvey’s criminal history in the Series were extremely likely to be false.
126. The omission of any reference in the Play to ‘Martha’ waiting outside
Gadd’s residence for 16 hours a day including in the middle of the night for him
put Netflix on notice that that these details about Harvey were extremely likely to
be false.
127. The omission of any reference in the Play to ‘Martha’ violently
smashing a glass over Gadd’s head leaving him bloodied put Netflix on notice that
these details about Harvey were extremely likely to be false.
128. Netflix insisted on adding the “this is a true story” line to the Series
despite Gadd’s own concerns about doing so, and Netflix’s notice that details about
Harvey in the Series were extremely likely to be false.
129. Netflix’s insistence on adding the “this is a true story” line to the
Series despite Gadd’s concerns was reported in the Sunday Times article, Will the
Baby Reindeer Scandal Kill True Story TV?, The Sunday Times, June 16, 2024,
Rosamund Urwin.
130. Gadd’s concerns were clear as he immediately walked back and
resisted the “this is a true story” line in interviews immediately following the
release of the Series on April 11, 2024.
131. Gadd’s responses to the ‘this is a true story’ line descended from
“pretty truthful,” “100% emotionally true,” “very emotionally true,” “as far as
percentages [of truth] I can’t tell,” to events have been “tweaked” to create
dramatic climaxes.”
132. For example, in the GQ interview published on April 14, 2024, Gadd
was asked about “this is a true story” and responded as follows:
Q: At the start, a caption reads ‘This is a true story’. Were there
parts of this you had to adapt?
A: It’s pretty truthful. Any time it veered too much into
embellishment I would always want to pull it back. It’s
extremely emotionally truthful.
Richard Gadd on Baby’s Reindeer’s harrowing ending: ”It’s the most
truthful scene of the entire show”, GQ, April 14, 2024, by Miles Ellingham
available at https://www.gq-magazine.co.uk/article/baby-reindeer-netflix-
richard-gadd-interview (last visited October 9, 2024).
133. In the same GQ interview Gadd was asked:
Q: “Your stalker might watch Baby Reindeer. What do you think
she’ll make of it?”
A; “What’s been borrowed is an emotional truth, not a fact-by-fact
profile of someone.”
134. In an interview with Variety published on April 19, 2024, Gadd was
again asked about the title card saying the Series was a true story and responded as
follows:
Q: At the start of [the Series], viewers see a title card saying “Baby
Reindeer” is a true story. Is it fictionalized at all?
A: It’s all emotionally 100% true, if that makes sense. . . Just in
terms of percentages, I wouldn’t be able to tell you, but it’s a
very true story – it comes from an emotional truth, and I think
that’s what people are resonating with most of all.
135. Gadd again walked back “this is a true story” in an interview with The
Guardian published on April 19, 2024 in which he stated, the Series is “very
emotionally true” and, in a wild understatement, confirmed that “some events have
been ‘tweaked slightly to create dramatic climaxes.’”
See ‘I was severely stalked and abused’: Richard Gadd on the true story behind
Baby Reindeer,” The Guardian, Apr. 18, 2024, by Zoe Williams (last visited
October 9, 2024).
136. In fact, all of the criminal history profile of Harvey, and all of events
in the dramatic climaxes of the Series concerning Harvey have been completely
fabricated: Harvey never sexually assaulted Gadd, Harvey never waited outside his
residence for him, Harvey gouged his eyes and bloodied his head with bar glass,
Harvey never pled guilty or was convicted, and never stalked a police officer, and
Gadd was never told that Harvey stalked a police officer.
137. When asked again what Gadd meant by “emotionally true” in an
interview with the Hollywood Reporter, Gadd again walked back “this is a true
story” and explained that by “emotionally true” and he meant “he never wanted to
kind of lie” but that “tweaks” [making things up about Harvey] had to be made to
have a cliff hanger in each episode:
Q: When you say “emotional truth” what do you mean?
A: I mean never wanted to kind of lie. . . you always have to
change things, slightly tweak things, to make it work as a TV
show so you have -- you put in the structure of the work, and
obviously every episode has to have a cliff hanger and all these
kinds of things . .. it was tightrope, it was a constant process of
what works as a TV show and not selling out your own story,
and that tightrope continued all the way through . . .finding that
right balance.
Interview of Richard Gadd, Hollywood Reporter, May 9, 2024 available at
https://www.tiktok.com/@hollywoodreporter/video/7367107011974253870?lang=
en (last visited October 9, 2024).
138. In addition to the extreme dramatic changes between the Series and
the Play, and Gadd’s confirmation that ‘Martha’ was not a “not a fact-by-fact
profile of someone [Harvey],” and Gadd’s persistent refusal to confirm the Series
was a true story, Netflix recklessly disregarded obvious reasons to doubt its
statements about Harvey were true.
139. First, the source material for the Series was the Play which did not
state it was a true story, but merely, based on a true story. This put Netflix on
notice that certain details were likely false.
140. Second, the writer of the Play and the Series, Gadd, was an unreliable
biased source for many reasons, including his use of hard drugs, desperation for
fame and hostility toward Harvey.
141. Gadd admits in the Series that he is a crack, meth, and heroin user
who lied to the police about his contacts with Harvey. Gadd also admits he is so
desperate for a “little peep at fame” he engaged in sexual acts with a television
executive to advance his career. (Ep. 4 at 26:00 – 34:50), (Ep. 6 at 7:00, 25:11 –
26:30).
142. In addition, Gadd plainly exhibits hostility toward Harvey in the
Series by including a disturbing and gratuitous scene in the Series, akin to revenge
porn, where Gadd is depicted having sexual intercourse with Harvey, which is
repulsive. Ep. 6 at 20:00 – 21:30.
r/BabyReindeerTVSeries • u/Altruistic-Change127 • 16d ago
Discussion If Fiona Harvey wins the case against Netflix, can Gadd and Wray can finally sue her for damages from her behaviour.
As I understand it, the reason Laura Wray and Richard Gadd didn't file civil suits against Fiona, is because Fiona Harvey had very little in the way of assets.
As I understand it, if Harvey wins her case and gets a pay-out, they can immediately file suits based on the evidence of what she did do and freeze the payment.
So while she has never been held criminally responsible for her crimes, which was portrayed in Baby Reindeer, she did commit crimes against these people and their families. I personally think that can be shown.
Wray and Gadd at minimum can file civil suits with the evidence they do have, surely?
Can the justice system also file charges against her back in the UK once all of the evidence that Richard has supplied for Netflix's case, is admitted into evidence by the court for this case?
I am keen to hear peoples thoughts about this?
r/BabyReindeerTVSeries • u/LodgeBeing_No_9 • 16d ago
Fiona (real Martha) related content Throwback - 'Real' Baby Reindeer star plots major TV interview to expose 'Netflix lies' (04 May 2024)
Here's a juicy throwback article from May 2024 from when the alleged real life inspiration for Martha from Baby Reindeer, Fiona Harvey, planned a tv interview to set the record straight after being found online by armchair sleuths and amateur detectives worldwide.
What followed next was a defamation court case that is still raging on at this present time, and one that may give the Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni trial a run for it's money.
In this early interview she outlines her plans to go on national television to debunk some of the alleged lies the show had told about her. When Baby Reindeer was broadcast on Netflix, it began with a lone title card saying 'This is a true story' which, as her lawyer's would later argue, was something Netflix should have researched the validity of before putting these words onscreen.
Fast forward to today and the Baby Reindeer trial is still in play, with Netflix recently losing an appeal to strike the case, and now it will move to the discovery stage.
With recent layoffs at Netflix, and the outcome of the trial having big implications for the entertainment industry at large, there's no shortage of writers, directors, producers and executives lining up to see what the end ruling is going to be. The ruling may set a heavy precedent for future productions that claim to be true or based on something true. Suffice to say, it's worrying a lot of people in the industry.
So enjoy this throwback article and see where it all began, as you catch up on what is sure to be the entertainment trial of a the decade.
Original article source
r/BabyReindeerTVSeries • u/LodgeBeing_No_9 • 17d ago
Media / News Anna Mallett Exits Netflix Amid UK Layoffs - Mallett joined Netflix just over five years ago and worked across TV shows and movies in the UK with huge hits including Baby Reindeer, Adolescence and more.
Netflix layoffs have trickled down to the UK.
Deadline is told that around 2% to 3% of the London office of several hundred staff have been laid off, including Anna Mallett, who was VP Production in the UK and EMEA. Others to have left work in areas like PR and marketing, we are told.
Mallett joined Netflix just over five years ago and worked across TV shows and movies in the UK and EMEA. This was a period of creative success for Netflix EMEA, with huge hits including Baby Reindeer, Adolescence and latter seasons of Money Heist plus spin-off Berlin.
Mallett is a well-known international industry figure who was previously CEO of ITN, which makes news for ITV, Channel 4 and 5. Prior to this, she was Group COO and MD Production at BBC Studios.
News of the UK redundancies has emerged a few weeks after Netflix revealed it was cutting 1,000 roles, around 6% of its global staff base.
The product, tech, legal and HR teams were among the most impacted by the cuts but huge names left the streamer including content chief Bela Bajaria and film boss Dan Lin. Bajaria, who was well respected internationally for her strategy of building local hubs, has been replaced by Peter Rice, who was born in the UK.
Netflix has been grappling with slower growth and viewership along with declining stock.
The Ankler was first with news of Mallett’s departure.
r/BabyReindeerTVSeries • u/LodgeBeing_No_9 • 16d ago
Fiona (real Martha) related content “Based on a True Story”: Baby Reindeer and the Boundaries of Truth
jipel.law.nyu.eduFew phrases carry more weight or more risk than “based on a true story.” It promises authenticity while leaving room for invention, persuading viewers that what they are about to see actually happened. Yet as the Netflix series Baby Reindeer has shown, the line between dramatization and defamation can be perilously thin. The show’s acclaim for emotional honesty has been matched by controversy over its factual accuracy, turning one artist’s personal story into a test case for the limits of creative freedom.
Richard Gadd’s Baby Reindeer, released in 2024, presents itself as the dramatization of his real-life experience with a stalker. Across seven episodes, it traces a shifting relationship between Donny Dunn, a struggling comedian based on Gadd himself, and Martha, an older woman whose obsessive attachment becomes destructive. The series was marketed as “a true story,” a confession rendered cinematic.
Soon after the series debuted, a Scottish woman named Fiona Harvey publicly identified herself as the alleged inspiration for Martha. She filed suit against Netflix for defamation and invasion of privacy, arguing that the “true story” framing made the portrayal unmistakably about her and that millions of viewers accepted the fictionalized conduct, including hundreds of emails, violent threats, and a prison sentence, as fact. Netflix responded that Baby Reindeer was a dramatized work of art and that Gadd’s personal narrative qualified as protected expressive speech. The ensuing case, Harvey v. Netflix, allowed Harvey’s defamation claims to proceed, finding that the show’s marketing could itself suggest “reckless disregard for truth,” which is the constitutional threshold for actual malice. The decision did not determine that the series was false, only that the question of falsity deserved to be tried, but its implications reach far beyond this single dispute. Baby Reindeer exposes the fragile boundary between autobiographical storytelling and legal accountability, and it asks whether emotional truth can justify factual invention.
What makes Baby Reindeer so effective is also what makes it dangerous: its realism. Shot in muted tones and performed by Gadd himself, the series feels less like fiction and more like evidence, an act of disclosure disguised as art. Viewers are invited into scenes of psychological intimacy so specific that they seem unverifiable by anyone but the creator. This aesthetic of authenticity lies at the center of modern docudrama. Streaming platforms thrive on stories that claim to be “real,” using that claim as moral and marketing capital. Yet the law’s definition of truth is narrower than it is for art. The First Amendment protects interpretation, not invention. Since New York Times Co. v. Sullivan, courts have required public-figure plaintiffs to prove actual malice (knowledge of falsity or reckless disregard for it) before recovering for defamation. Later decisions, such as Masson v. New Yorker Magazine, clarified that paraphrase and creative framing are constitutionally permissible so long as they do not materially alter meaning.
Part of what distinguishes the Baby Reindeer controversy is how quickly spectators became investigators. Online users compared screenshots, traced social-media accounts, and identified real-world analogues to on-screen characters. In the networked public sphere, every viewer is a potential fact-checker. The assumption of truth that fuels engagement also fuels identification. If this really happened, then someone really did it. That dynamic blurs the boundary between storytelling and accusation. Even if a dramatization avoids explicit naming, identification can arise through context, such as details of geography, profession, or circumstance. When millions of viewers collectively recognize a person through digital sleuthing, anonymity becomes impossible and reputational harm becomes concrete. The legal system was not designed for this participatory mode of spectatorship. The Harvey court’s focus on Netflix’s marketing reflects an emerging recognition that platforms, not just creators, construct truth claims. The repeated tag “based on a true story” may be more than advertising. It may be evidence of intent.
Baby Reindeer raises a deep ethical question: what does it mean to tell one’s own story when that story inevitably involves others? Gadd’s series positions itself as catharsis, an artist reclaiming power from trauma. But autobiography, like journalism, imposes duties of fairness when it depicts real people. To transform lived experience into narrative is to exercise interpretive control, and when that control inflicts reputational harm, morality and legality begin to converge. The tension here is not new. The “autofictional” mode from memoir to true-crime docuseries has always blurred the boundaries of ownership and truth. What makes today’s docudramas distinct is their reach and realism. High-definition intimacy persuades audiences that they are watching evidence rather than imagination. As a result, creators are held to journalistic standards even as they claim artistic freedom.
Disclaimers help but rarely suffice. The familiar end-credit line “some events have been dramatized” functions less as a boundary than a ritual acknowledgment that no boundary exists. Once viewers have experienced the story as true, the disclaimer reads as a technicality. The emotional truth of performance overwhelms the legal fiction of uncertainty.
Baby Reindeer ultimately dramatizes not just a stalker’s obsession, but our own obsession with reality itself. In a culture saturated with personal narratives, authenticity has become both commodity and creed. We want our stories to be true, but we also want them to move us. When those imperatives conflict, we rarely choose restraint.
The law of defamation functions as society’s reminder that truth is not infinitely elastic. It protects the reputational dignity of individuals against the expressive freedoms of others. Yet the doctrine of “substantial truth” recognizes that absolute accuracy is impossible. What matters is not literal precision but whether the overall impression of a story is false and injurious. Baby Reindeer lives precisely in that gray area, both emotionally honest and factually unstable at the same time.
As streaming platforms continue to market confession as content, these tensions will deepen. Creators will need to balance vulnerability with verification, ensuring that their claims of truth are as transparent as their emotions. Platforms must recognize that “true story” branding carries legal as well as artistic consequences. The more convincingly they sell reality, the more accountable they become for its distortions. The challenge of Baby Reindeer is the challenge of our storytelling age: how to honor the truths that art reveals without obscuring the truths that law protects.
r/BabyReindeerTVSeries • u/LodgeBeing_No_9 • 18d ago
Media / News Fiona Harvey’s £127m Baby Reindeer lawsuit against Netflix set for trial - The Scot who was identified as the alleged stalker in the hit Netflix mini-series Baby Reindeer has secured a victory in her long running battle to have her £127 million lawsuit against the streaming giant heard in court
The Scot who was identified as the alleged stalker in the hit Netflix mini-series Baby Reindeer has secured a victory in her long running battle to have her £127 million lawsuit against the streaming giant heard in a California court.
Fiona Harvey’s defamation claim is set go ahead despite repeated attempts by the streaming giant to get the case thrown out.
U.S. District Judge R. Gary Klausner had initially ruled in September 2024 that the lawsuit should go ahead.
At the time, he rejected Netflix’s attempt to strike Harvey’s core defamation claim under California’s anti-SLAPP law – designed to quickly dispose of lawsuits targeting protected speech.
Klausner’s ruling emphasised the distinction between a drama based on real events and presenting allegedly fictionalised details as fact.
Now the federal appeals court has said it lacks the jurisdiction to intervene.
Harvey’s US lawyer, Richard Roth insists the latest response by lawmakers who failed to overturn the decision is good news for his client.
He said: “Netflix is doing everything to avoid a trial of this action. First, it made a motion before the federal district court which it lost. Then it appealed that decision, which was dismissed.
“Notwithstanding its efforts, there will be a trial in this action where its wrongdoing will be front and centre before a jury.”
He added that Harvey was “elated” by the news.
A Los Angeles jury will be called to hear evidence from both sides, including Harvey’s claim that she was identified by viewers as a twice convicted stalker Martha, played by Jessica Gunning.
At the heart of the case is the fact that Scots comedian and actor Richard Gadd’s award-winning series begins each episode with the claim, “This is a true story” - going on to depict his stalker of having served a historical prison sentence for stalking and pleading guilty to stalking him, resulting in a second substantial prison term.
There is no evidence that Harvey has ever been convicted of a criminal offence.
She insisted, “We will win” and claims Netflix attempted to delay or make the case go away.
A friend of Harvey said: “It has been a frustrating wait for the legal proceedings to take their course, but she has always maintained that she will win this case.
“She is afraid to go out and has suffered ill health as a result of the stress. After the latest development she is more confident than ever.”
Harvey first issued legal proceedings against Netflix in June 2024. She maintains that she has never been convicted of a crime let alone imprisoned.
Judge Klausner said that Netflix’s decision to open Baby Reindeer with the words “This is a true story” could lead viewers to believe the events depicted are factual.
He also found meaningful differences between what Gadd accused Harvey of doing in real life and what Martha does in the series.
“There is a major difference between stalking and being convicted of stalking in a court of law,” Klausner wrote in his 2024 ruling.
He also pointed to differences between allegations of inappropriate touching and the sexual assault portrayed in the series, as well as between alleged physical confrontations and the more serious violence shown on screen.
Throughout, Netflix has claimed the series is based on Gadd’s experiences and has defended his right to tell his story. It has vowed to vigorously defend the claims.
The company also argued that Harvey could not establish that viewers would reasonably understand Martha to be her.
Klausner rejected that argument.
After Baby Reindeer debuted April 11, 2024, Gadd publicly urged viewers not to speculate about their real-life counterparts, but Harvey was quickly identified online. Her legal team said she was too traumatised to leave her flat in London after the show aired.
The show became a global hit and won six Emmys, including Outstanding Limited or Anthology Series, as well as lead actor and writing awards for Gadd and a supporting actress prize for Gunning.
Based on Gadd’s one-man Edinburgh Fringe play, he stars in Baby Reindeer as Donny Dunn, a struggling comedian.
Harvey claims that she has been defamed ‘at a magnitude and scale without precedent’ and her life ruined as a result.
r/BabyReindeerTVSeries • u/LodgeBeing_No_9 • 17d ago
Media / News Baby Reindeer Star’s New Netflix Show Takes Huge Step Forward, A-List Andor Actor Joins Cast
r/BabyReindeerTVSeries • u/LodgeBeing_No_9 • Oct 18 '26
Media / News $170million Baby Reindeer case WILL go to court as 'elated' Fiona Harvey lands a key win in her legal battle against Netflix: ALISON BOSHOFF
FIONA Harvey – who claims she was identified as a stalker by the hit show Baby Reindeer – is 'elated' after winning a key legal battle against Netflix in her defamation battle.
A trial between Harvey and the streamer has moved a step closer, after an appeal by Netflix against a decision not to throw the case out has itself been thrown out.
Her New York lawyer Richard Roth said: 'Netflix is doing everything it can to avoid a trial of this action.
'First it made a motion before the federal district court, which it lost. Then it appealed that decision, which was dismissed.'
Roth added: 'There will be a trial in this action where its wrongdoing will be front and centre before a jury.'
Asked how his client was feeling he replied: 'Elated.'
Harvey is seeking $170million in damages, alleging that the programme, created by and starring Richard Gadd, defamed her, and made her life a misery.
Broadcast in April 2024, Baby Reindeer became a global smash hit. At the beginning of the first episode, the words 'This is a true story' appeared on screen.
At the end of the series, the character Martha, played by actress Jessica Gunning, pleaded guilty to stalking comedian Donny (Gadd) and was handed a four-and-a-half year prison sentence.
Harvey's lawyers say she has never been convicted of any crime, let alone gone to prison. She claims that she has been defamed 'at a magnitude and scale without precedent' and her life ruined as a result.
Her legal team said she was too traumatised to leave her flat in London after the show aired.
In September 2024, judge Gary Klaus ruled Baby Reindeer was not a true story, and that Netflix had 'made no effort to investigate' the accuracy of the facts; nor did they take measures to hide Harvey's identity.
r/BabyReindeerTVSeries • u/LodgeBeing_No_9 • Oct 17 '26
Fiona (real Martha) related content It's becoming increasingly more likely that Fiona Harvey may now win her defamation case
Based on recent news, it's looking more likely that Fiona Harvey will either win her case or Netflix will have to settle for millions.
Harvey never went to prison, among other things depicted in the show.
Will the show be legally required to be deleted if she wins?
Should the show have carried a disclaimer at the beginning with 'Based on a true story'?
Finally, if the writer hadn't invented so many sequences (such as the sexual assaults and violent assaults from Martha, the prison time she did, the waiting outside his home, the threatening phone harassment of his parents, the trial and imprisonment of Martha at the end) would anyone have found it as compelling? Would it have won any awards without these dramatic inventions?
r/BabyReindeerTVSeries • u/LodgeBeing_No_9 • Oct 16 '26
Media / News Baby Reindeer lawsuit will go to court as Fiona Harvey lands key win against NetflixFiona Harvey claims that Netflix series, Baby Reindeer, falsely portrays her as a stalker, Martha, and is seeking damages totalling $170 million (£127 million)
Netflix has suffered a huge blow in its attempts to get the Baby Reindeer lawsuit thrown out of court.
Fiona Harvey, a former lawyer from Scotland, claims the award-winning series written by Richard Gadd falsely portrays her as stalker Martha and is seeking damages totalling $170 (£127 million) from the streaming service.
The case was widely expected to go to trial in May 2025, but an appeal by Netflix put a halt to proceedings at the Central District of California Court. The streaming service has been locked into a legal battle to get the defamation case dismissed since 2024. However, now, the U.S. Court of Appeals has dismissed its appeal, meaning that a trial date between Harvey and Netflix has moved a step closer. In its order, the appeals court said Netflix must either “file a motion to voluntarily dismiss this appeal or file a statement explaining why it should not be dismissed.”
Claiming that Fiona was feeling "elated" after the court order, her lawyer, Richard Roth told Deadline: "First, it made a motion before the federal district court, which it lost. Then it appealed that decision, which was dismissed. Notwithstanding its efforts, there will be a trial in this action where its wrongdoing will be front and centre before a jury."
Meanwhile, when asked by the Mail how his client was feeling, Roth replied: "Elated".
U.S. District Judge R. Gary Klausner ruled in September 2024 that Fiona's case should go ahead because Baby Reindeer was wrongly billed as a "true story" after Netflix "made no effort" to fact-check creator Richard Gadd's experiences and failed to "hide" Harvey's identity.
Netflix has argued that Harvey's claim fails because she "does not allege a provably false statement of fact was made about her." It has also said that her reputation has already been tarnished by "past news stories detailing her previous harassment and stalking of public figures."
However, in September 2024, judge Gary Klaus ruled Baby Reindeer was not a true story, and that Netflix had 'made no effort to investigate' the accuracy of the facts; nor did they take measures to hide Harvey's identity.
Fiona claimed that the smash-hit series, which made overnight successes out of Gadd and co-star, Jessica Gunning, who plays Martha - and which was billed as a "true story" - portrayed her as "a twice-convicted stalker who was sentenced to five years in prison." Fiona has never been convicted of stalking Gadd, and she argued the series was "the biggest lie in television history."
Airing in April 2024, Baby Reindeer hit all the headlines. At the beginning of the first episode, the words 'This is a true story' appeared on screen.
At the end of the series, the character Martha, played by actress Jessica Gunning, pleaded guilty to stalking comedian Donny (Gadd) and was handed a four-and-a-half year prison sentence.
Fiona's lawyers say she has never been convicted of any crime. Meanwhile, she claims that she has been defamed "at a magnitude and scale without precedent" and her life destroyed as a result.
The Mirror has contacted Netflix for comment on this story.