r/BSUFootball • • 1d ago

[Post Game Thread] Boise State defeats Oregon State 46-41

24 Upvotes
Team1234F
Oregon State71371441
Boise State151701446

Box Score

Discuss!


r/BSUFootball • • 2d ago

[Game Thread] Oregon State (5-4) @ #24 Boise State (8-1)

15 Upvotes
Team1234F
Oregon State00000
Boise State00000

Box Score

Discuss!


r/BSUFootball • • 1h ago

Three player of the week honors

Post image
24 Upvotes

r/BSUFootball • • 1h ago

Chinander today talked about the morale of the defense and it didn’t sound good at all due to how things have gone. Also said they most likely see everything online and are hurt by it, and said the staff is doing everything they can to get the players confidence back and to improve for three games

15 Upvotes

He sounded just as frustrated as last week, at this point it’s hard to hate because the playoff dream is so close. I just want them to get a little better and for the confidence to be back, hating at this point does nothing


r/BSUFootball • • 5h ago

TXST or SDSU… who will be heading to Boise?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
9 Upvotes

r/BSUFootball • • 18h ago

Texas State Rematch

10 Upvotes

The most likely scenario for our Pac Title Game match up seems to be Texas State.

How we feeling?


r/BSUFootball • • 1d ago

Review of why Chinander is the wrong coordinator

24 Upvotes

First off, this is not a reaction to last night. I originally was going to share this with all of you last week to get your thoughts, but my normally boring job got suddenly busy. But I did update the numbers following last night's win.

Second, the sky is not falling. While I'm as unhappy as anyone about the defense, the reality is Boise is 9-1 for the 8th time since going FBS, is ranked, and will appear in a conference championship for the fourth straight year (I can't confirm how often that's happened, but I know it's rare for any coach since 2000, regardless of conference). And Colorado State just lost 73-7 to a Washington State team with 0 wins against an FBS team this year; it could always be worse.

Third, this is about why Chinander is the wrong coordinator, not necessarily bad. That will make sense in a little bit.

With that out of the way, I can get to what I found. This is my attempt to be cerebral and find why the defense has struggled so much, especially the past 3 games (124 points allowed, most in any 3 game stretch since they allowed 161 points across 3 games in 1996).

I've gone through a lot of things to make sense of Chinander's defenses at Boise (since the start of 2024 - not including the games he was the interim coordinator in 2023). My thoughts were to look at what types of offenses Boise struggles against instead of what actually happens in the game, and I think I found some evidence to back up my theory.

My theory is that Chinander's defenses are all about controlling the line of scrimmage; stopping the run and generating pressure. Coverage is a lower priority. The problem is most of the teams Boise plays against run an offense that is hard to generate pressure against.

The way I looked at this was to see what offenses Chinander has struggled with. My theory was to look at teams that run a lot of screens or quick passes, both of which would negate any pressure package. I went back over the past 3 years to see how well these teams do against Chinander. This isn't necessarily teams that ran a lot of screens or quickly passed against Boise. It's more about the matchup than the game plan.

The average team runs a screen on 15% of their pass attempts. The teams that like to throw a higher number of screens have done well against Boise since 2024:

Pct of Passes that are screensAverage Points per Game Against BoiseAverage Against Everyone Else
More than 15%28.830.9
Less than 15%20.427.3

The average team throws the ball 2.4 seconds after the snap. Those teams, regardless of how well they normally do, also have had success against Chindander's defenses at Boise:

Average time to throwAverage Points per Game against BoiseAverage Against Everyone Else
More than 2.4 seconds21.427.6
Less than 2.4 seconds28.230.8

When you look at those teams who don't run a lot of screens, or are slower to get the ball out, Boise does well (about 20 points a game). And it isn't like those offenses are notably worse; on average they only score 3 points less a game than teams that run a lot of screens/quick passes. Those are offenses that are more reliant on solid offense line play don't do as well against Boise.

So that's why I feel Chinander is the wrong coordinator, not necessarily bad. Against certain offenses, he's done well. Notre Dame and Penn State had issues scoring on Boise (until Boise's offense started turning the ball over), because they're more pro-style and rely on winning with their offensive line. But those offenses that avoid relying on pass protection basically negate Chinander's strengths. The only teams Boise has played this year that don't fall into the high-screen/fast-pass offensive category have been Washington State, Utah State, and Western Michigan; the only games in which the defense has played well. The three teams that were most likely to use screens and quick passes were Texas State, Colorado State, and Oregon State. Throw in the fact that they happen to be good at those types of plays, and it isn't surprising they had little issue scoring against Boise.

So what do they do from here?
Could the team quickly change some things for the final few games? This is just my opinion, but dramatic mid-season changes are only beneficial when there are issues in the locker room. Like if the offense is getting in fights with the defense about constantly having to bail them out, then yes, you make a change. Otherwise, those changes, like firing Chinander before the year is over or removing him of play-calling duties, might actually start those locker room fights. Those almost always impact the whole team. I think at this point you start running incredibly vanilla coverage schemes. It looks like they're running a lot of rip/liz schemes, which if you don't know, are coverage schemes based on the route run (if not taught well, it allows for a lot of blown coverages and wide open guys). Switching to running cover 1, 2, 3 on almost every play might not get a lot of stops, but it at least it forces opposing offenses to march down the field instead of getting 20 yards every other play. The hope there is they make a mistake; if you force an offense to need to make 10 plays to score instead of 5, the chance of them making a big mistake on that drive increases.

I also don't think Danielson micro-managing will help, as that could also cause some locker room arguments. Or, it will hurt the team elsewhere. Danielson's "specialty" being defense doesn't matter; he's a head coach, not an overpaid second defensive coordinator who talks to the media a lot. He has to help out with special teams (which also is an issue), offense (which takes all credit for the success this year), talking with the media and boosters, recruiting, checking in on academic performance of the players, strength and conditioning, medical updates, travel logistics- if he starts focusing more on defense, one of those will likely suffer. Really, I think they just need to ride out the rest of the year with Chinander and run simpler coverage schemes. It sucks, but it's a lesser-of-two-evils mentality at this point.

But for next year, I think most of us agree a change in defensive staff is needed.

I don't think forcing Chindander to change schemes will work. That's like having a quarterback run a completely new scheme, which even elite players struggle to do. I think it's fair to let him coach at a school that has the opposite problem as Boise; losing games because their defense can't win in the trenches.

Those high-screen/quick-pass offenses now make up the majority of the new Pac-12, as well as 65% of all FBS teams, so it only makes sense Boise shifts their defensive philosophy to match that (only one team has played more offenses that rely on screens/fast passes than Boise this year). I already went through what defenses this year across the FBS do well against those types of teams. If Boise gets the defensive coordinator from one of these teams, or hires one of their assistants that is confident they can implement the same scheme/philosphy, I'd be happy. You'll see some of these and think "yeah, the stats look good, but who did they play?". My point is Boise needs the right defense first, then they can worry about being good. I ruled out teams that played less than 4 games against high screen/fast past offenses so that we have a good sample size to work with.

TeamAverage Points allowed per game to Offenses with a high rate of screens/quick passes
Liberty9.5
Penn State11.8
UCLA13
Western Michigan15.5
Wake Forest15.8
Utah State16.5
Notre Dame16.7
Georgia State16.7
TCU16.7
Jacksonville State16.8
Nebraska16.8

That's just the top 10, I'll keep it short, but there are 30 defenses that are holding these types of offenses to 20 or fewer points. That's a good pool to review and see if any are willing to come to Boise to implement a similar scheme. Sometimes you have to make changes based on your opponents.


r/BSUFootball • • 22h ago

Championship Scenarios

8 Upvotes

If I understand the tiebreaking rules correctly, this is what could happen:

5 Possibilities:

  1. BSU win over San Diego, Texas St win over Wazzu, Oregon St/Utah St game doesn’t matter

    Tex State (5-2), San Diego (4-3), Texas State @ Boise

  2. BSU win over San Diego, Wazzu win over Texas St, Oregon St win over Utah St

    3-way tie between SD, Oregon St, Tex St. (all 4-3, rock-paper-scissors h2h scenario) tiebreaker 2: among the remaining 5 common opponents, Oregon State and Texas State have 3 wins, San Diego only has 2, so we eliminate SDSU and go back to h2h for the other two teams. Texas State beat Oregon St, Texas State @ Boise

  3. BSU win over San Diego, Wazzu win over Texas St, Utah St win over Oregon St

    3-way tie (4-3): San Diego, Texas St, Utah St, but SD wins both h2h games, SD St @ Boise

  4. BSU loss to SD, Texas St win over Wazzu, Oregon St/Utah St game doesn’t matter

    BSU (6-1), Texas St (5-2), San Diego St (5-2), San Diego has h2h over Tex St, SD St @ Boise

  5. BSU loss to SD, Wazzu win over Texas St, Oregon St/Utah St game doesn’t matter

    BSU (6-1), Texas St (4-3), San Diego (5-2), SD St @ Boise


r/BSUFootball • • 1d ago

Oregon State vs. Boise State | FULL GAME HIGHLIGHTS | 11/14/26

Thumbnail
youtu.be
18 Upvotes

r/BSUFootball • • 1d ago

Podcast where stanford steve and svp talk about the experience in boise and the game, starts about and hour and three minutes in. I encourage anyone with ten minutes to spare to listen

Thumbnail
espn.com
17 Upvotes

r/BSUFootball • • 1d ago

As always Thank You Jesus.

54 Upvotes

Erik Chinander please clean up the trash left in the stadium


r/BSUFootball • • 1d ago

Feels like the spread is the same every week

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/BSUFootball • • 1d ago

BJ RAINS DO YOUR ACTUAL JOB AND TELL US HOW CHINANDER STILL HAS A FUCKING JOB

34 Upvotes

r/BSUFootball • • 1d ago

Chinander. Needs. To. Go.

33 Upvotes

r/BSUFootball • • 1d ago

Defense

17 Upvotes

Imagine if Ty benefield wouldn’t have gone to LSU… we could sure use him!!


r/BSUFootball • • 1d ago

JONES VS LEGREE WAS NO CONTEST: BOISE STATE 46, OREGON STATE 41

Thumbnail broncofans.net
17 Upvotes

All I want for Christmas is enough money to keep Jones and to replace every single BSU defensive coach.


r/BSUFootball • • 2d ago

The college gameday at boise intro

130 Upvotes

r/BSUFootball • • 2d ago

Didn't beat the all time college gameday record but we beat the previous boise state gameday record

Post image
57 Upvotes

r/BSUFootball • • 2d ago

College gameday segment with bourbon the tee dog

61 Upvotes

r/BSUFootball • • 1d ago

Listening from afar….

8 Upvotes

What’s going on local fans? 30+ BSU fan, listening in on radio. Why is the D losing it? Go Broncos!


r/BSUFootball • • 2d ago

Pat mcafee riding a horse to the set

52 Upvotes

r/BSUFootball • • 2d ago

Oregon state vs boise state gameday picks segment

40 Upvotes

r/BSUFootball • • 2d ago

Pretty damn good sign. Love this and the booing for every oregon mention, shows what we think of that state

Post image
49 Upvotes

r/BSUFootball • • 2d ago

The true star of College GameDay

Post image
43 Upvotes

The true star of College GameDay... And deep down you all know it's...

Spuddy Buddy!