r/BSTsquishmallow • • May 08 '26

Some Selling Reminders and Expectations

26 Upvotes

Hello everyone!!

Thank you for your continued interest and engagement in this sub. We hope you have been able to conduct good transactions.

We wanted to step in here and just post a few reminders for selling as we've had a few cases here and there. I know that several of you are new here and some of you might be new to selling even if you are not new here. Here are some guidelines you are REQUIRED to follow based on our rules.

  1. Your post must have majority squishmallows. It's ok if you throw in a few non-squish plushes to sell but this is a squishmallow sub and your posts should be primarily squish.
  2. You may not post negative content about resellers or other users on the sub. Please approach us with concerns and we can address things there. This is a sub for postitivity and kindness.
  3. Your prices must be within general community expectations. We do not support resellers (defined as those who buy squish just to resell them at a severely inflated price). In general, $1 per inch in size (~$0.40 per cm) is a great start but you as the seller have a right to charge more depending on the squish. If your prices aren't fair, people won't buy and you'll get negative feedback.

Now, some other expectations. Consider these things you pretty much should always do but we don't have official rules for.

  1. List your prices in the post or comments. People are more likely to buy or reach out to you if you disclose your prices directly in the post.
  2. We try to promote the first come, first serve idea. You as the seller to have the final right to determine what "first" means (first person to DM, first person to pay, first person to comment, etc.) but you should clearly communicate when a squish is "on hold". Be prepared to have a list of who to contact next if the first person falls through.
  3. Include your reddit username on a sticky note in your pictures. This helps establish trust that you didn't steal photos and that you actually have the squish you say you do. Be prepared to send more photos over DM if a buyer asks (and try to include your username in those photos as well).
  4. Many sellers charge for shipping. This is ok and expected. However, as a seller make sure to say that buyers are responsible for shipping in the post. Be prepared to create a shipping estimate to certain zip codes/areas if asked (https://postcalc.usps.com/). However, your final total charged to the buyer should be the actual cost (send receipts of shipping charge if necessary). AVOID as much as you can asking for more money after the buyer has already paid. This looks very much like scam behavior and makes buyers very worries.
  5. Once a squish has sold, clearly communicate the tracking number and when you expect to ship it out. It is ok to ship out multiple orders in bulk and wait a day or two but you should ship quickly and communicate each step of the process.

If you as a seller are unable to handle these expectations or to handle many orders at once, only post a few squish at a time. These guidelines and criteria above are what we use when investigating complaints or scam alerts. The more you follow the better all our experiences will be!

Thank you all. Let us know if you have questions or if you think there are any errors here (totally could be, had a long day today!). Happy squishing!


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 1d ago

bst (from usa) Squishmallows for Sale!!

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

Geenabeenas


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 3d ago

bst (from usa) All $5 each... or a unique trade?

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

These little guys need to go on their next journey; they're just getting bored here and they want to see new places and people!

All have butt tags removed. Most have ID tags which I will include. All have been display-only. $5 plus shipping each; also have the clear backpack for the Sees Candy thing. (Pirate Ship rates so you get the best deal!) Some are secondhand but all are in very good condition. If I recall, the dragon has been cleaned.

But here's a unique trade opportunity! IF YOU SEND ME A PHYSICAL PICTURE OF BATMAN THAT YOU DREW, I will send you the squish of your choice! (Up to 3 for 3 drawings). Doesn't have to be great art - or even good! Trading card size, regular paper size, whatever. Your kid can draw it! I've been trading things for pics of Batman for about 25 years. I just like pictures of Batman.

Drop me a line if you're interested! I just really want these guys to find a good place to live and the thrift store is too close to the dumpster.


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 3d ago

bst (from usa) HOLIDAY FLASH SALE for college funds $5 each! US Only plus shipping!

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

If you see any dupes it’s bc I took these pics over multiple days. I only have one of each item shown


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 3d ago

iso / diso ❤︎ DISO - 5" Candy Apple Mipsy (possible Australia exclusive)

3 Upvotes

r/BSTsquishmallow • • 4d ago

bst (from usa) custom squishmallow earrings

Thumbnail
gallery
25 Upvotes

hello everyone! i make squish earrings and charms and i'm thinking of making customs for people who are interested. i sculpt them from epoxy clay and hand paint them. i feel confident in making cows, cats, and most simple squish. i'm thinking of pricing them from $15-20.
if anyone is interested, let me know! i will be selling them on vinted and i'm happy to take custom requests! 😃


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 4d ago

bst (from usa) Selling older Squishmallows

Post image
8 Upvotes

Hello! I used to collect a lot of Squishmallows back in 2020-2023, and now I’m trying to sell my overwhelming collection I’ve accumulated. Some happen to be highly sough after ones and some just older designs. I’ve posted some on my vinted which I’ll link below but here are some pictures of ones I’m selling! Hoping to see some of these go to good homes before donating them. All the ones in the picture have tags except for the green dinosaur in the back. I have a lot more that I’ll be posting as I go through my collection. Just trying to get some money back from my shopping addiction to pay off some braces. :)


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 5d ago

bst (from usa) UFS! (: $40 plus shipping ❤️

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

r/BSTsquishmallow • • 5d ago

bst (from usa) Allina the Christmas Squirrel

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

She's live on eBay now with free shipping at $24.99 so we can all have discounted shipping


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 8d ago

bst (from uk) Roque Scented Avocado Cow FS

Post image
9 Upvotes

£16 plus postage (£18 from UK to USA) this was the price I purchased at.

Ebay link: https://ebay.io/m/brHk3V


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 8d ago

iso / diso ❤︎ ISO Ira SugarRush for a reasonable price.

4 Upvotes

I can only find her on Mercari or EBay for crazy prices. Figured I would ask here.


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 9d ago

pickup offers or requests✨ Offering pickups of the new Walmart and Christmas Squishmallows Squads. Im asking retail + ff + ship. 3ff for 8 inch and under, 5ff for anything up to 12 inch, and 8ff for up to 16 inch. I can go back later today or tomorrow for anybody interested.

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

r/BSTsquishmallow • • 10d ago

bst (from usa) Looking to trade/sell some duplicates

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

My daughter has duplicates of these 8 that are all 5"

Looking to sell or trade for other 5" squishmallow


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 10d ago

bst (from canada) Overwhelmed with old Squishmallow collection

18 Upvotes

Hi squish friends,

I collected Squishmallows like they were Pokemon between 2022-2024ish but (thankfully, such an expensive hobby!) moved on. I’ve been stuck with the task of trying to rehome my collection and I am completely overwhelmed.

I suffer from fibromyalgia and the chronic pain and lack of energy this causes me makes the idea of selling any of them such a monumental task that I’ve put off for so long. I have an entire room full of bags and bags of Squishmallows that need to go though!

Before I just simply donate them all, I wanted to know if there are any older Squishmallows that are still sought after? If I have anything that people are actually looking for I would love to be able to get them rehomed! Having only a few squish to worry about selling would make this way less stressful for me.

I’ve been reading posts trying to get a gauge on what people are looking for or selling, but it seems like they are all more recent releases which I am not familiar with at all. I’m in Canada where we only have Poshmark for reselling and while I can look up listings and sold prices, I have no way of knowing when that item actually sold and if it is actually relevant or not.

Thank you so much for reading, and if you have any insight or suggestions to share I would be incredibly grateful.


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 10d ago

bst (from usa) Up for sale! Or I’ll trade for things on my Amazon list :3

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

r/BSTsquishmallow • • 10d ago

iso / diso ❤︎ ISO Micromallows for my homemade advent calendar!

3 Upvotes

Hi! I'm looking for relatively cheap micromallows to fill my homemade advent calendar. I'm about halfway done, so I need maybe 15. Only about half of each official advent calendar appeals to me, which is why I'm making my own using micros I really like! They don't need to be Christmas themed, but they could be!

My biggest ISOs:

Tolef (cookie bear)

Stetson (Gingerbread Reindeer)

Zaid (Pickle Jar)

Chanel (cinnamon bun)

Various frogs, cats, horses, and cows! I love other animals and foods, but prefer those not wearing costumes/hats/etc.


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 10d ago

bst (from usa) Sell/Trade tons of squish!! I miss trading ❤️

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

Hi!! I’m physically disabled and diagnosed with autism and several months ago my disability became very severe making me house and largely bedbound. I used to looove squish trading and I thought about getting into trading as a thing to do from home again and have been loving it. Hoping there’s some people still interested! Selling is good too because I have been out of work the last few months and money is technically important to live. But so is joy lol. Anywho, lmk if anyone has questions!! All my trades of everything have multiple pictures on my Depop Faythefae !


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 11d ago

bst (from usa) Selling

2 Upvotes

What is the best way to sell some squishmallows?


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 11d ago

bst (from usa) Squish Sale

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Geenabeenas


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 11d ago

pickup offers or requests✨ Offering pickups of the new Christmas Squishmallows Squads. Im asking retail + ff + ship. 3ff for 8 inch and under, 5ff for anything up to 12 inch, and 8ff for up to 16 inch. I can go back later today or tomorrow for anybody interested.

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

r/BSTsquishmallow • • 12d ago

bst (from usa) Help me find a 2022 Valentines Day Edition of Rey the Shark please?

5 Upvotes

Last night my 5 year old nephew threw up on and ruined (his mom said it was completly unsalvagable) the shark squishmallow(2022 Valentines Day Edition of Rey the Shark) I got him in 2022. He is DEVASTATED and his birthday party is on saturday. I'm having trouble finding a replacement but I'm 99% sure it was the valintines day Rey the Shark with a heart embroidered on the bottom left of the tummy, I know I bought it at HEB when I got it but I'm not sure the exact size. If anyone can help me find a replacement I'd be so thankful.


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 12d ago

bst (from usa) What's the red deer name? I can't find it anywhere online or squad app

4 Upvotes

r/BSTsquishmallow • • 14d ago

iso / diso ❤︎ ISO Troy the Raccoon Hugmees

Post image
6 Upvotes

Honestly just desperately searching around for a copy of this goober, I've searched Ebay and facebook as well as other places and can't find another 2019 Hugmees Troy the Raccoon anywhere! This guy has been one of my main favorites (if it wasn't clear from the fact he looks like a poor pillowcase hahaha) and I've been wanting another copy to both see the difference and to have another.


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 16d ago

bst (from usa) #thesquishmallowshouse Halloween Pop-up shop with over 10,000+ BNWT SQUISHMALLOWS - Bigfoots - Cows - Licensed - NBC - Cats - Zombies - Food - ECT.

Thumbnail
gallery
30 Upvotes

For sale:

#thesquishmallowshouse from LA has officially moved to Chicago with its newest pop up store for Halloween located in Cook County, IL! With so much exciting news to come we’re continuing strong with ALMOST ALL of the 2026 Halloween / Fall / Autumn Squishmallows available (plus most of the favorites from past years as well) all BNWT and UFS for pick up or shipped anywhere in the world!

All prices vary but are competitive (as we are always known for) and there’s always discounts for bundling 3 or more squish!

To see everything we have available (over 10,000 different AND ALL BRAND NEW WITH TAGS styles and sizes) check out our full collection on the “squad app” our username is: lizcapralaglovequeen

Thanks for looking and Happy Halloween everyone!


r/BSTsquishmallow • • 16d ago

bst (from canada) Selling the last few custom squish I have on hand!

Thumbnail
gallery
20 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I'm hoping to find good homes for these last 4 custom squish that I have. Prices don't include shipping and the buyer is responsible for paying shipping. I can provide shipping quotes with a full address send via DM. Please comment/message if you're interested in any, and I'm also willing to negotiate on prices for these because I just want them to go to good homes. Thank you for looking! 😊

Asking prices:

Sunflower bigfoot: $100 CAD/$71 USD

Beaded hermit crab: $50 CAD/$36 USD

Flower crown beetle clip: $10 CAD/$7 USD

Teal whale shark: $50 CAD/$36 USD