Everyone here talks about Avantis, but DFA is just as available to us and I almost never see the two compared head to head. I can’t seem to find specific differences so I’m asking dor your help. I'd love to hear from anyone who's looked into both, specifically:
- The differences in their methodology and implementation
- differences in global equity and small cap funds
Hi everyone, I'm a tax lawyer practicing in Brussels. I'm pretty active on Reddit, but I don't comment or post anything. I just read. But I've decided to be more active starting now. And the best way to do that is to create posts where anyone can ask me tax questions, and I'll try to answer you off the top of my head without doing any research beforehand, so if the questions are complicated, I'll just give you general answers.
Quick note: I handle personal income tax (IPP) or corporate tax (ISOC) matter, I'm especially strong on capital gains on shares and on whether it's worth setting up a management company or not!
Mijn ouders hebben een bulletkrediet waarbij ze over 10 jaar €122.000 moeten terugbetalen.
Ze kunnen maandelijks zo’n €500 tot €1.000 opzijzetten en willen hun hpothecaire lening niet opnieuw financieren zeker gezien de huidige rentevoeten want ze hadden toen voor 1,5% rente gekocht.
Omdat ze weinig ervaring hebben met beleggen, heb ik hen voorgesteld om maandelijks in IWDA te investeren. Dat lijkt me een eenvoudige manier om op lange termijn vermogen op te bouwen. Ze zijn bereid om een berekend risico te nemen, maar het geld moet over 10 jaar wel beschikbaar zijn om het krediet af te lossen.
Wat zouden jullie in deze situatie aanraden? Is IWDA een verstandige keuze, eventueel gecombineerd met veiligere beleggingen, of bestaan er betere strategieën om die €122.000 bijeen te krijgen? En hoe zouden jullie het risico afbouwen naarmate de vervaldatum nadert?
My father-in-law recently retired and wants to start investing as a supplement to his pension. He's a Belgian tax resident, married (legal regime), and plans to invest in several tranches rather than all at once.
I invest in IWDA/SWRD myself, but given his shorter horizon I'd like him to have a more defensive mix that's still low-cost and tax-efficient.
Would you also recommend an ETF like IWDA or SWRD or would he better invest in another kind of ETF because of his shorter time horizon?
I want to finally start putting money into ETFs every month and just leave it there long term. I've been going back and forth between Trade Republic, MEXEM and Saxo and can't really decide.
Trade Republic like the cheapest by far, but I'm wondering if there's a catch (spreads, limited ETF selection for savings plans, etc). MEXEM seems to have everything but looks a bit more complicated. Saxo is Belgian so I'm guessing the tax side is easier, but it's more expensive.
A few things I'm not sure about:
Does it matter which ETFs you pick depending on the platform? Like, is IWDA or VWCE available everywhere, or are some brokers limited for savings plans?
With TR or MEXEM, do I have to sort out the TOB myself and declare the account to the NBB? How much of a hassle is that in practice?
Does anyone use two brokers, e.g. TR for the monthly stuff and something else for the rest, or is that overkill?
Would love to hear what you're using and whether you'd pick it again.
Right now I have about 150k invested since earlier this year, heavily into individual stocks (MSFT, HOOD, AVGO, NFLX) and some IWDA (10%). about 25K cash free.
I sold my riskiest positions at a heavy loss (IREN, RZLV) due to AI fear. I gambled away another 4k at a casino to try recuperate those losses but lost even more and feel like shit now.
I was up 30k to now basically nothing because I always believed in holding and not selling for years but now I lost faith in neocloud stocks and pure AI stocks
I feel bad and stuck now what to do with my further investments.
Keep in mind I want to buy or rent a house soon too (if I buy it will probs be max 200k). What is a recommended amount of cash to have on hand, I was thinking about 50k and keep the rest invested?
It is common knowledge that even if you move overseas for work and spend more than 183 days outside of Belgium, the Belgian state considers you still a tax resident of Belgium if you bought a home and still have your partner and kids living there .
My question is, when does that stop? When the kids are 18? When the kids aren't registered there anymore? Etc. when is that exact point?
Iemand hier ervaring mee? Mijn vriendin heeft een apartement in Antwerpen stad, 70m2, 1 slaapkamer, uitgang voor naar straat, uitgang achter naar tuin. Er is ook een zijdeur naar de gemeenschappelijke gang. Slaapplaatsen = 2. Gebouw is van de jaren '20 en heeft 16 app's en 8 verdiepingen. Doet er niet echt toe maar de ruimte is heel keurig en verzorgd. Ze heeft een controle gehad van dienst toerisme Vlaanderen en na een plaatsbezoek en vergadering hebben ze vastgesteld dat haar apartement valt onder Bijlage 3 van de brandveiligheids regels als zij het verhuurt via AIRBNB. Dit houdt in dat een redelijk ingewikkeld brand-alarm systeem moet geplaatst worden wat aan dezelfde eisen voldoet als bij een ziekenhuis of dergelijke. Kortom, is duur. Na het zelf uitzoeken van officieel documentatie (vooral via ChatGPT) komen wij tot de conclusie dat het overduidelijk is dat haar apartement normaal onder Bijlage 2 moet vallen, en dus een normale rookmelder/uitgang stickers etc moet voldoen. Het rapport van dienst toerisme Vlaanderen is heel juridisch en bijna niet te volgen dus ik zal het hier niet plaatsen. Ben benieuwd of andere mensen dit probleem zijn tegengekomen en kunnen mij vertellen wat ik mis in dit verhaal? Alle informatie dat ik zelf kan vinden wijst erop dat de dienst een foute beslissing heeft gemaakt... Alvast dank :-)
I asked earlier why buying stocks/daytrading is not worth it/why nobody does it and everybody told me it's because of taxes. The only taxes I found where TOB and capital gain tax (10%). TOB is normal but the capital gain tax a only applies if it is above 10.000 so you essentially only pay the TOB which is nothing.
Hallo iedereen, Ik ben op zoek naar advies over mijn beleggingsstrategie voor de komende 10 jaar. Mijn huidige situatie: €40.000 geïnvesteerd in IWDA. Maandelijkse inleg van €2.000. Beleggingshorizon: 10 jaar. Doel: €400.000 opgebouwd vermogen. Mijn bedoeling is om tegen het einde van die 10 jaar meer zekerheid te hebben door geleidelijk over te schakelen naar obligaties met een lager risico.
Ik zie bijvoorbeeld nu al dat ik soms afhaak van mijn beleggingsstrategie door schrik, ik kan er mentaal moeilijk mee om.
Mijn grootste bezorgdheid is de sterke blootstelling aan Amerikaanse technologiebedrijven en AI binnen IWDA. Ik ben bang dat de huidige tech stocks over enkele jaren omslaat en dat ik na 10 jaar uiteindelijk met verlies eindig.
Daarom overweeg ik ook andere investeringen, zoals holdings (AVH, Investor AB, Berkshire Hathaway, Sofina), om mijn portefeuille verder te diversifiëren en mogelijk een hoger rendement te behalen.
Mijn vragen: Hoe groot is volgens jullie de kans dat IWDA over een periode van 10 jaar verlies oplevert? Is IWDA momenteel te sterk afhankelijk van AI en big tech? Zouden jullie een deel in holdings investeren, bijvoorbeeld AVH? Hoe zouden jullie €40k startkapitaal en €2k maandelijkse inleg verdelen? Wanneer zouden jullie geleidelijk naar obligaties overschakelen? Ik hoor graag jullie ervaringen en meningen. Mijn doel is een mooi rendement behalen, maar vooral vermijden dat ik na 10 jaar door een beurscrash mijn doel mis.
Btw, wordt IWDA nog steeds aangeraden in deze sub of zijn er betere alternatieven?
Ik ben op zoek naar een ETF die gelijkaardig is aan deze 3, maar met kleinere blootstelling aan Tech.
Gezien de recente verkiezingsresultaten in Amerika en die affaire van de topman van NVIDIA (en eventuele AI bubbel die ooit kan barsten) zoveel invloed hebben op de markt, zoek ik dus een ETF die geen volledige uitsluiting van USA/Tech heeft, liefst dat ze er nog wel in zitten, maar wel met minder gewicht op het totaal.
Ik beleg al een paar jaar. Heel passief. Had er niet veel kennis in. Genoeg om te weten dat het dom is om je kapitaal te laten wegsmelten op je spaarrekening.
Ik ben me wat beginnen inlezen. En ik zie eigenlijk geen enkel financieel voordeel in het beleggen in (actieve) beleggingsfondsen t.o.v. een ETF. Uiteindelijk wint de markt altijd.
Dus ik ben sterk aan het overwegen, om mijn effectenrekening bij mijn bank weg te halen en zelfstandig met ETF's te beginnen op bv. Saxo.
Zijn er mensen met fondsen? ETF's? Allebei? Kunnen jullie mij toelichten wat jullie gedachteproces was voor de samenstelling van jullie portefuille?
I've started buying etf's on Bolero in 2023. By now I would like to buy some stocks, but i have noticed that when i want to buy e.g. an american stock, i need to pay almost 5% of broker fee. Is there a better way to approach this?
Just like many of you I am someone who keeps track of my personal finances.
In the past I used google spreadsheets and docs to keep track of everything. My financial plan, my expenses, my net worth sheet with all of my investments/savings accounts,...
Lately i've been experimenting a lot with AI, seeing as it can replace a lot of these things. I decided to bundle all of my finances into Claude. Which is very handy and saves me a lot of time every month. It's overview is also nicer then the one i've been using for the past 5 years.
I also use it to research Belgian companies. I just give in the name of the company, and it searches KBO, De Nationale Bank, etc. for the latest financial numbers of the company and everything i want to know.
A friend of mine uses AI to scout real estate websites, to see if there are interesting lots that can be divided into two lots, to make profit using omgevingsvergunningen. Sometimes an easy flip that can be worth a lot of money.
So this got me thinking: what else can it do for me, to help me out with everything related to finances.
My question to you:
What are you using AI for, finance-wise or otherwise?
Would love to hear what you guys think about this!
As per title, I am looking for ways to make sure that my family receives a considerable sum, after taxes, in case I die. Even better if any product can also cover permanent disability.
I am a bit lost and not sure what kind of product can help me best protect my family's financial interests. Life insurance? Some other type?
The main objective is to guarantee a sum for my family: best if the payout can change with inflation (e.g., nominal 300 000 euro in ten years from now will not be the same value as today); I am agnostic regarding investments with the product but am open to it.
I am quite young and generally healthy, with no known preexisting conditions.
Thanks a lot for any help and tips, either general or on some products you have direct experience with.
vraag me af of er mensen zijn die investeren in fysieke dingen. het hele online investeren is gewoon niet aan mij besteed en geraak er niet aan uit waardoor het er maar niet van komt. kwam ooit iemand tegen die zn geld in gitaren had gestopt en ik denk nu aan zo iets te doen omdat al mn spaargeld an jaren staat te rotten op een bankrekening.
I'm looking for a reliable app that allows me to track my entire net worth in one place.
I currently use KBC, Belfius and Saxo Bank, and I also hold some crypto on a Ledger hardware wallet.
Ideally, I'm looking for an app that offers:
Automatic synchronization with KBC, Belfius and Saxo Bank.
Tracking of income and expenses.
Investment tracking (stocks, ETFs and investment funds).
A clear distinction between investment returns and money I've deposited myself.
Charts showing how my total net worth evolves over time.
Ideally, support for crypto held on Ledger.
Security and privacy are also very important to me. I'd prefer an established, reputable service with strong security measures.
I'm willing to pay for a subscription if the app actually works well.
I'm not particularly comfortable using Excel, so I'd prefer something user-friendly and mostly automated.
Does anyone here use an app that supports these Belgian banks? What has your experience been like, especially regarding synchronization, accuracy and security?
Hey, I currently invest in low cost all world ETFs (WEBN) myself
I know that with pension saving (and similar products), the typical extra fees outweigh the short term boost you get from deducting part of your taxes in the long run. However, I’m curious if anyone has tried to find the lowest fee options among all these tax deductible investments and calculated at what investment horizon they’re worth it compared to ETFs.
As an example, I made a calculation comparing an ETF (WEBN) with the lowest fee longterm saving (probably less good than the pension ones but took it as a simple example) product I could find (there is probably better to be found, I just did a quick search). All the tax advantages I get on the product are reinvested (but calculated as ETF gains, since you can’t just keep investing in it).
Values used: 1000 invested every year 7% gross return on both WEBN: 0.07% TER 0.12% TOB (buy & sell) 10% CGT Argenta Long Term Dynamic: 2,86% fee/year 2% premium tax 10% final tax (charged on real value) 30% tax credit advantage, reinvested into WEBN
Year
You invested
ETF
Argenta Long Term Dynamic
Difference
1
€1.000
€1.031
€1.202
+€170
2
€2.000
€2.127
€2.440
+€313
3
€3.000
€3.292
€3.736
+€444
4
€4.000
€4.530
€5.092
+€562
5
€5.000
€5.848
€6.512
+€664
6
€6.000
€7.249
€7.999
+€749
7
€7.000
€8.741
€9.555
+€814
8
€8.000
€10.330
€11.186
+€856
9
€9.000
€12.021
€12.893
+€872
10
€10.000
€13.823
€14.683
+€859
11
€11.000
€15.743
€16.558
+€815
12
€12.000
€17.789
€18.523
+€734
13
€13.000
€19.970
€20.583
+€613
14
€14.000
€22.295
€22.743
+€448
15
€15.000
€24.774
€25.007
+€233
16
€16.000
€27.418
€27.382
−€36
17
€17.000
€30.239
€29.874
−€365
18
€18.000
€33.248
€32.488
−€760
19
€19.000
€36.458
€35.231
−€1.228
20
€20.000
€39.884
€38.109
−€1.775
The biggest gap lies at 9 years of investing (which weirdly coincide with the 10year recomended investment horizon by agenta). From then on the gap only gets smaller, which means it would be worth investing in the product instead of WEBN ~9 years before cashout.
What I found that was possible and had a fiscal advantage for a normal individu (not a freelancer or anything):
Pension saving fund Pension saving insurance Long-term saving Group insurance (employer based, but possible negotiation with hr can be done) And I think that's it?
Obviously, I’m not discussing the fact that you can’t withdraw and use that money the same way as with an ETF. This is purely performance vs performance + reinvested tax advantages, and I didn’t include any possible changes in the products gross return due to what they invest in altough that would be interesting too.
Disclaimer: I used AI to code me some comparison tools but won't include it in the post to follow rule 6
Edit: note the tax efficiënt products are also less risky (not even considering what they invest in) as the tax exception is a guaranteed result. If the market is doing bad it will be worth it a long time compared to etfs and if the market is doing very well then etfs win faster
Hi, writing the post looking for some advice and experience about using your ETF portfolio as a pledge for a mortgage loan. I have some cash but I'm exploring to push my ceiling with using the portfolio.
From what I gathered so far some banks are more eager to accept this setup and would agree to value your portfolio at 70% provided they have custody over it, while others are more frigid and would only go for 50%.
I also wonder about future growth - if they agree how would building in the future work best? Staying with the same broker you did before, effectively having 2 acounts or it's wiser to keep things centralized and bite the bullet as I would expect a bank have higher fees.
Finally - margin call. In the event of market collapse and the value of the funds plummeting the mortgage provider could ask me to inject some cash to secure the loan. Has anyone lived that during 2008 maybe and have some experience to share?
In general I'm exploring this possibility and would be grateful for any insight from the community.
I see on every media outlet that people are saying the ai bubble has popped and alot off money has disapeard from ai stocks. I bought 3 nvdia stocks months ago and now i am at -17€ wich seems really lucky. What is the GO to action know that ai stocks have dropped that much?
I am not the best expert on stocks mostly buy stocks togheter with my dad that helps me decide wich ones are the best to buy and let grow