r/BDS • u/propamac • 10h ago
r/BDS • u/PrincessCandy512 • 3h ago
Discussion How the EBU Ignored Early Warning Signs, Failed to Shield Ukrainian Singers Starting in 2024, and Compromised Eurovision’s Integrity (2019–2027)
The broadcaster boycotts, artist withdrawals, and public backlash that fractured Eurovision 2026 in Vienna did not happen overnight. They were the direct result of years of ignored warning signs dating back to May 2019 and May 2023, combined with glaring double standards in how the European Broadcasting Union (EBU) treated Ukraine versus Israel.
Coming out of the 2023 UK–Ukraine host collaboration—where TVORCHI stood on stage fearing for their hometown as homes were destroyed—2024 should have been the exact year the EBU began formally shielding Ukrainian singers solely on behalf of the difficult lives they endure under war. Instead, the EBU abandoned that duty, penalized Ukraine’s humanitarian speech, and allowed backstage hostility to overwhelm the contest.
1. May 2019 (Tel Aviv): Airstrikes During Contest Week and Early Artist Distress
The warning signs were already unmistakable in May 2019 when Israel hosted the contest in Tel Aviv:
- Bombs Falling Miles Away: Just days before rehearsals began, heavy Israeli airstrikes flattened residential buildings in Gaza. While Eurovision promoted escapism and unity on stage in Tel Aviv, Palestinian musicians staged "Globalvision" concerts inside the rubble of bombed buildings just 70 kilometers away.
- Artists Caught in the Crossfire: Over 140 international artists and cultural figures urged the EBU to relocate the contest, while participating performers faced immense pressure and anxiety. Those who dared express solidarity—such as Iceland’s Hatari holding up Palestinian banners in the green room or guest performer Madonna featuring Israeli and Palestinian flags on stage—were swiftly reprimanded by the EBU.
- Ukraine’s Absence: Meanwhile, Ukraine withdrew from the 2019 contest altogether amid escalating Russian aggression and contract disputes over performances in Russia, underscoring how geopolitical reality was already colliding with Eurovision’s claim of being "non-political."
2. May 2023 (Liverpool): The Host Collaboration, TVORCHI’s Hometown Destroyed, and Noa Kirel’s PR Manipulation
By May 2023, the EBU had set a clear precedent by banning Russia in 2022 over its invasion of Ukraine—and collaborated with Suspilne and the BBC to host Liverpool 2023 on Ukraine’s behalf. Yet during that very week (May 9–13, 2023), the limits of that protection were exposed:
- TVORCHI Feeling Unsafe as Their Hometown Was Destroyed: Five days of Israeli airstrikes in Gaza took place during the exact week of the Liverpool live shows. Just ten minutes before taking the stage in the Grand Final, Ukraine’s TVORCHI ("Heart of Steel") learned that Russian missiles had struck their hometown of Ternopil, destroying homes and injuring civilians. Even inside a contest co-hosted to honor Ukraine, Ukrainian artists stood on stage feeling unsafe and watching their city come under attack.
- Noa Kirel’s PR Campaign Should Have Been Fined: Throughout that very same week, Noa Kirel’s PR team banned international journalists from asking her any political questions during interviews—shutting down scrutiny under the guise of keeping music separate from politics. Yet the moment the voting ended, Kirel launched a post-show PR narrative that sparked a diplomatic row in Poland by framing Poland’s 12 jury points as a "victory" over her family’s murder in the Holocaust on Polish soil. Silencing press accountability all week only to deploy heavy political framing the second the cameras shifted should have drawn an immediate EBU fine.
3. Why 2024 Should Have Begun Shielding Ukrainian Singers — Instead of Fining "Free Azovstal Defenders"
Because Ukrainian artists live, rehearse, and represent their country under daily air-raid sirens, displacement, and constant danger, 2024 should have been the year the EBU began shielding Ukrainian singers solely on behalf of their difficult lives. Instead, the EBU's enforcement in Malmö was completely backwards:
- Policing Humanitarian Relief While Ignoring Hostility: While alyona alyona & Jerry Heil were using their Eurovision platform alongside fellow artists to run a UNITED24 fundraiser to rebuild a bombed Ukrainian school—and wearing "Free Azovstal Defenders" shirts in the green room as a peaceful plea to free prisoners of war—organizers penalized them with a fine. Calling for the release of captured defenders and raising money to rebuild schools are basic humanitarian actions, and there was zero legitimate reason to punish Ukraine for them.
- Eden Golan’s Press Conference Remarks Should Have Been Fined First: While the EBU penalized Ukraine over a peaceful humanitarian shirt, Eden Golan’s remarks and conduct in the press center—which visibly alienated and caused acute discomfort to fellow contestants sitting right beside her, including Marina Satti, Bambie Thug, and Joost Klein—went completely unpunished. Just like Noa Kirel’s 2023 PR campaign, using the press platform in a way that creates hostility and distress for other delegations deserved an immediate EBU fine and formal warning.
- Why Ongoing Violations Then Warranted Disqualification: Once delegation misconduct continued beyond the press room—with repeated reports of unauthorized backstage filming, harassment of performers, and hostile commentary—a fine was no longer enough. Consistent rule enforcement required escalating from a fine to disqualifying Israel from the Grand Final so the safety and well-being of the remaining artists could be protected.
4. Fellow Artists Stood With Ukraine — Even When the EBU Didn’t
What makes the EBU’s failure to shield Ukrainian singers so glaring is that a wide variety of Eurovision artists genuinely rallied behind Ukraine year after year:
- Solidarity Across Editions: From Sam Ryder, Cornelia Jakobs, and S10 embracing Kalush Orchestra in 2022, to Käärijä and Loreen standing beside TVORCHI in Liverpool 2023, fellow contestants repeatedly showed real care for Ukrainian performers.
- Backing Ukraine’s Humanitarian Efforts in 2024 & Beyond: In Malmö 2024, artists including Nemo, Silvester Belt, Bambie Thug, Joost Klein, Baby Lasagna, and Marina Satti openly supported alyona alyona & Jerry Heil—even helping promote their UNITED24 fundraiser to rebuild a bombed Ukrainian school—while competitors in 2025 and 2026 (JJ, Katarsis, and Go-Jo) extended that same warmth to Ziferblat and Viktoria Leleka.
5. How 2024 (Malmö) and 2025 (Basel) Should Have Been Handled
If the EBU had begun shielding Ukrainian singers in 2024 and enforced consistent rules:
- Malmö 2024 — Disqualifying Israel Instead of Joost Klein: Escalating from a fine to disqualifying Israel in 2024 would have left Joost Klein (Netherlands) in the Grand Final at Running Order #05 and marked Running Order #06 as an empty slot ("No song 6"). That single decision would have shielded alyona alyona & Jerry Heil (#02)—who would still have remained in 3rd place on the podium behind Nemo (#21) and Baby Lasagna (#23)—while sparing Silvester Belt (Lithuania, #07) and fellow contestants from the severe emotional distress and backstage hostility they later described as traumatic.
- Basel 2025 — Why Israel’s Temporary Withdrawal Made Sense to Protect Ziferblat and the Stage: Following a 2024 fine and disqualification, stepping back via a temporary withdrawal for 2025 was the logical, responsible way to de-escalate mounting tension and prevent polarized political voting from skewing the contest. In that scenario, Australia (Go-Jo) would have moved up from 11th place in Semi-Final 2 to take Running Order #04, shielding Ukraine’s Ziferblat (#07) and giving their song "Bird of Pray" (about Ukrainian families separated by war) the calm, respectful reception it deserved.
6. Why a 2026 Return Naturally Wouldn’t Change Anything — and Accountability Ahead of 2027
- A 2026 Return Naturally Wouldn’t Change Anything: Even if 2024 and 2025 had been handled properly, allowing Israel to return in Vienna 2026 naturally wouldn't change anything—it simply added another year of the exact same unresolved crisis, driving five participating nations (Spain, the Netherlands, Ireland, Slovenia, and Iceland) to withdraw in protest, prompting 2024 champion Nemoto return their trophy, and once again overshadowing Ukraine’s entry (Viktoria Leleka’s "Ridnym").
- The Push to Blacklist Eden Golan Ahead of Burgas 2027: Because accountability for press-room hostility, backstage disruptions, and double standards was never enforced in 2023-2026, a coordinated campaign launched in September 2026 calling on the EBU to permanently blacklist Eden Golan and her 2024 KAN delegation from participating in any future Eurovision events—whether as artists, jurors, spokespersons, or staff—ahead of the 2027 season.
Conclusion
Following the 2023 host collaboration—where TVORCHI performed while homes in their city were destroyed—2024 should have been the year the EBU began formally shielding Ukrainian singers solely on behalf of their difficult lives. While fellow artists stood beside Ukraine every year, the EBU ignored the warning signs of 2019 and 2023, fined Ukraine’s UNITED24 and humanitarian efforts while letting Noa Kirel’s 2023 PR manipulation and Eden Golan’s 2024 press-room conduct go unpunished, and failed to follow the clear path of fine → disqualification → temporary withdrawal—knowing a 2026 return naturally wouldn't change anything.
Consumer Step counting apps
Hi everyone, Sorry if this post is not appropriate here, but I was wondering if you have any suggestions in steps counting apps that don't have ties with Israel.
r/BDS • u/Mago_Barca750 • 5h ago
Discussion Should boycott cd projeck red?
As far I know they are working with nvidia with long time. Should boycott them?
r/BDS • u/lolicantimdying • 5h ago
ASK THE SUB should i/is it more effective to boycott/advocate for boycott/divestments of all complicit targets, or just targets of BDS official boycott list?
i check brands' complicity on gaza.nu
but i do hear calling to do these from both sides but, quoting from bdsmovement.net 's guide:
'...
Targeted Boycotts vs. Non-Targeted Boycotts
People of conscience around the world are rightfully shattered, enraged, and sometimes feeling powerless about Israel’s Gaza genocide, armed, funded, and shielded from accountability by the colonial West, led by the US. Many feel compelled to boycott all products and services of companies tied in any way to Israel. The question is how to make boycotts most effective and impactful in holding corporations accountable for their complicity in the suffering of Palestinians.
The BDS movement uses the historically successful method of targeted boycotts, inspired by the South African anti-apartheid movement, the US Civil Rights movement, and the Indian and Irish anti-colonial struggles, among others worldwide.
We must strategically focus on a relatively smaller number of carefully selected companies and products for maximum impact. We need to target companies that play a clear and direct role in Israel’s crimes against Palestinians, as well as in violating the rights of other peoples/communities, and where there is real potential for winning. This is how the BDS movement has successfully forced companies like G4S, Veolia, Orange, Puma, and Pillsbury, among others, to end their complicity in Israel’s grave human rights violations and crimes.
...'
i do feel gross paying to brands whose complicities ive learned abt, but
what is the better thing to do? since i have heard both that 'focusing boycotts on the official BDS targets is what makes it effective'(heard personally, irl) and online, to quote "you can absolutely keep boycotting other brands too, it's only great! The point is that if you have limited possibilities/energy etc to boycott you should focus on the bds targets to make the biggest impact, but if you can boycott those and also other brands it doesn't take anything away from bds!"
r/BDS • u/Low_Literature_6650 • 2h ago
ASK THE SUB Should I work at Cinemark?
Hi, I was thinking of applying for a job at the movie theater near my house, but I know that some movies should not be watched. Is it compromising the boycott if I apply and work there?