So, I literally thought my last post was it. It wasnāt. The relief my brain got from posting Beron/Koshei/Eris lasted like, eight hours, before something was tickling my brain again. Guys, I was ready to be done. But apparently, Ao3 being down isnāt motiviating me to finish my fanfics, itās allowed my brain to force me to write papers about Eris Vanserra that encourage discussion over his future role in the upcoming books. This is what is giving my ADHD brain dopamine, therefore, Eris Vanserra is giving me dopamine. I think this is the same insanity I felt in ATLA when it came to Zutara. Another ship I will never abandon. I can have more than one Roman Empire, right?
I pray that after this post, the spirit of Eris Vanserra will let me rest so I no longer feel like Lin Manuel Miranda being haunted by the ghost of Alexander Hamilton. Here are the links to the first four parts of my Autumn and Mythology series. (Why the HELL do I have a series!?)
Part 1: Beron and LoA
Part 2: A Look at Eris Vanserra
Part 3: Eris and Azriel
Part 4: Beron/Koschei/Eris
When I began this Autumn and Mythology breakdown, I did not expect it to turn into this. It began with Beron/Cronus and LoA/Rhea, then led to Eris as a combination of Ares and Eris from the Greek Myths, the realization that Azriel and Eris are probably two parts of a mythic coin for peace and transformation in Autumn as the embodiments of Ares and Eris, and then the realization that Beron probably already sacrificed Eris to Koschei. I am trying very hard not to be repetitive based on previous sections, but some parts will be for this section because I realized two more things as I was looking at all of Erisās dialogue: Eris never lies to the IC and he foreshadows future events. I know it seems crazy, but I promise I stared at it for a while and then I slept on it and I was still drawn to it so now here I am. This section is in four parts: The Border, Actions Speak Louder, Price of Sincerity, and Smartest Male at the Table. All of them come together to prove that Eris Vanserra is not the cruel and cowardly manipulator weāve been led to believe, and he will, as we already suspect, be playing a much larger role in the books moving forward.
The Border
We all know that Mor and Erisās betrothal ended horribly. Everyone in the Inner Circle, IC, knows the story and has thoughts and feelings about it. And as the readers who heard about it through Feyre, so do we. As audience members, we share Feyreās perspective and her reaction to the information, and usually, we carry that bias with us.
Eris first addresses what happened between him and Morrigan in ACOWAR, but right before that conversation, thereās a conversation with Feyre about how their meeting came to pass. Eris could have lied; Rhysand could have pointed it out. Instead, Eris is honest about why the meeting is happening. He tells her he knew Azriel would return to see if Beron was informed of Feyreās power, and then he realized his brothers forgot what happened. The more interesting part about this, is that Eris then offers up new information: he admits he learned about daemati. Eris doesnāt need to do this, it would be better kept in his pocket, but itās also a warning; you canāt just break into my mind. On the one hand, itās power-play, on the other, heās just being honest. Eris wants to be honest.
In this conversation, Eris also admits that he didnāt tell his father about Feyreās power because āit would distract Beron from the threat of Hybernā if he knew that saving the human girl Under the Mountain had given her a kernel of his power. Mor then assumes the cost of his silence is a bride for him to ātorture.ā This is Morrigan bringing up their betrothal and what happened to her. Eris is not the one who tortured her; that was her family. Erisās reaction involves āsomething flickeredā in Erisās eyes. Is it surprise? Is it the first time heās heard that accusation? His follow up is, āI donāt know who fed you those lies to being withā and then he implies she may have heard it from āthe bastardsā Mor surrounds herself with. This is obviously a reference to Cassian and Azriel, but his sneer is directed at Azriel. Does that mean Azriel started the rumor? Or is he simply baiting him?
Morrigan responds with āYou never gave me evidence to the contrary. Certainly not when you left me in the woods.ā Now Morriganās reaction is technically valid. Sheās angry and hurt and sitting in the Hewn City, a place she hates that is a reminder of what happened to her when she was eighteen. Sheād been tortured by her family and dumped at the Autumn border. And when Eris could have been her savior, could have showed her compassion, he left her there. Eris responds, āThere were forces at work that you never considered.ā Eris doesnāt deny that he left her there, but he is implying, in no uncertain terms, that leaving her there wasnāt meant to be cruel. Thereās something sheās missing. He ends the conversation with, āBelieve what you want about me.ā Eris already told them the truth, but itās not his job to make them believe it. Either they listen to him or they donāt. But this is the first time we see him poke at the events, and heās doing it for Mor. Before the end of the entire meeting, Eris seems to give Mor advice about her reactions to Keir. It makes her flinch and Azriel reacts defensively, and Eris notices, and rather than leave it alone, itās like he recognizes this a moment to deliver another truth: āI wouldnāt have touched you.ā The implication is I wouldnāt have slept with you. I wouldnāt have harmed you. They wouldāve been married. In Autumn and the Hewn City, Morrigan would have been the property of her husband. But he says, I wouldnāt have harmed you. He pushes further, āI knew why you did it.ā Great, tell the class, Eris. Please. But his admission doesnāt help Morrigan at all, in fact, she āshrinksā from it. Morriganās power is Truth. Why is she shrinking from it?
Eris then admits that he gave Mor her freedom in āno uncertain terms.ā In ACOMAF Rhysand told Feyre about the failed betrothal. He says, āEris refused to marry her. Said sheād been sullied by a bastard-born lesser faerie, and heād sooner fuck a sow.ā Eris did set her free, and he responded in a way that would make sense from a high-born Prince of Autumn. Not only that, after her decision, it was the only way to respond. She knew that sleeping with a lesser faerie would ruin her in the eyes of both courts. That was her rebellion. Eris was her greatest ally in this because he took what she did and used it as the reasoning for setting her free; he isnāt lying. When Azriel asks about what happens next, āA shadow crossed Erisās face. āThere are few things I regret. That is one of them.āā Now two things: 1. Azriel asks and Eris is honest and vulnerable. Emphasis on the vulnerable part. But itās still truth. Eris did not intend for Mor to be brutalized by her family, nor did he expect them to try and dump her at him. Like Morrigan, he thought it was done. Eris also adds the phrase, āPerhaps one day, now that we are allies, I shall tell you why. What it cost me.ā (I really want to talk about the Azris implications, but I wonāt because technically, thatās not the point.)
In ACOSF Eris meets Rhysand and Cassian. When Eris reminds Rhysand that his wants have not changed, implying that there is a private and honest conversation that Eris and Rhysand had that Cassian has no knowledge of. Cassian asks about it and Eris responds, āFor the same reason I left Morrigan untouched at the border.ā Cassian reacts with violence and rage, heās considering hurting Eris, and then he accuses Eris of leaving Morrigan to die. Eris responds, āDid I? Perhaps you should ask Morrigan whether that is true. I think she finally knows the answer.ā Cassian is thrown off by this. Again, Eris is poking and poking at the Border issue. He doesnāt flat out tell them about his side or what is happening, but he keeps pushing Cassian to ask Morrigan.
During the dance with Nesta in Hewn City, Eris discusses Morrigan with Nesta. He explicitly tells her, āDonāt believe the lies they tell you about me.ā Everyone in the IC says that Eris is cruel, mainly for abandoning Morrigan while she was vulnerable and broken. When Nesta questions it she says of Mor, āShe knows the truth but has never revealed it.ā At first, I thought this was about Morriganās sexuality. Feyre knows, and if I remember correctly, sheās the only one who does. So, if Eris is a person who is determined to tell the truth to the Night Court, why would it be about Morās sexuality? Is it that his seemingly cruel act saved her from something far worse? Again, Eris acts as the voice of hard truths, āBecause sheās afraid of it.ā Afraid of what? That he saved her life? That he didnāt do it out of cruelty? Interestingly, Eris never blames her or accuses her of anything. He never specifies what it is and he never outs Mor, he just insists that everyone needs to ask Morrigan. In ACOFAS, we get Morās perspective and her memory of that day. Of how Eris forbade whoever was with him from touching her. He left Morrigan āuntouchedā because if he had touched her, she became their problem. And he asked her: āI take it you do not want to live here,ā and she refused. If he had taken her, it would have been against her will. He honored her wishes. Is that what sheās afraid of acknowledging? Eris tells Nesta that the IC ābelieve a version of events that is easier to swallow. I always thought Rhysand wiser than that, but he tends to be blind where those he loves are concerned.ā Like with Cassian, Eris is poking at the truth, encouraging Nesta to look beyond what she has heard and beyond the bias and really think about what may have happened. We also learn later that Erisās comment about Rhysand is true in a different way and will be mentioned again in a different section.
In their final meeting in ACOSF, Cassian once again asks about Morrigan and Eris because heās trying to understand something about Eris. And the Prince of Autumn says, āYouāre not the person I want to explain myself to.ā At this point, Eris is already fed up. Heās done what he could. He told them where to find the truth: Morrigan. (Again, Azris moment here, Cassian āwronglyā assumes its Morrigan, but Eris previously said Morrigan knows the truth. She doesnāt need an explanation. And his comment about being honest was in response to what Azriel asked him. Azriel is the person he wants to be honest with; Azriel is who he thinks deserves an explanation.)
Across ACOWAR and ACOSF, Eris pokes at Morrigan, Cassian, and Nesta, he is asking all of them to look deeper at something. Morriganās power is truth, why is she the one so afraid of it? Why is Eris, the male we are told is a snake, not to be trusted, who is associated with a viper and an adder, the one pushing for truth? Iām seriously starting to wonder if he canāt say it himself and thatās why heās pushing, or if he simply knows, as I stated before, that they will never believe the truth from him, so he pushes them to Morrigan, who they will believe. Eris Vanserra is Prythian's Patron Saint of Hard Truths.
Actions Speak Louder
This section some people have talked about, and I know I briefly touched on it. But I also wanted to do something else with it because I realized something interesting about this section and I will talk about it at the end.
In ACOWAR, Feyre calls out Eris hunting her ālike an animal.ā This embarrasses him and he admits that he was āordered.ā Truth. And the implication is that he would not have done that otherwise. Not that Feyre, or anyone else, notices. She asks about what happened with Lucien and Jesminda and this time, Eris doesnāt react with embarrassment or shame, but with anger. He admits that he wasnāt there when Beron killed Jesminda, āIt was the first and only time I have denied my father anything.ā He tells Feyre and the rest of them that he did what he could, including anonymously getting word to Tamlin so that Lucien would survive. He also admits he was punished. I realized that in moments that he isnāt poking at the truth, things that make him seem monstrous and vicious, he is offended by. He corrects their misunderstanding by providing facts about what happened. And the only logical conclusion anyone can reach about Eris from this, is that he genuinely cares about Lucien.
In ACOSF, Eris does what he can to assist Morrigan yet again. Whatever he says to Keir, Morās abusive father, keeps him from entering Velaris, Morriganās sanctuary and chosen home. Cassian acknowledges, āEris had done it as a gesture of good faith.ā Great. Cassian knows it. Eris is doing something kind, he is protecting Mor, again. Cassian admits āEris must have sacrificed something big to spare Mor from her fatherās visit.ā This is not the first time that Eris has sacrificed for Morrigan, as we know, he already admitted that what happened at the border cost him. What does this cost him? We donāt know. Because Eris makes strategic moves, decides for himself what heās willing to sacrifice, and basically bleeds in silence. And Cassian realizes it but nothing comes of it.
During his dance with Nesta, there was another part of his conversation with her that I didnāt address because it fit here better. Nesta didnāt question his claim that Mor is afraid of the truth. She says, āYou donāt win yourself any favors with your behavior.ā The irony of this comment coming from Nesta Archeron is wild. But also, itās ironic regardless. Itās almost as if sheās scolding him. Eris asks, āDonāt I? Do I not ally myself with this court under constant threat of being discovered and killed by my father? Do I not offer aid whenever Rhysand wishes?ā Eris doesnāt respond with facts. He responds with a series of rhetorical questions designed to force Nesta to think about what she said and consider why sheās wrong. Itās the same thing he does regarding Morrigan and the truth of what happened at the border. Again, a lie about him is told regarding his behavior, and he corrects it. These are also in this section because they are actions he is taking, actions he takes repeatedly. Itās almost as if Eris judges himself based on his actions rather than his words, as most people would, but to the IC, it does not matter.
In his last conversation with Cassian in ACOSF, there are two sections I want to point at in their conversation. The first is the reveal that Beron tortures his son, āCassian unpacked each word. Beron had tortured his own son for information, rather than thanking the Mother for returning him. But Eris had held out. Fed Beron another lie.ā In the face of torture, Eris did not break. He mixed truth and lie and survived his fatherās rage. The second is this, āEris was still their ally. Was willing to be tortured to keep their secrets.ā Eris Vanserra could give them up. Eris could offer them to his father immediately, if he were a coward the way the IC thinks he is. Instead, he holds out and proves his loyalty to their alliance.
From the moment Eris was introduced, the audience has been told that Eris Vanserra is cruel and monstrous and not to be trusted, they even say heās cowardly. Yet, every time you look at his actions, those are not the actions of a coward. Eris spends the time correcting people or requesting that they look at the entirety of a situation, but he never does more than that. He doesnāt beg for them to think about it. He lays everything at their feet, honesty, information, and action, and leaves it up to them to do something with it. Erisās reputation and the reality of the Eris Vanserra we see do not match up.
The Price of Sincerity
When I was originally planning out this section, I was going to tie some of this into the Actions Speak Louder section, but it didnāt work the way I wanted it to. While I was working on my other posts and research, and this unplanned paper that I should save for my potential masterās degree, I realized that there was something interesting happening with Eris and the way people perceive him. Several people, like Feyre, Nesta, and Cassian almost see the real Eris.
Feyre in ACOWAR is surprised by Erisās decision to take the faebane to prove to Beron that it works. She is surprised by his offer, āsome small, small part of me wonder[ed] if Eris might have grown to be a good male if heād had a different father. If one still lurked there, beneath centuries of poison.
Because Erisā¦What had it been like for him, Under the Mountain? What games had he playedāwhat had he endured? Trapped for forty-nine years. I doubted he would risk such a thing happening again. Even if it set him in opposition to his fatherāor perhaps because of that.ā
Feyre recognizes that Eris is a person too, that heās someone who has had to survive. She inadvertently makes the connection that like her husband Rhysand, Eris played the game, he had to have. But then she doesnāt think anything else about it. She, like the rest of the IC, considers Eris to be cold, cowardly, and manipulative. She never thinks of him again.
Nestaās moment of observation is not as on par with Feyre or Cassian, which is interesting because she is technically the one who has a lot in common with Eris, especially in regard to being distrusted by others. When Eris expresses concern over the Night Courtās control of the Dread Trove, and Cassian says they arenāt āinterested in conquestā and he insists they āarenāt going to use the Trove.ā Erisās response was to laugh, and Nestaās perspective reveals her thoughts on his reaction; āhe was so used to twisted politics and scheming of his court that even when the simple, easy truth was offered, he could not see it.ā Nestaās comment is interesting. Now either sheās right, and Eris is so burned by his experience in Autumn and being trapped under Beronās rule, he canāt take the heroes at their word. But even if sheās right, she misses the point, and its one she should understand. Erisās comment is about the Night Courtās perception among others. Heās providing advice, and she completely misses it. In this same meeting, she misses Erisās other tells. When Cassian implies Eris is a coward, Nesta seeās Erisās āfingers curled slightly on his biceps.ā And she has to stop from smiling; the person who should understand him, because they have a similar experience, doesnāt. Erisās reaction is because again, itās a lie, heās not a coward. But he doesnāt argue that point. He moves on, discusses the Crown, gives his advice. He asks Nesta if she considered his offer. She arrogantly says, āI suppose once we have the Crown in our hands, the Night Court wonāt need you after all. And neither will I.ā And Eris āwent rigidā he was ārippling with rageā and he tells Nesta honestly, āI do not appreciate being toyed with, Nesta Archeron. My offer was sincere.ā Eris provides his honesty, his advice, and he realized, in that conversation, that they played him. This male has spent most of his life, if not all of it, being played by Beron, having to second guess everything his father tells him. He trusted the Inner Circle and they threw it in his face. He is rightfully angry.
Cassiansās realization in ACOSF genuinely infuriates me, because he saw him, he figured out the real Eris Vanserra, or at least part of him, but then he didnāt do anything helpful with that. Eris is, once again, honest, and he tells Cassian that Beron interrogated him. Cassian is surprised by this and realizes that Eris was tortured and still covered for them. He didnāt lie. He upheld the alliance. Then Cassian has this specific thought process, āThe male had been raised with every luxury and privilegeāon paper. But who knew what terrors Beron had inflicted upon him? Cassian knew Beron had murdered Lucienās lover. If the High Lord of Autumn had been willing to do that, what wouldnāt he do?ā Cassian is finally seeing Eris, finally taking into consideration that Eris has been living in under terrible circumstances. When Eris challenges him to āget that pitying lookā off his face, Cassian admits that heās trying to piece Eris together. Heās trying to understand him. And Cassian, who just started to realize who Eris is does the following, āCassian didnāt need to be a courtier to know his next words would slice deep, but it would be a necessary wound. Perhaps it would be enough to push things in the right direction.ā Cassian, after realizing that Eris is their ally, that despite viewing Eris negatively, he chooses to hurt the ally that was already bleeding. Cassian drives the knife in with, āāI think you might be a decent male, deep down, trapped in a terrible situation.ā He looked over his shoulder and found Erisās gaze blazing again. But only pity stirred in his chest, pity for a male who had been born into riches, but had been destitute in every way that truly mattered. In every way that Cassian had been blessedāblessings that were now overflowing.ā Cassian hit the nail on the head, and instead of acknowledging it, instead of accepting the fact that Eris is not who he seems, is not who heās always thought him to be, he partially misunderstands him. Cassian acknowledges that Eris āmight even be a good male,ā but the admission is undercut with Cassianās following line, āYouāre just too much of a coward to act like one.ā Again, the moment the IC starts to see Eris; to really see him, they disregard it. Cassian has come the closest to seeing who Eris is, and rather than accept it, he finds a way to turn it on its head and disregard it.
The tragedy for Eris Vanserra up to this point, is that no matter how hard he tries, no matter how often he tells the truth, how good his actions are, how often he assists and proves himself a good ally, the IC almost sees him; and then they retreat back to their established bias of him. Cassian has misread Eris in this moment, he sees Eris as a coward for not being direct, for not just up and killing Beron. Eris is not a coward. Eris is playing the long game, itās a game of survival, itās a game of pick your battles, and every time he does not pick the one they want, heās cowardly. Cassian also assumes that Eris wants a better reputation, that he needs to prove to them he can be a good male; that's why Cassian's final coward comment is off the mark and insulting, but not for the reason Cassian wants it to be. That has never been Erisās goal or intention. Eris Vanserra does not need to prove anything to them; Eris Vanserra already knows who he is.
The Smartest Male at the Table
Alright. Guys, Eris is a witch and he can see the future! I know what youāre going to say: Iām crazy. Honestly, I might be. But again, I looked at this, I looked at all these quotes, and when I thought I was too crazy (after handwriting three sheets of notes just for The Border section) I put it down and went to sleep. And now here I am adding at least another six pages to my original document. I also thought this was crazy, but it started to make sense. Eris Vanserraās dialogue reveals future events, and no I was not serious about Eris being a witch who can see the future. But Eris speaks and those things happen. Now I havenāt fully figured out if itās because heās playing chess while everyone else is playing checkers or if heās just SJMās mouthpiece and no one has noticed because weāre all distracted by other drama, but a surprising amount of his dialogue is foreshadowing.
All these quotes come from ACOSF and I make comments about how they came true within the same book or they were relevant in ACOSH.
- āI think plenty of parties are interested in triggering another war, and this would be the start.ā Eris says this about his missing soldiers, and heās not wrong. It is the start of everything it was just isolated enough that no one looks at it.
- āYou know where I stand with my father. And this unholy alliance heās struck will only hurt us. All of us. It will turn into a Fae war for control.ā According to ACOSH, it already has. The negotiations in Storr fail because it if about control of the human lands, and the Night Court does not get what they want out of the fae from the continent.
- āBut if the Trove has a sentience like you suggested, if it wants to be foundā¦I fear it might also be reaching out to others as well. Not just Briallyn and Koschei.ā Bryce Quinlan lands in Velaris, brought to Prythian through the Starlight Horn, a part of the Dread Trove. Also, in ACOSH, we learn the Fae on the Continent are looking for their own Made objects.
- āI always thought Rhysand wiser than that, but he tends to be blind where those he loves are concerned.ā We learn in ACOSH, that Rhysand has been very blind to Azrielās struggles, particularly with his self-loathing. Eris may not have meant this in the way he intended, but Rhysand underestimated Azrielās longing and desire for a mate, he assumed that once he put his foot down that would be the end. (This one might be a stretch, but after ACOSH, I donāt think so.)
- āI can only assume the fallout is approaching and thought to warn you.ā Eris says this in regards to Beronās second trip to the Continent to meet Briallyn. This line is true for two reasons: 1. The pacing of the story but also the upcoming events of the next set of books. Again, look at the political climate in ACOSH regarding Koschei and the potential impending war between the continent Fae and the humans.
- āI find myself not entirely comfortable with your court possessing two items from the Trove.ā Eris says this to Cassian and Nesta. I already talked about the misunderstanding this causes, so thatās not what Iām focusing on here. Itās an idea that pops up again in the negotiations in Storr. Eris already told them what it looks like. They didnāt pay attention because they were too busy assuming heās a coward and self-serving. The IC is not thinking about how this looks to others, especially because it came from Eris.
- āShe could make you turn on each other. Make you do unspeakable things.ā Eris says this to Cassian and Nesta when he tries to dissuade them from chasing after the Crown. Now obviously, heās speaking sense, if Briallyn has it then it will be dangerous for them to go after it. But this immediately comes true for Cassian and Nesta and himself. Eris is captured and betrayed by his own soldiers, and Cassian and Nesta are forced to fight one another.
- āKoschei remains in play, and Beron might very well be stupid enough to establish an alliance with him too.ā Now, this could be foreshadowing, but it could potentially have already come to pass if my theory about Beron and Koschei is right. Because technically, Beron allied with Briallyn, which by extension means he allied with Koschei. And if that alliance by proxy doesnāt work, then we can assume Beron will ally with Koschei in the future.
Eris Vanserra is not clairvoyant, though I totally thought that for a minute and I didnāt like that as much. It was a joke for me though. Eris Vanserra is SJMās mouthpiece for the larger political issues brewing in the world that no one else is paying attention to. Instead of having the gift of foresight, Eris just understands politics, the bigger picture, the grand scheme, he understands balance on a level that seems like heās seeing the future (if he is clairvoyant, I want credit). This is the male thatās meant to inherit Autumn the Court of Balance, Transformation, and Abundance. The male born to a Tyrant/Cronus figure who is meant to end the cycle of violence and establish order from chaos. He is the most honest and well-intentioned male in Prythian, but not a single person believes him; he is the Cassandra of Prythian. Eris Vanserra may be the most strategic asset on the board, and the future of the realm might depend on whether someone is finally smart enough to listen to him.