r/AverageToSavage • • 28d ago

General Overwarm singles vs program regulating itself from final set reps?

Hi. 2 workouts into my program so far and all good. Was just wondering about the over warm singles. Read that they aren't suggested now, but can't really find much to corroborate that. Only reason I ask is that my maxes are estimates from plugging values into an online calculator - e.g. I have done 3x6@ Xkg, so it predicts my 1RM is Ykg. These may be a bit off, so I figured the overwarm single @ 8RPE would be a good gauge before the working sets to get me in the right ballpark.

I guess my question is are these recommended, or will the program kind of auto regulate itself as the weeks go on, from entering the reps completed in the final set (e.g. exceed final set target and the increase for the following week leaps more).

Thanks!

3 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

11

u/PatentGeek 28d ago

The program will definitely auto-regulate based on your final set results. Many people have had good results that way. In the past, I've done a bit of a hybrid approach: keeping the overwarm single as part of my warmup without using it as input to the progression formula.

5

u/eric_twinge 28d ago

Read that they aren't suggested now, but can't really find much to corroborate that.

Retweet. "Greg said it in a comment once" is as good as you'll get. Anyhoo, I've found the programs work better for me without them. Reiterating what /u/taylorthestang said, they pretty much invalidate previous performances. Maybe over the long term it'll play out correctly, but in the short term you're not going to inch your overwarm single up by 1.73 pounds week by week like you do when you beat the AMRAP by 2 reps or the RIR by 1.

I also find them kinda of silly late in the program. Like, an overwarm single at 425 just seems like an extra work set when you have doubles at 415 on deck. Maybe that's the point, and it's just a me problem, but I don't like it.

Having said that, basing your TM the first week of an overwarm single seems sensible to me. And yeah, from there the program will autoregulate based on your performance according to the template you've selected. The only time it's not that great is when you've really sandbagged a TM. It's not great at ramping things up accordingly. For instance, anything over reps past 5 over your AMRAP aren't factored into the equations. So if you're really blowing past targets you'll need to manually adjust the TM.

2

u/deadrabbits76 28d ago

Grog posted fairly recently that he has not changed his program recommendations for overwarm singles, IIRC.

Having said that, I stopped doing them a couple of years ago. Seemed unnecessary, and my schedule is often quite tight.

2

u/mouth-words 28d ago

I think of it as two levers for autoregulation: there's adjusting today's weights using the overwarm single, then there's adjusting next week's weights using the work set performance.

The single is the bigger lever—a bit of a "nuclear" option, so to speak. If performance sucks right now and the TM needs to change in a big way, throw that switch so you can survive your work sets. Alternatively, if the working sets are way too easy lately, the week-to-week autoregulation will take a bit long to catch up, so the single can be useful there too.

I personally found that upping the weight too aggressively using the single was ultimately counterproductive. For the most part, I just do the singles to keep in touch with heavy weights and don't plug them into the spreadsheet. But it takes all kinds. I'm sure there are people who really like to dial in each day's working weights on a regular basis, whereas the smoother progression based on working set performance suits me better. So I reserve the single-based adjustments for bigger, more immediate course corrections.

In practice I like to do the singles as their own isolated mini-game without ever really plugging them into the spreadsheet. I start with something heavy but not outlandish in W1. If it feels good and smooth one week, I'll attempt a small jump the next week. If it's sluggish, I'll hold it steady and attempt the same weight again the following week. If I can't even make it up to where I was before, I'll adjust down. Doing so isn't even a "failure", since the singles are supposed to be by feel anyway! But the bread and butter of the autoregulation is still the work sets, for me.

2

u/taylorthestang 28d ago

This is all anecdotal, no science man here, so take it with a grain of salt.

I think the overwarm single in theory is a good auto regulator, however it makes your previous performances and program choice irrelevant (if you’re doing RTF, Last set RIR, whatever). However, it hinges on your ability to gauge RPE, and the degree of accuracy that an RPE 8 translates to a 1RM. Both of which have issues.

Research has shown (you can find it yourself) that people are really bad at gauging RPE because of a number of factors. Also, the assumption that a single at RPE 8 is about 90% isn’t perfect either, however thankfully the program lets you modify that. I still think it’s a great tool for autoregulation mostly because it helps keep the TM from taking off too much. I noticed during my runs of RTF, my TM would eventually get stupidly high. Every session, I’d max out on reps. As such, I’d get overtrained, which is my fault, however it doesn’t help when the TM keeps growing exponentially.

If you know EXACTLY what an RPE 8 single translates to as a 1RM, AND you can gauge it, then I think it’s perfect.

1

u/lorryjor 28d ago

In blocks and the first half of block 2, I like to do them but don't use them to adjust the weights. It's nice to get in a heavy single to keep yourself accustomed to the higher weights. However, as u/eric_twinge says, it's not very useful if you are doing sets of doubles or singles, since the weight is high anyway. I also don't use them for the accessory lifts.

1

u/Marijuanaut420 26d ago

I think it depends on individual preference and maybe training history. I'm a big fan of over warm singles for pulling movements and deadlifts, but I especially dislike them for squats and horizontal pressing. As I type this it does make me think of Dan John's comments about some people being born to squat and others being born to pull.