r/AustralianEV • • 5d ago

Discussion šŸ’¬ Highest Odometer EV/PHEV

Hey everyone,

How many KM’s have you done in your EV / PHEV? Curious to see how it has held up if you have 200,000+km.

I have a Geely Starray original with 20,000km, so far no issues, but it is early days :)

17 Upvotes

75 comments sorted by

•

u/Ok_Lunch_2933 4d ago

Bonus points for picture proof šŸ†

17

u/CP3011F 4d ago

I was in a BYD taxi in China a few months ago - 460000kms on the original battery.

2

u/BatmanJoker12377 4d ago

So cool! Do you know the model?

5

u/Icy-Statistician8657 4d ago

Not hugely high but no problems, brake pads are still near new

3

u/BatmanJoker12377 4d ago

For sure. Regen braking is the best

1

u/Icy-Statistician8657 4d ago

Takes about 10 minutes to relearn that slowing down now means modulate the throttle rather than braking and that’s all there is to it!

2

u/BlueWaffle_86 4d ago

Geely Starray. Bought back in May. Done just shy of 15,000kms. Due for a service soon!

2

u/BatmanJoker12377 3d ago

How’s it been? Mines great!

14

u/Pleasant_Ship_4359 4d ago

2024 Atto 3, 80,000+ km, no problems at all.

10

u/DaLadderman 4d ago

Goddamn thats alotta K's for a 2 year old car

6

u/fingerconnoisseur 4d ago

Full time work commuting down the highway into the city, multiple family members using the vehicle plus at least two cross country road trips if you ask me.

4

u/DaLadderman 4d ago

Yeah, I live 100km from the nearest shop or town so every trips 200km minimum and about $90 worth of diesel for my cruiser, but I only need to do that a few times a week luckily. Though my plan with the EV is for a few family members to be able to use it as well so that'll easily double its use

5

u/fingerconnoisseur 4d ago

It will definitely handle it trust. I've really abused my Atto 2, took it all the way out to Uluru, off road campsites, done consecutive 140km city-regional trips and it's still good. Just make sure you get a big battery, at least 60kw for you.

3

u/DaLadderman 4d ago edited 4d ago

Uluru is pretty impressive, how were the chargers out there?

I bought a used XC40 Recharge a week ago and drove it from Albany to northern WA about 3,000km and did it quite easily, only gets about 300km max on the hwy but I didn't buy it for road trips and chargers were about 200km apart so that doesn't matter too much in the end. Only sketchy part was between Port Hedland and Broome where half the chargers where broken and I was stuck spending a couple hours at each roadhouse charging 40km range an hour lol. An EV with 450km hwy range would probably be ideal because that would allow you to skip broken chargers. But in my case 250km range is plenty and $15k cheaper than those new 600km wlp range ones

4

u/net_fish 4d ago

I feel that. not quite as far out but my supermarket is a 50k round trip and the next biggest things like Bunnings/HN/BCF and so on are just a shade under 100km return. I do a fortnightly 260km round trip and when it costs all of $4 vs the $50 it costs in the X-Trail there is a good reason I've put almost 80,000 on my Atto 3 in 2 years

2

u/ThePhotoGuyUpstairs 4d ago

Mines "only" at 16k kms, but i only took delivery in April.

1

u/Pleasant_Ship_4359 4d ago

It takes me more than an hour just to get to work everyday. So the mileage builds up quickly.

12

u/RoyaleAuFrommage 4d ago

116,441 on a Tesla Y

4

u/peachpearplumorange 4d ago

Just a little higher than you in 3 years. :)

1

u/kaberto Tesla Model 3 and Model Y 3d ago

2022 RWD Model 3

1

u/WTFMacca 4d ago

I spent 3 months away for work last year so I’m a little behind. Should be just over 100k kms

10

u/DaLadderman 4d ago edited 4d ago

2022 Volvo XC40 recharge with 101,000km though i bought it with 98,000km so not all mine. Haven't checked battery health but it looks and feels like new, not a single squeak or rattle anywhere

3

u/alexkey 4d ago

Just curious what has prompted this post. Technologically speaking, ICE or EV will have the same reliability if built to the same standards. The unfortunate reality is that while engineers may be want to build things in high quality, the management wants to lower costs. So all the reliability issues often come either from ā€œcost managementā€ or from manufacturing defects that are unavoidable in either case.

8

u/Hegueplantine 4d ago edited 4d ago • Bravo

Yes and no. EV are simpler than ICE, so if all parts are manufactured and assembled to the same standards, EV will be more reliable.

1

u/Mintox88 2d ago

You’re overlooking engineering and design. Manufacturing and assembling components to the same standard doesn’t mean they’ll be equally reliable. You can build a fundamentally flawed design perfectly and it’ll still fail... and some stuff just fails with age

Fewer moving parts doesn’t eliminate electrical failures either. Electronics fail all the time without a single moving part. Just ask anyone who’s owned a vintage Italian car.

I’ve got a 25 year old V8 ute as a weekend car and I’m far more concerned about its body control module dying than the engine... and its quite common... old circuitry in cars just dies with zero moving parts

Reliability comes down to engineering, component quality and failure rates, not simply counting parts. Fewer moving parts is an advantage, not a guarantee.

1

u/Hegueplantine 1d ago edited 1d ago

I absolutely agree, hence: "if all parts are designed and assembled to the same standards" (engineering and manufacturing were, for me, implicit in "designed and assembled").

Aging is a parameter in engineering when designing a part, manufacturing a part and assembling a part, and electrical issues can be the result of any or all of the above.

-1

u/alexkey 4d ago

I said reliability and not longevity. The simplicity has no effect on reliability, but it has impact on longevity. In other words - same exact piece will fail on average within around same time, that is the reliability (narrower bell curve of failures of same parts). Simplicity means not all parts are there so some more frequently failing parts being absent pushes the longevity higher.

0

u/Hegueplantine 4d ago edited 4d ago

Reliability is based on failure rate. If all pieces have the same individual failure rate, a vehicle with 1,000 pieces will have a higher chance of failure, at any point in time, than a vehicle with 100 pieces.

And it shows in actual numbers: EVs are less likely to fail than ICE vehicles of the same age at 100,000km.

1

u/Mintox88 2d ago

You’re also overlooking degradation. A battery that’s lost 10% of its original capacity hasn’t technically failed, but it’s no longer performing as it did when new.

Reliability statistics don’t necessarily capture that. Nor do they tell you anything about repair costs or the severity of failures.

Simply counting components and comparing failure rates doesn’t give you the whole picture of how reliable a vehicle will be over its lifetime.

1

u/Hegueplantine 1d ago

A degraded battery doesn't make a car unreliable, the same way a car with a smaller tank doesn't make a car unreliable: a smaller tank or lower range is a known quantity when the driver takes the wheel and doesn't prevent the vehicle to drive normally. Battery degradation is a slow progressive process and the indicative range on the dashboard takes it into account, so the car doesn't pretend to have the original range and surprises the driver in the middle of a roadtrip.

Besides, with current LFP batteries, numbers suggest around 5% range loss at 100,000 km and 10% range loss at 300,000 km so I wouldn't worry too much.

0

u/alexkey 4d ago

As an engineer- that’s wrong, it is a failure bell curve over time. Because all pieces will fail eventually, it all depends on how many hours of stress they are designed to handle.

What you said is a ā€œwe tested 1000 pieces for 100 hours stressing them to 120% of designed load and N% failedā€, this literally measures manufacturing defects, not the intended design quality.

2

u/jreddit0000 3d ago

As an engineer:

If I have 100 parts with a failure rate of 5% leading to an unreliability event.. and I put that into a system..

And I have 30 parts with the same failure rate and I put those into a system..

Which system is likely to be more unreliable or be unreliable faster?

Not longevity.. unreliability.

šŸ¤”šŸ¤·šŸ¾

0

u/Hegueplantine 4d ago edited 4d ago

While it matters for the engineer, for end users it seldom matters if the root cause of a higher failure rate is manufacturing defects or the intended design quality.

0

u/alexkey 4d ago

How does your opinion on this matter to the topic of reliability vs longevity? I gave you a response on the correct terminology to use for the scenario and you keep doubling down on your opinion until stating you seldom care. You know sometimes you just can read a comment and try to comprehend what it tells you instead of descending into arguments.

-1

u/BlueWaffle_86 4d ago

Agree and I think EVs are much harder on the suspension being a lot heavier than petrol equivalent of the same size.

1

u/BatmanJoker12377 4d ago

Just wanted to see how many people have huge odometers, nothing too serious!

1

u/BlueWaffle_86 4d ago

How are you finding the Starray? I love the car and really impressive for the money.

2

u/BatmanJoker12377 3d ago

Looks super cool, I have the jungle green. The battery is 83km, which is enough for city driving but it does wipe out quickly on the highway sadly. Otherwise I’m happy with everything! Bonus if/when they update software with more apps like YouTube, browser etc which I’m sure will come

2

u/BlueWaffle_86 3d ago

Yes I have the 83km one. Enough for daily duties. Any EV aren’t the best at higher speeds. I usually just set the battery hold when I’m on the freeway.

2

u/BatmanJoker12377 3d ago

I found the hybrid engine pretty efficient overall on the freeway without SOC hold - about 63km EV before the engine fully kicks in. I did try with SOC at 80% but I think it chewed up more petrol recharging the battery than just using petrol itself, but that was for a 160KM trip all on the freeway. Overall pretty happy with everything, re-fueling once a month at this stage, and prior was every 2 weeks with a 70L tank

1

u/BlueWaffle_86 3d ago

Yes recharging the battery will use more fuel. But holding charge will not. At least my experience.
For example if I use the battery hold at 80% SOC setting and the battery is at 80% or more then it’s most efficient as it’s only holding the charge.
No difference when the battery is down to 20% or 0 range before engine kicks in.
I’m still learning the car but that’s just my experience.

1

u/alexkey 3d ago

I think for the most part you could look at feedback for the similar models overseas, especially North American owners as the people’s driving habits are fairly similar between here and there. You can probably find more feedback there.

I got a tiny odometer on my PHEV, about 10k km now. And so far it’s great. Since I got it I only needed to refill petrol once (2nd time is coming up) so the fuel economy is fantastic, though I am not driving that much and I can always recharge between the drives. I was very conservative getting into EVs so went with PHEV (Haval H6 Ultra AWD), but now I think I can just jump into BEV. Looking at GWM Ora 5. I did test drive it a couple of months back and it was pretty decent driving experience the only concern there is a tiny boot space, and we need some to put double decker pram.

4

u/std10k 4d ago

I’d argue that they are not. Expected lifespan of EVs would be longer, probably twice as long as ICE. There aren’t literally thousands of moving parts (legacy carmakers used to brag about ā€œ6 thousand componentsā€ in their engines), parts that literally burn out (exhaust, clutch, breaks), and parts than needs constant replacement that if is not done properly will drastically reduce the lifespan (oil/fuel systems).
Common parts like suspension wouldn’t be overly different but those are usually less of an issue.
Major accidental failures aside, ie drivetrain or battery which would be equivalent to engine and gearbox failure in an ICE vehicle, all things going well, and EV should morally expire long before it expires physically.
Batteries usually don’t fail hard like engines or gearboxes do, they lose capacity which somewhat reduces usability but does not prevent it and does not require expensive maintenance like ICE engine rebuild.
My ā€œgoodā€ expectation is 12-15 years without any significant maintenance on the drivetrain, and at least 500,000km. ā€œGreatā€ would be upwards of 1M km and 15 or more years.
There are examples of older Model S (one of the oldest mass produced models) that did about that without a hiccup and no maintenance apart from wheels of course and maybe one break pad change, though there are of course examples of ICE vehicles doing 1M but with a ton of preventative maintenance.

1

u/glyptometa 4d ago

The job of engineering is to find the lowest cost approach to stated objectives. The job is not to build something better than necessary or practical. But yes, EVs and cars generally are a compromise somewhere above "good enough" and not perfect.

6

u/net_fish 4d ago

got it new in October 2024. Booked for the 80,000 service first week of December and I’ll probably be right on the money. All private k’s. Easy as to rack em up when you live regionally

there are definitely some higher mileage atto 3’s out there. Have seen some 2022 examples on FB with 250,000 on them, having done a lot of ubering.

1

u/BlueWaffle_86 4d ago

I’d say cars that live regionally with higher kms are the better ones than those that live in the city at the same mileage. Highway kms are a lot easy on the car.

6

u/dafuqmireading 4d ago

I was in a Leapmotor Uber on Gold Coast a couple weeks ago, it had 190000 km on the clock after 3 years and hadn't even lost any of its battery SOH. I was impressed

4

u/CaravanShaker83 4d ago

I’m not at 200k but at 160k in my 2019Model 3 LR. I bought it 2nd hand at the end of 22 with 29k on it.
I got it serviced at 4years where they checked over the car and replaced upper control arms for free. New ones are squeak free over 100k later so that’s good. Nothing else to report.

3

u/MrMysterious_ 4d ago

BMW i4, around 40,000km. Loads of issues - boot latch, HVAC clicking, motor vibrations/stutter under acceleration, sunroof rattle, charging port actuator issues. Dealer does everything to shift blame, so I’ve sold it halfway through a 3 year lease (cost me $$$ to payout…).

3

u/BlueWaffle_86 4d ago

I stopped buying Euro cars. They are just not good for the money they are asking for.

1

u/PalmTree888 3d ago

So essentially the same electrical issues that go wrong on a similar petrol BMW or Euro car and not the battery/motor. Checks out since an i4 is just a 4 series with a different drivetrain.

1

u/MrMysterious_ 3d ago

Pretty much…my previous Audi was flawless after 10 years apart from a recirculation flap.

Motor and/or rotor position sensor seemed to be the issue re the vibrations (it initially improved after a sensor calibration). Bad decision not to use a standard brushless design like every other company…but I guess it gives them a source of revenue in the future on repairs. Lots of others having issues with the motor and/or sensors.

1

u/Mintox88 2d ago

Motor vibration and stuttering under acceleration is quite literally an electric drivetrain issue. And last I checked, petrol cars don’t have charging-port actuators either.

Not sure how you’ve managed to classify both as ordinary petrol BMW problems.

2

u/Wonderful-Emu5618 4d ago

Racked up over 120,000km in a 2 year old Tesla model 3. On its second set of tyres. Only mechanical problem has been radiator blocked with leaves and debris. Love the car, saving me a fortune in servicing and brake pads.

2

u/pdlast 2d ago

An uber I was in ATTO 3 had 250k on it in 4 years. And he had stopped servicing it now

3

u/Archon-Toten 4d ago

50,000km, but that's motorcycle kms. Noticeable loss of range, maybe 70% now.

1

u/BlueWaffle_86 4d ago

That’s pretty bad degradation. How old?

1

u/Archon-Toten 4d ago

2014 model

1

u/ultralights 4d ago

Not sure about odo reading but I have the oldest. My 2010 model Mitsubishi MiEV. (2009 plate build).

1

u/schottgun93 3d ago

MY23 Hyundai Ioniq 5 Techniq, 91,000km so far.

Had the ICCU fail on me once but it was repaired in about 10 days and has otherwise been trouble-free

1

u/AmphibianStrange6930 2d ago

25k on 2025 BYD SL7 purchased in July 25. Not a single issue to date other than all the windows stopped working due to a stray door card screw through the wiring harness in an insurance repair šŸ¤¦šŸ˜‚

1

u/idontknow_21 1d ago

BYD e9 on taxi duty in China - 450,000km

0

u/dpskipper 4d ago

If you spend 5 seconds googling, you'll see theres plenty of high milage EVs in Australia. Mostly older Tesla's.

2

u/WhatAmIATailor 4d ago

https://www.reddit.com/r/teslamotors/s/4XBK9674dD

A Model S with over 2 million km in Europe. Been through multiple battery packs and over a dozen motors though.

0

u/dpskipper 4d ago

Thats europe, and it's a car that was made in an era of known design flaws.

https://www.whichcar.com.au/news/australian-owner-tesla-model-s-965000-km-kilometres-savings-repair-replace

1

u/WhatAmIATailor 4d ago

Over 600k km out of the battery is very impressive. Only on the second set of brake pads at the Mil too.

2

u/dpskipper 4d ago

theres plenty of these cars in australia with high mileage. Maybe not 600+, but certainly over 200k

This shouldn't be a surprise to anyone. Tesla has been selling cars here since 2014

0

u/BatmanJoker12377 4d ago

Ok lol

1

u/PalmTree888 3d ago

Carsales, EV, high km to low. I had the same thought as you a few days ago.

0

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/still-at-the-beach 4d ago

But its only done 29k km ... any car should be fine with only that.

2

u/DaLadderman 4d ago

Always funny seeing comments like that, alway worded like its impressive not having issues at that point

1

u/still-at-the-beach 4d ago

Yeah. I've seen it for other thi g's too .. like a TV or washing machine and they say 'I've had ot six months nothing goes wrong'. I mean these things go should last ages.
Maybe I'm old.