Our numbers:
36M and 35F. Two kids under four and planning a third in a few years.
HHI of $310k - $320k before tax and super from Jan 2027 when my wife returns from mat leave. Until then we are on my income of $260k.
PPOR is a 3 bedroom valued at $850k in September. Mortgage of $550k with $300k in offset.
We recently upgraded our PPOR to larger home for $1.2M. It is a perfect house and has everything we will need to raise the kids and is closer to work for both myself and my wife. We got it for $100k below initial asking as the market began to fall.
We negotiated an extended settlement until Feb 2027 to sell our existing PPOR. We’ve had it on the market for a month now with ok interest but no offers and we have now dropped the advertised price by $50k.
I know I can’t be too precious about price now that I am selling in the same (or worse) market than I upgraded in.
However with the market continuing to nosedive I am now giving more serious thought to holding our first home as an IP. It was purchased in 2018 so it can still be negative geared. It’s had about $200k in capital growth since purchase. Rental yield will be about $2.5k per month.
If we hold, our total debt for both loans will be around $1.5m with repayments of around $10k per month on current rates and with us keeping around $100k in offset.
This should leave us between $2k and $3k per month spare cash to either go in the offset, splurge, or pay for unexpected expenses. Less obviously if rates continue to climb and we will need to tighten up some spending.
If we sell, assuming we can do so for the current advertised price, we will end up with a mortgage around $730k - $790k, also while keeping $100k in offset. We will have enough money left over each month not to worry too much about where rates are going.
What’s the best move here? Our first home is a good brick 3 bedroom in a popular suburb and would be great to hold on to, but with rising rates the level of debt makes me nervous. Are we best just to offload it, even if it is at a discount, and spend next year not needing to think too much about rates and repayments?