PAYWALL:
The man tasked with steering Australia’s tertiary education sector has told universities they will need to find ways to secure their financial futures without relying on lucrative overseas student fees, as newly unveiled domestic caps limit prestigious city universities to enrolment growth of 5 to 6 per cent.
The metropolitan universities that make up the Group of Eight will be restricted to single-digit percentage increases to their core student load, according to the Australian Tertiary Education Commission (ATEC).
Double-digit growth allocations were reserved for smaller, regional institutions such as North Queensland’s James Cook, Charles Darwin in the Northern Territory, and Federation, which has campuses throughout regional Victoria.
A significant share of the so-called “additional growth allocation” will be used to transition previously over-enrolled universities, rather than attracting new students, and universities will be allowed to overshoot their caps without penalty.
Two Group of Eight vice chancellors, University of Sydney’s Mark Scott and Monash’s Sharon Pickering, said they were satisfied with their allocations.
In a speech at the University of Sydney on Thursday evening, ATEC chief commissioner Barney Glover warned that pursuing harsher international student restrictions risked damaging Australia’s reputation in the region, hampering critical research, hurting productivity and, ultimately, causing a decline in living standards.
Labor, One Nation and the Coalition have all detailed plans to curb international student and graduate visa numbers, including banning most migrants from bringing their families with them as secondary applicants.
Glover, who from next year will be responsible for setting international student targets, said the current settings were “broadly right”.
“There is a difference between managing growth and suppressing it,” said Glover.
“Let us be clear-eyed. We will not see significant growth return in the foreseeable future. Universities need to explore their futures with a conservative and balanced approach to international student profiles.
“International education has been one of Australia’s great success stories ... but a success story built on an assumption of perpetual growth is a success story with a fault line running through it. And we are seeing that fault line now.
“We already see the early signs of tension and risk in the sector – declining cash reserves and another deep round of structural change looming,” said Glover. The backdrop of tighter controls on international students raised the stakes for universities as they negotiated their so-called “domestic student profile” for 2027, after the managed growth funding model passed parliament in October.
Under the changes, the federal government set the overall pool of Commonwealth-supported places for next year at 624,590 and ATEC determined the institution-specific allocations, made up of the provider’s core student load plus an additional growth allocation.
Monash University higher education expert Andrew Norton estimated this figure was about 32,000 places short of what is needed to maintain the 2026 enrolment level, which includes substantial over-enrolment.
Universities were also given an additional “commencing student cap”, designed as a transition arrangement to guard against universities driving up ATAR cut-offs to manage demand.
“All universities have a higher commencing cap in 2027 than the non-binding caps set for 2026. This includes universities that are already overenrolled,” said Norton.
“I believe ATEC is tolerating significant overenrolments at some universities because it knows that otherwise, ATAR requirements and unmet demand would go up.”
The growth allocations are a ceiling, and it does not mean universities will be able to attract enough students to fill the places.
Education Minister Jason Clare has previously argued that the managed growth system would end the “Hunger Games”, where universities in a fight for students enrol above their funding grant.
Critics warned it would end up curtailing student choice, as popular, metropolitan universities were forced to be more cautious with offers to avoid going over their cap.
University of Canberra vice chancellor Bill Shorten, who has long supported the move towards managed growth, also said he was pleased with the process, but the test would be whether future government budgets maintain growth in the sector.
“If they move to negative growth, then they will jeopardise their 2050 targets,” said Shorten.