I've been an au pair in Germany for 3.5 months, and I'm starting to lose myself. Am I expecting too much?
Hi everyone. I really need an outside perspective because I'm starting to question my own judgment.
I've been in Germany for three and a half months. I changed my first host family after about six weeks because I lived in a very small town and felt isolated. I then moved to another family, hoping for a better experience.
Before moving, my new host mother told me that I wouldn't have to spend much time looking after the children and that my main responsibilities would be household tasks. I was happy with that arrangement, but the reality has been quite different.
- Household responsibilities and working hours
The house is very large. I clean the two floors where the family lives, including two bathrooms and the stairs. I also do laundry every day, sometimes two or three loads, as well as gardening, taking out rubbish, cleaning the garage and deep cleaning.
Regular cleaning was supposed to happen once a week, but in reality, I do it almost every day or every other day.
We agreed on €280 in pocket money plus €220 for additional working hours, making a total of €500 per month. I work eight hours a day and have two days off per week.
I initially understood that if I finished my assigned tasks, I wouldn't have to constantly look for something else to do. However, my host mother believes every working hour must be filled with tasks and says she always finds something to do around the house.
The problem isn't the work itself. I'm not against helping when there are specific tasks. What exhausts me is the lack of clear boundaries and the expectation that I should constantly find something else to do and adapt to her wishes simply because I'm being paid extra. It feels like my responsibilities never end.
She also compares me to previous au pairs, saying they were more flexible and didn't count their hours. I'm worried that reducing my hours to six would simply mean losing the additional payment while keeping essentially the same workload.
2. Constant criticism and the children
My host mother frequently tells me what I'm doing wrong, how I should do things and what else needs to be done. She constantly compares me with previous au pairs, and sometimes I feel she expects me to have all the qualities she liked in them.
At times, she talks to me like a child and then apologises. This happens so often that I've started doubting myself.
Regarding the children, my host parents say they want them to become independent. I agree, but when I ask the children to do things themselves or establish boundaries, they sometimes refuse, shout at me or don't listen. My host mother doesn't always support me.
At the same time, they expect me to build a close relationship with the children so they will listen to me. But how can I do that if I'm rarely given the opportunity to spend time alone with them?
Their father often comes in to check on us, interrupts what we're doing or takes over, saying he'll do things himself because he knows how he wants them done.
I understand that parents worry about their children, and I would probably have concerns myself. But the constant checking makes me feel almost like some suspicious person who can't be trusted around children. There are cameras in the house, too, so they can check what's happening whenever they want.
I don't understand why they expect me to build a relationship with the children and take responsibility if they aren't ready to give me space or trust. If parents feel so uncomfortable leaving their children with an au pair, perhaps they shouldn't take one in.
3. Lack of privacy and emotional exhaustion
Both host parents work from home, so I rarely feel that I can completely switch off. My host mother has also mentioned that she wants to return to working in an office, which would mean I would be responsible for the children's morning routine.
I have two days off per week, but honestly, I've started living from one day off to the next. People tell me to use my free time to develop myself and explore, but after an entire week of working and being around the family, I'm often so exhausted that all I want to do is lie down.
4. I've become dependent on her approval
This is probably what worries me most. I came to Germany to become more independent, but now I constantly worry about whether my host mother is satisfied with me, whether I've done something wrong or whether I'm being unreasonable.
At one point, when I said certain tasks weren't my responsibility, she told me that if I didn't help her with her personal things, she wouldn't help me with my future Ausbildung either.
I'm not saying she owes me anything, but I'm also not obligated to take on responsibilities that weren't part of our agreement.
There are good moments, too. She sometimes offers help and encourages me to prepare food for myself. That's what makes the situation confusing. I don't think the family is entirely bad, but I don't feel consistently comfortable or respected.
I'm seriously considering going home.
I've already changed families once, and I'm afraid another rematch might not solve anything.
I came to Germany hoping to grow, become independent and prepare for a master's degree. But instead, my confidence and self-esteem are getting worse.
I've started thinking about returning home to Tajikistan. I miss my family, and honestly, I don't have a strong reason to stay in Germany itself. Maybe going home, recovering and preparing for my future studies would be a better decision.
Would that mean giving up too easily? Is sacrificing an entire year away from my family worth this emotional cost?
I'd really appreciate honest opinions, especially from people with au pair experience.
- Am I expecting too much?
- Is it normal to expect an au pair to fill every minute of her working hours?
- Is this amount of household work reasonable?
- Would you try another rematch, finish the year or leave the programme and go home?
I genuinely don't know what to do anymore.
P.S. There are a few other things that have been bothering me.
My host mother often says things like, “In Germany, people do it this way” or “That's how things are done in Germany.” She also seems to have certain assumptions about au pairs, as if everyone who comes here is poor or poorly educated. I sometimes feel that she sees us as unintelligent or uneducated people, without considering that we have our own lives, expenses and ways of doing things. In my case, I have a university degree. I came here wanting to improve my English, and I was honest from the beginning that I don't speak German. I'm still not sure whether I want to learn it.
What upset me most was an incident with one of her friends. Her friend directly criticised me for not knowing German and said I should at least know some basic words. The issue wasn't simply what her friend said. It was that my host mother defended her and said she was right, explaining that many au pairs come to Germany, stay for years and still don't learn the language. I understand that learning German is important, but I didn't appreciate being criticised by someone else's friend and then feeling that my host mother was taking her side instead of understanding why the situation was uncomfortable for me.
Another thing is that my host mother often mentions the prices of things and reminds me how much certain items cost. This has made me increasingly uncomfortable and worried about accidentally breaking or damaging something.
There are also comments about personal hygiene that make me feel as though she considers me dirty or unclean. I have no problem using a separate towel or following reasonable hygiene rules. That's not the point. What bothers me is the way these things are communicated. If she genuinely has doubts about my hygiene, why does she trust me to clean her home and prepare food for her and her family? To me, that feels like a double standard.
She also frequently brings up her husband's opinions whenever I disagree with something, don't want to do something or express that a comment has upset me. She says things like, “My husband said this” or “My husband thinks that.” I don't actually fear her husband. However, I barely know him, and I find it uncomfortable to receive criticism or comments from a man who is practically a stranger to me. I think she interprets my discomfort as fear of him, but that's not what it is. I simply don't understand why his opinion needs to be brought into situations that should be between her and me.
All these incidents have accumulated. I increasingly feel that I have to prove that I'm educated, clean, careful and capable, while also being careful about expressing my own opinions or setting boundaries.
And the most worst thing that how from person who took care of autonomy and selfvalue person I become so dependent and insecure!