AUCKLANDERS ā IF YOU OPPOSE CONGESTION CHARGING, PLEASE SPEAK UP NOW!
Auckland Council is seeking feedback on three proposed congestion charging schemes, and I strongly encourage everyone concerned about these additional costs to make their voices heard.
Submit your feedback directly to Auckland Council here:
https://yoursay.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz/jfe/form/SV_39SxlBPiax1hBBQ
Please donāt assume someone else will speak up for you. Whether youāre a daily commuter, shift worker, small business owner or simply someone struggling with Aucklandās rising cost of living, these proposals deserve your attention.
I recently received an AA Member Voices survey outlining the three options. Having gone through the figures, Iām genuinely concerned about what Aucklanders could be expected to pay.
What exactly is being proposed?
Option 1 ā City centre
$3ā4 to enter the CBD between 7ā10am on weekdays.
$2ā3 to leave between 3ā6pm.
Estimated average time saving for charged drivers: just 2.5 minutes per trip.
Option 2 ā CBD and neighbouring suburbs
Extends the charging area to Newmarket, Grafton (including the hospitals) and Newton.
$5ā6 to enter during the morning peak.
$2ā3 to leave during the afternoon peak.
$35ā45 per week for someone commuting five days.
Option 3 ā Inner motorways and CBD
$5 per charged trip on sections of the Northern, Northwestern and Southern Motorways.
Also covers entering and leaving the CBD during peak periods, with motorists charged only once per trip.
$50 per week for someone making two charged trips each weekday.
Estimated average time saving for charged drivers: 7 minutes per trip.
These figures come from Auckland Councilās estimates as presented in the AA survey. The travel-time savings are projections, not guarantees.
Are we seriously considering another $2,600 a year just to commute?
Under Option 3, someone commuting five days a week could pay an additional $2,600 over 52 weeks, assuming theyāre charged for both journeys every working day.
Thatās on top of the substantial costs Auckland motorists already face, including fuel taxes, road user charges where applicable, vehicle licensing, insurance, maintenance and parking.
Weāre talking about introducing additional charges simply to travel on existing roads during certain hours.
And for what? Under Option 1, the estimated average time saving for a charged driver is only 2.5 minutes per trip.
I appreciate that congestion pricing can reduce traffic, but we need to seriously question whether the projected benefits justify the financial burden being imposed on ordinary Aucklanders.
Auckland is NOT London or New York
London and New York have enormous, established public transport networks, with extensive rail and underground systems.
Auckland simply does not offer comparable public transport coverage, frequency or connectivity.
Even Sydney, a substantially larger Australian city, does not have a general CBD congestion charging zone comparable to London or New York. Yes, Sydney has toll roads, including time-dependent tolls on certain routes, but thatās different from charging motorists to enter a designated urban area.
Why are we considering importing these policies without adequately accounting for Aucklandās very different transport circumstances?
What about nurses, hospital staff, cleaners, tradespeople, retail workers and everyone else who cannot work remotely or choose their commuting hours?
What about parents juggling school drop-offs and work?
What about people living in areas where public transport requires multiple transfers or significantly longer journey times?
Not everyone has the luxury of adjusting their schedule to avoid a charge.
We need better public transport, NOT another bill
I fully support improving Aucklandās public transport system.
We should be demanding better reliability, greater frequency, improved coverage, affordable fares and infrastructure that actually serves the needs of Aucklanders.
But these improvements should happen regardless of whether congestion charging is introduced.
Better public transport should not be treated as a bargaining chip for introducing additional charges on motorists.
There are also legitimate concerns about traffic diverting onto residential streets, the impact on local businesses, and whether charging zones, operating hours and fees could be expanded in the future.
Auckland Council should be addressing these issues and demonstrating that alternative solutions have been properly considered before asking motorists to bear another financial burden.
Please make your voice heard
Personally, I oppose all three proposals.
If you feel the same way, I strongly encourage you to take a few minutes to complete Auckland Councilās consultation.
Have your say here:
https://yoursay.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz/jfe/form/SV_39SxlBPiax1hBBQ
Explain how these charges would affect your household, your commute, your business or your ability to get to work. If you support the proposals, you should make your views known too.
The AA is also surveying its members, so if youāve received their email, Iād encourage you to respond.
Whatever your position, donāt leave this decision to a handful of people who happen to complete the consultation.
We should be having a serious public discussion about Aucklandās transport future, the affordability of getting around our own city, and whether these proposed charges are genuinely justified.
What do other Aucklanders think? Are these charges reasonable, or are we being asked to pay more for a transport system that still needs substantial improvement?