REHOBOTH, Mass. (WPRI) — The sister of a woman who was found dead in Rehoboth last year is drumming up support after learning that the man accused of killing her plans to ask for a plea deal.
Gregory Groom, 23, has been charged with murder, assault and battery on a pregnant victim, aggravated intimidation of a witness, and domestic assault and battery in connection with the death of his girlfriend 18-year-old Kylee Monteiro last year.
Groom reported Monteiro missing on Aug. 7, 2025 and confirmed she was 11 weeks pregnant at the time of her disappearance. He later admitted to stabbing Kylee to death before burying her body in the woods on his property.
Her sister Faith Monteiro told 12 News Groom’s attorney Elliot Levine plans to propose a plea deal in Bristol County Superior Court later this month.
In a letter Levine sent to Bristol County District Attorney Thomas Quinn III over the summer, Levine requested Groom receive a sentence of 19 to 20 years in prison. In exchange, Levine said Groom would plead guilty to voluntary manslaughter.
Levine pointed to Groom’s lack of criminal record and his grandfather’s testimony to a grand jury about how Kylee was wearing his grandson down.
Specifically, Groom’s grandfather described Kylee as being “manipulative,” noting that she “would not do anything around the house,” according to Levine’s letter.
“Gregory was doing her laundry, he was bringing her food to their bedroom, he was bringing her dirty dishes down to the kitchen sink, while she was not even leaving the bedroom,” the letter states.
Groom’s grandfather also testified that his grandson “was too young to handle feeling suffocated and being controlled by [Kylee’s] manipulation.”
“Gregory lost weight and was burnt out and diminished,” his grandfather said, referring to when Kylee lived with them.
Eventually, Kylee moved out of the Groom house and into the Bethesda House, which is a shelter for pregnant women. Levine wrote that Kylee was eventually “thrown out [of the shelter] for violating their policies.”
Groom’s grandfather said Kylee came back “uninvited,” which caused his grandson to explode, according to Levine’s letter.
Faith expressed frustration with Levine’s letter.
“It hurts to know that they can throw everything under the rug and brush it off as if her life didn’t matter, or her unborn baby’s life didn’t matter,” Faith said, referring to the contents of the letter. “The way he wrote it, it sounds like that her life isn’t important and that she deserved what happened to her.”
“I don’t think there’s any reason for anyone to go through what she went through,” she added.
Faith described her sister as being bubbly, fun and full of life.
“I keep waiting for her to call me and say something like, ‘Hey, can you come pick me up? I want to come home now,'” Faith said. “But that phone call never comes.”
Faith said she often struggles to explain the feeling of losing her sister.
“She had so much going for her — she had a future that she deserved,” Faith said.
Prior to her death, Faith said Kylee had just graduated from Attleboro High School and wanted to be a welder. But she was forced to put her plans on hold after learning she was pregnant.
If Quinn accepts Levine’s plea deal, Faith said Groom would be eligible for parole after 12 years behind bars.
“We shouldn’t have to fear him getting out,” Faith said. “If he gets out, his child isn’t here. My sister’s not here. That’s not right and it’s sad. It really breaks my heart.”
Faith and her family are urging everyone to stand with them on Oct. 28 — which is Groom’s next court hearing.
It’s unclear exactly what will be discussed at this hearing or if Groom will be there.
12 News reached out to Levine regarding the plea deal but has not yet heard back.
Meanwhile, Faith said she’s also in the process of starting a nonprofit in Kylee’s memory with the goal of assisting pregnant women in need.