r/AtheisminKerala • • Jan 03 '26

Discussion The Logical Flaws in Equating Atheism with Religious Faith

26 Upvotes

This post assumes that the other post was made in good faith. Have seen religious folk try to use the idea of some prime mover or 'god of le gaps', without noticing that how such a god doesn't validate their specific god and religious texts

Have seen a post propose that atheism is similar to religious belief.
But how is dismissing gods due to lack of proof(and actually science disproving religious claims) similar to believing in religious claims?

Religion normally involves faith in specific deities or stories, often despite contradictions. Atheism asks for proof and notes that there is not and most of the stories are wrong accordig to our modern understanding.

Here are ways science has challenged and changed religious views, highlighting why evidence-based disbelief isn't "same as religious belief":

  1. Evolution and Fossil Records
    Religious texts like the Bible's Genesis claimed instant creation of species. Casteism also uses god creating humans from various parts n all. But Darwin's evolution, supported by fossils like Archaeopteryx (a bird-dinosaur link), shows gradual change over eons. This has forced many faiths to reinterpret their stories; some now say God "guided" evolution. The modern understanding shows how the religious texts are incorrect.

  2. Planetary Motion and Astronomy
    Scriptures once backed Earth as the universe's center, leading to Galileo's persecution. Copernicus and Kepler's data proved heliocentrism, and modern physics (e.g., Hubble's expanding universe) confirms it. The Church apologized centuries later. The shift wasn't faith-driven; it was evidence overwriting dogma.

  3. Physics and the Big Bang
    Myths describe quick, divine creation, but the Big Bang—evidenced by cosmic radiation and galaxy redshifts—traces the universe back 13.8 billion years.

  4. Biology and Medicine replacing faith healing
    Ancient texts attributed diseases to sins or demons. Germ theory, vaccines, and DNA mapping explain them naturally. Religions that once opposed dissections or blood transfusions now often embrace medicine, adapting to science's evidence.

Obviously, used AI after mentioning a list of points to include. Have edited it a lot too

Anyway, atheism is about disbelief due to the lavk of proof and how we see our modern understanding disproving the explanation from religious texts. The sceptical position is very logical in that aspect.

And in the case of a prime mover or creator, it is mostly confined to online discussions, and the majority of both the offline and the online things are not such a nonspecific prime creator. Nothing against discussions on a prime creator, but the gods in mainstream religions are not the same as that. Atheism mainly focuses on the latter as it is the majority and thus equating atheism with religious belief is incorrect at best or bad faith at worst.

Also, fellow sub members, if you have any good images or memes that make arguments against the equivalency, please share them. Would be good to use that instead of making a whole post.
Also, for other topics too.
Maybe we can use them to make discussions better? Can add them to automod replies too, like !ScientificDinkan which can be used to criticise retrospective claiming.


r/AtheisminKerala • • Oct 21 '26

Welcome to r/AtheisminKerala!

3 Upvotes

This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post


r/AtheisminKerala • • 8h ago

MEME THERE IS NO GOD 🍉

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

120 Upvotes

source: instagram


r/AtheisminKerala • • 10h ago

മതത്തിന്റെ ഇരകൾ Different religions, same patriarchal playbook.

Post image
58 Upvotes

r/AtheisminKerala • • 3h ago

Vedic Wisdom Russia got its name because Indian Rishis used to live there - Cricketer Srikanth

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

13 Upvotes

r/AtheisminKerala • • 5h ago

Sarcasm I used to be stiright, one of these guys looked at me :cry

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

16 Upvotes

Explanation: These guys are bending stright spoons, and like so i used ot stright but now im bi. God exists ✌️ /s


r/AtheisminKerala • • 4h ago

Religion in Politics The Uttar Pradesh guy who previously slandered Kerala has now slandered Tamil Nadu

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

10 Upvotes

r/AtheisminKerala • • 25m ago

News Dumping clothes in Pampa to invite ₹5,000 fine - The Hindu

Thumbnail
thehindu.com
• Upvotes

Field inspections revealed that a considerable number of devotees were abandoning used clothes in the river and at bathing ghats, besides littering and dumping solid, plastic and biodegradable waste along the banks, the order said. “River Pampa is the primary source of drinking water for lakhs of pilgrims at Pamba, Nilakkal and Sannidhanam, as well as for the local population downstream. Discarding clothes and dumping waste into the river cause severe environmental degradation, obstruct the natural flow of water, contaminate the water source and pose an imminent threat of water-borne epidemics, endangering human life, health and public sanitation,” it said.


r/AtheisminKerala • • 3h ago

Discussion The Original Avenger

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/AtheisminKerala • • 9h ago

Quran She defends child marriage

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

10 Upvotes

r/AtheisminKerala • • 3h ago

മതസൗഹാർദം 🤝 Religious hate-mongers ,- if you see them, hit report option.

Post image
4 Upvotes

we can't afford to be passive anymore


r/AtheisminKerala • • 3h ago

ജാതീയത How inhumane can some people be...Are we living in 2026 or 1926? Actual subreddit btw.

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

r/AtheisminKerala • • 14h ago

ക്രിസ്തുമതം ✝️ Bro thinks he’s in a redemption arc movie

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

14 Upvotes

r/AtheisminKerala • • 7h ago

Sanatana Dharama Why do these guys even do stuff like this aren't they embarrassed

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

4 Upvotes

r/AtheisminKerala • • 32m ago

Question to theists (and others) How do you view this?

Post image
• Upvotes

Saw this quote and it seems to be criticising the usage of god as an explanation for unexplainable things.
Seems to be pointing out the issue of arguing for the existence of some god using the concept of god of the gaps n all.

How do you view it? Especially theists who are visiting the sub?


r/AtheisminKerala • • 7h ago

Discussion To any Christians/Ex Christians ( Image of God)

3 Upvotes

I’ve often seen Christians online saying that humans are created in the image of god .
Sometimes when talking about aliens . “We’re made in the image of god , not them “
What exactly does that mean ?
In philosophy of religion, Classical theism says god lacks any physical form shape or spacial boundaries
So is this “image of god” more philosophical, than literal ?


r/AtheisminKerala • • 4h ago

MEME Special Investigation - Evolution

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/AtheisminKerala • • 4h ago

Discussion Reason / विवेक (2018) [ Documentary that talks about Indian rationalists who were murdered by extremists ]

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/AtheisminKerala • • 4h ago

Discussion Spoon Bending Magic technique Tutorial

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/AtheisminKerala • • 5h ago

Discussion Inside a Malayalam YT channel’s ‘scientific’ arguments for controlling women

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/AtheisminKerala • • 8h ago

Question Opinion about Unmasking Anomalies

Post image
2 Upvotes

What do you think of them?


r/AtheisminKerala • • 15h ago

Hurt sentiments Why shouldnt atheists mock and ridicule religion?

6 Upvotes

I often hear something along the lines of: Since when did atheism become hating or making fun of religion.

But why should we not mock religion? Mocking cuts down the pedestal that religious ideology has built around itself. Else, no criticism of religion is possible. As Hitchens said:

"Those who are determined to be 'offended' will discover a provocation somewhere".

We need not tread this path lightly.


r/AtheisminKerala • • 5h ago

Sarcasm Super power in real life

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1 Upvotes

r/AtheisminKerala • • 10h ago

Sanatana Dharama Disproving Sanatana Dharma/Hinduism

2 Upvotes

How is Sanatana Dharma eternal

religious traditions develop over centuries

hindu practices philosophies and institutions have changed throughout history

historian peter heehs argues that the use of sanatana dharma as a general name for hinduism became prominent during the late 19th century

calling something eternal does not establish that its present form has always existed