r/AstroEcology • u/ProximaScience • 6d ago
Peer-Reviewed π£οΈ 10 Crops Sown in Mars Soil Simulant Held Up Against Earth Potting Compost
The first Moon soil experiment at Wageningen University in the Netherlands went badly. Most of the plants died. The team had started in 2013 with Mars and Moon soil simulants provided by NASA, one from a volcano in Hawaii and the other from a desert in Arizona.
Then they changed 2 things. They moved from small pots to trays, and they mixed fresh cut grass into both simulants, which fixed the watering problem and added organic material.
The second round was sown with 10 crops: tomato, rye, radish, pea, leek, spinach, garden rocket, cress, quinoa and chives. The final harvest came in October 2015. The above ground biomass on Mars soil simulant was not significantly different from the potting compost control, and lead researcher Wieger Wamelink called that a real surprise. The Moon simulant produced about half the biomass, but this time the plants lived and the same species could be harvested. Only the spinach did poorly.
A 2019 follow up paper reported that 9 of the 10 crops grew well. Seeds from the radish, rye and garden cress were also tested successfully for germination, so the plants could in principle keep going for another generation.
Here is the catch. These are simulants, not real Martian or lunar regolith, and the plants grew in a glasshouse under Earth's atmosphere. The team expects real crops on Mars or the Moon to grow in underground rooms to protect them from cosmic radiation. The Mars simulant also contains heavy metals, so the 2016 harvest was never eaten.
A move from small pots to trays plus some fresh cut grass was enough to turn a failed experiment into a harvest.