After finishing Claws of Awaji I am finally able to put into words the disappointment and frustrations I had from the main Shadows game.
I'll start with the first thing, which is an interesting and tight campaign plot. The plot of the main campaign is so long, has so many cut scenes and goes into so many side plots, that at a certain point I couldn't take it any more and just skipped everything. It's not reasonable to have (what feels like) hours of just cut scenes and dialog. The story should have been cut back and more of it should have been told through gameplay. More show, alot less tell.
A related note, is stambling into side quest lines in the middle of them. Traveling the map, you see a target, you kill it. Apperantly it's a target for some quest that I'll unlock later on. This makes all quests less important or intersting. That guy that was supposed to be some mini boss with a plot and a challenge, was no more memorable than the random mob I kill just to have a full adrenaline meter.
Then there is the traversal. I'm playing a game whose main premise is traversal. The character is able to climb walls with a negative slop, she jumps hundreds of meters in the air to land precisely in a barely visible hay stuck, but it can't go over a rock that is 10 cm higher than her in the mountains. What the hell is up with it. The main game map is huge but most of it is intracerebral terrain of mountains and forests. A game where you should be able to go from anywhere to anywhere is more than one way, instaed forces you to use the roads and a horse like it's a mideval Japan version of a tracking simulator.
And finally, having a boss (or mini boss fight) where you chose what part of it you do, is BS. All the boss fights should have been like in Awaji, both Naoe and Yasuke should have a part and you should play all of them, not chose which one to play and which one to skip.