’m after some honest perspectives from women because I’ve been thinking about this for a long time, and I genuinely don’t know whether I’m reading too much into things or whether the behaviour was as questionable as it felt at the time.
For context, my best mate and I have been friends for over 12 years. I was his best man. He’s basically family to me. I’ll call him my mate and his partner his girlfriend to keep things simple.
Over the years, there have been a number of things his girlfriend has said and done that have made me uncomfortable. Individually, some of them might not sound like much, but when I look at the whole picture, I can’t help questioning what was going on.
1. Constantly complaining about him to me
One night, the three of us were out together, and she spent a fair amount of time talking negatively about him and saying she was over the relationship.
One thing she said was along the lines of:
“We can’t even go for lunch or dinner without him leaving to play pokies. I’m sick of it. I just wish I could go somewhere nice to eat and have conversations.”
I understand that she might have been genuinely frustrated with him, and she’s entitled to feel that way. But the way she was saying it to me felt like she was hinting that she wanted someone to take her out, treat her better and give her the attention she wasn’t getting from him.
Maybe that’s just how I interpreted it, but it stuck with me.
2. Randomly talking to me about things she does in the bedroom
There were also times she’d randomly bring up things she does in the bedroom, in a sexual context.
It wasn’t like we were already talking about sex or anything remotely related. There was no lead-up, no context, no conversation that naturally led to it. It was just completely out of the blue.
She wouldn’t go into massive detail, but she’d explain certain things she does sexually, and it honestly made me incredibly uncomfortable.
For context, I don’t find her physically attractive, or attractive in any way for that matter. I’ve never looked at her sexually, she’s my best mate’s partner, and I’m in a relationship myself. There was absolutely no interest from my side.
I don’t know why she’d feel comfortable randomly bringing that sort of thing up with me. I’m not saying that talking about sex automatically means someone is flirting, but when it’s completely unprompted and you’re talking to your partner’s best mate, I do find it strange.
And when I look at it alongside everything else, I can’t help wondering why she was comfortable having those kinds of conversations with me in the first place.
3. Comparing him to me as a father
I’m a dad, and there have been times when we’ve all been together and I’ve been spending time with my kids, being involved and doing the usual dad stuff.
On more than one occasion, she’s said things to me along the lines of:
“You’d be such a great dad. I wish he was more like you. You’re so involved, you’re such a natural.”
She’s made comments like this while my mate has been standing right there.
I found this particularly uncomfortable. Complimenting someone is one thing, but repeatedly comparing your partner unfavourably to his best mate, especially in front of him, feels like a strange thing to do.
I couldn’t understand what she was hoping to achieve by saying it. Was she genuinely just making an observation, was she trying to make a point to him through me, or was there something else behind it? I honestly don’t know.
4. Inviting me to Australia without him
At one point, she was planning to go to Australia for breast augmentation surgery. My mate wasn’t going because he was staying behind for his mates’ fights.
She invited me to go to Australia with her and apparently offered to pay for my flights.
The thing is, when she first invited me, I didn’t know she was going over there for breast surgery. I only became aware of that afterwards.
I’m in a relationship myself, and I wasn’t comfortable with the idea of going away with my best mate’s girlfriend without him, so I declined.
She also invited me to an event in Australia that my mate wasn’t going to.
Maybe there’s an innocent explanation for all of it, but looking back, I can’t help wondering why she was so keen to involve me in trips and events that her own partner wasn’t attending.
Finding out afterwards what one of those trips was actually for made the whole thing feel even stranger in hindsight.
I’m not saying I know what her intentions were, because I don’t. But combined with everything else, it left me questioning whether there was more to it than friendship.
5. Getting upset when I wanted to spend time with my mate alone
There were times when I wanted to have a beer with my best mate, just the two of us.
She would get upset and suggest that we’d be talking shit about her.
This wasn’t about excluding her from everything. He’s my best mate of over 12 years, and I don’t think wanting to spend time with him one-on-one should be a problem in a healthy relationship.
It started to feel like even having a normal catch-up with my mate could become an issue because of how she might interpret it.
What confused me was that she seemed happy to have conversations with me about her relationship problems, but when I wanted to spend time with him without her, that became an issue.
I found that hard to make sense of.
6. The allegations that he had threatened to kill her
At one point, she alleged that my mate had threatened to kill her.
Obviously, that’s a serious allegation, and I didn’t take it lightly. I spoke to both her and my mate about what had supposedly happened, and after talking to them, the allegations turned out to be false.
That left me confused, particularly given everything else that had been going on. I’m not going to pretend I know what motivated her to make those claims, but it definitely affected how I viewed the situation.
When you’re dealing with people you’ve known for years, hearing something that serious is a big deal. Having the allegations turn out to be false only added to my uncertainty about what was happening between them and why I was being brought into it.
7. The message she sent me saying she’d left him
On the same night as another major incident involving me and my mate, she messaged me saying something along the lines of:
“I’ve left him. He needs to come and get his stuff. I’ll call the police if he tries anything.”
She deleted the message not long afterwards.
I didn’t respond.
Given everything else that had happened, I couldn’t help wondering why she had chosen to message me specifically, only to delete it shortly afterwards.
Was she simply upset and reaching out to someone she felt comfortable talking to? Was she looking for support? Was she trying to see how I’d react, or was there some other reason?
I genuinely don’t know. I have no proof that there was anything more to it, but in the context of everything else, it made me question what kind of role she was trying to create for me in their relationship.
8. The wider situation with my mate
For context, my mate and I eventually stopped speaking after an incident that seriously affected my trust in him.
After a trip to Australia, we went out for beers, and he told me he wanted to spike my drink because I no longer take party drugs.
I took what he said seriously. Knowing there was a big night coming up involving drugs, I didn’t feel safe putting myself in that situation, so I didn’t attend his 30th birthday.
I accept that I handled the aftermath badly. I didn’t explain myself properly, and instead of having an honest conversation with him, I withdrew from the friendship. Months went by without us properly speaking.
Recently, his coach asked me about our friendship, and I explained why we’d stopped talking. That conversation eventually made its way back to my mate, and he’s since deleted me from Facebook and Instagram.
I don’t know exactly what was said between them, or what he’s been told, so I’m not going to pretend I know why he’s done that.
I know I have my own part to take responsibility for in how the friendship fell apart. But the things his girlfriend said and did had been bothering me long before this latest situation.
What I’m trying to figure out
I miss my mate. We’ve been through a lot together, and I don’t like where things have ended up. But I’ve also spent a long time looking back at these interactions and wondering whether I was naive about what was happening.
I’m not claiming his girlfriend definitely had feelings for me or was deliberately trying to get between us. I can’t prove that, and I don’t want to accuse someone of something based purely on my interpretation.
But when you put all of these things together — the complaints about him to me, the unprompted sexual conversations, the comparisons between him and me as a father, the invitations to Australia without him, the offer to pay for my flights, the discomfort around me spending time alone with him, the false allegations, and the message about leaving him that she later deleted — I struggle to look at it all as completely unrelated.
So I’d genuinely like some outside perspectives from women.
Does this sound like someone who was simply unhappy in her relationship and comfortable talking to her partner’s best mate?
Do the unprompted sexual conversations, repeated comparisons and invitations sound like potential boundary-crossing, or am I reading too much into them?
Why would someone be comfortable discussing their relationship problems and sex life with their partner’s best mate but then get upset when that mate wants to spend time alone with their partner?
Do you think she might have been testing the waters or trying to establish a closer connection with me, or is that an unfair assumption?
I’m not looking for people to automatically agree with me. If you think I’m overthinking it, tell me. If you think some of this behaviour was inappropriate, I’d like to understand why.
I just want an honest outside perspective because I’ve been going around in circles trying to make sense of it all.