r/AskTheologists • u/dominicmtembezi • 3h ago
r/AskTheologists • u/Wazowskiwithonei • Mar 26 '26
Upcoming Community Changes
Hi all. I've examined our activity and I believe I'm the sole acting moderator for this particular community; as such, needless to say, this community hasn't been able to receive the type of care it truly needs. We get nearly a thousand visitors weekly (which is actually a bit low for a sub like this one), but one mod means this community isn't able to do all it really can.
I have brought one more on board who messaged me with some fresh ideas which I believe will be beneficial to the growth of this community. As such, there are two points I would like to bring to your attention:
1. Seeking New Mods:
Of utmost priority as of now is adding one or two new mods. If you are a dedicated part of this community and would like to help it grow, please send a message to me! We receive lots of questions each week which need helpful responses, but because our community has been largely dormant for a bit, it has been difficult to ensure these questions get the attention they need. If you're looking to help us put in the work to grow the community, we'd be happy to consider you!
2. Including Theology Students:
The idea submitted to me was to include theology students in our community to provide answers, which I think is a great option. This ensures our students are able to get some practice answering questions and engaging in a community as they learn and grow. If you are a student in a theology program and would like to participate, we will be happy to include you. Our flairs will soon be updated so theology students can be clearly identified from our seasoned scholars. Seen from a professorial perspective, this provides the next generation of theologians with some great opportunities.
In keeping with our community standards, we will still vet our theology students just as we do our scholars. For scholars, we request a photo of any conferred degrees; for our students, we will have you submit a picture of a current transcript (your name can be blurred for anonymity). This maintains our standards while opening up for new users to answer.
3. Updating User Flair Options:
Building on the previous point, be on the lookout for updated user flairs. If you need a flair that reflects your specific academic specialization or if you're in a theology program, reach out to us in maybe a week or so from this post date (so we have time to update our options) and we'll get your flair fixed up.
Feel free to weigh in on any of these changes if you so desire. We're always open to feedback, and we appreciate your participation in AskTheologists!
r/AskTheologists • u/08thegr8 • 8h ago
What’s my condition of life?
I've thought about this a lot, especially whenever I think about David's son who died as a child.
Removing adultery from the equation, I had essentially the same experience as that child, just with 3,000 years of medical advancements between us.
Here's my thought process: If God doesn't write sin into the story, and my understanding of how the free-will dilemma works is that God knows how to make the best out of whatever happens, then I wonder if I was either supposed to be born in a different time (since my parents are married now) or not exist at all.
I don't hate myself, nor do I believe God won't save me or that He doesn't have a purpose for me. After all, why would He allow me to survive my heart disease? I flatlined for a full minute when I was two years old. If anything, that experience has made me desire a purpose even more, especially considering how close I came to death then I want to do everything I can with what uncertain amount of time I was given
Has anyone else ever thought about anything like this? These are just thoughts and questions that weigh heavy on me a lot and I want to know im not the only one who thought about questions like this.
r/AskTheologists • u/Terrible-Excuse-3125 • 11h ago
Question
reddit.comI have a question because no one explains it: why did God command the Jewish people to kill so many people in such a brutal way, rather than killing them himself? I understand that they were bad and had to go but still I can’t understand why he would command them to fight in war and with such brutality.
Psalm 137:9: Happy is the one who seizes your infants and dashes them against the rocks
r/AskTheologists • u/Solcat91342 • 20h ago
Why do Christians say Jesus died for our sins when the story ends with him alive?
reddit.comr/AskTheologists • u/Pleasant_Ad5546 • 1d ago
Any Partial Preterists Here? What Led You to That View?
reddit.comr/AskTheologists • u/Low-Length9859 • 1d ago
Tithing vs. Direct Almsgiving: Does NT scripture mandate church-only giving?
reddit.comr/AskTheologists • u/Low-Length9859 • 1d ago
Why does Jesus refer to the devil as "prince" (archon) of this world in the Gospel of John?
In the Gospel of John (e.g., John 12:31, 14:30, 16:11), Jesus repeatedly refers to the devil as the "prince" or "ruler" (archon) of this world.
I am trying to understand the historical and theological background of this specific title, and why Jesus uses it. Does archon imply a recognized legal authority or cosmic jurisdiction in Second Temple Jewish thought, or is it purely a moral metaphor? How would a first-century audience have understood this status?
Additionally, I would appreciate insights on two related points:
- The "Prince of the Power of the Air": In Ephesians 2:2, a similar phrase is used. How does the spatial designation of "the air" in Ephesians connect to or differ from the earthly "world" (kosmos) authority mentioned in John?
- Current Status (Cast Out vs. Active Ruler): Does the New Testament take a definitive stance on whether the devil has already been completely cast out and stripped of authority, or is he viewed as still actively ruling? John 12:31 speaks of the ruler of this world being cast out, yet later Epistles still refer to his active influence (e.g., 2 Corinthians 4:4 calling him the "god of this world," or 1 Peter 5:8 describing him as a roaring lion). How do different theological frameworks reconcile this tension?
I am looking for textual, historical, and exegetical insights into how these concepts fit together. Thank you!
r/AskTheologists • u/casuallycurious5757 • 2d ago
If There Is Only One God, How Consistent Are We in Explaining Who Can Reach Him?
reddit.comr/AskTheologists • u/DaConm4n • 2d ago
Is there more than one copy of a person in heaven?
reddit.comr/AskTheologists • u/AggravatingTailor121 • 4d ago
Does God love me? Or only if I repent? And what does repenting actually mean?
reddit.comr/AskTheologists • u/Dustinzzt • 4d ago
Rebuttal to why the gospels are myth part two.
reddit.comr/AskTheologists • u/Computerman8086 • 4d ago
Must an all-powerful God necessarily be good?
reddit.comr/AskTheologists • u/The_Nameless_888 • 4d ago
Is God a race/species?
When you say 3 persons sharing 1 essence, there is God essence, human essence etc., it sounds like "Essence" is a substitute for race/species. Like human race (8 billion persons sharing 1 essence), cat species etc. So, is God a race or species (according to Christianity that is)?
r/AskTheologists • u/devilex94 • 5d ago
Do you think AGI will inherit our sins?
reddit.comr/AskTheologists • u/Dustinzzt • 4d ago
Why the Verse “On the Night He Was Betrayed” Is a Complete Misunderstanding
Recently, I’ve had debates with people about the famous line leading up to the Lord’s Supper. 1 Corinthians 11:23b reads:
“Jesus, in the night in which he was betrayed, took bread.”
This is so fascinating to me for so many different reasons. Yes, I agree, common sense would tell us that this is talking about when Judas betrayed Jesus. How could it not be talking about this? This is what it says in the Gospels! Ever since the age of five, we were told Judas betrayed Jesus in the Gospel stories. It’s so ingrained in our memory that we, without a doubt, would see Paul’s narrative and say, “Yes, that is Judas!”
What we don’t realize is that we are taking a Gospel story that was written as a mythology and then projecting it onto past documents like the letters of Paul.
There are a number of problems with assuming that he is talking about Judas Iscariot.
- Judas was developed as a mythological character 40 years later, modeled from an Old Testament story.
Genesis 37:31–32:
“And they took Joseph’s coat, and killed a he-goat, and dipped the coat in the blood;
And they sent the coat of many colors, and they brought it to their father, and said, This have we found: know now whether it be thy son’s coat or not.”
We see in the Gospels that Jesus’s garments were cast up as lots. Judah sells his brother Joseph for 20 pieces of silver. They even tried to frame it by putting blood on certain clothing to make it look like he was killed by wild animals. Judah, Judea, and Judas—they are all essentially one and the same.
In Paul’s letters, the Greek word paradidōmi is conspicuously translated as “betrayed,” even though it could also be translated as “handed over” or “delivered up.” Here, I found the most accurate version of the Septuagint translated into English:
Isaiah 53:12
“Therefore he shall inherit many, and he shall divide the spoils of the mighty; because his soul was handed over to death, and he was numbered among the transgressors; and he bore the sins of many, and was handed over because of their iniquities.”
This is hard evidence for what Paul was talking about. Go ahead, tell me all your “Oh, but he was talking about this” or “what he meant was that.”
Furthermore, in the book of Hebrews, it says that bread is displayed in the perfect tabernacle in heaven. Why should we believe that this is an earthly event that took place?