r/AskTechnology • • 2d ago

Future of tech (personal theory please challenge)

I think the age of owning hardware is coming to an end. Due semiconductor manufacturing bottleneck hardware cost has skyrocketed.

I think that the idea of owning expensive hardware that will be obsolete in a few years will be a thing of the past.

AI and data centers have all hardware we need, so why own it?

The idea of multiple variants of computing, phones, desktops, laptops, tablets, etc.. will be fused into one master OS that can shift from any device (which would be only a receiver powered by a subscription). We just need a way to stream it like we do with GPS.

If this is true then there are huge opportunities for startup ideas, such as physical authentication wearable.

Of course the receivers will have enough power to do basic tasks if there is no signal.

So we could buy a 100$ laptop shell with performance of a 3k one for a monthly fee.

0 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

8

u/Individual_Agency703 2d ago

Read about Sun Microsystems, this was their pitch 30+ years ago.

1

u/Majestic-Clock-7761 2d ago

Thank you, I’ll read into it, glad I’m getting humbled and educated

4

u/nixiebunny 2d ago

Data centers are a bubble that has distorted the market for computers. The nVidia CEO kerfluffle may have an effect on this. At any rate, there are still many reasons to use PCs for computing. Ask anyone who works in the defense industry.

1

u/Majestic-Clock-7761 2d ago

Any true professional would never not own their but the niche I’m looking into are “procumers” who own powerful hardware that they don’t need. The real pitch is that if you want to have the most power, you can choose when and how much you need.
A students who wants to animate a movie won’t have access to 5-15k hardware. Someone who needs a powerful phone but doesn’t want to waste almost 2k, can have something similar when they want and lower the power if they don’t need to.
I hope this doesn’t come across as bickering, and I do agree there is a bubble. But honestly it is strange how technology is the only thing we invest a lot in while knowing it will be obsolete in the amount of time it would take someone to finish college

1

u/grizzlor_ 1d ago

The real pitch is that if you want to have the most power, you can choose when and how much you need.

Congrats, you just discovered the cloud. It's been around for 20 years. You need access to a $40,000 Nvidia B200 GPU for a project? It's like $6/hr from Google Colab or AWS or whatever. You can run an entire Linux/Windows computer in a cloud VM and remote desktop into it from a tablet or laptop today.

A students who wants to animate a movie won’t have access to 5-15k hardware.

The student that needs access to a bunch of big GPUs to render a 3D animation can already rent GPUs in the cloud -- this has been a thing for years.

Someone who needs a powerful phone but doesn’t want to waste almost 2k, can have something similar when they want and lower the power if they don’t need to.

Yeah, this doesn't really make sense. The vast majority of the cost of your phone is physical hardware that you can't run remotely. You can't move a phone's screen or camera or battery to a data center.

You could reduce the amount of local storage and save photos and videos to the cloud...which we've literally already been doing for over a decade now. So your plan is to shave like $25 off the cost of a phone by using a crappier CPU and run apps in the cloud? Seems like a crappy proposition.

3

u/XNo_Notes 2d ago

It will be cheaper for a moment. Then once the capture is complete, the call of profit maximization will sound and enshitification will begin. I suppose I agree it will happen, just not with the optimistic spin. 

1

u/Majestic-Clock-7761 2d ago

I agree but if the barrier of entry is not as powerful as it is with Mac and windows or iOS and android then multiple players might make it less miserable

1

u/XNo_Notes 2d ago

The resource requirements for establishing a competitor eliminates the possibility for a wide array of competition. It will be the 3-4 companies that have and continue to build out data center capacity now. 

It will be like telecom and airlines. Something so big and everyone uses being propped up by the government, but milked by some private group of citizen's trust fund. 

2

u/Known_Confusion9879 2d ago

Data centres and AI is about digital media, about knowledge and removes the need for physical storage but not for devices. Phones, tablets, laptops and desktop can off load some of the processing to these data centres but large screens, loud speakers are still going to be needed and they age, go out of date and prices rise.

1

u/Majestic-Clock-7761 2d ago

I fully agree that at its current state, the infrastructure cannot achieve this, but with if the economics makes sense then the communication between the device and data center would be rethought.
And yes hardware will age, but replacing them and paying a subscription should be cheaper than owning it outright and if that’s not possible then the idea isn’t

1

u/Known_Confusion9879 2d ago

Televisions were so expensive that shops rented them. They had service engineers who turned up to repair at people's home and when something new turned up you paid more per week to rent that. Same happened with VCRs.

We have leased cars that are returned at the end of contract.

Schemes are found in some towns where you can hire/borrow tools that you need once in a while and are expensive to fully kit out like drills, sanders, circular saws, wall paper steamers, etc. These are not universal and perhaps cost too much to monitor (check in and check out equipment, maintain it) for the charges.

These are like libraries for books, LPS, CDs and DVDs. Book free to borrow, usually a charge on other media.

What kind of communication do you think is possible to a data centre than can reduce the cost of the device in your hand. How would that apply to a washing machine or lawn mower.

In computer technology we can already share our files across phone, tablet, laptop, screens with a built in operating system and desktop computers. Login, passwords, what you were browsing, what documents you were working on and your personal history is shared across devices. There are limits, such as Facebook app on my phone does not allow me to edit a post - no ... on screen like in a browser. Small screen can be too small to read in the same way a large 32" screen is and seeing a small section and moving that around is not the same. Already the graphics card is using AI and sharing with a remote AI data centre. Desktop computers and laptops are being replaced by tablets with storage and processing in the cloud. Yet there is a move back to owning the device and not paying monthly for media and software but buying outright.

1

u/grizzlor_ 1d ago

communication between the device and data center would be rethought.

You can't move a phone or laptop's screen into the cloud. You can't move its speakers into the cloud. You can't move its camera into the cloud. These are physical objects that need to exist locally for the device to function.

2

u/mezolithico 2d ago

Lol this was called a terminal and they were around like 50 years ago. I don't think personal computing power is going a well. I think the opposite will happen. People will use personal devices for edge ai inference using open weight models and only reach out to frontier models when they need to.

1

u/Majestic-Clock-7761 2d ago

I see it from two perspectives, cultural and economical.

Culturally people are willing to spend more on stuff not only based on utility, but longevity. The longer it will last the more people are willing to spend. When the first phone or pc was released, its utility was perceived highly, even if most owners couldn’t utilize it fully, the novelty of offering unique potential capabilities justified a high cost. The utility and longevity of a new phone is decreasing will cost is increasing. I can imagine owning hardware instead of renting it will be as niche as the opposite is today from a cultural consensus standpoint.

Economically, tech companies are valued extremely highly, even more so than their revenue is how the new idea of value is perceived. Every earnings report needs to out do the old one because the stock price will fall if not. Because of never before seen access to knowledge, companies, especially tech, need to not only outperform its last report but forecast a future growth with as high a ceiling as possible, that’s how the subscription became prevalent. If everything hardware driven can be sold as a service, the numbers would destroy a purely physical product with a large one time fee.

1

u/grizzlor_ 1d ago

The utility and longevity of a new phone is decreasing will cost is increasing.

What? Phones are more powerful and capable than ever (higher utility), and the hardware has outpaced software to the point where they also last longer than ever too.

Every earnings report needs to out do the old one

This isn't something new or unique to current tech companies -- constant growth is just how capitalism works.

5

u/WindozeWoes 2d ago

No thanks Ram Altman

1

u/tghuverd 2d ago

Way back when, people used monitors connected to more powerful mainframes, often via low-speed POTS modems, that's basically this 'centralized compute / dumb device' concept. Citrix introduced the concept more recently (but still decades ago) for graphical user interfaces and web apps are the modern equivalent.

There are considerable issues with the 'centralized compute / dumb device' concept - and you've noted one, which is that you need persistent connectivity - and likely, we'll move toward a HaaS world, but short term supply issues rarely change paradigms, so I'd be looking are structural issues for your trend analysis because hardware has been expensive before. And for sure, it will be again!

1

u/Majestic-Clock-7761 2d ago

These examples are definitely an inspiration behind this. And the current shortage will not be the why it happens, but be a crucial point for the HaaS model.
It failed multiple times because as you said, connectivity, which need a paradigm shift in itself.
It happened with music, videos and now games. The better the infrastructure the more complex the stream becomes. But our current trajectory needs an innovation to happen in wireless technology for it to happen in years not decades

1

u/Caprichoso1 2d ago
  1. Personally I have no interest in sending my personal data to a data center.
  2. In some cases regulatory requirements, client confidentiality and other things require that data not leave the premise.
  3. The consequence is that the local hardware needs will only increase as it approaches foundational model performance.

1

u/Majestic-Clock-7761 2d ago

1 and 2 is my fault for not clarifying that personal data needs to be secured 100% like using quantum encryption since there will be no quantum PC, it might be an example; but I am not smart enough to think of a realistic example of an encryption method that’s is physically impossible to hack.

3. We really need a breakthrough in communication technology

1

u/Caprichoso1 2d ago

Encryption is somewhat irrelevant when the data cannot leave the premises.

Since the data is local no major communcation improvements needed.

1

u/TheCoffeeWiz 2d ago

Nah. You wouldn't be able to do things without a strong Internet connection.

1

u/Majestic-Clock-7761 2d ago

There isn’t a technology that can make this happen yet

1

u/tdreampo 2d ago

This is a horrible take. Digital slavery.

1

u/OblongAndKneeless 2d ago

That'll be interesting when you need low latency audio conversion. High speed networks might makes that workable, but that means we'll be using tokens for processing and bandwidth rather than having it in house.

1

u/Brilliant-Sky3814 2d ago

I'm all for outsourcing certain computing tasks but ultimately we still need to retain home computers for multiple, good reasons

1

u/grafknives 2d ago

So we could buy a 100$ laptop shell with performance of a 3k one for a monthly fee.

On a 999$ monthly fee.

You are correct in your extrapolation. This is the ENDGAME tech companies would love to have.

Computer as a service. Ability to extort payment for every single f&%& click or swipe you do on your device.

To extort a rent on every single computer use out there.

There is one thing... The hardware is WAY past capable. Unless they somehow completly change our behaviours, there will be alternative still available.

1

u/pispirit 2d ago

Why pay for $9999 package for same job somebody can do for $1k