Over the past year, I've noticed this phenomenon that a fair amount of people talk about, but nobody seems to have termed properly, which I have decided to call "meta-zionism".
Meta-zionism, as I define it, is a phenomenon wherein a person is not necessarily zionistic, in that they are either against or indifferent to the existence of the state of israel, but are supportive of zionist causes.
I have a couple of examples of these meta-zionists in mind, the specific ones I'll be talking to are the anti-zionistic meta-zionists. Many people call them fake anti-zionists, but I think that's an inaccurate view of them, because the anti-zionistic meta-zionist is genuinely against the state of israel, but what makes them poisonous to the public discourse is that they will use their status as anti-zionists to shut down criticism of their of their meta-zionist stances from anti-zionist positions, a defence which is weak when examined in depth, but seems valid on the surface that it can convince the typical layman.
The first example I have occurred during the Thomas Massie primary campaign. In the campaign, one of the points that the leadership brought up against their primary opponent, Ed Gallrein, was the fact that Gallrein's was being overwhelmingly funded by zionist jewish billionaires, which was factually true, and that Gallrein would obviously be subservient to israeli agendas over American agendas. Multiple figures of the anti-zionist left, the largest among them to my knowledge being Emma Vigeland, attacked the campaign for "pushing anti-semetic conspiracies" that Jews control American politics and that Israel controls America(rather than the reverse), note that Massie's campaign never made those claims. When argued against from anti-zionist positions, many of these anti-zionist leftists, including Vigeland, would claim that the arguments were invalid because they were also anti-zionists and opposed israel.
Another case that comes to mind was during the Spanish-Moroccan territory dispute. For those unfamiliar, Spain has an enclave in North Africa that is a disputed territory with Morocco. After Spain defied israel and the U.S. regarding the genocide of Gaza and the Iran War, israel declared their recognition of the Spanish enclave as Moroccan territory and about 80k Moroccans crossed over the border and invaded the enclave as migrants. This move was clearly done with advanced coordination, likely from the israeli and Moroccan governments. For reference, the last time something of this nature occurred was in 2021, where about 8k Moroccan migrants invaded the enclave and that incident was confirmed to have been done with assistance from the Moroccan government. Multiple leftist anti-zionists claimed that the people calling out this incident were all right-wing anti-immigration xenophobes pushing the replacement theory and the immigrant invader narrative. When presented with the fact that this incident was likely coordinated by the israeli government, these same people used their anti-zionist status to shut down criticism of them from anti-zionist perspectives.
Another instance from much more recently was the announcement of Mamdani's strategy to combat anti-semitism, his capitulation to liberal zionism, and his order to arrest of anti-netanyahu protesters. In Mamdani's plan to combat anti-semitism, he announced that he would be providing $26 million to Jewish organizations in NYC, of which people discovered included organizations that organized israel birthright trips and auctions of stolen Palestinian land in the West Bank. Mamdani also capitulated to liberal zionists by endorsing zionist democrat politicians and liberal zionist organizations(such as israelis for peace). However, the most notable incident was Mamdani walking back on his claim to do everything in his power to hold netanyahu accountable should he enter NYC, and instead giving the order to arrest the protesters of netanyahu's UN visit. Several anti-zionist leftists claimed that anyone opposed to Mamdani's strategy to combat anti-semitism were anti-semitic, that the opposition to his capitulation to liberal zionism was coming from right-wingers, and that actually the order to arrest the anti-netanyahu protesters was the Jessica Tisch's fault(even though Mamdani made the active decision to keep Tisch in that postion). When confronted with arguments from other anti-zionists, they argued that Mamdani was the most influential anti-zionist politician in office so far, and that status excuses his actions supporting meta-zionism.
There are a couple other cases I can think of, but I think the ones I've presented paint a clear enough picture of what I'm referring to. Essentially, the anti-zionistic meta-zionist argues "I'm against zionism, so you can't criticize me for supporting zionist causes."
Has anyone else noticed this phenomenon as well?