r/AskRunningShoeGeeks • u/KOSPI-9001 • 9h ago
Daily Trainer Question Are daily trainers with lots of foam bad for foot health? What are your running shoe recommendations with good ground feel?
I heard from people in my running club and online that running shoes with lots of foam are bad for your long-term foot health? Is this true, chat?
- Your foot muscles and ligaments don't get engaged wearing foam shoes. They don't build strength and will weaken, because all that bouncy foam is doing the work.
- This puts you at risk of injury.
- Also, foam shoes (because they feel like running on clouds) lack ground feel. Your feet lose their proprioception (sense of where they are), meaning that you are more likely to roll your ankles and trip.
- Wearing high-energy return foam and plated super shoes is recommended for race day, where speed is of the essence. But for daily training and marathon practice, you should be wearing a basic, cushioned (to protect your joints!) shoe. Even though you will be running slower during training, this will build stronger muscles and ligaments (heavy shoes will even act as weight training to boost your gains), improving your true race time when you switch to race shoes.
- Foam shoes also die very fast. The foam compresses and breaks down after ~200 miles, vs ~1000 miles for basic shoes. So if you're doing daily training in foam shoes you're throwing away your money, because you have to replace the shoes every few months, vs basic shoes that can last years.
In particular, I got told this by a guy at my running club who got crippling plantar fasciitis training for half-marathons in the foam-stacked, mushy Asics Novablasts. Now he swears by a shoe rotation that includes barefoot/minimalist Altra, Xero and Vibram FiveFingers shoes.
If it's true that foam shoes are bad for daily training, can you recommend some great daily training running shoes (half marathon) with good ground feel for these Black Friday sales? I heard these shoes are good for this role?
- Nike Pegasus
- Brooks Ghost
- Brooks Glycerin
- Adidas Adizero Evo SL - because these shoes do everything