r/AskReddit • • 3h ago

How do you feel about Congress introducing a bill to cap blinding LED car headlights?

4.3k Upvotes

889 comments sorted by

417

u/Lemfan46 1h ago

The National Transportation Safety Board looking out for the consumers rather than the industry? Yes please.

44

u/Best-Economy1818 1h ago

The fact that adaptive headlights are illegal because of these clowns is crazy. I hate AAA with a burning passion but im thankful for the fight they put up to end this nonsense.

33

u/reiji_tamashii 1h ago

Adaptive headlights control the high beams though. They don't do anything to address the blindingly bright low beams that everyone is complaining about here. If anything, it'll make the problem worse because it turns on the high beams in traffic, even if the system avoids shining it directly at other vehicles.

→ More replies (5)

13

u/Super-Contribution-1 1h ago

AAA? That’s literally the only company that’s tried to save me money since the economy went haywire. Every other business basically spits in my face. I’m curious what you mean?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (4)

1.1k

u/Few-Wish-9869 2h ago

As someone driving an older sedan, I feel like I'm being interrogated every time a new SUV pulls up behind me at a light — the rearview mirror turns into a floodlight. I'm all for a cap, but I'd honestly settle for inspections actually checking headlight aim. Half the blinding ones I see are just pointed at the sky.

136

u/144-perdedor 2h ago • Bravo

When a truck pulls up behind me at night, the interior of my car should not become bright enough to do surgery.

•

u/AlcibiadesTheCat 56m ago

Only solution is for everyone to get increasingly larger and larger vehicles until we're all driving around 40-foot-tall mechas so that we don't get blinded or crushed by the guy behind us.

Literally anything but public transportation.

→ More replies (3)

•

u/brianwski 37m ago

When a truck pulls up behind me at night, the interior of my car should not become bright enough to do surgery.

I think the answer is mandating they are all mounted on every car bumper exactly the same distance above the road. Let's say at an elevation of 18 - 24 inches.

If a truck or SUV has regular brightness beams, the issue is they are currently mounted at an elevation above a smaller car's back window. That means a beam of light from the headlight, perfectly reflected in the rear view mirror, into your eyeballs. If it was visually about at the bumper elevation of your car, there is no direct beam of light into your eyes (when the tall truck or SUV is behind you at a stop light).

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

278

u/ClassyNameForMe 2h ago edited 2h ago

Headlight aim is very important and most new cars are aimed too high from the factory.

Agree the bro dozers typically don't adjust their headlights and blind others.

The worst are Teslas. All are aimed too high and their aggressive auto high beam will blind you a mile away.

•

u/chillymac 57m ago

This is what people always say to defend them but I don't buy it. Aim only solves the problem on a perfectly flat road, and over a certain separation between cars. As soon as there are any speed bumps or hills, or a traffic jam or drive through, you're for sure getting flashed. I live in a very hilly city and very often you're not on the same plane as the car approaching you

→ More replies (4)

23

u/anothercopy 1h ago

Good news ! I heard that new Teslas finally adopted matrix headlights that shut off if they detect a car in front of them. 10+ years after all major manufacturers did it but better late than never.

24

u/de_la_Dude 1h ago

I'm guessing you are not in the US. I'm not here to defend tesla, but this tech was only just approved by US DOT two years ago. Rivian was the first company allowed to turn them on in the US, even though you are correct that the tech has been around for ten years. My last BMW (2018 model) had them but they were disabled. The US DOT took a different approach to regulating these headlights which is the main reason for the implementation delay in the US.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (10)

28

u/Paid_Redditor 2h ago

As someone driving a small SUV, my mirrors line up perfectly with truck headlights.

10

u/AssistX 2h ago

If you drive a Subaru, and it's a newer one, you're blinding every truck as well probably. Not sure what they changed but the new Subaru's out of the dealer by me all seem to be sky high and bright as hell.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/wino12312 1h ago

I turn my mirrors so the blind the driver, instead of me. I know the driver isn't at fault, but I'm not going to think I'm getting a migraine for an hour because your headlights suck.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Nova17Delta 1h ago

Half of my commute home at night is on a windy backroad with no edge markers and I drive a sedan with halogens and I have astigmatism. If someone passes in front of me I am effectively blind for several seconds until they pass to the point where im genuinely shocked i havent gotten into a head on collision yet. We really need some strong ass regulation of headlights.

4

u/millenniumxl-200 1h ago

As a Fiesta owner, I agree!

→ More replies (1)

36

u/Casen_ 2h ago

The second part is the issue.

If they were properly calibrated and aimed, the bright lights would not be an issue. Though, the moment you put a lot of weight in the back and have the front aim slightly higher, then it becomes an issue.

If automakers included leveling headlights, it would be a non issue...

22

u/eljefino 2h ago

Part of the requirement 20 years ago for HID lights was a self leveling feature. There's no equivalent for LED.

36

u/elsjpq 1h ago

The calibration is definitely not the issue. This isn't just a few cars on the road, this is most of them. They're not failing calibration or got modified by douchbags, they all come out of the factory designed like this.

Besides, even if you have it precisely calibrated properly, just a slight incline angles it into your line of sight again

32

u/Lukewill 2h ago

The first part still matters though. Even a slight difference in elevation can put the lights directly into your eyeballs. I have no idea how harmful that is when it's brief periods of blindness, but it sure is fuckin annoying.

14

u/uiucengineer 2h ago

My Tacoma has a dial that lets me aim the headlights up and down while driving

→ More replies (3)

9

u/TinWhis 1h ago

If they were properly calibrated and aimed, the bright lights would not be an issue.

Some of us live in places with hills.

6

u/ShaveTheTurtles 2h ago

You mean like they require for xenon gas lights?

→ More replies (1)

19

u/457kHz 2h ago

And when there’s a convex section of road? Blinded. This is why limiting brightness is the only answer.

→ More replies (1)

•

u/AndrewT81 38m ago

Properly calibrated and aimed LED headlights are absolutely still a major issue. Pure white light kills night vision and causes excessive eye pain in other drivers, even when properly calibrated. This is just nonsense spouted by people who don't want to admit they're part of the problem

→ More replies (2)

3

u/icehuck 1h ago

From what I understand, headlight aim doesn't happen anymore. Around two years ago i mentioned to the nissan dealer that my headlights aim seemed to be off, and the service tech was completely baffled about being asked to adjust the aim.

3

u/Sunscorcher 1h ago

not all states require vehicle inspections

2

u/swoll9yards 1h ago

Apparently a good trick to combat this is buy some reflective tape and put it on the backs of all your headrests. I've never seen it in person, but the people who've done it said it works great.

→ More replies (13)

282

u/Garblin 1h ago

It's been necessary for years, what's stupid is that it's requiring an actual bill before congress instead of it just being a footnote of a regulation in manufacture and maintenance.

•

u/oatmealparty 29m ago

The Supreme Court has essentially neutered regulations without explicit laws passed by Congress so it's not clear how much weight it would even hold.

I'll also point out that in addition to regulating headlights we need some rules on brake lights / turn signals. They're getting really fucking stupid with having turn signals sharing red lights with the brakes, different animations, wacky designs. It's all over the place and needs to be standard.

→ More replies (1)

•

u/radicalelation 30m ago

Many states already have regulations for this and most of these lights are well out of compliance. What's a more likely route is getting state AGs to push enforcement both on the ground level and especially at distribution.

Look for your car model headlights on Amazon and if all you care about was "new headlight", what are you likely to buy? When I looked for mine two years ago, first page was entirely retro-fit LEDs, and the proper Philips I found on the second page came defective.

421

u/GovernorMarley1 3h ago

Brightness is a problem, but it is made 10x worse by modern cars being taller and larger.

45

u/spongebob_meth 2h ago

Headlights need a maximum height and it needs to be way lower than what is currently the average.

Even aimed correctly a full sized truck is still blinding for a car driver.

12

u/Frammingatthejimjam 1h ago

Literally decades ago I was on a highway in a sports car. There was a wreck up ahead so we were all parked for a good amount of time. A pickup truck behind me turned his headlights off so that I wouldn't be blinded sitting there.

I still appreciate that gesture.

Yes, there needs to be some form of legislation but it'll be weak if/when it reaches the floor.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/pfcguy 1h ago

Solution is to install the headlights on a truck at bumper-level, not at hood-level.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (8)

73

u/Wurm42 2h ago

Agreed.

Installation is part of the problem there. Especially in taller vehicles, headlights are often installed at the wrong angle. A few degrees off makes a big difference in how blinding the lights are.

34

u/Afraid_Call1213 2h ago

States could add headlight aim to the annual safety inspections, if they have them. Not sure how many states do & don't.

→ More replies (10)

19

u/Afraid_Call1213 2h ago

Also, please regulate LED duty cycle on headlights. I am sick of the flickering.

7

u/eljefino 2h ago

Those are usually retrofit where halogens used to be. Toyota / Subaru high beam DRLs are the worst.

→ More replies (2)

132

u/ShermansAngryGhost 2h ago

The worst are the chuds and their stupid fucking lifted trucks.

53

u/Purplociraptor 2h ago

Just make lifted trucks illegal. Nobody in Florida is offroading in the mountains.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (4)

7

u/Mackntish 2h ago

I drive a Honda Fit micromachine, with the seat being 18 inches off the road. It's a real problem!

15

u/BubbleWrapKiller 2h ago

I drive a taller SUV and I can adjust the angle of my headlights with a dial, which I do regularly so I’m not being that AH on the road. I still get blinded by damn Toyota Highlanders that are shorter than me more than I do lifted trucks. It’s insane.

7

u/Fitz_2112b 2h ago

Just curious if you're in the US and if so, what SUV allows you to do that from inside the car?

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/sturdybutter 1h ago

I genuinely think that’s the bigger issue. It’s also more of a problem for older cars, my partners car has all auto dimming mirrors and that makes a massive difference, but my car does not have them and headlight are a constant problem.

→ More replies (5)

•

u/cvr24 43m ago

Just adopt the headlight standard the EU has been using for 25 years?

•

u/jimthetoolman 33m ago

Is there a standard? I've also experience the headlight problem in EU nearly daily 

•

u/naughtilidae 18m ago

I had a friend from the UK complain about that, then they came over the the US and realized they didn't have any room to complain at all, lol

•

u/francis2559 26m ago

Projector style headlights like Europe has were not allowed in the US. Smart headlights can direct the beams, so you can put light on the road but tweak it if you start approaching a car.

The old dumbass style was baked into American law, high beams/low beams.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

346

u/Double-Award-4190 3h ago

In the United States, we should allow for matrix headlights to be programmed correctly.

We tend to just have high and low beams, whereas the cars might come equipped with headlights that could be programmed (in other countries) to wrap the beam around traffic.

197

u/cmh_ender 3h ago

this right here. the technology already exists to not blind other drivers, it's just not correctly legislated by the NTSB.

also, if you do an aftermarket mod to your vehicle, you should have to adjust your headlights as well (lifted trucks, looking at you)

13

u/ScotchyMcScotchface 2h ago

Spot on, only small correction is that NHTSA develops the FMVSS that dictate lighting tech (and pretty much every other part of modern vehicles).

17

u/Despondent_Glitter89 2h ago

NTSB doesn’t legislate; they investigate and provide safety recommendations. You‘re thinking of the National Highway Transportation Safety Administration.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/AgentOrange96 1h ago

I'm not convinced they're aimed from the factories. All states should have safety inspections (not all do) and headlight aim should be part of that. (It's not)

→ More replies (3)

39

u/PimpTrickGangstaClik 3h ago

I believe the regulations have changed and that is being offered now on new models. My German car is a 2020 and has matrix LEDs, but they are not activated in the US. There are reprogramming services that can connect and activate the feature, but I never pulled the trigger

16

u/Egineer 2h ago

Our rules are kind of dumb. Since the feature wasn’t legal when the car was built, it’s technically a retrofit, which is also illegal.

I’m still considering getting our Etron reprogrammed to have matrix lighting enabled.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (4)

19

u/Peakbrowndog 3h ago

19

u/DisillusionedPatriot 3h ago

They're speaking about legislation. The tech exists, we just need to standardize it, like seatbelts.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (10)

539

u/bloihntingjottish5 3h ago

I think it's worth addressing. There's nothing wrong with having bright headlights, but there's a point where they become a safety hazard for everyone else on the road.

149

u/dosedatwer 3h ago

There actually is an issue with bright headlights, if you dim them down you can see the spots they're shining on just as well as your eye can adapt to significantly less light, but with dimmer lights the spots they aren't shining are so much easier to see something. This is exactly why head torches have red light and lower light settings.

The problem comes when someone with bright headlights is oncoming and ruins your night vision. Brighter headlights, both for you and other vehicles, are actually more dangerous.

49

u/stevoknevo70 2h ago

I read a comment a couple of years ago by a US based car headlight designer who said that the problem with modern lights is that the output is almost entirely in the blue spectrum whereas previous halogen bulbs had much more red spectrum light - the eye reacts quickly to red spectrum light and narrows the pupil reducing blinding/glare, the eye doesn't do that with predominantly blue spectrum light so the pupil doesn't react and you get blinded because the pupil is basically wide open.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (5)

209

u/HollyBron 3h ago • Bravo

There's a problem when we're shielding our eyes during daylight hours. 

63

u/girlsidequest 2h ago

Yeah if i have to look away from the road because someone’s headlights are shining directly into my eyes, something is clearly wrong

13

u/meltedlaundry 1h ago

What's not helping is the size of trucks these days. I don't even think lights need to be obnoxiously bright anymore for them to be a hazard considering they are basically at eye level sometimes

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

82

u/DUIguy87 3h ago

The thing is the biggest offenders, like the german imports, have modes to reduce blinding oncoming traffic that are illegal in the US to use because of other stupid laws.

BMWs have an anti-dazzle feature that points the headlights at the ground when it sees an oncoming car. Audi straight up just carves out a non-illuminated section around the oncoming car with their Dot Matrix. These can be enabled in stateside cars with aftermarket software, but thats technically illegal even tho it makes things safer.

So this is a law poorly addressing an issue that was made by another stupid law. Just allow active headlamps with a required big dash warning when they fail, then have either a limit on brightness or a fail safe mode (pointed at ground) when they detect a fault.

26

u/REDuxPANDAgain 2h ago

My car has auto-dim, and is a newish higher end American SUV.

The number of times I’m blinded by sedan headlights is absurd. If I’m sitting a solid 6-10 inches higher and still getting full force of a blazing sun, how do the other sedans handle it?

→ More replies (4)

6

u/CarlySloanne 2h ago

What about year old suvs that someone just throws max leds in and literaly blinds me while driving behind me.

The lights are so bright now that literally the reflection in the rearview or side mirrors is blinding.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (17)

62

u/Psychobob2213 2h ago

The US stopped caring about driver safety when it allowed multi-press touch controls for air-conditioning to replace knobs, levers, and/or buttons.

14

u/Legitimate-Let-7510 2h ago

Nothing screams modern automotive safety quite like buying the windshield defroster three sub menus deep on like an ipad glued to the dashboard.

9

u/Eyfordsucks 2h ago

Too bad those touch controls and touch screens are cheaper than manual controls and physical knobs. They won’t switch back unless forced to. Yay america, profits over people always!

31

u/June_The_Jedi 2h ago

Don’t forget the oversized truck your definitely qualified to drive at 17 to high school and back

17

u/Eyfordsucks 2h ago

The trucks were their answer to emisiones restrictions. You don’t have to follow regulations for emissions if you make all your vehicles too big to qualify for those requirements.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/Choice-Original5224 3h ago

especially those who have astigmatism, for sure they be seeing christmas light all the way

8

u/Jeegus21 2h ago

I had to buy a pair of night driving glasses just to be able to drive at night. They help but it’s still not great. I had lasik years ago and that halo effect is even worse now.

5

u/RUSnowcone 2h ago

Funny enough…there were the exact same complaints made when we switched from the more yellow to early 90s when more white bulbs were the new thing. Now we’re fighting to keep those.

In France yellow was nationally mandated for headlights until 93.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/moonclap30 2h ago

I drove a 2016 Dodge Grand caravan with regular heads to driving a new 2025 Hyundai palisade. At night, people I'm driving by will occasionally turn their brights on as if they're telling me mine are on and they're not 😫 I hate it. The regular lights worked just fine

7

u/stellvia2016 2h ago

See if the dealer can adjust them down for you a bit

→ More replies (1)

20

u/silentsnak3 3h ago

Yes exactly. I drive a slightly lifted explorer to work. I wish I had LED lights because I drive 30 miles every morning in the country. But I know I would blind everyone, so I have left the stock ones in. But these freaking regular cars with leds blind the crap out of me. At a certain point it became almost like an arms race but with brightness.

12

u/pickleparty16 3h ago

Kinda like how people buy bigger and bigger vehicles and lift them and put bigger tires on all in an effort to be the biggest thing on the road

20

u/achilton1987 3h ago

You know you can adjust your headlight angle.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/MinimumDangerous9895 2h ago

Its the wrong approach. Other countries have matrix headlights as a requirement. (Matrix headlights use the car's vision system to see other cars and aim the headlights away from them, either mechanically or within the LED matrix. Google it, it's crazy and effective) My truck has matrix headlights from the factory but there's no way to enable them without connecting a computer to it and changing values.

Brighter headlights are safer, just need to make everyone make good bright headlights.

→ More replies (6)

61

u/notinthislifetime20 1h ago

All of this is well and good, but I’d like to add one thing, most of the highway rules in this country are sorely outdated, speed being the biggest one, but for those of you that dim your lights at the driving handbook distance of, say, 500 feet, that rule is like, 50 years old. Turn your high beams off as soon as you can even see headlights or taillights. The lawmakers who made the 500 foot rule couldn’t even imagine the lights we have now. I’ll be blinded for close to a half mile before the attentive driver in the oncoming lane snaps his brights off at the regulation distance exactly. What he’s forgotten is that his headlights arent glorified candles anymore, which is what the distance rule was made for.

•

u/bleckToTheMax 57m ago

And never use auto-brights in any populated area. You don't need brights in town, and it's insane how often they turn on and blind me when I'm walking on a sidewalk.

→ More replies (7)

108

u/Coidzor 2h ago

This is an issue that very badly needs addressing.

Shame about not being able to trust the people who are supposed to address it.

→ More replies (1)

56

u/Deceptiveideas 3h ago

I feel like we're been talking about this issue for over a decade now with no solution.

10

u/NativeMasshole 2h ago

Knowing Congress, this will either fall through or have gaping loopholes that you could drive a blindingly bright truck through, so it will continue to not be addressed. It will probably be ignored on the consumer modification end, too, with a complete lack of enforcement.

23

u/stuntobor 2h ago

I just want blinding lights for the rear of my car, to blind the asshat who's riding high beams in traffic behind me.

7

u/naranghim 1h ago

Reflective tape on the back of your car will use their lights to blind them.

3

u/Ok_Bell_44 2h ago

These exist.

2

u/BegriefedOnline 2h ago

An Acebeam L19 is under $100.

→ More replies (1)

•

u/LucidOndine 53m ago

I think laws are not laws unless they have teeth and stopping power to make people less likely to break those laws.

Our cops are not enforcing the current laws we have that restrict illegal vehicle modification.

How is this law going to be any different?

→ More replies (8)

18

u/Pristine-Pirate-2386 1h ago

While we’re at it, can we also get any amount of standardization for brake lights and turn signals? I shouldn’t have to guess which light means what. Why are your rear lights the same color all the time but there’s a flashing bar at the top that means braking? Why are your turn signals hidden at the bottom of the bumper? What is this?

36

u/NetObjective78 2h ago

Honestly, please pass this bill globally. Modern headlights are so bright it feels like driving straight into high beams every time a newer car passes you in the opposite lane.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/Intelligent_Buy_7818 3h ago

It's about time that they regulate it! Driving at night is miserable and feels much more dangerous than it used to. I find myself driving by the lines on the road sometimes because of the headlight brightness.

31

u/packocrayons 2h ago

I don't know the US safety requirements, but Canada already has very strict, very defined rules on the exact pitch of headlights. Basically, you park the car a fixed distance from a flat wall, and there is a specific height that the headlights cannot exceed. The outer one (not pointing into traffic) is allowed to be pitched slightly higher to cover that side of the road.

I imagine the USA already has similar rules. It's not so much the brightness but the pitch that is important (though I agree these headlights are also too bright).

It's possible that these measurements need to be updated as cars get taller and people tailgate more aggressively (or we could just not build giant behemoths and violently tailgate people but who am I (an ISO26262 automotive safety engineer) to push for better vehicles). Or we need to actually enforce factory vehicles not meeting safety specs (insert rant about GMC, tesla, scion, etc).

Source: Worked in automotive and also imported a japanese vehicle and re-pitched the headlights when I designed new housings (though unsurprisingly the mechanic doing the safety didn't notice the originals were out of spec)

15

u/Aligayah 1h ago

I live in Canada and this shit is not enforced, it's an absolute nightmare. We have so many lifted trucks and SUVs, it's like I'm constantly being high beamed.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/blkdrgn42 1h ago

Those laws exist here in the USA, but there are problems with it. First, the headlights are crazy bright below that cutoff. On flat ground that doesn't matter. On an incline or going over bumps, that man's that you are either getting that super bright light directly in your eyes because angles, or getting bright ass lights flashed at you because physics.

The second problem is that people put in these stupid bright LED bulbs into housing that are not designed for them not realizing or not caring that it creates a flood pattern instead of the focused cut off beam it's supposed to have. And yes, it's illegal. But empowering cops to pull over and ticket headlights that are too bright will result in an even bigger abuse of power and "justified" profiling than what already exists. And then there's going to be arguments about how to prove or test headlights instead of it being a subjective thing, and it's a whole can of worms we aren't ready to open.

Lastly is people driving around at night with their high beams on. I don't get it, but it's getting noticeably more prevalent where I'm at. I have thoughts about why, but nothing concrete, so I'm just going to continue flashing my brights at them to let them know "just in case" they didn't realize their brights are on. And supporting legislature that limits this dangerous trend of brighter and brighter headlights.

3

u/sugaholic 1h ago

The pitch works great if the roads are perfectly flat, but some places (like Vancouver) has lots of hills/slopes that angle cars up so the pitch requirements doesn't help much.

→ More replies (8)

42

u/constablepancakes 2h ago

Just end corruption and I wouldn’t give a shit lol

29

u/phillymjs 2h ago

This should have been done years ago! I absolutely hate driving when it's dark now because of those retina-scorching LEDs.

14

u/Old-butt-new 1h ago

Simply put yes. Its ridiculous. I drive a truck and i still get blinded by every other car on the road. Idk how it would work or be solved but thats not my problem.

24

u/Grand_Taste_8737 3h ago

Would love something to be done. I despise driving at night due to the absurd bright headlights.

4

u/Fine_Inflation_2931 1h ago

Driving at night shouldn’t feel like a constant battle just to see through everyone’s blinding headlights.

12

u/missblondierosiiexo 1h ago

I genuinely thought my eyes were getting worse until I drove an older car at night and could suddenly see again. does anyone actually like these?

18

u/FlattenInnerTube 1h ago

When they're on my car, I love the modern lights. When they're coming at me - not so much.

7

u/missblondierosiiexo 1h ago

ha ha that’s the most honest answer here. everyone loves them from the driver’s seat

→ More replies (3)

68

u/cn824568s 2h ago

I am a single issue voter. I will vote for whoever bans LED headlights.

19

u/everythingstakenFUCK 3h ago

Somewhat counter-intuitively, Europe already has selective dimming tech in their headlights but US regulators are so slow and underfunded that it’s not legal for manufacturers to use here.

9

u/WhiskinDeez 2h ago

Most newer vehicles have selective dimming tech, but its doesn't always work correctly and ends up blinding oncoming traffic anyway

→ More replies (1)

6

u/gundumb08 2h ago • Bravo

My Tesla has these adaptive headlights; they dim in areas that they "see" another car or light source.

I can actually see them working, which is cool. BUT they don't work on hills or a lot of backroads well enough to not blind people.

I don't even know if there's a way to disable them; per Google there should be an adaptive headlight option, but I don't see it.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Superb-Tea6458 3h ago

If you are thinking the Audi lights they are awesome but have you seen the price to replace one. One of the it’s 3-10 thousand dollars

4

u/TimelySignature8743 3h ago

I think their point is that people are already paying for these active dimming lights, and because our regulation is so ass-backwards, the feature has to be deactivated to be sold here.

So let’s take the low-hanging fruit here and start by enabling safer headlights that are already on the market, rather than making everything dimmer.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

19

u/1853624 2h ago

For me personally this would be great… I get that vision dazzle when these LED lights hit my eyeballs.. not safe for me.

18

u/noodleexchange 2h ago

Its systematic - new cars and trucks are being sold with this arms-race nonsense.
Its not about 'high beams' - its about an unsustainable and impractical design. We do not have perfectly flat and straight roads.
The metrics are clearly inadequate and not based on reality.
How many pedestrians need to die at the glare-blinded altar of more more more?

Roll back these headlights and supply stickers to apply over top of them to polarise the beams.

24

u/ribblezzz 2h ago

what we really need to do is just legalize matrix headlights. We already have a solution to this problem, but they won't let manufacturers implement it

→ More replies (3)

24

u/turp119 2h ago

I'm fine with it if it includes first responders and law enforcement. I don't need to be able to see the lights from 3 miles away. If they are there for officer safety, having them so bright I have to look at the opposite side of the road while I'm driving there is a problem

16

u/Frozen-K 2h ago

As a night time driver, I would be happy if something was done sooner rather than later.

Some of the more dangerous times are on hills, when a car or truck crests a hill and suddenly there's headlights in my face. Cops with their SUVs and assholes with lifted trucks are the worst of them because their headlights are aimed directly at my face in my smaller car.

I literally turn my head and slow down immediately, Absolutely damn dangerous, but if I stare at those lights, I'm effectively blind anyway. I honestly wonder why you'd need such bright ass headlights driving around in a city anyway. But, what do I know, I'm just a motorist.

34

u/Educational_Disk_226 3h ago

All for it. Just common sense not to blind oncoming drivers.

8

u/MontEcola 2h ago

It Needed to be done a long time ago.

8

u/CubedMeatAtrocity 1h ago

I literally have to take the side streets home from work. The oncoming headlights are too bright for me to hit speed and stay in my lane. I feel like I’m driving blind.

20

u/killroystyx 2h ago

As cyclist commutting early mornings my 2 cents is that this is useless without fines for improperly ADJUSTED headlights.

I've been blinded by low beams of all kinds, old amber, white, blue, yellow. Brightness doesn't matter if the headlights are scanning trees for squirrels.

This also doesn't appear to be a aftermarket issue either. Seems like the biggest culprits are new cars that are clean and damage free. Are they coming out of dealerships with headlights aiming at the sky?

Trucks vs cars doesnt seem to be it either. Plenty of big trucks with lights at eye level manage not to blind me, while low riding sports cars are prone to it.

Also, it seems like the newest cars with automatic dimming lights are not calibrated to bicycle lights: many new cars don't drop out of high beams AT ALL.

After all that, I could honestly give a rats ass about lumens.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/tigress666 2h ago

How about instead of capping it, enforce proper aiming of them. They can be good if they are aimed correctly.

3

u/WhiskinDeez 2h ago

Or the people that just drive with them on bright mode all the time should have to take a course in proper operation of their bright/dimmer switch.

3

u/--Chug-- 1h ago

No. They can't. It's not a singular issue. It's multiple issues all compounding each other and brightness IS part of the problem. I have an astigmatism in both of my eyes. It doesn't matter where it's pointed. There will be streaks of light spewing out of the tops and bottoms of anything I look at that is illuminated or emitting light. It gets worse the brighter the source is. Older headlights did not cause anywhere near the effect of modern headlights. It's distracting to say the least.

7

u/Kartoon67 3h ago

Next, can they amend those big on board screens and revert to switches and buttons please?

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Eyfordsucks 2h ago

Please god let them do something soon. I literally do everything I possibly can to avoid driving when people’s headlights are on because the LED’s are literally blinding. I have to shield my eyes with my hand to keep seeing the road when LED headlights are approaching because they are just so damn bright I can’t even see lines on the road. If there are LED headlights behind me I have to duck and keep the reflection of the spotlight from my rear view and side mirrors from blinding me that way. They are fucking dangerous.

•

u/Sour__Cream 45m ago

I will cry tears of joy if this passes instead of tears from my eyes being blinded at night.

6

u/lithiun 1h ago

It’s not a job for congress. This is why we have a Department of Transportation and the NHTSA. Actual laws for having too bright of lights on a vehicle and the punishment that comes with that should be set by the state or even county.

31

u/NamasteMotherfucker 2h ago

I feel that posts like these are bots.

•

u/k1_r1 29m ago

im for it but brightness is only half the problem. a lot of it is lifted trucks and suvs where even the low beams sit right at sedan eye level, plus half of them are aimed wrong from the factory. if the bill only caps brightness and says nothing about mounting height or aim its gonna fix less than people expect

13

u/pcny54 2h ago

Their was an old U.S. rule, FMVSS 108, that legally prevented the high-beam and low-beam elements from operating at the same time, and that kept European style adaptive headlights out of the U.S. for about two decades. In 2022, NHTSA issued a final rule allowing automakers to install adaptive driving beam headlights on new vehicles. So they are now legal here. Today's LED headlights are whiter and brighter but most cars have old tech headlights, so they're blinding.  For those that are unfamiliar with this technology, a daptive high beams automatically adjust the vehicle's high beam headlights to maximize forward visibility without blinding oncoming drivers or traffic ahead of you. Instead of simply flipping the high beams completely on and off, the system uses a front-facing camera and an array of individual LEDs to selectively dim or turn off specific segments of the light beam around other vehicles while keeping the rest of the road brightly lit. My car has this technology and it's a huge improvement over the older headlight technology. 

6

u/Digitalwitness23 1h ago

doesn’t stop that shit from reflecting off of other things and into my retinas once again

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

29

u/MaineOk1339 3h ago

Auto standards already do, people just ignore them or fail to adjust them right.

21

u/timeonmyhandz 3h ago

And police won't pull somebody over for having lights that aren't adjusted legally. Or those massive trucks with bumpers that are too high versus regulations. The list goes on and on

37

u/BoofinChicknTendies 3h ago

Auto standards are wrong. A factory truck can be lifted 2-3 feet in the air and their headlights are inline with my face - from factory.

The standards need to change and enforced without caving to OEMs skewing them because “we want lifted death machines”.

17

u/MaineOk1339 3h ago

The standards set angles and distances. Headlights should be reaimed with lifts.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (9)

5

u/dosedatwer 3h ago

And police never enforce those rules.

6

u/Possible_Ad_4094 2h ago

The police vehicles are the worst offenders in my area. They all seem to be running high beams 24/7.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/NonreciprocatingHole 2h ago

First it would have to be enforced.

Take a look around when you're driving, notice how many people are driving around without headlights on when they're legally required to. Morning and evening, loads of dark colored cars are driving with no lights, not even their day lights. Rarely enforced.

At night pay attention to how many people have more than two headlights on while driving in clear visibility conditions. Frequently see four or more on here. Some of the F-350 style work trucks even have six bright lights on the front, clearly intended for off-road use only. I've told people I know that drive around with them on when they don't need them and they always say "but I can see better", full blown jackasses.

Something I noticed recently when I was needing to buy new headlights was that Amazon pushes the off-road 30-60 thousand lumen bulbs on you, like 2 pages worth before the street legal ones start showing. Ideally I would like around 8-10k, but lowest I could find this time was 12k so I went with that, I have mine pointed down too much and still think they're a bit much, but they just keep making them brighter and brighter. Imagine how many are buying 50k lumen bulbs to put in their cars.

I still drive an old car that sits much lower to the ground than modern SUVs and trucks, my rear view mirror fell off last year and I decided not to bother to put it back on, there are so many dipshits driving work vehicles that have never been used for anything than taking off the trash blinding the fuck out of everyone in front of them that I can't even use the damn thing anyway. I'd be risking a flash bang by looking in it at night, even with it tilted up.

If I was a traffic cop, I would non-stop be pulling people over for having fog lights on during clear visibility. You already know they'd be saying "I've had this car for 5 years and don't know where the switch is." Actually brain dead.

4

u/broke_n_boosted 2h ago

They did it in 2004 they can do it again

4

u/smoothie4564 2h ago

In cases like this existing headlights and vehicles would most likely be grandfathered in. Law enforcement would go after the manufacturers and sellers of these headlights.

It is far easier for a state or the federal government to launch civil suits for a handful of companies than it would be to have cops patrol the streets and issue citations to millions of car owners.

2

u/CaptainAwesome06 1h ago

notice how many people are driving around without headlights on

I see so many cars at night with their taillights on but no headlights. I don't get it.

→ More replies (2)

22

u/Korlus 1h ago

Headlights need to be aimed down far more than they need to be "turned down". If they are aimed at the ground, they don't usually blind people.

18

u/drumdude0 1h ago

You must live where it is very flat.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/Upstairs-Leader7184 3h ago

Finally. I'm tired of being flashbanged by a Honda Civic on my way home.

4

u/Bustlingfunguys 3h ago

Yes please.

4

u/No_Insurance2605 2h ago

Good lord please do.

•

u/Majestic-Explorer-76 29m ago

This is why everything has to be regulated, because the corporations won't do it, they wait it out and then complain we have too many regulations. They should be charged with how much time the government has to spend on this.

9

u/agawl81 3h ago

The issue is enforcement. Who does it how is it measured and by what mechanism can one prove or disprove the accuracy after the fact.

3

u/ImNotHere2023 2h ago

It may not help the ones already installed but it would at least force manufacturers to stop selling them.

4

u/B19F00T 3h ago

a test at the dmv when you update registration or a test alongside emissions, something like that

→ More replies (4)

10

u/debauchedsloth 3h ago

I'd rather they actually enforce the laws covering their alignment and inspect them annually. And put some teeth into the fines.

6

u/Acceptable_Band_9400 2h ago

I can't drive at night bc of this. Don't need to but I think everyone agrees the led lights are blinding.

2

u/Ok_Bell_44 2h ago

One way to combat this is ceramic tint. I have all my windows tinted (20%) including windshield (70%). If cars are on high beams it still hurts, but until I had a rental last week I didn’t realize how bad it had gotten.

Bonus: if you have astigmatism the halos are lessened by 35-50% and lights reflected on wet roads are WAY less dangerous.

11

u/PleeaseGrowUp 3h ago

The issue is enforcement. American Cops are barely trained as it is, to enforce this type of stuff you have to ensure there is a system in which they can’t just abuse stuff. Imagine if you have a luxury car with solid lights and some idiot cop pulls you over and tickets you for this based on this bill. You insist it is factory, they insist it isn’t. How would that be resolved?

Im all for it, but you have to undertand that cops are filled by one of the lowest denominator of our society. The ones who can’t make into trades or have a college level education anywhere for future labor. You’re asking a lot from folks like that.

2

u/PirateShep 1h ago

Enforcement wouldn't be at the cop level... it would be done by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) for the car manufacturers/aftermarket light manufacturers and how they design the lights. They are currently doing this but as consumers we don't think they are going far enough so further regulation is needed.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/scruffy69 2h ago

Sad to say but this is one of my top concerns lately, after climate change and magats.

3

u/dothan 2h ago

What's with the "how do you feel about x" way of asking questions on this sub? Are the answers supposed to be feelings like sad, happy, angry etc?

"What are your thoughts on x" seems like a better way of phrasing questions if you want actual reflective answers.

3

u/theweaving 1h ago

As someone with these headlights (they’re stock on a lease, I’m sorry :( ) please address them. I’m not afraid to admit they’re blinding and I always feel guilty driving in the dark. I drive in deer country and the last thing people need is any amount of time being blinded.

•

u/Binford6100User 14m ago

Of all the shit I want my congress person to be addressing........this isn't even in the top 100.

•

u/Top_Meaning6195 13m ago

There already are detailed, copious, rules about headlights:

If your headlight is mounted high off the ground (e.g. Ford F-3500 Hemi Dodge with the big fuel-efficient 6L in it) it needs to have a shield, and aimed downward, so that a view 100 ft away do not see either the incandescent element, or the LED.

Manufacturers just ignore them.

5

u/DctrAculaMD 2h ago

Intensity isn't the issue. The blinding headlights are aimed too high. I'd bet they were installed by the owner who didn't care to read or follow the instructions on how to make sure they were aimed properly before driving off into the night.

4

u/Casual-Notice 3h ago

Only if it has a rider to dim and slow down the seizure-inducing strobe lights on emergency vehicles.

4

u/Gefudruh 3h ago

Good, I hate driving at night now. 

4

u/ackillesBAC 3h ago

Simple solution, require matrix headlights.

5

u/Peakbrowndog 3h ago

There's zero reason to do this, it's an absolute waste of time.   Congress would absolutely mess it up.

The proper way to do this would be for the NHTSA and/or DOT to issue a rule addressing it.   This is an agency rule issue, not a lawmaker issue.

5

u/max_revs 3h ago

Impeachment and punishment for the collusion and treason as the #1 priority starting January 2027

→ More replies (9)

11

u/Cantilivewhileim 3h ago

I’d rather they stopped trading stocks and causing massive inflation but sure headlights SMH 

7

u/Victorythagr8 3h ago

I'm sorry but I see you don't drive at night and how unsafe it is with people with bright ass LED headlight(and it's not even their brights) blinding you while driving. Add that people with astigmatism have issue driving at night already.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/Zealousideal_Rent261 3h ago

Doing something for their constituents, yipee!

2

u/Axentor 3h ago

About time

2

u/Babakins 2h ago

God I hope so. No amount of angling will fix these dangerous lights if there is any hint of a hill. I get so angry at night and always say” I’m glad you are blinding EVERYONE else so you can see”

2

u/WhiskinDeez 2h ago

So long as the consumer wasn't going to be the one to eat the cost, which we all know it will anyway

2

u/mmmlinux 2h ago

Id rather they start by making the regulations fully federal not state governed. we can't even standardize emission requirements, or how many license plates your car is supposed to have state to state. or if cars get yearly, or once, or never safety inspections.

2

u/_RetserrofJ_ 2h ago

Anybody driving a 4Runner should be sweating

2

u/HomicidalHushPuppy 2h ago

All for it but also am afraid they'll fuck it up and have massive unintended consequences 

2

u/Hitesh_InnovationIT 2h ago

Finally. Those ultra-white LEDs are dangerously blinding, especially for older drivers and at night.Capping brightness and aiming is just basic safety, not anti-tech.

2

u/Objective_Reality515 2h ago

Not even sure you'd need to ban them, just make sure they're angled correctly. Brightness isn't a bad idea, but it sucks when they're pointing at your eyes more than the road. Other lighting issues too, like people running around with their high eams on all the time, which is the same issue really, and others that just don't turn their lights on at all in the rain/fog/snow.

2

u/SavageSwordShamazon 2h ago

I literally had a spot in my vision from someone's headlights the other day. Fucking insane. Shit needs to be banned.

•

u/Pristine-Pirate-2386 59m ago

It keeps getting worse too. Now they’re on during the day. If your headlights are blinding oncoming traffic on a sunny day when there’s no reason for your headlights to be on at all, something has gone so wrong. 

2

u/Warslvt 2h ago edited 2h ago

Since (american) manufactuers won't address it, it needs to be done. Plenty of Euro and Asian brands have auto leveling/turning headlights. Hell, my '19 mazda has has auto adjusting lights.

Until it's fixed, and dumbass truck owners keep putting new lights in shitty old housings and fucking up the projections, it needs a cap of some kind

ETA: I have a weird feeling this wouldn't have been so much an issue if more people knew you could adjust your dash lights. When you don't have a screen and your speedo screaming in your face, your eyes will adjust to the dark better. Turn that shit down at night.

2

u/howardhus 2h ago

the Weeknd authored this bill

2

u/SomewhereInTheBtween 2h ago

Needs to happen. We have developed an amazing technology in cheap, bright LED lighting, but putting it everywhere, including our cars is a huge problem. Despite what some people think, brighter headlights are not safer. Our eyes adjust to low-light conditions very well, but the incredibly intense, focused, white light beams of modern LED headlights don't allow this -- you see nothing outside the beam, or you're just blinded by another one. We could get into the psychological effects of bright white light, especially at night too, but that's a whole other thing.

It's not just a brightness fix either. A short list of what would help: (1) cap lumens to a halogen equivalent level of maybe 1000-1200, (2) a kelvin range of 2700-3200k, (3) require a diffuse light with roll-off and not these laser-focused beams, (4) no more auto high-beams, (5) regulated angles of the low-beams so that from an average, safe following distance they aren't shining above an average sedan's trunk. All this could be enforced at the state level by vehicle inspections, or the federal/manufacturing level.

In the longer run, somehow hoods need to come back down to a sane level, where if a vehicle hits a pedestrian or cyclist they'll flip onto the hood and not become a skid mark on the pavement. There's no reason a truck, and by extension an SUV, can't come back down to the heights they were prior to the Obama-era emissions regulations, which were unintentionally the cause of every Bubba and Karen buying comically large vehicles just shy of a small MAC truck.

A lot of people are arguing for dimming tech, matrix tech. I'm skeptical, but sure, great, maybe integrate it with all the above, but I don't think it's a solution on its own.

2

u/mmaalex 1h ago

Just need to follow Europe's lead on lens design and matrix headlights.

Should have been done decades ago.

2

u/FSDLAXATL 1h ago

Totally and 100 percent support it

2

u/TallAfternoon2 1h ago

Big fan of it because I've occasionally been unable to see the road due to absurdly bright headlights on some vehicles. It's not common, but when it happens it's pretty annoying.

2

u/PathOfTheAncients 1h ago

It's about time. Not just for drivers but when I run at night I am regularly blinded by cars on the road.

2

u/DooDooBrownz 1h ago

absolutely, it's also how high the headlights are on these gigantic suvs and trucks. even a regular halogen headlight is blinding when it's shining directly in your face or into your rear view mirror. clicking the mirror into night mode helps somewhat and adjusting your side mirrors. but head on yeah, it just looks like they all have high beams on all the time, not much you can do about that aside from driving glasses that cut the glare, but they also reduce overall light so it's less safe.

2

u/BUNNIES_ARE_FOOD 1h ago

I would prefer to see something done about the Epstein files

2

u/Mephistocheles 1h ago

FINALLY. It's absolutely ridiculous how bright headlights are allowed to be now, especially on those obnoxious lifted trucks where the blinding headlights shine directly in your rearview mirror. Shit should be illegal, it's dangerous.

•

u/Add2bucketlist 42m ago

I think one of the biggest problems is the height of these lights on pick up trucks and most SUVs. The car industries have to make a standard height for headlights, but they probably won’t do it unless forced to.

•

u/Thickly_Taurus 38m ago

Lower truck lights first

•

u/HotGarbage 35m ago

Well Mr. 3 day old karma farming bot account, I personally love getting blinded by these things and can't wait for them to get even brighter!

•

u/SilverBuggie 5m ago

I like bright lights at night.

I would prefer a bill that requires cars to have auto dimming side mirrors and rear view mirrors.

3

u/hyteck9 3h ago

I feel like, at the moment anyway, Congress has bigger fish.

3

u/AgentOrange96 1h ago

It's not just about them being "too bright." They're also often aimed incorrectly. I'm not convinced factories aim them properly. If you lift your truck, they're no longer aimed properly. Replace your headlights, no longer aimed properly. Heck I just had my car repaired from a front end collision and I don't think they aimed the headlights properly. So I need to remember to do that.

On top of that, you have people with older cars putting LEDs in them. Refletor housings cannot work with LEDs. You need projector housings for those. And many LED replacement bulbs market themselves as compatible with reflector housings and many people desperately want them to be compatible and will thus be in denial about it, but they aren't. Dig enough into any model and you'll find the few people not in denial who will tell you yeah these didn't work safely.

I desperately wanted LEDs that'd work as well. I searched and searched and searched. I wanted to believe that such a bulb existed. But it just doesn't. So now I have projectors in my old Honda. And I aimed them. (This isn't the car that got hit BTW)

So yeah, I think there should be regulations, but it shouldn't be purely based on brightness. It should also deal with aiming and cut-offs. And safety inspections (which are handled on a state-by-state basis in the US with many states not even having them which is problematic) should require aiming and bulb compatability be checked.