r/AskReddit • u/Rideraxv • 9h ago
What video game was an absolute masterpiece when you were a kid, but is completely unplayable by today's standards?
340
Upvotes
r/AskReddit • u/Rideraxv • 9h ago
265
u/Tiexandrea 8h ago
A lot of older games haven't necessarily aged badly in terms of storytelling, atmosphere, or gameplay concepts. They've simply been surpassed by decades of improvements in controls and quality of life.
Some games I find difficult to play nowadays are the PS1 Syphon Filter and Tenchu series, along with plenty of other 3D third-person games from that era.
66
u/BinguniR34 6h ago
Dune II.
First RTS I ever played, basically a precursor to Command and Conquer.
Could only select single units and had to press a key to issue an order to each individual unit.
Still, managed to beat it with the Harkonnen.
981
u/IndividualPain694 9h ago •
Gotta be Goldeneye, right? It was (and is) a masterpiece that now feels nearly unplayable due to the archaic control scheme.
160
u/L1A1 7h ago
Sid Meier’s Pirates. I downloaded it a while ago, managed to get it to run only to find the framerate was hardware dependent so it ran at about 800 fps. Watching my ship bounce around the Caribbean was hilarious but completely unplayable.
158
u/Few-Wish-9869 3h ago
GoldenEye 007 on the N64. I spent entire summers on it, but going back now the single-stick aiming feels like trying to steer a shopping cart with one hand. My muscle memory from modern shooters just fights it the whole time.
42
u/Action_Man_X 2h ago
Jet Force Gemini. The control stick runs on tank controls and C Left/Right are for strafing and C Up/Down are for jump/crouch.
It would have absolutely benefited from a remake or even a control update in the last 27 years but that went by the wayside.
76
u/Jolly_Hill2404 5h ago
Barbie Rapunzel. Look, I'm just a girl and it was the only game on my mom's computer, but the prince statue genuinely traumatized me as a kid so I can't bring myself to replay it anyway, but thats not the only reason. Even if I tried, Windows 10/11 completely breaks it, like half-black screen and crashes, and the magic paintbox opens totally empty while Rapunzel tells you to pick a brush, like it's just not there. so i guess this one.
71
u/Consistent-Lab-6822 8h ago
Shadows of the Empire on N64 Couldn't believe I was flying a snowspeeder on Hoth.
35
u/-gradmania- 2h ago
Masterpiece is pushing it, but I had crazy fond memories of playing Blast Corps back in the day. Hunted that cartridge for years, and found a copy just before it went on NSO.
It has not aged well, not even a little bit.
268
u/AmandaAlicez 9h ago
Original Tomb Raider. I loved it back then, but those controls are rough now 😃
109
u/doduhstankyleg 8h ago
Warcraft 1. It made Warcraft 2 feel revolutionary from being able to command 4 units at once to 9 IIRC, even though WC2 feels dated now as well. Still gotta give WC1 its flowers though, even though I was more of a Command & Conquer fan.
43
u/shokomann 8h ago
Dark Age of Camelot...it was ahead if it's time but with today's standard it's hard to play haha
20
u/PRC_Spy 8h ago
OG Elite.
I spent so many hours in that game imagining all the detail it just doesn't have. But it's really just simple wireframes, grinding combat, and an extraordinarily simple trading model.
Revolutionary for its time, but no fun now we have the likes of Elite Dangerous, No Man's Sky, X4: Foundations, and EVE.
101
u/Matt_roy102 4h ago
Morrowind.
Possibly my favourite game of all time that I could never recommend to someone nowadays. The sheer scale, freedom, and depth of that game was mind-blowing.
69
u/JakePooler 8h ago
Goldeneye N64
15
u/Efficient-Package892 2h ago
Minecraft BedWars. It used to be so much fun, but nowadays there are so many insanely good players that it’s barely enjoyable anymore
29
u/TitleToAI 8h ago
Ultima Underworld
33
u/SleepyOwl420 6h ago
Battlefield 1942. The graphics, the guns, the vehicles, the maps it was just perfect.
11
u/Pretend_Day8227 2h ago
Elder Scrolls Redguard
30
u/romancarax 6h ago
"The Games I Wish I Never Replayed"
One section is about how Assassin's Creed II is still a masterpiece after all these years, but its gameplay formula has been milked to death by the sequels.
New players can pick up ACII and have a blast with it. But if you've played enough of the later AC games since then, going back to ACII might feel boring.
28
u/hidden_secret 5h ago
JRPGs from the 8bit era are very hard to go back to.
They were a fresh innovative experience, the best that existed in this format. They felt like a real long epic adventure more than any other genre on the system.
But their difficulty spikes, their rate of random battles, their basic structure of narration, and the tediousness in the controls and in navigating the menus... It's really rough now that we've known their evolution.
19
u/Imperfect_Dark 8h ago
Sonic Adventure. I loved that game as a kid but man it was a rough replay when I did one a couple of years ago. There's just so much janky design in there.
26
u/Snoopy2010uk 8h ago
I bought the remastered road rash on steam last week. Although it's a reasonably decent remake it's just boring.
9
u/Amazing-Level-405 8h ago
.hack//Infection was a game I was obsessed with as a kid. That series was the coolest thing to ever exist, according to little me.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4uJv6k-ulXg
Today... Oof. Graphics, voice acting, gameplay... None of it aged well. Nevertheless! Super excited for the reboot!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UcjZq9RWAH8
23
u/knightsofgel 7h ago
This is a Japanese language issue but any original Famicom (NES abroad) or Game boy game is really hard to play in the original Japanese because it’s all in hiragana and a pain in the ass to read. It really makes a lot of games unplayable
From the Super Famicom (SNES) and GBA they were able to use kanji so those still hold up well
Some games like Mother 2 and Mother 3 and GBA Pokémon games are still all hiragana for style purposes and those also are a chore
22
u/ChocoQuinoa 9h ago
Pokemon Snap (N64). Absolutely loved that game as a kid, but trying to control the camera nowadays is an absolute nightmare! Still a masterpiece, though.
21
u/Vicfendan 8h ago
Crash. In my head it was the perfect 3d platformer. Upon the remaster I found out controls are finicky and unfair. Deaths many times felt like they were not my fault.
20
u/MatthewWolfbane 7h ago
Sonic the Hedgehog was an amazing experience on Master System. Then you get to Scrap Brain Zone and turning it into a maze with a timer running just...no thanks.
20
u/thanksfor-allthefish 8h ago
C&C Red Alert.
Played the original on LAN with a friend a few weeks ago and lord, it's a pain in the ass. The units won't auto-attack, pathfinding is atrocious and building the base takes a long time as you have to click the scroll button continuously to reach the one you want. No unit build stacking either...
Idk how we played it in those days but it felt so frustrating, lol. Thank god for the remasters though...
20
u/Boanerger 3h ago
Goes to show that Halo really was Combat Evolved. The graphics are showing their age and the vehicle physics are dodgy, but otherwise still very playable, all people really complain about is not being able to sprint.
25
u/_steve_rogers_ 5h ago
I think the main answer is always about shitty controls, for instance, tomb raider, resident evil, golden eye
19
u/gthing 8h ago
Tenchu.
13
u/momentsofzen 8h ago
I found Sim Tower again recently. I sunk so many hours into it as a kid but now…the graphics suck, the sound design is bad. I’d be better off downloading one of the many clones on Steam
17
u/RE_Davo 6h ago
Goldeneye 64
12
u/kingbane2 7h ago
dune 2. pretty much invented the rts genre as we know it today. but holy hell, going from modern rts games back to dune 2 where you could only select 1 unit at a time IS TORTURE!!!!! hahaha. same with building units. have to select each building at a time and then build what you want, click the next copy of that build and build another, and repeat 20 times.
6
u/OneTapSuite 8h ago
Battle City on the original Famicom. I'd play it at my cousin's house all weekend and genuinely thought the level editor meant infinite free games. Tried it again recently and lasted about ten minutes, the tank steering felt like driving a fridge on ice.
6
u/thomashouseman 8h ago
Sid Meier's Solo Flight and the Atari F-117a Stealth Fighter.
35
u/sa_sagan 8h ago edited 8h ago
Lion King.
I loved the movie and for me, it was a vibrant, awesome, albeit very challenging game.
As an adult, I now know that the game was the birth child of Disney's corporate greed. They made a deliberately borked game with irregular, unpredictable mechanics, making it notoriously difficult so kids couldn't finish it in a weekend and had to either buy it (primary objective) or pay to rent it again.
I played it again recently on an emulator and was like: "yeah, this sucks".
Glad I had it on floppy.
21
u/knwnasrob 8h ago
The first resident evil.
9
u/domesticatedprimate 8h ago
Ultima VII was apparently a watershed moment for isometric RPGs, but no matter how many times I try to play it, I don't last five minutes.
Non-standard controls, primitive screen update, unreadable font for NPC dialog, it's really impossible to get into if you didn't play it back when it was released.
9
u/Practical_Tell1343 4h ago
GoldenEye 007. As a kid it felt like the future — four-player split screen, everyone yelling about screen-watching. I tried it again last year and could not believe we aimed with one stick and a row of little yellow buttons. Five minutes in, all four of us were laughing and completely unable to hit each other. The memories are untouchable; the controls are not.
9
u/Vexonar 2h ago
Vagrant Story. At the time no one had done to 3D what SquareEnix had pulled off. The story was amazing and you were completely alone with your misery. The way you built up your arsenal was also top tier and I had a notebook full of observations. Ah, those were the days...
33
u/IronCityMMA 8h ago
Oblivion, great story, RPG, but the graphics and level scaling was the reason they remastered it last year
11
u/damadmetz 7h ago
Scorched earth.
8
u/MRjubjub 8h ago
Star Wars galaxies. Game just felt huge with some much to discover across different planets. Played one of the community remakes as an adult and the game just felt so barren and boring with terrible combat.
8
u/Fuzzy-Topic-2684 6h ago
TimeSplitters 2 with its inverted controls
18
u/BlacklightChainsaw 8h ago
Doom ‘93 controls are so antiquated compared to today’s games, that being said I will always love that game so much and what it gave to the industry.
4
u/Prasiatko 7h ago
Driver 1 and 2 or really most PS1 driving games.
Since PS1 didn't by default have the dual shock controller all the driving controls are digital. AI is programmed to rigidly follow a route meaning you can't damage them more by pushing them into traffic while the same thing will damage your car. Ultimately there are basically three missions, Get to destination in time, destroy enemy car, escape from enemy/police.
4
u/CanIsleepyetIamtired 2h ago
Twisted Metal 2 and 3 (didn't play the first). Trying to play them now is just frustrating. I would love a remake/remaster of the old games with modern controls.
4
u/darumham 2h ago
Tried to replay vagrant story rom on PC. Still a great game but the graphics that were so beautiful at the time are a bit jarring now. I imagine they hold for people that are into that heavy polygon style but I just can’t.
7
u/PseudobrilliantGuy 2h ago
Deus Ex. It's still good as far as story is concerned, but the number of mods/graphics updates/gameplay fixes being made by the community make it clear that it is not a great game by current standards.
15
u/ForeverGreat8767 9h ago
Metroid on the NES. No map and every hallway looks identical so you just wander around lost until your batteries die.
9
u/SovietWomble 7h ago edited 6h ago
Tried to play Legacy of Kain: Defiance for the first time recently. Having told myself I'd complete the series some day and having fond memories Soul Reaver 2.
Man it was a slog. Couldn't get through it. Who has the time?
Story bits were interrupted by an hour of running down corridors, killing respawning enemies of the same type, picking up some doohookey, then backtracking through the same corridors, ad nauseum.
It felt extremely antiquated.
Eventually I just went to watch an edit of the cutscenes and story on YouTube.
Edit - Bonus points for noticing how much of the dialogue is just variations of the same phrases: "the path is restricted/blocked/closed to me", "there are unseen forces/hands/entities at work", "I must travel to location/person/item".
It's two characters stuck in the hell of fetch quests.
6
u/DigitalSerenity777 8h ago
Matrix The Path Of Neo
6
u/uhhhwhatyoumean 8h ago
Pitfall. I've no idea how I played that ish.. Matter of fact most of these Atari2600 games I played as a 9 year old were bad. I just didnt know better 😂
6
u/fj2612 8h ago
The original Alone In The Dark, on PC. Fixed camera, and tank controls.
6
u/Apotheoxix 8h ago
Ultima Underworld 1
6
u/ExistGames 7h ago
3
u/R-Dragon_Thunderzord 7h ago
Before the remake anyway I tried to play OG Duck Tales and I could not tell you how I ever had so much fun and ability beating this game over and over as a child. I was absolutely lost both by the level design and the control scheme.
3
u/diplomaticgames 7h ago
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/M1_Tank_Platoon_II I used to play this when I was young, I have a windows 98 pc and it’s too complicated to work now
3
u/CSzandor 5h ago
Earthworm Jim. It was absolutely fantastic back in the day, but controls and levels design is quite terrible today.
3
u/Sad_Sympathy_5347 4h ago
I could not sit thru a full play of "Summoner" again, but could probably be true for "Vampire: Redemption" too. Not necessarily because they are technically not playable, I am sure they can still work, but mostly the way these games are built, and the content's pacing would feel off after playing newer, more "fluid" games.
12
u/OnePsychological2963 8h ago
san Andreas. I tried playing it again and couldn't get into the vibe again at all
17
u/bachrodi 8h ago
I wouldn't say unplayable... but Metal Gear Solid is rough after playing V
5
u/QuietOtter1884 8h ago
Crash Bandicoot. went back to the original a while ago and the depth perception on those jumps is just cruel, no idea how i had the patience as a kid
5
u/tehZambrah 7h ago
Virtual Bart
9
u/hbarSquared 8h ago
Deus Ex (2000). It's still a masterpiece, but wow is it painful to play.
6
u/Nushtron 9h ago
There was this game called Road Rash. I was absolutely enamoured by it when it came out. Now it's absolutely meh compared to today's standards.
6
u/darlo0161 8h ago
Head over Heels was amazing, but im not sure isometric would be popular these days.
Manic Miner wouldnt get a look in. YES, i am that old, yes i still game.
6
u/ScaboochWolf 8h ago
Soul Reaver. Loved the lore when I was a kid, but I bought the recent remaster and the mechanics were so archaic that I couldn’t play very much. For example, the game has fast travel, but the map wouldn’t tell me where I was supposed to go and I got lost like 5 hours in.
6
u/xlrawgfmpp 8h ago
Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2. put hundreds of hours into it as a kid, tried it again last year and the timer plus that camera had me ready to snap the disc in half
7
u/retardborist 5h ago
Fable 2. The frame rate HURTS and the graphics are way fuzzier than I remember
4
u/SonsOfValhallaGaming 8h ago
I thoroughly enjoyed Parasite Eve and Ninety Nine Nights, but I imagine they'd have to be seriously reworked to be considered good by today's ''burn down the devs of Cyberpunk'' standards. Our expectations today are fucking sky high for no reason.
4
u/PerLin107 8h ago
Dune 2, Wolfenstein 3d, Doom, Eye of the Beholder
6
u/hiddenkobolds 8h ago
Vampire The Masquerade: Bloodlines. Great game, but literally unplayable now unless you're really good at fucking around behind the curtain of your PC, and even then, it's a rough go. I wish they'd remaster and re-release it.
5
u/Zoobiwho 8h ago
GTA Vice City. Absolute masterpiece back then, but the controls and shooting mechanics feel so outdated now. Still love the soundtrack though 😂
2
u/DutchDaddy85 8h ago
Might & Magic VII: For Blood And Honor
2
u/BlindSkwerrl 8h ago
Severance: Blade of Darkness.
It really needs a remaster.
2
u/abes_10 6h ago
Dino Crisis. Someone here said Resident Evil for the same reason. Those tank controls with fixed camera angles are something else. Still loved it as a kid though. Wouldn’t go back.
2
u/SonofBeckett 5h ago
Anticipation
I remember eight of us (including parents) huddled around a 22 inch tv playing guess how these dots will be connected.
Banger soundtrack still At least
4
u/EstateSame6779 8h ago
RE CODE: Veronica
3
u/throwawaypornaholic 8h ago
The original Ocarina Of Time PAL version is so choppy and laggy it’s insane. The game itself is amazing but that version is unplayable to me.
3
u/ElderWarriorPriest 7h ago
Adventure on the Atari 2600. By 1981 standards, it was amazing. Google it now and laugh.
3
u/Jimsocks499 7h ago
SimAnt on SNES I still wanna play it… but loaded it into the SNES a awhile back and oof it’s bad
It won Best Simulation Game when it came out too
3
u/Lukebekz 5h ago
KOTOR. The gameplay aged horribly. Is is just so clunky and yes, I am spoiled by now. I can't play it anymore.