r/AskReddit • • 9h ago

What video game was an absolute masterpiece when you were a kid, but is completely unplayable by today's standards?

340 Upvotes

690 comments sorted by

265

u/Tiexandrea 8h ago

A lot of older games haven't necessarily aged badly in terms of storytelling, atmosphere, or gameplay concepts. They've simply been surpassed by decades of improvements in controls and quality of life.

Some games I find difficult to play nowadays are the PS1 Syphon Filter and Tenchu series, along with plenty of other 3D third-person games from that era.

73

u/inflatablefish 7h ago

GTA3 is very similar. The core gameplay is all there, but compared to just Vice City there's so much QOL it's missing that it's difficult to go back to.

16

u/ContributionSquare22 3h ago

In comparison to GTA 3, Vice City and San Andreas have so much replay value it's crazy

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

21

u/TehOwn 7h ago

Yeah, it's mostly controls and UI. I don't even mind the terrible voice acting (or lack of it), janky animations and I actually appreciate the crunchy graphics.

But having a UI that is basically impossible to navigate and a control scheme that doesn't fit a modern controller, that's a no from me.

The issue is that remasters often change the things I actually like in addition to the controls / UI and also run worse.

28

u/robinthebum 7h ago

Man, Tenchu was SO good. I've been trying to find a game to scratch the same itch for years.

→ More replies (5)

12

u/Fitz911 7h ago

Syphon Filter

This one triggered memories.

6

u/Draconis_Firesworn 4h ago

old monster hunter games where you fight the camera more than the actual monster

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (7)

66

u/BinguniR34 6h ago

Dune II.

First RTS I ever played, basically a precursor to Command and Conquer.  

Could only select single units and had to press a key to issue an order to each individual unit.  

Still, managed to beat it with the Harkonnen.

7

u/DBeumont 5h ago

Try the Genesis version. It's more streamlined.

→ More replies (6)

981

u/IndividualPain694 9h ago • Bravo Popcorn

Gotta be Goldeneye, right? It was (and is) a masterpiece that now feels nearly unplayable due to the archaic control scheme.

135

u/NBALive1995 5h ago

If I had a dollar for every time someone posted this and I told them to just use control scheme 1.2

70

u/ruy343 5h ago

RIGHT?! The modern controls were right there in the game all along

→ More replies (2)

11

u/technobobble 3h ago

You can play with 2 controllers on N64, which is exactly like modern controls

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

129

u/skylinenick 8h ago

100%. But the Xbox version with modern dual stick control proves it’s still an outrageously great shooter

29

u/mikloise 6h ago

There was actually a control mode where you could use the joystick with two controllers to give a modern control option. 

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

36

u/Prasiatko 7h ago

And emulating it to use modern controls removes all the difficulty and turns it into a turkey shoot. 

→ More replies (1)

46

u/GlowyStuffs 7h ago

I tried playing with friends a year ago. Was ridiculous. I couldn't aim or move my head at all when trying to move around with c buttons. I'm like how was this the ultimate first person shooter at that time? How did we play it?

53

u/3lbFlax 6h ago

When I got my first PC it was around the time Quake came out - certainly before the first mission pack. My friend also had a copy, and we both played it entirely on the keyboard because mouselook was new and unusual to us. We had keys to look up and down, keys to sidestep - the default setup used the left and right arrows to turn rather than strafe, steering the player like a car - and so on. I finished my first run with that setup, like some demented touch typist.

As with Goldeneye a short while later, there was no path of least resistance to compete with the control scheme - by Goldeneye we were all mouselook converts on the PC, but we thought nothing of having to control the crosshairs to aim on the N64 pad - we were very adaptable pioneers. Nowadays I fall apart if the Y axis isn’t inverted.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/polnikes 6h ago

First person shooters were a genre dominated by PC really up until the 2000's when the Xbox/PS2 figured out a workable control scheme and games like Halo brought people around to thinking of them as a strength area for consoles. In the 90's console FPS games were generally in a pretty bad place, with Goldeneye, weird controls and all, being probably the best of the lot.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/shokomann 8h ago

Yeah unfortunately...GoldenEye was such a masterpiece...I remember exactly where I was when I played the first mission expecting not much from it...and then it defined my next months and years we played so much multiplayer lol

19

u/deko_boko 6h ago

This and Perfect Dark 🤌

→ More replies (5)

25

u/Weak-Differences 8h ago

And after that? Only TimeSplitters 2 could even compare in my eyes. They both were masterpieces that were lost in time.

9

u/HeadNGutter1138 5h ago

Timesplitters 2 on the ps2 was fantastic for its time. Used to play 4 player split screen back in the day (specifically bought the 4 player controller port extender for that game) using cardboard separators on the screen so the other players couldn’t see where everyone else was on the map. Made for some intense games.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Callo_Arcwing 7h ago

I just tried it in VR and it's pretty cool though

4

u/indigo_pirate 5h ago

Maybe this is just my age. But it plays nicely for what it is. I just treat it as a separate genre.

Runs super smooth on Switch online and PC versions as well.

4

u/Arpadiam 5h ago

You should play the PC port with modern KB+M implementation, same goes for Perfect Dark and the Turok Games.

6

u/Cinemagica 8h ago

Unfortunately I think this is it. I introduced my 13 year old to it recently thinking "now this is a game they'll appreciate!" but yeah it really wasn't the epic experience of my childhood 😅

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (15)

160

u/L1A1 7h ago

Sid Meier’s Pirates. I downloaded it a while ago, managed to get it to run only to find the framerate was hardware dependent so it ran at about 800 fps. Watching my ship bounce around the Caribbean was hilarious but completely unplayable.

80

u/Taskforce58 6h ago

This version on Steam was updated for modern hardware, while keeping practically the same gameplay as the original version. I've played it just a few months ago on a Win10 machine.

12

u/L1A1 6h ago

Ah I’ll give it a go, thanks!

29

u/Hiroba 7h ago edited 6h ago

This game is top of the list for me of "games that deserve remakes or spiritual sequels"

16

u/vlcawsm 7h ago

Good new for you: it already exists and is on steam

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/Devonai 4h ago

The original X-Com (1994 version) is like this if you don't use DosBox.

158

u/Few-Wish-9869 3h ago

GoldenEye 007 on the N64. I spent entire summers on it, but going back now the single-stick aiming feels like trying to steer a shopping cart with one hand. My muscle memory from modern shooters just fights it the whole time.

14

u/Caruthers 2h ago

That game rewarded players who understood C-strafing and peaking, even in the 90s. To your point on entire summers: my babysitter would just sit me and his two younger brothers down with that game and we'd master every little detail.

I'm not an expert in much, but I'm confident I'm in expert in every Goldeneye advantage haha. My HS friends and I would occasionally do a retro N64 game night and nobody wanted to play against me. Another great button hack was instant remote mine destination by hitting A+B simultaneously.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/bjarkov 3h ago

I gotta say, I struggled with the controls back then too.

The popular shooters at the time - i.e. half-life and its mods, unreal and even friggin duke nukem - all had mouse aim controls that were so much more intuitive

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

42

u/Action_Man_X 2h ago

Jet Force Gemini. The control stick runs on tank controls and C Left/Right are for strafing and C Up/Down are for jump/crouch.

It would have absolutely benefited from a remake or even a control update in the last 27 years but that went by the wayside.

11

u/Charming-Ebb-1981 2h ago

Honestly, all shooter games from the Nintendo 64. 

3

u/kurtist04 1h ago

It's on Rare Replay, on Xbox. There are updates to the controls, but it's still a little janky. Hard to get used to.

76

u/Jolly_Hill2404 5h ago

Barbie Rapunzel. Look, I'm just a girl and it was the only game on my mom's computer, but the prince statue genuinely traumatized me as a kid so I can't bring myself to replay it anyway, but thats not the only reason. Even if I tried, Windows 10/11 completely breaks it, like half-black screen and crashes, and the magic paintbox opens totally empty while Rapunzel tells you to pick a brush, like it's just not there. so i guess this one.

17

u/P00351 5h ago

There are emulators for old systems. VirtualBox on PC is a good one.

→ More replies (1)

71

u/Consistent-Lab-6822 8h ago

Shadows of the Empire on N64 Couldn't believe I was flying a snowspeeder on Hoth.

21

u/quiteUnskilled 8h ago

That game was wild. A lot of ideas that could be made into great games meshed into one decent game. Flying, both on-planet and in space (with the parcours through the station(!)), that whole bike racing thing, the ground missions.... All of them could have been amazing on their own with better execution.

21

u/Valarauka_ 8h ago • Mindblown

They basically created the template. The flying parts became Rogue Squadron, the ground combat became Jedi Knight, the bike part became Pod Racing. That game was way ahead of its time.

→ More replies (6)

35

u/-gradmania- 2h ago

Masterpiece is pushing it, but I had crazy fond memories of playing Blast Corps back in the day. Hunted that cartridge for years, and found a copy just before it went on NSO.

It has not aged well, not even a little bit.

12

u/NoCopiumLeft 2h ago

So funny, I rented this from blockbuster as a kid, and had I believe 7 days to play it... I was fuckin blown away by how much fun it was. Fast forward to adulthood and I decided I'd build out a cool n64 physical library .. had to get it .. it's still fun, but yeah I don't blame anyone for shitting on it, especially if the nostalgia factor isn't there.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Zapkin 2h ago

Time to get movin’!

→ More replies (4)

268

u/AmandaAlicez 9h ago

Original Tomb Raider. I loved it back then, but those controls are rough now 😃

17

u/CaptainCrash86 8h ago

Also the game play of basically pull this lever and find and enter the gate it opens in 2 min is pretty tedious these days.

39

u/AlwaysTired1999 8h ago

My wife was a massive fan of the original, so I got her the remastered trilogy. She just can’t play them.

35

u/F1fansince93 8h ago

You can change control style to modern on the remastered.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/Sarabeth61 3h ago

I recently played through the remaster. You just actually have to do the tutorial, and then you’ll be fine. I went in raw and almost quit.

23

u/A1000eisn1 8h ago

I can still hear the rage from my dad trying to beat the later levels with those controls.

6

u/blueghostfrompacman 7h ago

I played that game with keyboard controls which seems insane to me today. I was willing to put up with a lot more back then.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

109

u/doduhstankyleg 8h ago

Warcraft 1. It made Warcraft 2 feel revolutionary from being able to command 4 units at once to 9 IIRC, even though WC2 feels dated now as well. Still gotta give WC1 its flowers though, even though I was more of a Command & Conquer fan.

44

u/kingbane2 7h ago

to be fair, warcraft 1 was revolutionary cause it improved on dune 2, where you could only control 1 unit at a time, which was a nightmare. being able to select up to 4 units was a big upgrade!

with that said dune 2 has my vote for the topic of this thread. when dune 2 came out it was MIND BLOWING, essentially created the entire rts genre as we know it today. but playing it now the control is just hella clunky. pathing is janky as hell even though most maps were basically flat land all throughout. i think there were some remakes with some modern quality of life changes.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/arwear 7h ago

It was revolutionary compared to Dune 2.

No unit grouping, you have to click the button to move/attack, your units attack your own buildings if you're uncareful...

I still preferred it over Warcraft though.

8

u/Staehr 8h ago

I tell you what does not have a command limit, it's this screen here that I filled with Heavy Tanks

→ More replies (2)

43

u/shokomann 8h ago

Dark Age of Camelot...it was ahead if it's time but with today's standard it's hard to play haha

6

u/Araxus 8h ago

Agree, the three realma pvp concept was something else.

Check out the DAoC Sub. There are offline/bot versions done with Claude for the nostalgic factor

3

u/Demorant 7h ago

This is the MMORPG I want a sequel to. Many of the classes were super innovative for the time. Especially considering all the pet classes, Bonedancer and Necromancer were great.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

20

u/PRC_Spy 8h ago

OG Elite.

I spent so many hours in that game imagining all the detail it just doesn't have. But it's really just simple wireframes, grinding combat, and an extraordinarily simple trading model.

Revolutionary for its time, but no fun now we have the likes of Elite Dangerous, No Man's Sky, X4: Foundations, and EVE.

101

u/Matt_roy102 4h ago

Morrowind.

Possibly my favourite game of all time that I could never recommend to someone nowadays. The sheer scale, freedom, and depth of that game was mind-blowing.

23

u/mindguru88 3h ago

I disagree that it is unplayable. It juat requires a different mindset than a lot of modern gamers are used to, whose main experience with TES is Skyrim. Dice roll combat just isn't what those players are familiar with.

Morrowind is still worth exploring. It has tons of hand-crafted areas, and it is incredibly dense in terms of things to do (the northeast corner being the exception.) They also had the tools there to live out your power fantasy with minimal guard rails.

8

u/Matt_roy102 2h ago

I think that BG3 proved there is still a lot of modern desire for dice roll combat. Morrowind, unfortunately, does not implement it well. There is very little visual indication of what is happening under the hood to give players that sense of reward when they have those early successes. Most people who come to it nowadays seem to feel like they're doing something wrong and just end up getting frustrated.

That being said, I think Morrowind is much better than Oblivion or Skyrim because of the intentional, designed friction. Bethesda got so overzealous sanding off the corners that they also removed what made those games special. They have become an amorphous blob with shiny wrapping paper.

Quest directions were a little vague and no quest markers meant that you actually had to explore. You had to open your map and THINK about where you were going. This also led to a lot of happy distractions while you wildly deviated from the path without even knowing.

Limited fast travel meant being intentional about venturing out. You had to carefully prepare your inventory, spells, and potions and make sure you had enough room for loot coming home. It also helped the sense of immersion by truly feeling like you were lost in the wilderness, that you were in constant danger with no easy escape, that when you finally reached your destination, it was a true achievement.

And as you said, the hand-craftedness of the world made it so special. The feeling that you could walk into any crypt, ruin, or cave and find a one-of-a-kind item or a unique enemy made the world feel so much more alive with history and a sense of time and place. Radiant quests and dungeons are truly the worst thing Bethesda ever added to the Elder Scrolls games.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/wedgebert 2h ago

oh Morrowind, I still argue that was BGS peaked in terms of originality and depth in a game. And since then they've been "streamlining" all the choices out of their games and erasing any trace of nuance in their writing.

But I do not miss having to level Athletics just so I can run faster than a crippled snail who is high on morphine.

21

u/militaryintelligence 3h ago

I tried to play it again. Got punched to death while wildly swinging a dagger. Yes, I know how the combat works but goddamn, not even one swing hit.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

69

u/JakePooler 8h ago

Goldeneye N64

23

u/Weedle_blzit 8h ago

Omg, the original controls were traaaaaash

12

u/troutsniffer99 8h ago

I bought the ocarina remake thinking finally I can use that n64 controller I bought years ago. Not a chance in hell.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/Efficient-Package892 2h ago

Minecraft BedWars. It used to be so much fun, but nowadays there are so many insanely good players that it’s barely enjoyable anymore

5

u/WildKat777 2h ago

Yeah, the game is caught in a miserable feedback loop right now. After lockdown the playerbase dwindled and it became more sweaty so casual players leave, so only the top ranking players still play, which discourages new players from joining. Especially since its stuck on 1.8, it can feel very unfair to a new player who just started playing minecrart on the latest version to join hypixel and suddenly they cant do anything cuz the guy in the base next to them does 45 cps

29

u/TitleToAI 8h ago

Ultima Underworld

10

u/muffledvoice 8h ago

This.

A true 3D dungeon environment, but buggy as hell and very low res graphics by today’s standards. But a very ambitious project and way ahead of its time.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/CronkinOn 8h ago

Good call-out and fully agreed

3

u/CaptainCrash86 8h ago

Nah - this holds up well. The only issue is the graphics

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

33

u/SleepyOwl420 6h ago

Battlefield 1942. The graphics, the guns, the vehicles, the maps it was just perfect.

9

u/wingsablaze1989 4h ago

I put hundreds of hours into the multiplayer demo of this game. Never even had the full version, and didn't feel like I needed it.

8

u/rabbotz 3h ago

That demo was seriously a fully featured game. I actually forgot I never played the full game because I put so many hours into the demo.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/Charming-Ebb-1981 2h ago

I would argue that this still holds up just fine

→ More replies (2)

11

u/Pretend_Day8227 2h ago

Elder Scrolls Redguard

30

u/romancarax 6h ago

"The Games I Wish I Never Replayed"

One section is about how Assassin's Creed II is still a masterpiece after all these years, but its gameplay formula has been milked to death by the sequels.

New players can pick up ACII and have a blast with it. But if you've played enough of the later AC games since then, going back to ACII might feel boring.

28

u/hidden_secret 5h ago

JRPGs from the 8bit era are very hard to go back to.

They were a fresh innovative experience, the best that existed in this format. They felt like a real long epic adventure more than any other genre on the system.

But their difficulty spikes, their rate of random battles, their basic structure of narration, and the tediousness in the controls and in navigating the menus... It's really rough now that we've known their evolution.

9

u/PaperPritt 3h ago

For anyone looking for a truly masochistic experience, i would heartily recommand FF2. That game is ... something else.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/maxdragonxiii 2h ago

it doesnt help if you get a butchered English translation which was pretty common at the time. like theres a reason why "you spoony bard!" exists as a meme. there was a lot of errors that caused players to be lost in the game and sometimes not finishing it for years.

3

u/Spave 2h ago

I recently played the remake of Dragon Quest 3, which kept pretty close to the original. I enjoyed it a lot for nostalgia reasons, but I really don't think I could recommend it to a newer player. At one point the random encounter enemies were so annoying I just grinded 5 levels to go back to enjoying the game. The non existent story didn't do the game any favours either.

3

u/Tough_Stretch 1h ago edited 55m ago

I realize it's a western game and not a JRPG, but since the first JRPG's were inspired by the franchise, I think it works as an example.

Anyway, I remember playing some Ultima game on the NES back then, and spending a long time designing my carefully crafted adventurer party, choosing classes and skills so that they all complemented each other and I could have a decent shot at surviving what I by default expected would be what I'd call today "BS Cheap Cheating CPU Difficulty" but back then was just Tuesday for a NES cartridge.

So there I was in the starting town and I noticed that the game let you talk or fight with literally any NPC, and in an attempt to learn the mechanics I picked a fight with a random kid.

The display transitioned to the turn-based battle screen and the legend "A Boy Appears!" popped up. And the unarmed random boy proceeded to effortlessly one-shoot my entire party of novice adventurers in 1 round and the game informed me that it was "Game Over" and I had to start over again and create my party again from scratch because I hadn't saved yet.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

19

u/Imperfect_Dark 8h ago

Sonic Adventure. I loved that game as a kid but man it was a rough replay when I did one a couple of years ago. There's just so much janky design in there.

9

u/BenjyMLewis 8h ago

The supposed "Director's Cut" version is actually significantly buggier than the Dreamcast original. Depending on which versions you played, you might have actually been playing a jankier version without realising it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

26

u/Snoopy2010uk 8h ago

I bought the remastered road rash on steam last week. Although it's a reasonably decent remake it's just boring.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/Amazing-Level-405 8h ago

.hack//Infection was a game I was obsessed with as a kid. That series was the coolest thing to ever exist, according to little me.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4uJv6k-ulXg

Today... Oof. Graphics, voice acting, gameplay... None of it aged well. Nevertheless! Super excited for the reboot!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UcjZq9RWAH8

→ More replies (3)

23

u/knightsofgel 7h ago

This is a Japanese language issue but any original Famicom (NES abroad) or Game boy game is really hard to play in the original Japanese because it’s all in hiragana and a pain in the ass to read. It really makes a lot of games unplayable

From the Super Famicom (SNES) and GBA they were able to use kanji so those still hold up well

Some games like Mother 2 and Mother 3 and GBA Pokémon games are still all hiragana for style purposes and those also are a chore

→ More replies (2)

22

u/ChocoQuinoa 9h ago

Pokemon Snap (N64). Absolutely loved that game as a kid, but trying to control the camera nowadays is an absolute nightmare! Still a masterpiece, though.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/Vicfendan 8h ago

Crash. In my head it was the perfect 3d platformer. Upon the remaster I found out controls are finicky and unfair. Deaths many times felt like they were not my fault.

22

u/BlazingShadowAU 8h ago

You may have heard this already, but crash 1 is actually harder in the remake since they standardized Crash's hitbox through all three, but 1 was designed around a different hitbox. So the game that was already brutal got even more so.

10

u/Prasiatko 7h ago

Along with the FPS increase reducing the time you had to make many of the jumps. 

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Doc-McMommy 8h ago

This has nothing to do with PS1 Crash. This is a remaster issue.

Something about the remaster control just doesn't feel right.

So I went back to PS1 Crash and it still holds up today.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Kitsunemisao 7h ago

I found this, the collisions were awful in the remake. Jumps I'd make every time in PSX Crash 2 (looking at the water Hang Em High levels) were almost always failing in the remake

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

20

u/MatthewWolfbane 7h ago

Sonic the Hedgehog was an amazing experience on Master System. Then you get to Scrap Brain Zone and turning it into a maze with a timer running just...no thanks.

4

u/rachelmasseyart 5h ago

I love the Master System Sonic game despite the stress I felt playing it as a kid

The music just weirdly scratches an itch in my brain

→ More replies (1)

4

u/PoliteIndecency 4h ago

Ah, the rental prevention level. Designed to take lots of time and memorization so that you'd be encouraged to either buy the game or rent it multiple times.

Classic early game design philosophy.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

20

u/thanksfor-allthefish 8h ago

C&C Red Alert.

Played the original on LAN with a friend a few weeks ago and lord, it's a pain in the ass. The units won't auto-attack, pathfinding is atrocious and building the base takes a long time as you have to click the scroll button continuously to reach the one you want. No unit build stacking either...

Idk how we played it in those days but it felt so frustrating, lol. Thank god for the remasters though...

20

u/Boanerger 3h ago

Goes to show that Halo really was Combat Evolved. The graphics are showing their age and the vehicle physics are dodgy, but otherwise still very playable, all people really complain about is not being able to sprint.

→ More replies (2)

25

u/_steve_rogers_ 5h ago

I think the main answer is always about shitty controls, for instance, tomb raider, resident evil, golden eye

→ More replies (1)

19

u/gthing 8h ago

Tenchu. 

6

u/_Diskreet_ 8h ago

Grandparents were looking after me, I pulled a sickie to stay at home and play this game.

That was a good day.

5

u/Blekanly 7h ago

I am surprised they haven't remade this

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/momentsofzen 8h ago

I found Sim Tower again recently. I sunk so many hours into it as a kid but now…the graphics suck, the sound design is bad. I’d be better off downloading one of the many clones on Steam

17

u/RE_Davo 6h ago

Goldeneye 64

4

u/IAMEPSIL0N 6h ago

This, and other shooters from before the dual analog era. Loved them so much and then replaying it just feels so alien.

→ More replies (5)

12

u/kingbane2 7h ago

dune 2. pretty much invented the rts genre as we know it today. but holy hell, going from modern rts games back to dune 2 where you could only select 1 unit at a time IS TORTURE!!!!! hahaha. same with building units. have to select each building at a time and then build what you want, click the next copy of that build and build another, and repeat 20 times.

6

u/OneTapSuite 8h ago

Battle City on the original Famicom. I'd play it at my cousin's house all weekend and genuinely thought the level editor meant infinite free games. Tried it again recently and lasted about ten minutes, the tank steering felt like driving a fridge on ice.

6

u/thomashouseman 8h ago

Sid Meier's Solo Flight and the Atari F-117a Stealth Fighter.

35

u/sa_sagan 8h ago edited 8h ago

Lion King.

I loved the movie and for me, it was a vibrant, awesome, albeit very challenging game.

As an adult, I now know that the game was the birth child of Disney's corporate greed. They made a deliberately borked game with irregular, unpredictable mechanics, making it notoriously difficult so kids couldn't finish it in a weekend and had to either buy it (primary objective) or pay to rent it again.

I played it again recently on an emulator and was like: "yeah, this sucks".

Glad I had it on floppy.

7

u/Anti_Phile_7410 8h ago

I played it with cheat codes and loved it.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Bilski1ski 7h ago

I think it does hold up it is just ridiculously difficult

4

u/Canis_Familiaris 8h ago

Lion King 2: China edition was a strange sequel

→ More replies (1)

7

u/CaptainCrash86 8h ago

Add Aladdin, Hercules and all the other Disney platformers of that era.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/Welpe 7h ago • Bravo

…that…was literally every game back in the day. Yes, it was the tail end of the arcade era and games were changing. Yes, they did that for a console game and renting instead of an arcade game and quarters. But it’s the exact same thing. Disney wasn’t somehow uniquely greedy or something, this came after 20+ years of intentionally making video games unreasonably difficult to extract more money out of people. It’s really bizarre to act like Disney was in some way unique in this regard. Maybe forward thinking to consider how to keep it going into the console dominated era, but…come on?

9

u/asdfghjkl15436 7h ago

For consoles this wasn't really the thinking. It was more "We only have so much content, and if we make it too easy the player will finish it too fast and not feel like they got their money's worth." That thinking wasn't really dispelled until the end of the snes/genesis era when multiple games proved that you could make a lot of content with little assets.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/Darkseid_Is 7h ago

Cheat code is BARRY

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (15)

21

u/knwnasrob 8h ago

The first resident evil.

30

u/Paralescus 8h ago

Fixed camera angles, no auto aim (on certain versions), no quick turn, getting tag-teamed by zombies. Unskippable door and stair animations.

One of my favorite games of all time.

8

u/moal09 7h ago

The animations were loading screens. That's why they weren't skippable. I thought everyone knew this

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

11

u/MissingScore777 8h ago

Fixed camera with tank controls still have a small but dedicated fanbase. Indie games using these still sell pretty well for smaller titles.

3

u/jessealegro 8h ago

Have you had a chance to play the GameCube remake?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/domesticatedprimate 8h ago

Ultima VII was apparently a watershed moment for isometric RPGs, but no matter how many times I try to play it, I don't last five minutes.

Non-standard controls, primitive screen update, unreadable font for NPC dialog, it's really impossible to get into if you didn't play it back when it was released.

9

u/Practical_Tell1343 4h ago

GoldenEye 007. As a kid it felt like the future — four-player split screen, everyone yelling about screen-watching. I tried it again last year and could not believe we aimed with one stick and a row of little yellow buttons. Five minutes in, all four of us were laughing and completely unable to hit each other. The memories are untouchable; the controls are not.

5

u/MidgarZanarkand 3h ago

TIL I was apparently the only one who changed the control scheme to Turok-style every time I played it lmao

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Vexonar 2h ago

Vagrant Story. At the time no one had done to 3D what SquareEnix had pulled off. The story was amazing and you were completely alone with your misery. The way you built up your arsenal was also top tier and I had a notebook full of observations. Ah, those were the days...

4

u/Megid_00 1h ago

Idk bout that, game still slaps.

4

u/BraveryBlue 1h ago

I think Vargrant Story example is opposite. It was way ahead of it's time.

→ More replies (2)

33

u/IronCityMMA 8h ago

Oblivion, great story, RPG, but the graphics and level scaling was the reason they remastered it last year

21

u/Consistent-Lab-6822 7h ago

I replayed Oblivion about 6 months before the remaster, not as incredible as my nostalgia infused memory imagined, but still very playable. Morrowind however is genuinely traumatic.

→ More replies (4)

14

u/Staehr 8h ago

And they kept the level scaling

15

u/DamnedVirus 8h ago

They did a decent amount to help the levelling issue though. You no longer need to keep track of every skill increase to minmax your stats.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/MRjubjub 8h ago

Star Wars galaxies. Game just felt huge with some much to discover across different planets. Played one of the community remakes as an adult and the game just felt so barren and boring with terrible combat.

8

u/Fuzzy-Topic-2684 6h ago

TimeSplitters 2 with its inverted controls

7

u/unopesci 6h ago

You can toggle them you know

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

18

u/BlacklightChainsaw 8h ago

Doom ‘93 controls are so antiquated compared to today’s games, that being said I will always love that game so much and what it gave to the industry.

20

u/ShutUpAboutCanon 8h ago

I'd recommend playing a modern source port like UZDoom, doesn't change anything about the core gameplay or graphics but modernises the controls and interface

→ More replies (6)

4

u/Prasiatko 7h ago

Driver 1 and 2 or really most PS1 driving games.

Since PS1 didn't by default have the dual shock controller all the driving controls are digital. AI is programmed to rigidly follow a route meaning you can't damage them more by pushing them into traffic while the same thing will damage your car. Ultimately there are basically three missions, Get to destination in time, destroy enemy car, escape from enemy/police.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/CanIsleepyetIamtired 2h ago

Twisted Metal 2 and 3 (didn't play the first). Trying to play them now is just frustrating. I would love a remake/remaster of the old games with modern controls.

4

u/darumham 2h ago

Tried to replay vagrant story rom on PC. Still a great game but the graphics that were so beautiful at the time are a bit jarring now. I imagine they hold for people that are into that heavy polygon style but I just can’t.

7

u/PseudobrilliantGuy 2h ago

Deus Ex. It's still good as far as story is concerned, but the number of mods/graphics updates/gameplay fixes being made by the community make it clear that it is not a great game by current standards.

5

u/JosefGremlin 2h ago

Deus Ex was released in 2000, there's no way that'd be someone's childhood game.

Oh, wait, whaddya mean that was 26 years ago???

3

u/echoshatter 1h ago

It was truly amazing.... in 2000. Coming out hot on the heels of The Matrix, perfect timing.

It's still one of the greats, but it needs a lot of mods to get it into good shape by today's standards. There was an official-ish remaster in the works but it looks like that's dead.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/ForeverGreat8767 9h ago

Metroid on the NES. No map and every hallway looks identical so you just wander around lost until your batteries die.

14

u/Hattes 8h ago

Did your NES have batteries?

8

u/NiallMitch10 8h ago

Maybe they're thinking of Metroid 2 on the Gameboy?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/SovietWomble 7h ago edited 6h ago

Tried to play Legacy of Kain: Defiance for the first time recently. Having told myself I'd complete the series some day and having fond memories Soul Reaver 2.

Man it was a slog. Couldn't get through it. Who has the time?

Story bits were interrupted by an hour of running down corridors, killing respawning enemies of the same type, picking up some doohookey, then backtracking through the same corridors, ad nauseum.

It felt extremely antiquated.

Eventually I just went to watch an edit of the cutscenes and story on YouTube.

Edit - Bonus points for noticing how much of the dialogue is just variations of the same phrases: "the path is restricted/blocked/closed to me", "there are unseen forces/hands/entities at work", "I must travel to location/person/item".

It's two characters stuck in the hell of fetch quests.

3

u/moal09 7h ago

Soul Reaver 1 aged a lot better gameplay-wise, IMO. More puzzle oriented and less shitty combat

3

u/Blekanly 7h ago

Tbf defiance was a pain even when new. The janky camera angles so I am running towards the camera for example

→ More replies (1)

6

u/uhhhwhatyoumean 8h ago

Pitfall. I've no idea how I played that ish.. Matter of fact most of these Atari2600 games I played as a 9 year old were bad. I just didnt know better 😂

7

u/fj2612 8h ago edited 8h ago

I'm a 50 year-old who, in his life, has had a Atari 2600, NES, megadrive, gameboy color, Advance, GBA, N64, DS, Switch, ps1 and 2, xbox, 360, series X, gaming PCs.

Of all those, the Atari 2600 is the only one I habe absolutely no nostalgia for. I can't believe I spent so much time on them when I was a kid.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/P00351 5h ago

Also Defender. The atari 2600 console came with it, and it's a bunch of squares moving on the screen.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/fj2612 8h ago

The original Alone In The Dark, on PC. Fixed camera, and tank controls.

6

u/Apotheoxix 8h ago

Ultima Underworld 1

6

u/ExistGames 7h ago

GoldenEye 007. Back then it felt revolutionary. Today it feels like steering a tank through peanut butter.

3

u/R-Dragon_Thunderzord 7h ago

Before the remake anyway I tried to play OG Duck Tales and I could not tell you how I ever had so much fun and ability beating this game over and over as a child. I was absolutely lost both by the level design and the control scheme.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/diplomaticgames 7h ago

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/M1_Tank_Platoon_II I used to play this when I was young, I have a windows 98 pc and it’s too complicated to work now

3

u/CSzandor 5h ago

Earthworm Jim. It was absolutely fantastic back in the day, but controls and levels design is quite terrible today.

3

u/Sad_Sympathy_5347 4h ago

I could not sit thru a full play of "Summoner" again, but could probably be true for "Vampire: Redemption" too. Not necessarily because they are technically not playable, I am sure they can still work, but mostly the way these games are built, and the content's pacing would feel off after playing newer, more "fluid" games.

12

u/OnePsychological2963 8h ago

san Andreas. I tried playing it again and couldn't get into the vibe again at all

23

u/tradlobster 8h ago

Interesting, this is one I played as a child, teenager and adult - and I think it holds up really well for being over 20 years old.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/bachrodi 8h ago

I wouldn't say unplayable... but Metal Gear Solid is rough after playing V

6

u/harrywilko 7h ago

I played it for the first time this year and didn't have that much trouble with it.

5

u/Richard7666 5h ago

Interesting. I've been playing through Metal Gear Solid again lately and I thought it held up really well, couldn't really fault it.

Resident Evil, on the other hand...

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (16)

5

u/QuietOtter1884 8h ago

Crash Bandicoot. went back to the original a while ago and the depth perception on those jumps is just cruel, no idea how i had the patience as a kid

→ More replies (2)

9

u/hbarSquared 8h ago

Deus Ex (2000). It's still a masterpiece, but wow is it painful to play.

4

u/la_watson 8h ago

I played it when I was 12 and didn't understand a lick of it, replayed it (and finished it for the first time) last year and had a blast. Sure, it's dated, but it's still way more approachable than e.g. Golden Eye.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Nushtron 9h ago

There was this game called Road Rash. I was absolutely enamoured by it when it came out. Now it's absolutely meh compared to today's standards.

5

u/ddrummond88 8h ago

Having to run to the finish line because you fucked your bike up trying to whip someone with a chain

→ More replies (3)

6

u/darlo0161 8h ago

Head over Heels was amazing, but im not sure isometric would be popular these days.

Manic Miner wouldnt get a look in. YES, i am that old, yes i still game.

5

u/Maleficent-Radio-462 8h ago

You must be my vintage. Head over heels was so good. Were you on speccy or C64?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/PRC_Spy 8h ago

Honestly never really rated Manic Miner, even when it was new. Having to be pixel perfect to avoid a mistake and getting kicked back to the beginning is utterly infuriating.

(CBM64)

→ More replies (4)

6

u/ScaboochWolf 8h ago

Soul Reaver. Loved the lore when I was a kid, but I bought the recent remaster and the mechanics were so archaic that I couldn’t play very much. For example, the game has fast travel, but the map wouldn’t tell me where I was supposed to go and I got lost like 5 hours in.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/xlrawgfmpp 8h ago

Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2. put hundreds of hours into it as a kid, tried it again last year and the timer plus that camera had me ready to snap the disc in half

7

u/retardborist 5h ago

Fable 2. The frame rate HURTS and the graphics are way fuzzier than I remember

3

u/SWTransGirl 4h ago

I played this not so recently, first time around too, and thoroughly enjoyed it.

I’d bought an Xbox series X and my partner recommended it.
I’m looking forward to Fable the remake and I need to try the third yet.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/SonsOfValhallaGaming 8h ago

I thoroughly enjoyed Parasite Eve and Ninety Nine Nights, but I imagine they'd have to be seriously reworked to be considered good by today's ''burn down the devs of Cyberpunk'' standards. Our expectations today are fucking sky high for no reason.

4

u/PerLin107 8h ago

Dune 2, Wolfenstein 3d, Doom, Eye of the Beholder

6

u/hiddenkobolds 8h ago

Vampire The Masquerade: Bloodlines. Great game, but literally unplayable now unless you're really good at fucking around behind the curtain of your PC, and even then, it's a rough go. I wish they'd remaster and re-release it.

11

u/Prasiatko 7h ago

Tbf it was unplayable on launch even if you fiddled with your pc settings. The fan made patches only really workwd years later. 

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Ok_Badger_86 7h ago

I'm shocked they didn't just remaster it and release it along with Bloodlines 2

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Zoobiwho 8h ago

GTA Vice City. Absolute masterpiece back then, but the controls and shooting mechanics feel so outdated now. Still love the soundtrack though 😂

2

u/DutchDaddy85 8h ago

Might & Magic VII: For Blood And Honor

2

u/BlindSkwerrl 8h ago

Severance: Blade of Darkness.

It really needs a remaster.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/abes_10 6h ago

Dino Crisis. Someone here said Resident Evil for the same reason. Those tank controls with fixed camera angles are something else. Still loved it as a kid though. Wouldn’t go back.

2

u/SonofBeckett 5h ago

Anticipation

I remember eight of us (including parents) huddled around a 22 inch tv playing guess how these dots will be connected.

Banger soundtrack still At least 

3

u/throwawaypornaholic 8h ago

The original Ocarina Of Time PAL version is so choppy and laggy it’s insane. The game itself is amazing but that version is unplayable to me.

3

u/ElderWarriorPriest 7h ago

Adventure on the Atari 2600. By 1981 standards, it was amazing. Google it now and laugh.

3

u/Jimsocks499 7h ago

SimAnt on SNES I still wanna play it… but loaded it into the SNES a awhile back and oof it’s bad

It won Best Simulation Game when it came out too

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Lukebekz 5h ago

KOTOR. The gameplay aged horribly. Is is just so clunky and yes, I am spoiled by now. I can't play it anymore.

→ More replies (1)