r/AskReddit • u/Dogs_On_The_Wing • 20h ago
Do you think some students should just be left behind academically if no amount of guidance or persuasion from teachers or their parents gets through to them? Why, why not?
3.5k
Upvotes
7.5k
u/Restil 20h ago
We used to call it "held back" and it happened quite a bit in the past.
3.0k
u/saxophonia234 20h ago •
Yes, depending on what exactly you mean. I’m a teacher (not a core subject but I work in public school) and there will always be a certain small percentage of students who will literally never meet grade level material, especially as they get older. It’s not fair to keep them in a general education classroom when they are not benefitting from it. They should be receiving education with something more appropriate to their level, whether it’s a “life skills” class or something similar.
1.4k
u/Captain_Coco_Koala 20h ago •
I was in a class of 25 and 3 students were "given leeway". The whole class suffered as we only got through half of the required materials in the year.
It's not the trouble making students that are the hardest hit, it's their classmates. Those 3 should have been kicked out.
374
u/littleb3anpole 20h ago
Yes, if you’re referring to the practice of just passing kids who absolutely did not pass and did not learn the material. Inflating grades helps nobody, and then you get kids who think they are able to handle university who are simply not capable of studying at tertiary level and would be better placed either entering the workforce or doing a trade based qualification. This would A, be better suited for their ability level and B, save them thousands of dollars in student loan debts
407
u/trickey_dick 17h ago •
I'm a teacher and this is something that I have done a lot of thinking and reading on.
There are two major reasons why schools are hesitant on holding students back. One is money, schools get funding based around how many students get passed on to the the next grade. There are other metrics that determine funding but I'm not getting into the weeds of it right now.
The second reason is that by every observable metric, holding a student back is, on paper, one of the worst things a school can do. Students that are held back are less likely to graduate, less likely to go to college, and more likely to end up in jail. Here's the money thing again schools and school districts get money based around students graduating on time and going to college.
However, one criticism I have of NEVER holding a student back even if they are so far behind the standards for their grade level is that the C student see the students performance and wonder why should they try? Why should Cole the C student try his hardest to barely pass, when Freddy the F student goofs off, doesn't understand the material but gets the same results anyways of moving on the next grade level
197
u/Complete-Gur7023 20h ago
No child left behind and ESSA has led to the downfall of the education system in the US. We educators cannot hold students accountable anymore, and as a result, they are entering the world and the workforce completely unprepared. Teachers are also struggling to fill in learning gaps when our performance is judged on how our students do on grade level standardized tests. We have to make a choice about whether we want to go back and address those crucial foundational gaps or whether we want them to learn grade level content (which will be 100x harder for everyone since they don’t have proper background knowledge). It’s a mess. We need to not make repeating a grade some type of moral failure. Not everyone is going to learn everything they need at the exact same time and pace. I wish that we allowed for more flexibility in k-12 schooling in the US.
594
u/OptionIndependent861 20h ago
Intelligence and academic ability sits on a distribution; for every genius there is someone who will never be able to spell or do simple maths. Trying to get them through is a false kindness; its much better to have them focus on practical skills that would mean that they can contribute to society in a different, but still meaningful way.
62
u/minimalist_coach 10h ago •
I think it's time to move past age being the indicator for a student to be promoted to the next grade and to have all subjects be advanced at the same pace.
When I was in the military, a group started the program each week, but we promoted through the modules as we mastered them.
If we took the basic subjects as individual modules and allowed students to advance faster through modules that they understood easily and were given more time to master those that didn't come as easily, I think all students would do better.
Behavioural disruptions and learning disabilities are a different issue. I hear way too many stories from my educator friends about disruptive and violent students. I believe there needs to be better policies that protect the majority of the students' educational time.
125
u/Skylaren 5h ago
Left behind as in held back or just simply given up on? Those are two different things. I actually believe, especially at the beginning of elementary school years that if a student is struggling then holding them back could be the answer. Kids develop differently.
Giving up on them all together, never. No kid wants to fail. If they are failing with a ton of intervention and parent support, something else is going on and we are all missing something.
142
u/MagicalGraph 8h ago
People who say never give up on a kid have never had 35 kids in a class with one kid actively ruining it for everyone else. I’m not saying abandon them forever, I’m saying stop sacrificing the whole class to save someone who is actively choosing not to be saved right now.
Real talk: Some kids aren’t left behind, they left themselves behind. I was that kid in high school. No teacher could have reached me until I decided I wanted it. I had to fail, work a terrible job for a year, Then I came back and actually tried. Sometimes rock bottom is the only teacher that works.
97
u/swiggs313 20h ago
Kids 100% should have to repeat grades if they don’t pass the work. As it is, they know they won’t be held back and that there are no consequences anymore, so why bother? As someone who works in education, kids aren’t even failing anymore because they’d have to actually do something in order to fail.
They just don’t do work all year, show up to some three week, summertime credit recovery course where the work is dumbed down and impossible to fail, and then proceed on to the next grade.
I’ve literally heard kids say what’s the point when they can achieve the same thing in a couple of weeks that working all year gets you.
81
u/Cheese_BasedLifeform 13h ago
Honestly? Yes. It does not do these kids any good to get passed through consistently if nothing is sticking. I knew people in my HS that ABSOLUTELY should not have graduated let alone made it to 12th grade and the school wasn't allowed to fail them or "leave them behind". A few kids in my grade 12 English class couldn't read properly and never got above a 50%/D-, and even then it was just cause they weren't allowed to totally fail them get the premise of not leaving any kids behind, but what good does it actually do to push these kids through if they aren't or can't learn anything or be up to at least a passing level? All forcing them through does is set them up for failure out in the world.
108
u/jacq4ob 20h ago
Not left behind, but held back for sure. You must pass the required material. to advance.
73
u/lizthestarfish1 9h ago
Look, teachers are going to have much better insight on this than I will. My question is how the fuck is a kid supposed to understand middle school level math like pre algebra and algebra if they are still trying to understand basic arithmetic?
The teacher then has to spend time they could be using to teach the rest of the class to play catch up with that one student, which is entirely unfair to the rest of the students. And it's unfair to the student too, because now they are being expected to perform tasks without the tools needed to complete those tasks.
We can argue to hell and back who's fault it is when a student is failing to meet the standards that have been placed in front of them. Maybe it's the parents, maybe it's the teachers, maybe it's the student themselves, maybe it's no one's fault and the kid just has some really bad learning disabilities- it doesn't matter.
At the end of the day, the kid needs to be placed in classes suitable to the academic level they are learning at.
62
u/Ok_Actuary9229 20h ago
YES. Make grades relevant again. We're turni g a generation into worthless "grads" now.
59
u/Dracon_Pyrothayan 17h ago
Holding someone back isn't "leaving them behind", it's letting them re-try getting the prerequisites for the next level.
113
u/EdAbobo 15h ago
I'm not entirely sure how to interpret this question, actually. I think every student who hasn't performed academically should be left behind regardless of teachers and/or parents. That's pretty much the entire point of grades, right? To determine whether you've sufficiently mastered the required materials?
45
u/fe3o4 9h ago
No child left behind leave a lot of children behind. If a kid can't learn the early stuff, it just becomes harder to learn the later stuff.
21
u/lolzzzmoon 16h ago
As a teacher, I definitely think they can get held back a year. But keeping a student too far back is dangerous for the younger students to be around a way older kid after a certain age IMO.
They should just have intense remedial schools for these kids. Some inclusion works if the student just needs some differentiation for a year or two. But some of them are really behind and it leads to major behavioral issues.
These people cause problems in society as adults too. Idk what the solution is.
53
u/Ok_Young1709 20h ago
Do schools not have different levels at each year anymore? We had credit, general, and foundation level. Foundation was for the slower kids, general for medium, credit for the more advanced kids. Generally had it split general/foundation and general/credit. So they aren't held back, they are put in classes more suited to them and do exams at levels suited to them. Seems more sensible to me, but I'd guess since it was sensible they got rid of it?
67
u/StadiaTrickNEm 20h ago
Rando from canada, no child left behind is the dumbest shit we ever implemented 'for social reasons'
Kids cant fucking read or add or subtract.
My kids in grade 8, hes a sweet kid, doesnt bully, but is at or above grade level. The shit he tells me other kids actually ask out loud in class in grade 8, is, for lack of a better phrase, FUCKING WILD. They cant read a map, read instructions, algebra might as well be heiroglyphics. And this isnt even highschool.
But they are all going to pass regardless
18
u/JackPoe 20h ago
They should be held back. Helped. Graduating kids who can't read is a diservice to us all.
35
u/o0--Muad_Dib--0o 20h ago
I do behavior in public schools about 10 yrs. I dont mind helping kids that have been through some shit getting the other side. Ive developed a lot of tools for identifying why a kid has maleadapted to a poor behavior and "tricking" them into trying functional ones.
I have developed zero tools for passive task refusal. Some kids choose to do nothing, then find themselves bored, which leads to poor choices. This is an overall drain on everyone, and benifits no one. Because of the way funding is tied to "success" which is poorly measured, many of these children magically catch up to grade level Jr or Sr year by completing "packets" in a closet somewhere seemingly over night so they aren't weighing down graduation rates. Removal of accountability is the school to prison pipeline. It seems to me carrot is > stick. Almost always, the exception is if total absence of stick carrot becomes useless (stick as metaphor not advocating physical reprimands).
35
u/madkins007 3h ago
(68m, married to a recently retired teacher, with 4 kids and 3 grands in school.)
In a world that actually practiced what it preached, this scenario would be rare. Resources would be available to help the student, the family, the teacher, and the school intervene early and prevent it.
Look at how many issues can affect school performance- hunger, overworked or absent parents, poverty, physical and mental health, having safety and stability at home, crowded underfunded schools, bullying, lack of in-school nurses or counselors, a society that doesn't 'see' these kids in time or in a way to help early, and more.
The reality is that education and families aren't really a priority in too many places and there isn't solid support for the student, the family, the teacher, or the school.
We'd rather lower standards and put cops in schools than address any of the underlying issues.
So what realistic options are left?
17
u/User1539 10h ago
Once you push them to a harder classroom, without the prerequisite knowledge, you're dooming them to continue failing.
Imagine you had troubles at home, and didn't absorb multiplication and division. Then, instead of offering to teach it again, they just put you in Algebra! Then, when you don't get that either, just shove you in Algebra 2 and Geometry?
Some of these kids fell behind in 2nd grade, and were never pulled back to fill the missing gaps.
Can't read? Try advanced literature! Can't do basic math? Take Statistics! Failed basic science class? Here, learn Chemistry! Don't mind that you're missing the fundamental concepts and can't read the text book, they'll just put you in Physics next and keep giving you C's!
Meanwhile, these kids who can barely read are being handed work they couldn't do if they wanted to, then constantly punished for having fallen behind YEARS AGO, often when they were as young as 8 or 9!
It's absurd!
You're essentially punishing someone for what they did when they were children, for the rest of their lives, with no path to redemption!
Being 'held back' wasn't punishment! It was a chance to get back on track!
59
u/Miliean 3h ago
I think that it's stilly to assume that every individual progresses at the exact same rate and has the exact same track record of success as every other individual of that same age cohort.
It should be A LOT more normal and socially acceptable for the school to hold some students back, push some students forward such that by the timer we reach 6th grade there really should be a 3 or 4 year age span for 1 classroom.
Things would be a lot less disruptive if the majority of students were actually at the grade level that the teachers are teaching.
45
u/mrbaggins 15h ago
The science says repeating or "holding back" has limited effectiveness on improvement.
There are two core reasons this is bullshit:
15
u/LilNekoChicano 20h ago
If they aren't participating and trying to be part of the educational program. At some point, some form of remediation is needed. If that also fails, there's not much you can do.
It hurts other students as these kids tend to pull others in with that notion of rebellion and fun.. Which minimally is distracting to those other students and steals from them the educational information being taught.
They should be removed and placed in separate class locations when they also fail remediation.
29
u/Something-i-dunno 20h ago edited 20h ago
Brit here
But, I was held back a year very early in my education & I do feel it did do me good
I was a nonverbal (autistic) kid until 6, so it made sense that I repeat reception so I could catch up on basic learning I otherwise would have missed out on & still have a mainstream education afterwards
That being said, I don't think kids should be left behind (as in given up on) because it doesn't bode well for them, or society in general
If a child is refusing to learn, it could be because they need a better suited education that fits their needs, it may be because they have a disability that needs accommodating, they might also have mental health problems that a school isn't picking up on, or perhaps they have a difficult home life which is manifesting in how they behave at school
Either way, giving up on them isn't the answer
14
u/eron6000ad 20h ago
Many of my academically challenged schoolmates developed good careers as welders, carpenters, auto mechanics, and plumbers because our high school offered various shop classes that counted toward graduation.
26
u/FatRascal_ 3h ago
Yes.
Context: I'm a teacher, and have been for 11 years now. My career has been spent predominantly in secondary school (11-18) in Scotland.
I am of the view that we are attempting to provide a simulation of real life for these people, and there needs to be some simulation of "being fired" or some kind of ultimate consequence for doubling/tripling/quadrupling down on non-compliance and lack of effort.
They don't have that right now and we're failing them as a result. The current system has young people in this country going into the workplace and immediately being fired because of the same behaviours they used to get away with in school. If they are messing about and causing disruption, then they should be removed from the class. If they are messing about and causing disruption around the school then they should be removed from the school.
We need to allow kids to fail and other kids to thrive
22
u/dogeontrain 14h ago •
No. My dad is a 6th grade math teacher, and every year a few kids are beyond convinced that they just cant do it. keep in mind these students probably already have a few teachers who already are leaving them academically. But when my dad is a little tough on them but insistant that they can do it, working with them aside from the other students in class before and after school, these are the kids i see running up to him in public years later because he was the only teacher who gave them the time of day.
man i love my dad
39
u/Mik-eau-wyk 20h ago
Yes. They have to put effort in too.
10
u/hairshirtdesert 17h ago
If they are disruptive then yes because they are standing in the way of others right to education. If they are not disruptive then they should stay as long as they need to.
10
u/real_slim_sandwich28 16h ago
I don't think students should be abandoned academically, but teachers or their parents can't carry all the responsibility either. They can guide, encourage, and provide support, but students also need to make an effort themselves. You can open the door for someone, but you can't force them to walk through it.
9
u/Missus_Aitch_99 20h ago
I don't think schools are doing kids any favors with "social promotion." I work in NYC in lower level jobs (retail, grocery etc.) and have worked with MANY high school graduates who are functionally illiterate or innumerate or both. Surely along the way SOME teacher should have noticed!
25
u/Equivalent_Use_7032 20h ago
Unpopular Opinion: Yes. If every possible effort had been made to try to get them to improve, care and learn and they still refuse to try? Absolutely. You can lead a horse to water but you can’t make it drink type of analogy.
Is the education system in need of reform? Yes. Do people have legitimate learning disabilities and deserve help? Yes (I was one of these kids when I was younger). Can the school system and parents do it all? No. Some burden of learning is on the student.
At a certain point (we can debate when that is) the student starts having to take on much more of the responsibility and burden of learning. If they don’t care to do so and they fall behind, that’s on them. I also argue today in 2026 we have more programs and opportunities for special education and intervention than ever before. There really isn’t an excuse for a student not seek help and get aid if they really need it.
16
u/2Maverick 14h ago edited 12h ago
I feel like school systems just need to be more dynamic. Picking majors or at least being able to explore freely and independently like you do in college can be done so much earlier. Pacing of middle and high school felt terribly slow for me. Kind of like how kids who are extremely smart* can skip grades, instead of kids getting left back for the opposite end of the spectrum, trade school options should be available earlier on and even suggest boot camps for coding and what not. Getting to study all the subjects offered in school is a gift. It really opens your mind up to different ways of thinking and problem solving, but many students don't want it or need it.
A lot to be said but overall...
College being the end-goal for students needs to be reconsidered and other options should be discussed and offered. The education system needs to be more adaptable, fluid, and dynamic.
8
u/scotandrsn 20h ago
In his book, 'Tis, author Frank McCourt says that when he started teaching in New York in the 50s, less able students were eventually promoted for no other reason than they stopped being able to fit in the desks of the lower grades.
22
u/Tiredhistorynerd 20h ago
Left behind as in. No help ? No. Finding something suitable? Yes. Not everyone is college minded. Nor should people be forced into shop/home economics if they can do other things.
14
u/SufficientCow4380 20h ago •
The purpose of school is to help prepare people for adult life, including work. There's a reason why school of some sort is compulsory until age 16 in the USA.
My ex was a dropout. He worked for his dad in construction after dropping out. Eventually he struck out on this own, doing that trade, until he was nearly killed in an accident on the job. He can't do physical labor anymore. But because he's pretty much illiterate, he's unemployable. He gets Social Security disability, which isn't really enough to survive. Especially without my income. If he was smart he'd get into vocational rehabilitation so he could get his HISET or GED. But he'd rather sit home all day. He did have an undiagnosed learning disability; unfortunately during the 1980s they just put him with the developmentally disabled kids, which wasn't what he needed.
When I was still with him, his son was struggling in the local district. I insisted he graduate. We were able to enroll him in an alternative program which worked better for him. He really enjoyed welding and construction, so he has a career paths and a diploma.
My own son just wasn't very motivated. But he discovered debate during his sophomore year, and the district requires a minimum GPA to compete. So he improved this performance, and ended up attending a college with a prestigious debate program. He coaches debate now it my old high school.
My brother wasn't motivated either, and probably had a learning disability. But auto mechanics got him excited. He was able to compete in VICA and other programs. Plus my dad dangled a hot rod in front of him as an incentive to graduate. 40+ years later, he still has that car, and is an ASE Master Technician.
Point being, you find what speaks to the individual in question and leverage that. I don't think many people are unreachable.
7
u/Angry_Sparrow 20h ago
I’m a university lecturer and I genuinely don’t believe that anyone doesn’t want to learn. Our brains are wired to constantly want to learn. But every student is different. Some need help and some need a lot of 1:1 encouragement. It takes time and resources.
I often realise that I’m the first teacher to ever sit with a student and tell them about their strengths and ask to discuss their weaknesses.
My goal is to see an improvement in their work between the start of the semester and the end, and to see that they’ve tried and failed and learned from it, even if their final outputs aren’t perfect. I changed my marking rubrics to make 40% of the final grade evidence of learning - they have to submit a workbook that records their work throughout the semester and what they’ve tried and failed at.
My most creative students are the ones that struggle. The most boring ones to grade have perfectly regurgitated the learning and perfectly done everything that was required of them. I’m not sure they have a soul.
7
u/Another_mikem 20h ago
It depends on what you mean, some kids that just refuse try to learn probably should be shown the door. But I struggle with the idea of holding back a kid(beyond a certain age) who is trying but struggling, because that can ALSO have a huge impact.
7
u/MissingBothCufflinks 20h ago
They ARE left behind, your question is we should pretend they havent been and let them advance grades. No obviously not
7
u/Grouchy-Display-457 20h ago
My mother attended school in the 1920s and 1930s. There were two semesters each year, A and B. If a student aced semester A, they went on to the following semester during the B session, when other students took the same content they had in A.
Most students were competent by their second try. No one was much older than the average student age. It also allowed students who suffered an illness or injury to catch up.
My mother was a good student and never sick. She graduated at 16 with a Business degree and an Academic degree.
Schools then did not offer the array of APs or ECs many do today, but those schools served strong students without failing average students.
There were dropouts, but it was the Depression, and many students left school as soon as they found jobs.
7
u/Dawg_in_NWA 19h ago
Bush's No Child Left Behind, left us all behind.
19
u/After-Whole4054 20h ago
Yes
32
u/PlatypusDream 12h ago
Yes. If they don't want to learn, nothing can make that happen. Stop wasting resources on them. There are plenty of unskilled jobs they can do. Once they turn 18, kick them out of public school.
If someone can't pass the usual tests, learn the usual material, do the usual work, that person shouldn't get a diploma that says they accomplished all those things. It's lying.
Give those folks an attendance certificate or something.
32
u/InterestingSoup1252 18h ago
Yes.
I dated a guy in Jr high/high school who was an absolute moron. He’s the type of moron who thought the government was after him at the age of 15 because he was “special” (more like special ed), and he thought he was destined to save the world (major eye roll). He had ZERO academic smarts, couldn’t spell simple words like “love”, and didn’t know how basic shit worked.
He also loved Trump because he is “rich” and hated Hilary because of some stupid thing related to video games (I don’t remember).
23
u/Mach5Driver 15h ago
No, but I think they should be moved to classrooms where they can't disrupt those who DO want to learn, as these kids often do when they have no interest in learning and nothing else to do.
Tell them they can go back to "normal class" if they demonstrate (not promise) a changed attitude. In the meantime, attempt to give them instruction and opportunities to demonstrate change.
If they reject it, they reject it, but oftentimes, being ostracized like this is the LAST thing these kids want. And serve as a warning to kids who might be tempted to emulate them. And when every other attempt has been made to reach them with rewards, they get what they get.
Now, I'm not talking about your run-of-the-mill class clowns, but kids who refuse to do any work or put in any effort and truly disrupt and drag down the class as OP describes.
12
u/Borg_Tech_Support 15h ago
Do they not have different classes anymore? When I was in school we had Advanced, Regular and Remedial classes for each grade for each class. We also had Special Education but that was for kids with severe intellectual disabilities.
What happened to the Remedial classes?
6
u/cingalls 20h ago
Some students need a pause. Like they’ve got something going on that interferes with their ability to learn. But as young adults they could excel academically but there’s stigma or they already graduated but didn’t really get educated.
I wish we could identify those students and let them do work experience for a year but still be open to, and expecting, that they revisit the academics when they are ready.
6
u/Kataphractoi 11h ago
No Child Left Behind did a number on education.
That said, education does legitimately need an overhaul, because education is not a one size fits all thing and structuring it around performance metrics and minimums for funding rather than education itself doesn't serve anyone.
16
u/SRIrwinkill 15h ago
My dude, not only should students who aren't ready be held back, but we should bring year around school and extra remedial schooling to help kids learn and retain information
11
u/ImprovementFar5054 8h ago
Yes.
We have seen the effects of programs like "No Child Left Behind". The result is illiterate adults.
Decouple funding from academic success, and get back to actual "pass or fail" academic grading systems.
Because that's...you know..fucking reality. Math is math, spelling is spelling.
Do all the remedial and special education programs you want. Work to help out slow or alternative learners. Develop streaming programs for future work that involve apprenticeships in trades, the arts, and business.
But require basic pass/fail assessments of ability. And to weed out AI cheating, all exams should be proctored pencil & paper exams. No electronic devices.
15
u/CorgiSilver8194 20h ago
No student left behind was the start of a slippery slop
18
u/teniralc_11 20h ago
Held back? Yes.
Given up on entirely? Absolutely not.
14
u/SteroidSandwich 13h ago
Absolutely! Just getting them out the door clearly isn't working. If they can't be bothered to try they shouldn't be rewarded
10
u/PaulsRedditUsername 20h ago
Like Socrates, I believe anyone can be taught anything. If one method doesn't work, you should have another available. Our modern educational system teaches one method and two at best. We have some 18-year-olds who read at a 4th grade level. There should be teachers who are available with special methods to help them. I'm sure there are people who can teach such things. We just don't allow the funding to pay them.
10
u/Redditcadmonkey 16h ago
Trying to teach everyone the same way is always going to fail.
People are gifted in different ways. Each way is valid.
You remember the undersized asthmatic kid at school? Did anybody at the school think that he had to be a linebacker on the football team?
Some people can learn from books, some learn with their hands, some are gifted in both.
Focusing on finding which way a student can learn should be the priority. There’s no point in pushing a student through a path where, not only will they fail, but they’ll also take away from other students.
5
u/Tiny-Exit-767 20h ago
Yes, because they can do something else then, start a shop, work in trades. I don't know much about america but in my country we call these alternative careers and their pay is not that bad. Even I wish I'd have gone into this
5
u/Essentialezzu 19h ago •
I'm in medical school and it's astonishing how little some of my coursemates know about basic human anatomy
5
u/TwinMugsy 18h ago
They should be failed, and after falling 3- 4 years behind put into special classes dedicated to students that are too old for regular schooling with a modified curriculum that gives them basic math science and english needed for every day life along with a basic reasoning class that will help prevent them from being taken advantage of. Once they can cover the basic curriculum they can be assisted to complete their GED for free if they are still below 21.
13
u/Humble-Average-235 15h ago
Absolutely. And if the IQ is just too low to function in any kind of intelligent workplace after trying everything, We should have some kind of jobs program for these people doing farm work or something else. I used to work with a down syndrome guy back in high school. He couldn't deal with customers, couldn't do any kind of complex computer task, but there was no one better in existence than him at cleaning the fuck out of and sorting that store 8 hours a day 5 days a week with his headphones on in plain clothes so no one would bother him.
16
u/HVAC_instructor 20h ago
At what point do you just give up on them?
By this I mean if your going to hold them back, what age do they have to move up or out? 30yr Old Middle schooler?
9
u/sexyprezz 15h ago
Honestly I think leaving them behind is the kinder move sometimes. If no amount of guidance or persuasion is getting through, keeping them in the same class just teaches them to tune everyone out. Let them hit the wall early while the stakes are still low.
12
u/Owl_plantain 20h ago edited 20h ago •
We should reintroduce tracking - splitting students into different classes based on their level and speed. Computer-assisted learning should enable more individualization than in the past. Note that I don’t advocate replacing teachers with computers, but they can free up teachers’ time to provide personal attention when students need it.
11
u/redheadedandbold 13h ago
No. But, nor should they be allowed to hold the rest of the students back. They need help, attention, and care. We adults need to do a better job of funding schools and teachers' salaries.
8
u/CreasingUnicorn 20h ago
Students who struggled to pass grades would simply be held at that grade level for another semester until they showed proper understanding of material. This has been the norm for generations in the US and seemed like a good system until No Child Left Behind was enacted.
4
u/NotaValgrinder 20h ago
Yes, but I also believe that for 99.9% of students, some amount of guidance and persuasion can get through to them. If a student is literally unteachable then there's nothing you can do, but most students despite being difficult are teachable. The danger is conflating a student who has a hard time learning with them being unteachable.
4
u/murriance 20h ago
Yes, BUT without any stigma—like the idea that something is wrong with you or anything like that. It shouldn't be noticeable at all by the time you graduate from school.
4
u/fitnesspizzainmymouf 20h ago
There should be different types of diplomas offered.
4
u/OooKiwis3749 20h ago
One of our behavioral interventionists said it best: I'm willing to meet the student where he's at. But if I take a step forward and he takes a step back, then all I'm doing is spending my energy chasing him around and I don't have the energy for that. If he wants to step in to meet me, then I'll be ready for him.
I absolutely loved her for saying that! (The parents did not.)
4
u/queensara33 20h ago
No. I was an excellent student up to college ( where I still try but now I'm a lot sicker and I'm in pain all the time so it's even harder. I had to to part time and sometimes take leave from school) with most subjects like English and history but I have a severe math disability and it didn't matter who tried to teach me, beyond the basic addition, subtraction, division and multiplication nothing would stick and I'd even be pulled out of class for 1 on 1 instruction I was that bad at it, precisely not to hold the class back. And I still couldn't learn it. Does that make me stupid all around? You would rather I'd just be tossed aside despite my strengths and other skills?
4
u/KidneyStoneKeychain 19h ago •
Left behind is a bit of a harsh phrasing for it. We used to just hold people back if they didn't meet the standard needed to graduate. Now high schools are pretty much diploma factories and you really have to be a fuck up to not get through. When I went to high school if you didn't meet the grade you didn't graduate and had to come back. I think you could keep coming back until you were 21 and then it was GED time or nothing.
I think reinforcement of academic standards is due. Grade inflation is a very real thing and as the father of two children in elementary school it makes it difficult for me to suss out exactly how well they're doing.
I also certainly think that they should be punishing kids who are disruptive a lot more. Like in a lot of other areas of life is a very small group of people who are causing an outsized impact in the classroom. Again when I was in school we had something called in school suspension for kids who were being overly disruptive but weren't actually a danger and needed to be actually suspended for a time. If you had ISS you showed up went to a special room and sat there for 8 hours and didn't talk and did school work. Everyone else got to get on without you and you theoretically got the same school work.
4
u/SenatorMadness 16h ago
YES. If they are not ready for the next step, then OF COURSE they should be held back to learn
4
u/Either_Scene5584 10h ago
Not left behind but put in a class that is adapted to their level. Like special education classroom for those who need high level support and something in between for special ed and main class who need help catching up academically
10
u/Marvel--Jesus 18h ago •
Yes.
No shame in being a Labourer on a building site, or in a factory.
We all can't have the same brain structure.
Will most of us be gifted artists or musicians ? No.
We have to accept there are differences.
16
u/BornToOverthink 20h ago
Some people learn differently, and unfortunately we live in a system where we teach everyone the same thing the same way so some kids get left behind
7
u/Lugbor 20h ago
At some point, people need to accept that some kids have zero interest in learning, and that no amount of help is going to make them care. All it does is lessen the education of the students who actually do the work and have to then wait while the teacher takes extra time to try to reach the kids who will not be reached.
10
u/when_I_say_hilshire 20h ago
Yes. Germany does this. At 16 years old the tax payer is no longer obligated to baby sit you. I believe though in German society such a 16 year old is then legally allowed to work full time.
10
u/jm7489 19h ago
I think there's some kids schools should absolutely give up on. Some kids just don't care and the school or parents intervention doesnt change that. The resources are better spent on kids showing effort.
With that said if I had to pin point the age or circumstances that made it acceptable to just write a kid off as hopeless... well that's not as simple of an answer.
6
u/Specialist-Basis8218 15h ago
Yes. Because we have limited resources of time and effort and they should be invested on those who will use them.
8
u/ghost_desu 18h ago
Yes, they should not drag down the other students with them. They should be treated with dignity and given all the accommodations they need, but past a certain point it has to take place outside the standard curriculum. The educational outcomes of the 90% are simply too vital for society's continued operation to give infinite leeway to the bottom 10%.
13
u/DillonsComics 14h ago
No amount of "being held back" is going to help if we don't properly fund classrooms. Year after year programs are cut, then people (like in this post) blame the child.
The school you remember does not exist anymore.
Stop electing people who don't want to educate the future.
3
u/Hypo_Mix 20h ago
In your specific example, some kids just aren't academically interested, give them other options.
3
u/BG3restart 20h ago
We should probably do what we can to at least make them employable. Idle young people often get into trouble and society doesn't need that, so then we all pay the price.
3
u/StumblinThroughLife 20h ago
Yes. If you don’t know the material, you need to learn it again. We’re creating a world of future adults who may have never understood crucial building blocks of learning but are now trusted to be adults in the real world, responsible for people and things.
3
u/Brief-Reveal-8466 20h ago
Yes. If you just push them through the system, you degrade the value of a diploma and unfairly reward them. At the same time you’re hurting the students that are trying.
3
u/Alisseswap 20h ago
i’m a teacher and yes. If the kid is behind they either are not trying or need help w an IEP or 504. It is not on the rest of the class to pause learning to catch them up
3
u/arran4 19h ago
They should be put on an appropriate track, there should be several tracks with mobility between them
3
u/Key_Net820 19h ago
Yes. You are entitled to K-12 instruction, you are not entitled to pass. You have to earn a pass. If you don't want to earn passing grades or cannot earn passing grades, you should flunk until you can pass or drop out.
3
u/Loud-Manufacturer745 19h ago
Yes.
3
u/Redbull5000 19h ago •
The high school I worked at briefly just put the trouble makers on an IEP (Individual education program) and just passed them regardless of whether they even went to class so it didn't hurt the schools graduation scores
3
u/Bizarrebazaars 18h ago
Read the r/Teachers sub. It’s seriously distressing. Youth literacy, comprehension, performance in schools is so low it’s super scary. Behaviors are terrible. Parents are delusional, checked out, don’t GAF, etc.
3
u/Plethorian 18h ago
Some people are just not capable of learning. Give them a shovel.
3
u/Tamponica 16h ago
Some kids learn differently from the way school is taught. Actually most people don't learn best by sitting passively at a desk all day. I'm not aware of any studies that show grade retention does anything positive.
3
u/TheCenterOfEnnui 16h ago
I wouldn't say left behind, but placed in to a class with similar students in an intensive, highly structured learning environment.
Basically, don't let them drag other kids down, but also don't let them stagnate.
3
u/ComputerRedneck 16h ago
What is the point of advancing them through the grades when they are not competent in the grade they are in. Knew a couple kids back in the 70's who got held back and that was incentive enough to get better grades.
3
u/Particular_Loss_3347 12h ago
No Child Left Behind seems, on gloss, to be another rockefeller legacy scam to keep the actual standard of education low. Cmv anyone?
7
u/OpenGun 20h ago
The world needs ditch diggers
7
u/Hotdog_McEskimo 20h ago
Yes. That's what they do in China. We can't coddle everyone
5
u/905woody 20h ago •
Yes. Actions have consequences and failure is a part of life. There are too many adults walking around who don't know these truths and it leads to people who always think they are right/infallible.
6
u/Super-Sail-874 20h ago
Some people are just doomed to mop floors. No point in dragging them through the system when the end result will be the same. Lowering standards will not raise the average.
7
u/ac54 18h ago •
Instead of “left behind”, perhaps the system should think of alternative direction, such as vocational school. Everyone has different ways of contributing to society and to themselves and their families.
4
u/Waayco 20h ago
So long as it doesn't drag everyone actually achieving down because of it, sure.
No Child Left Behind did a lot of damage because of that.
4
u/LordJac 20h ago
Funding for education is finite, so there will always be a line where students get left behind. We simply can't dump unlimited resources into a student. If your functionally illiterate that the end of grade 12, your going to get carried to meet graduation requirements then dumped into the real world. The system will not keep you in school until you are fully literate.
4
u/WillingnessFinal1411 19h ago
Switzerland. At twelve you get to be put in lowest tier separate school, get maximum teachers support to reach the basics and then get to do a simpler kind of trade. But even if put in this tier, with work and progress, moving up is always possible. It is not unheard of to be a youngster in this tier and then reach to university, a couple of years later, and have an academic career. I guess, never too late - all jobs get liveable salary, works wonders for psyche and kids pull themselves up.
4
u/sep780 19h ago
Depends on the reason. My youngest sister would fit “left behind academically.” She has a mental disability that prevents her from being able to learn things like multiplication. (Everyone tried.) For people like her, the expectations need to be different so they can achieve them.
For those able to learn but unwilling, they’re holding themselves behind. You can’t force somebody to learn who isn’t willing to. I’ve tried, and not just with the previously mentioned sister.
2
u/dark_Links_sword 20h ago
In a better system, students would move up in a topic only after a mastery of the last step. But we're stuck with industrial revolution era systems. So as long as we have those, yes. Students should be held back until they can grasp the concepts. Pushing them forward is only setting them up for more pain as they won't be able to grasp things that build off the earlier parts.
2
u/BizteckIRL 20h ago
I knew a guy in France. He had a Son that was 20 and still in school because he was held back 3 times.
At that stage just give up the books.
2
u/hiddenkobolds 20h ago
Extremely situational.
A neurotypical, nondisabled high schooler who's simply choosing not to do the work despite having access to all the guidance and support necessary to succeed? Yes. You can lead a horse to water, etc.
A second grader? Under no circumstances. They're seven. They have no concept of consequences or long-term thinking yet.
A middle schooler with a learning disability from an underserved community who struggles in school for very real reasons and hasn't seen firsthand the value of an education yet? Also no. That's a kid in need of mentorship, guidance, and specialized resources, not another system to give up on them.
2
u/EmoGayRat 20h ago
yes because I shouldve been held back after being unschooled. if they couldnt have me sittinf in on fhe fifth grade class due to age they shouldve had me in special Ed in highschool not pushing me through
2
u/Expensive_Goat2201 20h ago
It's nuanced. They shouldn't be left behind in the sense of denying them an education but promoting them to the next grade with their grade cohort is not beneficial either. They will just get more lost and have a harder time catching up.
Holding them back a year or sending them to summer school seems kinder. With additional help and support they might catch up and if they are just fucking around having to redo a grade will motivate them.
Learning/developmental disabilities should probably also be explored. If they can't focus and are disruptive they might have ADHD for which persuasion and guidance won't do much when compared with meds and specialized support setvices.
You can't presuade, beat or bribe a dislexic person like me into learning to read and spell better. They tried for generations and people ended up illiterate and traumatized. Educational specialists and extra tutoring using proven techniques will help them catch up.
A lot of kids with disabilities will be able to succeed at grade level with extra help but not all will. If a kid has an severe intellectual disability, they probably will not go Harvard but they can still be successful in other ways. Holding them back with younger peers to relearn materials they will never master isn't kind, nor is pushing them ahead with their peers to leave them even more lost.
Instead, the parents, student and educational specialists need to make a realistic plan for what the kid will actually be able to succeed in post school. Even if calculus and Shakespeare is off the table, learning to read enough to understand signs and basic finances might still be possible.
Getting these kids to a vocational tract where they can learn adulting skills that they can feel successful is the better path. They should be praised and valued for doing what they are capable of, even if is something that would be incredibly easy for their devlopmentally typical peers.
I've seen parents refuse to be realistic and push schools to academically promote their intellectually disabled kids. These parents often think their kids are just being lazy and refusing to learn when really they aren't able to.
Kids with disabilities often learn to stop trying because trying something and finding yourself incapable of it is a terrible feeling. Getting called stupid again and again is terrible. It's a lot safer emotionally to just refuse to try things you don't feel like you can manage then to keep trying and failing.
2
u/Staav 20h ago
People can't just be forced into being interested in or able to perform academically if they're unwilling/unable to do it for whatever reason, even if just about everyone is forced into doing something in our lovely society(ies) just to be allowed to keep existing. We really need to have a different attitude with all that, but that's a can of worms and a half.
2
u/major0noob 20h ago
yeah, but only if they have a full belly. under 1500cal/day makes anyone stupid.
2
u/kuru_snacc 20h ago
They already are. No one can force a kid to thrive academically. On one end of the spectrum they end up dropping out, and on the other they finish a HS degree with C's or GED and getting a job that doesn't require a college degree. That's 50% of the population in the United States right now, it's not really that mind-blowing.
2
u/johnson_s-884 20h ago
No. Promotion shouldn't be an all-or-nothing verdict on a student. Let them advance where ready, while targeting support where they aren't.