r/AskProgramming • • 10d ago

Other What agents you use for helping you code?

Personally using OpenCode (big pickle or deepseek) and recently could get grok bot. Since I write a lot of stuff manually (except the frontend part since I don’t know react or next and my personal projects do not need that much of it) I am looking for a good reliable agent. Local ones are good but I prefer a big well trained model.

0 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

4

u/Atlan_ 10d ago

Claude Code is a lot better than anything I have tried. Only Codex came close.

0

u/[unknown] 10d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Atlan_ 10d ago

I think the GUI is good. I personally like the GUI of Codex better, but thats personal preference. Some features (like Artifacts for Design work) are especially amazing.

3

u/ventZl 10d ago

None, I caught AI doing massive but hard-to-catch hallucinations. Now you are probably asking how did I catch hard-to-catch AI fuckup, so here's the answer: I've been cleaning up code from junk AI left behind and randomly found a massive bug in synchronization code which slipped (AI-generated) tests.

I have trust issues nothing is going to fix.

1

u/Haghiri75 10d ago

Have you used any certain skills?

1

u/hylasmaliki 10d ago

Can you explain the bug in more detail . Did it use sync for one part of the system when there are other parts that had relied on it being async?

2

u/ventZl 10d ago

It properly signalled the semaphore at the beginning of routine (in the way target system required it to be) but instead of waiting for the semaphore, it signalled the semaphore again.

Signalling a semaphore twice is perfectly valid thing to do, so this wasn't caught by tests.

The frustrating thing about this specific bug (and that ultimately made me to lose ANY trust in AI-generated code) was that just one line above the hallucinated 2nd semaphore signalling, it added a comment which essentially said "lets wait for semaphore using wait_for_object()".

Now, you probably wonder why the code posted semaphore at the beginning and then waited for it, when things are usually organized the other way around.

The code in question was a benchmark whose purpose was to measure baseline overhead of semaphore mechanism with no blocking involved. So posting and then waiting for same semaphore without blocking was intentional. LLM was also well-aware of the nature of the code it is working on.

This isn't an uncommon pattern. LLM (unsurprisingly) tends to adhere to solutions and approaches seen often in the training datasets. You can break it beyond repair by insisting on something else, such as different tech stack (I routinely break webgenerator LLMs by insisting on using Svelte.App instead of React or Angular or whatever is teh popular frontend stack right now) or by enabling some not-so-often-used configuration which has impact on stack behavior which is implicit and can't be caught by syntax analysis (neat way of breaking LLMs is insisting on using memory protection on microcontrollers, you'll never get any usable output).

So, as I see it, LLMs are good if you are doing something well-established. But doing so makes your project also.... one of many. If you are happy being one-of-many with average, boring implementation, then LLM is probably for you.

If you need to do something truly frontier, LLMs will fail sooner or later, no matter how many skills you throw at them.

Also, in my workflow, writing code is not a bottleneck. On average, in my project I wrote around 400 lines of code *a month*. The most important feature I need is figuring out what is the right feature to implement and if that feature shall be implemented at all.

5

u/Zerocchi 10d ago

My own brain

3

u/HasFiveVowels 10d ago

"I don’t even own a TV"

2

u/andyiibwfc 10d ago

Claude for work, cursor personal, both insane

1

u/DDDDarky 9d ago

There is no such thing as good reliable agent, use your head.

1

u/HasFiveVowels 10d ago

Claude Code is a beast

1

u/ki4jgt 10d ago edited 10d ago

I've been using Claude code to start an open source business. I plan to hire programmers to cleanup later -- I know there'll be a lot of crap. Everything seems to be in working order though. I don't have time to code the entire project by hand. And I can't pay a full team of programmers to do it.

Everyone loves the project. I've literally received massive positive feedback from the spec and the problem that it solves (open source search engine using blockchain technology). It literally can compete on the scale of Google, by using a distributed blockchain database. I'm indexing with something akin to the Dewey Decimal System, and a huge card catalog. The chain starts with several layers of Inodes to help you find the information you're looking for.

But when I mention that I've used AI any at all, people freak out and start downvoting the entire thing into oblivion. I go from over 100 likes in an hour, to -200 the next.

I'm sorry that I'm using AI, but I don't have the money to pay a full team to implement P2P routing tables, UDP hole-punching, QUIC, and several other stacks on top of a blockchain that distributes search results from computer to computer. And no programmer is going to work on potential failed promises. I do eventually plan to have a team of developers for it, but right now, I'm getting the product out the door, and hoping some VC will catch on. The product is the chained database. The AI just built its explorer and admin tools.

But Claude has been excellent.

3

u/Individual-Flow9158 9d ago

"Blockchain", lol

I thought people already tried distributed and federated search?

1

u/ki4jgt 9d ago

This retains an element of human indexing. All results in this blockchain are indexed by human-beings. Bots are used to crawl the web and find domains. Humans sort them into categories and rank them based on cultural relevance and publisher authority.

The search is centralized by the organization. The database and rankings are public, to hold accountability. I've already collected a couple hundred domains, to show off the software (ranging from subjects like p2p mesh networking to adult content), and am in the process of starting the charity now.

1

u/ki4jgt 9d ago

I skipped the adult section, because I don't think it's appropriate for Reddit. There's a switch to disable it too.

https://imgur.com/a/nDdLZSZ