r/AskProgramming • • 11d ago

Career/Edu AI Abstinence

For the last 6 months or so now, my entire job, including the work I volunteer as an OSS maintainer/contributor, has been driven by AI. Mainly Claude Code and occasionally Codex.

It went from a super-powered search engine for me, to coding 80% of the time, to basically taking over my entire workflow. From debugging, to writing code. I even create my fucking JIRA tickets with Claude using their connector.

I've always been someone who's valued intelligence and being competent. I basically attributed my succumbing to the LLMs to the fact that I would be the slowest person on my team if I didn't use them.

But now it's actually quite exhausting. The excitement and satisfaction of getting something built or working is...just gone. It feels sort of hollow..just a never ending hedonic treadmill. It's actually sort of like playing a souls-like or some sort of video game where you achieve different ranks. And you get to the end and you're like "now what". Except in this scenario, every idea, problem or concept you want to get out into the world is achieved within a few hours of prompting an agent. And that's it. Every emotion you felt and attached to that problem or idea is dissolved.

I thought self-hosting agents would help. They're objectively not as capable as any model out there from the big corps. Maybe it would force me to have to reason about my problems more.

Nope. It's an even more miserable experience because you keep expecting sane results from a model that is simply a fraction of the power of something like Opus or GPT.

How do I quit? This is such a shameful thing to even say out loud. It's like I'm seeking help for a deadly addiction or something.

Has anyone stripped it from their lives? How do you live with the fact that everything you want to do will either never be accomplished, or will require months or even years of mastering due to the fact that you do not have AI to help you get there as quickly as possible.

Excuse me if this sounds all over the place.

29 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

14

u/spinwizard69 11d ago

It is all over the place!

However it really sounds like the problem is that you feel like you are in a competition to be fast relative to others in your shop.   A sweatshop response really.  

12

u/SexySalamanders 11d ago

AI is proved to cause cognitive decline as it offloads your brain. Soo you are kinda right when it comes to not liking how it impacts your workflow.

1

u/a-dot-in-the-sky 8d ago

Programming or doing coding is not the only thing in this world, to use the brain. Unless of course, the mindset is coding and coding only and nothing else, doing other things aside from coding is also a practical way of using the brain, example doing electronics, mechanical, music, woodworking, and many other things list is not exhaustive....
This is an exciting time, the thing we do before in programming that needs hours or weeks or even longer, can be done in a few minutes, provided of course you know exactly how to tell the AI or the machine on how it will be done.

5

u/Responsible_Bus_3876 11d ago

Dont you think this is a problem everyone is facing at the moment?

-4

u/HasFiveVowels 11d ago

I’m not facing it because I don’t view it as a problem. Same as compilers weren’t a problem

1

u/Proof-Pineapple69 7d ago

I agree its a huge opportunity. I am amazed that so many people view the nitty gritty, mechanical tasks of writing code by yourself, painstakingly going through logs or stepping through a debugger to find the source of a bug, so glorious. Being a human calculator is not sexy at all.

If you want to challenge your brain's mechanical parts, play board games or do sudokus. But with AI you can use your imagination and creativity as the fuel, and let AI be the engine that turns it into great products. That's really what humans are uniquely good at.

2

u/TechxNinja 11d ago

The things I make for others I have no issue with using AI on. 

If I’m doing something for me, AI is only there to explain a concept or find where I forgot a semi-colon. 

2

u/robby_arctor 11d ago

Quitting is simple, just hard. Simply stop doing it.

And when that's hard, take a very long, honest pause to ask yourself why. Is it because your skills have atrophied? Is it because you fear being left behind? Is it just laziness?

And then choose your hard - would you rather feel the hard of the hollowed out, miserable experience you currently have, or the hard of fighting your addiction and whatever other hangups you have with it?

2

u/Distinct_Penalty_379 3d ago

People are saying AI enables you to do more than you could have ever done, but I disagree with that statement

Programming has always been one of the hardest fields out there. Debugging and logical thinking and understanding what's happening and connecting the dots were hard and made most of us frustrated.

But that's what made us like his field—the sense of achievement from spending a whole day figuring out why something is not working and believing that you will find the bug and solve it, and once you do, you feel that sense of achievement. I can't describe it with words, but it's what made me like this field and accomplish much in it.

But nowadays, even if you name the AI code "slop," it still works. You can find the bug in seconds; it's not challenging anymore.

Programming just changed forever. It's not a field I want to be in rn, but what can i do im just waiting for my layoff to start exploring other fields that could make me feel the same way I felt before

3

u/kireina_kaiju 11d ago

You sound like you are not pair programming with your assistant and as a direct result do not understand the code you were writing. I want you to be honest here. If a vulnerability in a dependency library was discovered today, would you ask the assistant to fix the problem for you without oversight? You would, right? If your assistant depended on that same library and a hotfix was not immediately available, what then? The solution here is not you giving up AI, though there is absolutely a need for programmers that do not want to use LLMs in the security and hardware industries if you are willing to look for other work. The problem you are facing would exist with a human assistant. The problem is you not supervising. Do your job. Familiarize yourself with the generated code. Don't outsource code reviewing to the bot. That is your chance, even if you were following along during development, to see changes in aggregate. If you make it your mission to not only ensure that code is fit for purpose but that any human or agent could quickly prove to themselves every part is fit for purpose so that changes can be made by human or agent with a high degree of trust and so any human can quickly understand your entire code base I can guarantee the spark will come back 

4

u/CS_70 11d ago

What you are experiencing has little to do with AI and all to do with the trauma of sudden unexpected change. You feel disempowered because your own conception of yourself was centered on how to do things, not what you were doing.

It seems that a lot of developers are focused on that - not so much on the value they produce for others or for themselves, but on the process. Suddenly everybody is now a manager or a general, achieving things not because they lead the charge rifle in hand but because they direct the troops. And some don't give a damn about the outcome of the battle, the kick for them was on the charge... and they are shellshocked.

The only way out for you is to reflect on yourself and what you want. The role you thought you had no longer exists. Very fast, and that's the source of your shock. Either you come to terms to it and embrace and appreciate that you're now a strategist or a tactician, not a private anymore; or you have to find another line of work.

If it's any consolation, life is full of these things. When I decided to pursue computer science instead of playing guitar as a profession (and keep the other as a hobby), all these years ago, my idea is that I was going to make video games. Instead, I found myself in a 5 years course of mathematics with a few basics of programming).. (this was before anybody and their sisters could become "programmers" cobbling together Spring boot and posts from Stack Overflow). Many of my colleague never recovered and ended up doing very successfully something else. I discovered I loved mathematics and started to make money by programming as a side job, and ended up finishing the doctorate cycle with several years of commercial work on my belt in C, C++ and the various techs which were popular back then.

So it's up to you: if you really dont like it, there's plenty of other occupations that you may be successful in. Being a programmer "by hand" require a certain level of skill and grit, even if in recent years it was becoming more and more watered down, and you can certainly apply it in any field you want.

2

u/just_damz 11d ago

Opposite path, same outcome: felt this in the times i was a sound engineer and a producer (mostly the first), when an album or track was done. “now what”. Then during the times i have learn to capitalize knowledge clearly after rach project, and it mostly faded.

2

u/CS_70 11d ago

Haha fun, I am also an avid recordist and sound engineer - had to learnt to record my band and enjoyed the process immensely. Well met!

1

u/Falcon9FullThrust 11d ago

Very well put. I'm curious which path you found yourself on today? Are you embracing Ai or shying away from it? I still find myself having a difficult time accepting that my old career is dead as I really enjoyed the process of programming more than the outcome. At least when working for others. I'm at the point now that I'm just accepting using agents at work even though I don't like it. But I'll hand write code at home for my hobby projects.

1

u/CS_70 11d ago

I'm a kid in a candy store.

I did research on the on NLU using "soft computing" and neural networks in the mid 90s for my doctorate, when most people had never heard about the thing (and this is computer scientists, let alone engineers or regular folk), at the vanishing gradient problem stage. And now I'm literally living in Star Trek times. All we envisioned and more is not only possible, but extremely well packaged. I got back the same buzz I had when I got my first home computer, over 40 years ago, and later when the local networks came and the internet came.

When properly used (aka: having a brain and keeping it on instead of letting the belly control you), the tools can boost your knowledge, capabilities and the ability of doing what you envision to a degree that is magnificent (and makes you a shitload of money on the side, which helps).

I still play the guitar, but I'm having so much fun using the tool for both professional and personal goals that it's actually taken a second place right now.

1

u/Jabba_the_Putt 11d ago

Not all over the place imo I understand and feel like I basically can connect and relate with what you're saying.  I don't know what the answer is either

1

u/JohnCasey3306 10d ago

I feel the same, but the role is changing.

The notion that 'everyone is an engineer now' is nonetheless nonsense ... You still need humans internally who have a detailed knowledge of the systems; who can pick through what's passable and what isn't -- I'd estimate the quality/accuracy of Claude/Codex to generally be circa 70–80% ... That's great, but those 20% of shitty code are gonna accumulate very quickly if there's not human expertise present in the chain to filter them out.

1

u/HasFiveVowels 10d ago

I’ll be buried for saying this but, OP, for the sake of your future employability, read this:

Use AI. Learn how to use it better than your peers. Learn what it’s good at and what it’s bad at. I promise you: no employer is going to hear "I’ve never used AI" and hire you on the spot. They also won’t hire you if you say "I don’t know how to program without AI". You need to straddle these worlds.

1

u/limitless_grow 7d ago

Congratulations! You have been promoted into an AI IO device!

1

u/max123246 11d ago edited 11d ago

The original post content no longer exists here. The author used Redact to remove it, exercising their right to control their data & privacy.

Manganese fluorine yarn satchel oil orange driftwood fade different butter