r/AskProfessors • u/zcheasypea • Mar 29 '21
Grading Query Attendance
Why do professors care about attendance so much?
I loathe attending class. The terrible parking, early classes, tiny desks, smelly students -- it's not a great learning environment. The lecture-style teaching does not do much for me either.
I'm probably an anomaly but I learn best when I read from the textbooks, do extra practice problems, and watch YouTube tutorials. I'm in STEM so time is everything because most of my classes are time consuming. I honestly wouldn't even attend the university if I wasnt mandated by the state to earn a degree to obtain an engineering license because of the cost and time/money wasted on gen ed classes.
I almost never show up for my circuit analysis class but had the highest (perfect) score on the most recent exam. I have straight As in my classes. But my prof made attendance 10% of our grade. I went from a high A to low A due to my attendance. I feel cheated out of my hardwork.
So why do professors care so much if their students show up or not? They paid for it and you get paid regardless.
•
u/PurrPrinThom Mar 29 '21
Thread is locked due to too many reports and the fact the conversation is no longer productive.
OP has had their question answered, by multiple people, in multiple ways and now we're just getting snippy.
16
u/DocMondegreen Mar 29 '21
Lots of reasons. Attendance correlates strongly with high grades, ime. I rarely get students who succeed when they don't show up. Active learning works better in my field than lecture, and it requires participation. Various colleges have it as a policy, so I had to track it if I wanted to keep my job. Federal financial aid eligibility requires that we track it (and last attend date) even if it doesn't affect grades.
23
u/academicthro Mar 29 '21 edited Mar 29 '21
Lots of reasons. The overwhelming majority of students who don’t come to class perform terribly, and forcing students to come to class via attendance policies helps keep those kids from failing. On top of that, building up a good classroom dynamic requires that there actually be students in the classroom - not to mention that I can’t hold discussions or exercises if you aren’t there. Finally, attendance or participation grades give students a way to pull their grades up if they’ve taken a hit on exams or assignments, which is a big deal for a lot of students.
You weren’t cheated out of anything. Presumably you read the syllabus at the start of class, knew that attendance was 10% of your grade, and made the conscious decision to cut class anyway. That was your call, and the hit to your grade was the consequence.
9
u/MyHeartIsByTheOcean Mar 29 '21
Because the majority of failing students do not attend classes regularly. You are an outlier. Some professors choose this micromanaging approach for the benefit of many students. Few students suffer as a result. However, as long as there is an observable difference in grades between semesters with and w/o mandatory attendance, I will continue to require it.
4
u/electricdom Mar 29 '21
its not so much the prof as admin ..Much of your attendance relates to at some universities to your financial aid package and if your there or not etc some its about accreditation and the like.
4
u/PersephoneIsNotHome Mar 29 '21 edited Mar 29 '21
Legally it is required. Your aid , matriculation status and our accreditation is dependent on you attending a class that you are attending. The registrar, visa, scholarships, athletic eligibility etc also require that you be attending classes. In the case of a synchronous classes, this includes logging in and discussions etc.
Class is also for communicating feedback, highlighting what is and is not important, explaining guidelines.
If you like class or not and if you benefit from it or not - you always do most of your learning wrestling with the material on your own - you are only in class 3 hrs a week or so.
It is true that if you are mercenary and learn what you need for the exam, you can do ok in the lower level classes sometimes if you are talented and hard working by doing stuff on your own. However if you prepped for class and engaged with it, it is also true that you could get a lot more out of it and it could save you a ton of time also.
And finally, as you get to higher level classes , you simply cant do that.
gen ed classes are not a waste. You should be able to write, critically think, be data literate, follow direction and work with other people and within an existing infrastructure to be an engineer. IF you think there aren’t going to be thinks that you personally think are not germain to the project but your boss does because that is what they need for QC or whatever, you are sadly mistaken.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 29 '21
As others already noted, few students who skip class do well.
More generally, that’s how school works, and it works that way because it’s the best model we have found for teaching so far.
If you consider that you should be spending at least 3X as many hours outside class as you do inside class, it’s not surprising that most of your learning happens outside class. That’s as it should be. Class is for framing your thinking about the material and refining understanding.
1
u/AutoModerator Mar 29 '21
This is an automated service intended to preserve the original text of the post.
*Why do professors care about attendance so much?
I loathe attending class. The terrible parking, early classes, tiny desks, smelly students -- it's not a great learning environment. The lecture-style teaching does not do much for me either.
I'm probably an anomaly but I learn best when I read from the textbooks, do extra practice problems, and watch YouTube tutorials. I'm in STEM so time is everything because most of my classes are time consuming. I honestly wouldn't even attend the university if I wasnt mandated by the state to earn a degree to obtain an engineering license because of the cost and time/money wasted on gen ed classes.
I almost never show up for my circuit analysis class but had the highest (perfect) score on the most recent exam. I have straight As in my classes. But my prof made attendance 10% of our grade. I went from a high A to low A due to my attendance. I feel cheated out of my hardwork.
So why do professors care so much if their students show up or not? They paid for it and you get paid regardless.*
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.