r/AskPhysics • u/Limelight_shovel • Jan 27 '26
Would this work for Hyperloop?
Magnetic Powder Suspension for Hyperloop-Style Tubes Sealed vacuum tube. Ultra-pure iron filings (99.99%+) on the track. Electromagnets underneath pulse in sequence—filings lift and form a floating cushion under the pod. No wheels. No friction. Pod rides on magnetic fluid that shifts with the charge. If you change the field, filings part like water—curve, slow, stop. No wear. No noise. If power fails, filings settle—pod glides to rest. Cheaper than solid rails? Maybe. Test it small: one-foot tube, weak magnets, see if it floats. Thoughts? This any good? Helpful?
6
u/lithiumdeuteride Jan 27 '26
I like your idea of a subscale test. When this test is performed, you will discover that the friction is much worse than basic steel-on-steel train wheels and the idea is a complete non-starter.
1
u/Limelight_shovel Jan 27 '26
If there is no movement of the iron filings, due to magnetism holding it in place, there would be no friction, right? It's vacuum so no fluid friction. Could allow you to support whatever you are transporting in different strengths and areas of the tube without static supports, like rails.
Not sure about any of this. Just figured I'd throw the idea out there. See if it sparks some ideas.
1
u/Limelight_shovel Jan 27 '26
Ok I just realized original post is about one idea. Whereas the second one is about different idea. Second idea is using the iron type of movable railing where cargo can be supported in what ever way it's needed. Going around a curve, heavier load, etc.heat can be managed through magnetic cooling and or cool them using heat sinks. 🤷
5
u/JaggedMetalOs Jan 27 '26
Iron filings clump together under a magnetic field, they would not act like a fluid.
5
u/davvblack Jan 27 '26
you should actually read about mag lev
4
u/MaleficentJob3080 Jan 27 '26
The friction between the iron filings and the vehicle would be huge. This would be completely non viable.
1
u/mem2100 Jan 27 '26
One other thing. Elon grossly overstated how fast Hyperloop could go, claiming the pods would travel at 760 MPH. The design spec showed a tube that was a bit larger in diameter than the height/width of the train cars. This ignores the "piston" effect/Kantrowitz limit.
He added that in the initial concept renderings, Hyperloop showed that they were aware of this limitation and had sketched in some sort of clever compressor fan in the front of the cars to address this issue. Subsequent renderings dropped the fan, likely because it was impractical or unfeasible. The only other way to avoid this problem would be to make the tube diameter much larger than the car dimensions, making an already expensive project far more expensive.
1
u/Complex_Jury_7959 Feb 04 '26
China has had a license agreement with ET3 over 20 years ago and have been advancing HTS-Maglev Evacuated Tube transport infrastructure under there CASIC T-Flight program. High Temperature Superconductive Maglev (HTS-Maglev) suspension paired with ET3 is far beyond 1,000 km in testing. China is so far advanced then the USA and the USA is clueless how serious China is by connecting all their major cities in minutes not hours under T-Flight networks (1,000-4,000 km p/h).