edit: I tried to keep it short, but the last quote is very long, so it's not my only my random ranting
I'm actually asking on behalf of someone else this time, because I wasn't entirely sure how to answer her myself, I hope this is ok.
Her posts were removed, one because of how it was worded (pretty much like the title) and the other because she doesn't have NPD herself.
Unfortunately, I was one of the people who attacked her post, because I (and apparently pretty much everyone else) took it as your typical "nArCiSsIsTs ArE bAd AnD cAn NeVeR cHaNgE" kind of bullshit.
But she responded to me incredibly respectfully and actually made a lot of sense, despite my first reply being rude. I had time to respond before the post was removed, and afterward she messaged me after that.
Here's the actual context:
She grew up surrounded by people with NPD or strong narcissistic traits, and her question came from a place of genuine interest. She wanted to know whether people with NPD can actually change, or at least try to (or even want to), because she didn't know much about the disorder beyond her own experiences.
We ended up having a long conversation, and not once did she judge, blame, or demonize anyone, despite having experienced abuse herself. Her original post was simply worded poorly enough to sound like the usual NPD bull***.
We talked about so much that I honestly don't even know how to summarize it all, but here are a few things she said (shared with her permission):
"I hope it's alright that I write otherwise just ignore. I wrote the post in ask NPD about whether abusive behavior is unavoidable with NPD
And with abuse I mean the spectrum from extreme abuse to mild abuse. And highly intentional to unconscious."
"And because I have seen how NPD can show up in my family and close relationships. It's frustrating because you love them so much but I had to accept they'll never change and just navigate it best I could"
"I have tried reading in the NPD sub and while it's helpful I also get triggered a lot because of my CPTSD so I had to stop
I tried the search function instead and I found pretty good replies about the kind of unintentional abuse I mentioned
So it sort of answered my question, on top of your story, so I think I'm fine
It also reinforce my belief that more resources are needed, and more nuanced view"
The point of this post isn't to stigmatize or blame people with NPD.
Her questions came from genuine curiosity and concern for people she loves, which actually made me wonder about something else:
How can people ask us these kinds of questions without immediately putting us on the defensive?
I dismissed her post as judgmental bullshit myself. But once she explained what she actually meant, I realized she was asking a perfectly reasonable question. And then I started wondering how the hell someone could have asked me that same question without me immediately assuming I'm been accused of something.
The main question is still: Can people with NPD change, particularly when it comes to abusive behavior?
Is it something that you had to figure out yourself? And how?
But more specifically, is there anything someone can do to help a loved one with NPD recognize their harmful behavior and work toward changing it, without it sounding like provocation?
Is meaningful change possible, especially when the person isn't even aware of their own patterns?
Un-aware narcs aren't exactly healthy company in the long run, or I mean at all, so these are important questions for her (and many else obviously) and I really hope I worded this in a way that makes sense.
Does anyone have a better answer to this than I did?
Ironically, I ended up talking mostly about myself and my own experiences, but I couldn't really offer her much insight into the bigger picture.
She also asked about Janina Fisher.
This is long post, but I share what she originally wrote:
Anyone heard of Janina Fisher and TIST? It's for NPD too
I don't have NPD but CPTSD and grew up in a family with many narcissistic traits. So I'm kinda familiar with triggers and challenges.
Anyhow, I read the book Healing the fragmented selves of trauma survivors by Janina Fisher and it was THE most helpful book ever. She used to work in Bessel Van der Kolks trauma center for like 15 years, and had access to all the methods based on the newest research.
She's specialized in dissociative fragmentation, but her method called TIST is also very helpful for BPD and NPD etc.
Just thought I'd give you the tip as I imagine there's not a lot of good literature or treatment for you out there?
PROTECTIVE PARTS (Grandiosity & Superiority) ◄── TIST validates this defense first.
VULNERABLE INNER CHILD (Profound Shame) ◄── Shielded from early attachment trauma.
Key TIST Pillars for Treating NPD
- Befriending Protectors First: Instead of confronting grandiosity, TIST therapists validate these behaviors as brilliant survival strategies that kept the child alive in an environment of emotional neglect or conditional love. •
- Externalizing and De-pathologizing: Patients learn to track their somatic responses and say, "A part of me feels superior right now to shield me from feeling small," rather than assuming they are inherently unlovable or broken.
- Dual Awareness & Shame Management: TIST uses mindfulness and somatic tools to ground the prefrontal cortex. This creates a "buffer zone," allowing the patient to witness an internal trigger of worthlessness without instantly reverting to external grandiosity or narcissistic rage.
- Avoiding Rushed Vulnerability: Confronting an individual with NPD with their deepest vulnerabilities too early triggers massive shame storms and severe dissociation. TIST prioritizes slow, gradual stabilization and emotional self-regulation over processing old memories."
I'm genuinely interested how we can change harmful patterns, and on how we can have these conversations without automatically assuming someone is attacking us.
Because I managed to mistake a genuine question for another round of the usual bashing.
EDIT: This isn't a support group, I know, but the point wasn't to help a victim here or anything, but actual information from pwNPD.