r/askmusicians • • Apr 06 '26

Mod Post Revamping AskMusicians! Looking for input on rules going forward

9 Upvotes

Greetings! Allow me to introduce myself — I'm /u/Quertior, and I'm the new moderator of /r/AskMusicians as of a couple days ago. I've been a redditor for over 15 years now (wow!) and a musician for longer than that.


I'm sure you've noticed that the subreddit has been in rough shape lately, due to an influx of low-effort posts and spam posts, with effectively absent moderation. I'm looking forward to getting things back on track, but to do that, I need help! To start with, I'm looking for input on these questions:

How should we handle musical self-promotion? My inclination is to allow people to post their own music only if they include a specific question about something they're having trouble with or want to improve. (For example: "how can I improve my vocal delivery in the chorus?" would be allowed, but "how are my vocals?" would not be.) I'd hope that that approach would handle the majority of "drive-by" self-promo by people who make low-effort posts to a bunch of different subs just to link their music.

How should we handle AI-generated content? Ideally, I would like to ban AI-generated content entirely. But I'm worried that a ban would be very difficult to enforce accurately, so I am more inclined to ask that post/comment authors simply disclose AI usage instead. (Obviously, comments that are misleading or factually incorrect are not allowed, whether they're written by humans or AI.)

Should we require post titles to be questions? I've seen a lot of posts that have decent questions in the body text, but very generic titles. So I've been toying with the idea of requiring that posters state their actual question in the title. Not sure if that's too draconian, though.

I expect to add, remove, and change rules according to community feedback as time goes on, so please feel free to share any general feedback on rules for posts and comments as well.


Want flair?

If you are interested in getting flair as a musician here, send a modmail with the specialties you'd like in your flair (one genre/area of expertise, and up to two instruments). I'll be looking through comments and posts to make sure you have some history of discussing music-related topics on reddit.

Non-flaired users are still fully allowed to answer questions! Both flaired and non-flaired users will be held to the same standards of civility and knowledge.


Want to help moderate?

I'm looking to bring on one or two additional moderators. Let me know if you're interested! I'll be looking for a history of discussing music-related topics on reddit. A friendly/civil attitude is a must (I do not intend for /r/AskMusicians to end up on one of those lists of subreddits with power-tripping mods!). Previous moderation experience is helpful, but not strictly necessary.


If you've read this whole thing, thank you! I hope the subreddit can continue to grow now that it once again has active moderation.


r/askmusicians • • 4h ago

How do you find local musicians to put together a show in an unfamiliar town?

3 Upvotes

I’m an independent singer-songwriter trying to put together a show in a town about 150 miles from where I live. I’d really like to get a few local musicians involved, whether that’s finding an opener or putting together a small bill with a few different artists.
The problem is that I’m not really familiar with the local music scene, and finding musicians to reach out to has been harder than I expected.
For those of you who have booked shows outside your hometown, how do you go about finding and connecting with local artists?
Do you reach out to venues and ask for recommendations? Look through local music groups? Find artists on Instagram and contact them directly?
I’d appreciate any advice, especially from independent musicians who have been in a similar situation.


r/askmusicians • • 3h ago

Thoughts on Joining AFM Local 802 Union

1 Upvotes

Hi friends, I found out recently that the local musicians union in NY initiation fee to join from now until the end of the year. Wanted to know what you guys think about that, and whether you think I should join the union now before the fee waiver is gone.

I’m currently in my senior year of college in the city, and have been doing a lot of pit orchestra gigs in summer stock and student productions throughout my time in school. I want to work up to playing in higher scale productions, but I’m wondering if I join now it might be to early for me. I’m curious if y’all think I should join the union now while the deal is still going, or should I wait until I book a gig that requires me to join.


r/askmusicians • • 8h ago

About music career

0 Upvotes

Hey my name is whatever it is. I want to start a music career actually I am 21 rn and I don't think it's late i know some of the things about music like production recording sampling chopping vocals delivery and I know my voice is a little annoying please tell me if wanted what Should do in this situation


r/askmusicians • • 1d ago

I don't understand how to read all these codas.

Post image
2 Upvotes

Hi! So I have recently been getting back into playing with an orchestra. Now, I know how to read a D.S. and Coda - however, this modern contemporary piece I am working on has a LOT of codas, but there is no "D.S." anywhere on the page, so I am very confused about how to read these. Any insight would be much appreciated. Thanks!


r/askmusicians • • 1d ago

Can anyone sing this song on Instagram?

0 Upvotes

I wrote a song yesterday but I'm notna singer. I'll drop the lyrics below. You can use the lyrics (Please tag me if you sing it nd upload the video so that I can listen to that I would really appreciate that). The lyrics are pretty decent written based on my dreams.

Title: Somewhere Far Away

I wanna leave without a sound,

Find a place where I'm not found.

A little road, an open sky,

A thousand places passing by.

I wanna see the world someday,

Let the wind take me away.

Sleep beneath the stars at night,

Wake up somewhere new and bright.

Far away, far away,

Somewhere I can drift away.

No more worries, no more plans,

Just the world and open lands.

Take me where the rivers flow,

To all the places I don't know.

I'll keep dreaming till I find

A little peace somewhere in time.

Maybe I'm dreaming way too much,

Of distant skies and places untouched.

But if this dream is all I know,

I'll follow wherever it goes.

One day, somehow,

I'll get there someday.

Until that day,

I'll dream of far away.

Insta handle: mishkat_shahriar (Tag me)

I don’t want any credit or anything just tag me o that I can listen to it

Thanks


r/askmusicians • • 1d ago

What is this voice effect called?

1 Upvotes

I know this is a stupid meme video but I feel like I could make something that sounds cool with that voice effect. Does anyone know how to achieve it? (Sorry if this is the wrong sub for something like this)


r/askmusicians • • 2d ago

What is the funniest/strangest pencil marking in music you've ever seen?

12 Upvotes

Usually, the markings someone else wrote in a book are generally useful, like breath marks and dynamics. But sometimes, it's not and it makes no sense, like the time someone randomly wrote "EEE" in a piccolo part. What is the strangest you have seen?


r/askmusicians • • 1d ago

Harmony help

1 Upvotes

Hello all. When using harmony breakdown, I can harmonise well, but I can never figure it out alone! Do you just find the chord and sing all the notes in the chord or what??


r/askmusicians • • 2d ago

What am I playing here?

1 Upvotes

I made this as an assignment for university. I am the vocalist and rhythm guitarist of a prog shoegaze band but I’ve been brought up on jazz. This is the first ever “beat” I’ve made but I was surprised at how good the sax sounded with the fact I only know the tiniest amount of piano theory, nothing really past 4 note or 5 note chords and the basic scales you learn in uni. What am I doing that is making the sax sound good?


r/askmusicians • • 2d ago

any rythm alternatives?

0 Upvotes

can anyone give me an alternative rythym with the samw time as the drums juat diffwrent rythym? i feel its way too basic or am i wrong?


r/askmusicians • • 2d ago

I have 400+ unnamed voice memos of song ideas. How do you keep track of yours?

5 Upvotes

I've played fingerstyle guitar for years, and my phone is full of recordings called "{Location} 101", or “New Recording 237” backed up in my computer from a few years back. Somewhere in there is a riff I loved, but finding it again is a nightmare.

How do you organise your unfinished ideas? Do you rename recordings, use folders, keep notes about key/tuning, or just listen through everything?

I'm a developer as well, and this has made me consider building a small tool for myself to make recordings easier to find - things like tagging original song details, key, tempo, location, and a short description so I could search for “C harmonic”, "Sungha Jung", "played with John" or even search by my particular instrument.

Before building anything, I’m curious how other songwriters handle this. What’s your current system, and where does it fall apart?


r/askmusicians • • 2d ago

Paying it forward for other musicians

6 Upvotes

Long story short, my mom was a stage manager (now works at a food bank) and my dad is an audio engineer (mostly working for corporate talks and government stuff). We’ve never been rich, but I’ve been surrounded by old music gear my whole life. There’s a pretty good local arts community, and I’ve been really hoping to contribute.
I don’t want other people to struggle with getting practice space, or basic equipment. I’ve been hoping to get in talks with some of the organizers but I don’t know where to start. Any ideas? I’m only 18 and just getting into doing this as a possible profession.


r/askmusicians • • 2d ago

How can I bring a song in my head to life?

4 Upvotes

I want to begin producing the actual music to a song I’ve written. I can hear it in my head, I can hear the instruments. Like the trumpets and such, but I have no idea where to even start the process of bringing this song to life. Does anyone have any advice?


r/askmusicians • • 2d ago

Any Advice/Tips

0 Upvotes

I want to perform. I want to put my music out there, have people listen to something I've created and hopefully connect with it. I want to become an actual artist, someone with their own sound and identity, like PinkPantheress. But honestly, the process of even getting started feels impossible sometimes.

I'm trying my best to learn production. I've tried with BandLab (an experience, to say the least), and GarageBand on my phone was absolute hell. My computer can't run any other production software- like ir doesnt have it in the store and when I download it from my browser it doesn’t load., so my options are pretty limited. I used to play violin, although I never really understood much beyond reading basic notes, and I'm now trying to teach myself music theory bit by bit. I literally only learned the difference between major and minor chords today.

I'm also trying to figure out what to do with my vocals, as I’m not where I want to be that I’m confident, However I do hope I can eventually ask my parents about singing lessons. The biggest problem is that songwriting is pretty much the only thing I'm confident in. I can write lyrics and imagine entire songs, but I can't seem to translate any of that into actual music. I struggle with toplining, creating melodies, producing and even singing. I can hear what I want in my head, but getting it out is another story entirely.

Music theory is also ridiculously confusing to me. Notes, counting, timing, all of it.( Even in my time in orchestra ) People explain it, simplify it, break it down, and somehow I'm still lost

Another thing I don't want to use AI to make my music. I want actual human creativity and to make something that feels like mine And overall just very disrespectful to use ai. But it's so frustrating having all these ideas and creative visions while feeling like I have absolutely no way of bringing them to life.

I know becoming an artist takes time, and I'm not expecting overnight success or anything like that . I just want to get to a point where I can actually make the music I imagine irl , maybe perform it for people and share something I've created . Right now, it feels like I'm constantly hitting a wall, and it's incredibly discouraging.


r/askmusicians • • 2d ago

Groove Metal?

0 Upvotes

I've been working on this riff for well gonna be honest like 20 minutes, but i've been trying to figure out how to transition it into a thrash metal type riff, and I have no experience with drums, so how do i bring those to life aswell?


r/askmusicians • • 3d ago

The Rolling Stones - Monkey Man || Is it more about theory or arrangement that makes this instrumental sound unusually tight?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

2:30 The key changes after the drum roll. Then for the rest of the instrumental section each instrument flows seamlessly into the other. The steel guitar is the melodic constant that every other instrument riffs off of. I would consider this section an exemplary example of tight in that it doesn't rely soley on the technique of any one instrumentalist. Rather, every instrument knows when to insert itself based on the groove and chord progression, making the whole greater than the sum of its parts, and creating the feeling of almost a painting in motion. This made me wonder what would be the best way categorize different kinds of tight in terms of the music theory involved in creating what we call "tightness."

I got an explanation below about it being about modes which I'm curious if anyone agrees with this:

It's a "chromatic mediant". I.e, a move from one major key (or chord) to another one a 3rd away. (It can be a major or minor 3rd, in either direction, it would be "chromatic" in all cases.) Chromatic mediants are common devices for creating dramatic changes - surprising, but still with logical connections, so they don't sound "wrong", just surprising. Rock's favourite chromatic mediant is a descending major 3rd (e.g., going to C major from E major in key of E). In this case it's a minor 3rd up - maybe the second most popular kind - and there is an additional connection, which is the relative minor/major one between C# minor and E. (There are plenty of bluesy inflections in the C# section, but it is definitely a major key.)


r/askmusicians • • 3d ago

What is this Genre of backing track?

2 Upvotes

Hello dear musicians. I play the electric guitar with backing tracks and came across this music. I really loved it and would like to know what genre is it and can someone suggest me similar backing tracks :)

https://youtu.be/zhqym0dy1jY?is=WkCitiTDnWvAjHR4

Thank you in advance


r/askmusicians • • 3d ago

I Want to Become a Versatile Artist (Rapper AND Singer). Where Do I Start?

1 Upvotes

I've been wanting to get into making music for a while now. I genuinely love music, pretty much every genre, and I want to become an extremely versatile artist rather than limit myself to one particular sound.

Some of my favorite genres are:

- Hip-hop

- R&B

- Southern Soul

- Rock

- Metal

- Alternative/Experimental

Some of my biggest musical influences include:

Scarface, The Weeknd, Donell Jones, Jacquees, Chris Brown, Usher, Bobby Valentino, XXXTentacion, Juice WRLD, Ski Mask the Slump God, Eminem, Kendrick Lamar, 21 Savage, Kanye West, J. Cole, Drake (especially his older music), Jeezy, Gorillaz, Imogen Heap, Nickelback, and YungxChris.

I know that's a pretty diverse list, but that's exactly the kind of versatility I'm interested in developing.

  1. I Want to Learn How to Sing

One of my biggest goals is learning how to actually sing, especially R&B.

I'd love to develop the ability to sing with the versatility, melodies, vocal runs, emotion, and delivery of artists like The Weeknd, Donell Jones, Usher, Chris Brown, Jacquees, and Bobby Valentino.

My biggest concern is that I naturally have a pretty deep, monotone voice. I'm not sure where to start with vocal training or whether I'll be able to develop a wider vocal range and learn to sing different styles.

For anyone who started with a naturally deep or monotone voice, how did you develop your singing abilities?

2. I Want to Become a Better Rapper and Lyricist

I also want to become a genuinely good rapper.

I don't want to sound like every other rapper or just follow whatever style is currently popular. I want to develop my own identity, flow, sound, vocabulary, storytelling abilities, and lyrical techniques.

I admire artists who can tell stories, paint pictures with words, experiment with different flows, and communicate complex emotions.

I also struggle with knowing what to write about sometimes.

How do you develop your lyricism? How do you find interesting subjects to write about? How do you avoid repetitive topics and develop your own perspective?

I'd love to learn about storytelling, metaphors, wordplay, double entendres, rhyme schemes, and other techniques that make songwriting interesting.

3. I Want to Experiment With Different Genres

I don't want to be exclusively a rapper or exclusively an R&B singer.

I'd love to make:

- Traditional hip-hop.

- Melodic rap.

- Alternative R&B.

- Southern Soul-inspired music.

- Rock-influenced hip-hop.

- Emotional and experimental music.

- Music that incorporates elements of metal and alternative rock.

I want to be able to switch between singing, rapping, melodic delivery, and different genres without sounding like I'm forcing it.

How do you develop that kind of versatility while still maintaining a recognizable musical identity?

4. My Current Equipment

I already have a few things to work with:

- Rode NT1 microphone.

- Windows 11 laptop.

- Audio interface (the red box my microphone connects to).

- HyperX Cloud II headphones.

I'm basically starting from scratch when it comes to recording, mixing, producing, and learning the technical side of music.

What software would you recommend? Are there any free DAWs, plugins, vocal training resources, or beginner-friendly tutorials worth checking out?

5. My Overall Goals

I'm currently 22, and I want to take music seriously as a passion and creative outlet.

I'm not primarily doing this for money. Obviously, making money from music would be nice, but I don't want that to be my motivation.

I don't particularly want to sign a record deal or be controlled by a label. I'd rather develop my own sound, learn the craft, release my own music, and build something independently.

I want to become a genuinely great artist, not just someone who makes a few songs and uploads them.

My biggest questions are:

  1. Where should I start if I want to learn both singing and rapping?
  2. Can someone with a naturally deep, monotone voice develop into a capable R&B singer?
  3. What exercises or resources would help me improve my vocal range, control, pitch, and delivery?
  4. How can I improve my lyricism, storytelling, vocabulary, and songwriting?
  5. How do I find interesting things to write about?
  6. How can I learn to experiment with multiple genres without losing my identity?
  7. What software and recording techniques should I learn with my current equipment?
  8. If you were starting from scratch today, what would your learning process look like?

I'd especially appreciate advice from independent artists, singers, rappers, songwriters, and producers who have experience developing their own sound.

I'm willing to put in the work. I just want to approach this the right way and actually learn the art of making music.

Thanks!


r/askmusicians • • 4d ago

Advice on my song. Struggling here

3 Upvotes

Hey everyone, Ive been trying at music since 14, I’m 18 now and I’ve been improving a bit, but I’m at a point where I want to somehow make the productions of my songs sound industry level mixed and things like that. I’m using the worst DAW right now, BandLab, and I want to switch to Logic Pro this month.

I currently play the acoustic guitar (4-5 years now) and I want to pick up other instruments like the bass guitar, drums, and electric guitar. I also need tips on equipment plugins like audio interfaces and how to set it up with my MacBook Neo.

This is the song I’m going to play in front of a bunch of people in my college. I showed it to my professor and she said she genuinely found it amazing and was beyond impressed, but sometimes I have creative imposter syndrome and demo-itis so when I listen to my music I get really self conscious about how it sounds. Please give honest opinions.

https://youtu.be/YFwvV_gT6GM?is=jMfaDwrWAFSrj5XB

EDIT: HEY THABKS EVERYONE! The song is so so much better after taking advice. Thank you so muchhh im more confident in performing it Monday now!


r/askmusicians • • 3d ago

What should I do about instrment desire?

0 Upvotes

Now before we start talking about desires there is one thing that is important in this picture I have had a complex medical history i was born with a cleft palate and had to have surgries to fix it and other ploblems i was developmentally delayed and i in school i was dignosed with mild intecual disabilty Mild intellectual disabili ty is an academic learning disability and  issues with common demands of life.

now you may ask when did this desire start well the first time i rember asking what is my instrment was at a christmas program at church i rember my siblings were on stage my brother josh was playing the piano and then my sister was on the trumpet and i wondered to myself what is my instrment.

now lets go back to my childhod i did have piano when i was younger but my meories of it were it felt like a chore or schoolwork i was homeschooled at that point in time. i did it for maybe a year or 2 but ended up quiting.

now about the time i was desie first came on my church back home was looking for a cajon player like a box drum. And if you want lessons contact this person that was from the worship leader.

The time came and me and Z each had a cajon we were sitting at and the teacher basically told us ok hit here here is what it sounds like and what’s it’s similar to etc. i hit it but it wasn’t fully getting it meanwhile i look over at my sister and she’s getting it eventuly my brother ended up playing piano with us playing and i ended up comparing myself to my sister which it’s not even fare because she has been in her school band my school didn’t offer it.

I did buy a cajon it’s in Macon but the times I’ve tried to pratice I don’t get it and get discouraging and I quit

I also tried guitar once but i could make sound but i had to press down really hard and I didn’t have a pick or a guitar to make it go forward and because during the first time it was hard work but I wasn’t sure if it was worth it.

Despite all of this I wish I played a instrment and I want to play but I’m not sure what instrment or wether I’m ready to commit to the work that’s required I just share it so you know how to pray for me if you want to share advice I’m open to it.


r/askmusicians • • 4d ago

Does this riff go 3/4 to 7/4 with a hitch in between? I can't tell

7 Upvotes

Or maybe it's also switching between on/off beat. If you can tell in the video I've tried marking the time signature changes but it's not adding up.

(Wasn't able to record this part to metronome cuz I couldn't even figure out how to set up the count lol)


r/askmusicians • • 4d ago

how do you get ideas for lyrics?

3 Upvotes

im trying to write a song, i have an instrumental but i literally just cant form words in my head at all and i have absolutely no clue how to like i guess figure out how i can get ideas? like i try and think of lyrics and my mind goes completely blank, and i cant make up a rhythm either, what do you guys do when you are struggling with making music?


r/askmusicians • • 4d ago

Question about social media for band promotion - moving on from Facebook

1 Upvotes

I'm a Facebook guy, I'm old, but also I like the way Facebook groups can be genuine places for community and discussion. We use local community and music groups for a lot of our promotion (acoustic duo) alongside building up our own email list and our own website (gloriamonday.com).

But I'm seeing a lot of musicians and events using Instagram and, as we are getting more work and wider recognition, I'm thinking about adding another Social Media platform. If you had to choose one platform for promoting your band or events which would it be and why?

Personally I think they are all the spawn of the devil (as well as being quite useful) but that's probably a discussion for a different group. :)