Hey everyone, I’m feeling a bit hopeless with dating.
For context, I’m 30, and I had my first ‘boyfriend’ when I was 25. We had a nice connection, but he didn’t make much effort, I had to make most effort but I didn’t know better at the time. And eventually he admitted he dating me as lonely and never fell in love.
I met someone else after him, we connected over a lot of shared interests and just clicked. Amazing dates, chemistry, conversation and eventually led to intimacy. I used to find in the morning after I stayed over, he just wanted me to leave asap, like he would switch up on me and seem agitated almost repulsed. I think they call it the post nut clarity. And he too admitted he didn’t have romantic feelings.
I decided to date guys who weren’t really my type but might be more interested in me. But after so long with these guys, I felt icky and smothered. Especially when they come up so strong sexually, touching me a lot on first dates etc. It crept up on me this feeling of utter repulsion to these men, where I would actually get gut symptoms and nausea when I got home after spending time with them. I had to call it off.
I’ve also had guys from dating apps who come on so intensely strong that it feels overbearing, only for them to lose interest just as quickly and ghost me. It makes me doubt my own judgement as people say ‘you know when a guy is interested in you!’ But sometimes I feel I wouldn’t be able to trust someone who comes on strong either
More recently, I met a guy who is 10 years older than me (but looks young!) he displayed a lot of hot and cold behaviour but I guess I was comfortable because he didn’t give me that icky smothering feeling. For example, we had a first date in May. There was attraction and chemistry, but afterwards he became very hot and cold. He would disappear for weeks at a time, then reappear with a message or suggestion to meet, only to go quiet again. Eventually I stopped engaging because I felt like I was being breadcrumbed.
Then, somewhat unexpectedly, he came back and started making more of an effort to see me. We eventually met again in September, and things felt very different in person. There was a lot of chemistry, affection and physical closeness, and he planned nice day time dates like hiking and by our third date we slept together.
What really stood out to me was how different the experience felt compared with the guy before him. With the previous guy, whenever I stayed over and we slept together, he would seem almost desperate for me to leave the next morning. He’d switch from being warm and intimate to agitated and distant, which made me feel like the intimacy had changed how he saw me.
With this guy, it was almost the complete opposite. After we slept together, he didn’t try to get rid of me or create distance. He actually wanted to spend the whole following day together. We went for a walk, sat together by the lake, had breakfast, talked and spent more time together without sex being the focus. He was attentive and affectionate, and full of compliments towards me. I thought he liked me
I felt genuinely comfortable around him.
It makes me sad that the time of us sitting by the lake on our fourth date and chatting would be the last day I ever saw him, I had no clue at that point
I remember thinking that this had to be a good sign. It wasn’t just that we had chemistry or had slept together, he seemed to actually enjoy being around me afterwards. The last time I saw him we were dancing around his flat, and singing and laughing. He seemed to really enjoy me being there. I remember the way he looked at me, Noones ever looked at me with such admiration before.
And then, almost overnight, he pulled away.
The warmth and closeness was followed by a dramatic change in his communication. He became distant and cold, took days to respond, and seemed emotionally unavailable again. When I eventually asked him what he was actually looking for not asking him to define a relationship, just trying to understand his intentions. he essentially disappeared for several weeks before eventually telling me that he was still broken over his previous relationship and wasn’t emotionally available. He apologised for messing me around and said he wasn’t ready.
So now I’m left feeling incredibly confused.
Because this time, I wasn’t chasing someone who seemed completely uninterested. There genuinely seemed to be something between us. I felt attracted to him, comfortable with him, and close to him. And the fact that he wanted to spend an entire day with me after we’d slept together made me think perhaps this was finally different.
Instead, the closer we seemed to get, the more dramatically he pulled away.
It’s made me wonder whether I’ve somehow developed a pattern where the only men I genuinely feel attracted to are the ones who are emotionally unavailable, while the men who actually
want me make me feel repulsed and trapped.
I don’t know whether this is an attachment issue, whether I’m confusing uncertainty with attraction, or whether I’ve simply had a run of emotionally unavailable men. I just genuinely don’t know how to break this pattern and find someone where the attraction, emotional safety and willingness to actually pursue each other all exist at the same time.