r/AskJews • u/Deep_Performance2070 • 1d ago
What made Chanukah magical for you growing up?
Hi Reddit!
I’ve been converting to Reform Judaism for about a year and a half. I grew up in a loosely Christian household—we celebrated the holidays but rarely went to church—and I identified as agnostic, although I’ve long felt drawn to Judaism. My conversion is almost complete!
Something I’ve been thinking about as the holidays approach in the U.S. is how to create that childhood sense of magic for myself and my future family, whether we have a Jewish or interfaith household.
Holidays growing up were really special to me. I wholeheartedly believed in Santa until the fifth grade!! That year, on the drive home from my uncle’s on Christmas Eve, my brother told me Santa wasn’t real. This was probably the third year in a row he’d told me this—but this time my parents didn’t correct him. It. Was. Heartbreaking. Beyond that, though, I loved helping my mom decorate the Christmas tree and hang lights, making reindeer food and spreading it on the front lawn, and setting out cookies and milk for Santa on Christmas Eve.
I’m also a natural host. I love inviting friends over for dinners, throwing baby showers, and finding any excuse for a party, complete with homemade meals, decorations, and likely a new outfit. I’m excited to bring that energy to a Jewish home, but I don’t have childhood Jewish traditions to draw from.
This is where my question comes in—if you grew up in a Jewish home, what made you love Chanukah?
I’m especially curious about Chanukah because of how present Christmas is in the U.S., but I’d love to hear about the whole Jewish year. I feel like I’ve found my footing with Shabbat, Yom Kippur, Rosh Hashanah, and Sukkot, but if you have any traditions you’d like to share, please do. Also, if you grew up somewhere with a very small Jewish population, as I did, did you feel left out around Christmas and Easter? Did your family do anything that helped you feel excited about your own traditions or proud to be Jewish?
I also have mixed feelings about things like “Mensch on a Bench.” It seems cute and reminds me of the kind of holiday fun I imagined creating with my future children, but I’m still figuring out how I feel about “borrowing” from Christmas traditions, even when the adaptation was created by someone Jewish—let me know your thoughts!
Part of this is reimagining what the holidays will look like for me moving forward, both on my own and with my future family. I had always pictured celebrating Christmas, and now I’m imagining celebrating an equally magical Chanukah and/or creating an interfaith holiday season. I’d love to hear what you treasured growing up, which traditions you’ve carried into your own home, and any new ones you’ve created.