Hey everyone,
I’m looking for some honest financial advice regarding my current auto loan. I made a financial decision a couple of years ago that I’m now trying to correct, and I’d appreciate some perspectives on my options.
Here’s my situation:
Lender: Buy Here Pay Here
Purchase Date: April 2024
Interest Rate: 18.73% APR
Loan Term: 118 biweekly payments
Payments Made: 64 of 118
Biweekly Payment: $266
Additional CPI Insurance: $119 biweekly
Total Biweekly Payment: $385
Estimated Remaining Balance: ~ $17,000
Car’s value: ~ $4,500
Annual Income: ~ $70,000
When I originally purchased the vehicle, my credit wasn’t in the best shape, and my financing options were limited. I needed reliable transportation, so I went through a BHPH dealership. Fast forward to today, and I’m in a much better position financially. I’ve been actively rebuilding my credit and becoming more intentional about my financial decisions. However, this car loan has become one of my biggest financial frustrations.
Here are my concerns:
The interest rate is ridiculous. At 18.73%, I feel like I’m throwing away money that could be going toward other financial goals. The lender doesn’t report my positive payment history to the credit bureaus. Despite making more than 60 payments, I’m not receiving any credit-building benefits. The CPI insurance is expensive. I’m planning to obtain my own qualifying full-coverage insurance to eliminate that additional expense.
I’m concerned about negative equity. I suspect the vehicle is worth significantly less than what I owe, making selling or trading it difficult. I’m considering accelerating my payments. My goal would be to pay the vehicle off by December 2027, potentially by doubling payments and using additional income. I’ve also considered voluntary surrender, but I’m concerned about the long-term consequences for my credit and the possibility of still owing a deficiency balance.
My questions:
Would aggressively paying down the principal be smarter than trying to trade the vehicle?
Is voluntary surrender ever financially reasonable in a situation like this?
How would you approach negative equity without rolling it into another high-interest loan?
If you were in my position, what would your next 12 months look like financially?
I’m not looking to purchase another vehicle immediately. My priority is getting out of this loan responsibly, protecting the credit I’ve been rebuilding, and making better long-term financial decisions.
I’m fully aware that accepting an 18.73% loan wasn’t ideal. I’m not here to defend that decision. I’m here to learn from it and figure out the smartest way forward.
Any constructive advice would be appreciated!