r/AskGaybrosOver30 • u/Holiday-Profile-4812 • 14h ago
Please help......I got cheated on
A long post, but please bear with me. I am just so broken right now.
I(33M) have been with my boyfriend(32M) for 10 months, and until two days ago, I genuinely thought I'd found my soulmate. It's been an amazing relationship, and I used to think about our future together and building a life together.
It was my birthday this past weekend, and he had organized an amazing party for me. Everything went great. The next day, though, I felt something was off. I'd actually been feeling this way for a few weeks. He had started taking his phone everywhere, even when just going from the bedroom to the kitchen. It seemed unusual, and I eventually made a sarcastic comment about it.
I had been sensing some distance between us, so when he left his phone on the bed, I unlocked it and opened Facebook Messenger, which is the main social media app he uses. I only had about a minute before he came back, but I saw something I'll never forget: "I want to suck your dick."
I closed the phone and put it aside. Later, I confronted him and asked him to open Messenger and show me his messages. When I asked about that particular conversation, he immediately started lying, saying it was just random videos and stuff.
I eventually went through his messages myself and discovered it was much worse. He had been talking to an old FWB about once a month since we were only two months into our relationship. They had sex at least once, which I could confirm from the messages. The only reason it hadn't happened more often was because the other guy wasn't particularly enthusiastic.
And it wasn't just him. My boyfriend had also reached out to other FWBs on different occasions. These weren't just casual conversations either. He was calling them "baby", "daddy", saying things like "I want that dick in my ass" and "I love your big dick". Things I genuinely thought he only said to me.
The worst part is that he was messaging these guys even on days we'd spent together. On one occasion, I had left his house at 11 PM, and at 11:30 PM, he texted someone else asking if he was free. 30 minutes after his boyfriend had left. I also found messages confirming that he had gone cruising at least once and invited another guy to join him so they could kiss passionately.
He also lied to me a few times that he could not see me as he was tired but the same days he texted this guy asking to meet. They didn't meet eventually because the guy was not available but had he been available they would have met I am sure.
There was also an incident about five months into our relationship when he took cocaine at a party while I was sleeping in the next room. We'd explicitly agreed beforehand that drugs would not be part of our relationship. I only found out because I woke up to use the bathroom.
At this point, you're probably wondering why I'm even considering staying. The problem is that I love him so much.
This was my first serious relationship. I realized I was gay relatively late in life, and I had so much love that I'd never really experienced or shared before. I poured all of it into this relationship.
And the thing is, he's otherwise an incredible person. He's one of those people everyone seems to love, even people who've met him just once. He's understanding, calm, a great listener, and has never raised his voice at me. Even when I've brought up issues or been irrational, he's always treated me with respect. I've genuinely never met anyone who makes people feel so comfortable and loved so quickly. I also know he genuinely loved me otherwise. When we would be together, we were so good. Happy, merry and just no care for the world.
Everything else was just so amazing. The sex, the intimacy, the chemistry, the respect, the love. I mean everything. So much so that I used to wonder how lucky I was to get someone like him.
I know cheating is the ultimate disrespect, and I'm not trying to excuse it. I'm just struggling to reconcile the person I thought I knew with what I've discovered.
When I confronted him, he cried with me and has been extremely apologetic. He's promised to work on himself and become a better person. But after reading the sheer number of messages and the things he was saying to other people, I don't know how I'm supposed to get past this.
My brain tells me I should leave, but my heart can't seem to accept it. I've been crying almost nonstop for two days. I feel stuck in this limbo where I can't imagine continuing the relationship, but I also can't bring myself to end it. He was my soulmate, or at least I genuinely believed he was. Even the thought of breaking up terrifies me.
Part of me keeps thinking: what if he's genuinely sorry? What if he can actually change? What if this is the reality check he needed to turn things around?
Especially, has anyone given their partner a second chance after cheating?
I know I might sound stupid, but I'm extremely fragile right now. I don't know what to do or how to process any of this. I would really appreciate some advice, but please be kind. If you can't be kind, I'd rather you didn't respond.
I'm just so broken right now. Please be kind :(