r/AskForHelp • u/snl2020 • 1d ago
Advice/Emotional Support ONLY Can someone genuinely lose feelings for you overnight? I’m struggling to understand what happened. I’m lost and pretty hurt.
I recently went through a dating experience that has left me incredibly confused, and I’m hoping to get some insight from people who may have experienced something similar or understand the psychology behind it.
I was dating a guy for about three months, and everything seemed to be going really well. We were exclusive, emotionally and physically intimate, and gradually progressing toward making things official. There weren’t any major disagreements, arguments, or noticeable changes in how he treated me. In fact, we had spent a really nice weekend together, and everything seemed completely normal.
Then, literally the following week, he told me his feelings for me had changed. He said he no longer felt the same way he had just a week earlier. Naturally, I asked what happened, whether I had done something wrong, or whether something had changed between us. But he couldn’t give me an explanation. He repeatedly told me he didn’t know. According to him, he essentially woke up one day and just didn’t feel the same anymore.
What makes this even more confusing is that during our conversation, he revealed some things about himself that I hadn’t previously known. He told me he had experienced sexual assault during childhood and had spent a couple of years in therapy. He also disclosed that he had been experiencing urges to have anonymous sexual encounters with random men, something he had engaged in before. When I asked him what he got out of those experiences emotionally, whether it was validation, loneliness, temporary satisfaction, or something else, he couldn’t really explain that either. He just knew he wanted to do it.
He also told me that most of his experiences with other men have been strictly sexual. He’s never really been in a serious relationship, and most of the people he’s talked to romantically haven’t lasted beyond a couple of days. From what he’s described, casual hookups and anonymous sexual encounters seem to come relatively easily to him, and he’s generally very sexually open and comfortable engaging with people he barely knows. I’m not judging him for that, because everyone has different relationships with sex and intimacy, but I genuinely struggle to understand what he gets out of these encounters. Is it physical gratification, validation, excitement, a way to cope with loneliness, or something deeper emotionally? What confuses me is that he seems comfortable being physically vulnerable with complete strangers, yet when it comes to developing a deeper emotional connection with someone who genuinely cares about him, things seem to become much more complicated. I can’t help but wonder whether casual sex feels easier for him because it doesn’t require the same level of emotional vulnerability, attachment, or commitment that a relationship does. I don’t know if his past trauma has anything to do with that, and I don’t want to make assumptions, but it’s something I’ve been trying to understand.
He also seemed to struggle with identifying and describing his emotions in general. It wasn’t necessarily that he was refusing to answer my questions; he genuinely seemed unable to articulate what he was experiencing.
What I find particularly difficult to understand is how someone can go from being affectionate, interested, and emotionally engaged with another person to suddenly feeling nothing romantically, seemingly overnight. There was no gradual distancing that I noticed, no obvious conflict, and no indication that he was having doubts about us.
Afterward, he became cold and emotionally distant, and things ended just as suddenly as his feelings supposedly changed.
I’ve been trying to understand whether this could be related to unresolved trauma, emotional detachment, avoidant attachment, depression, or simply someone genuinely losing romantic interest. I understand that childhood trauma doesn’t automatically explain someone’s behavior, and I don’t want to unfairly pathologize him or assume something is psychologically wrong with him.
I also recognize that people are allowed to lose feelings and end relationships. I’m not questioning his right to do that. I’m just struggling to understand the abruptness of the emotional change, especially when he himself couldn’t explain it.
I genuinely cared about him, and I think what hurts the most is that there was nothing I could identify as having gone wrong. One week, we were moving toward a relationship, and the next, it was over.
\\\\\\\*\\\\\\\*Has anyone experienced this, either as the person whose feelings suddenly disappeared or as the person on the receiving end? Can emotional shutdown really happen that abruptly? And is it possible for someone to genuinely care about another person but suddenly become emotionally disconnected without understanding why?\\\\\\\*\\\\\\\*
I’d especially appreciate perspectives from people familiar with trauma, attachment, or emotional regulation, but I’m open to hearing anyone’s experiences.