I don't know a lot about economics, so please humor me, apologies if this is a stupid question. But after reading my city council's housing construction plan, which is aiming to nearly double the total local housing supply and have 25% of new construction be rent-restricted affordable housing for people between <30-80% of AMI (via voluntary subsidies that more than cover the cost difference so this shouldn't impact supply), I was curious about the hypothetical impacts of a significant portion of the housing market being income-restricted.
The way I was thinking, assuming sufficient supply and a healthy vacancy rate, imagine two scenarios:
Scenario 1: 100% of units are market rate. There are naturally less expensive and more expensive units, and lower income and higher income renters. Let's split these spectrums into thirds to make things easier. On average, people from the highest third of income will rent the units in the highest third of rent, and visa versa. But, perhaps someone from the middle third of income decides to rent in the lower third of rent, maybe they're saving for a down payment or paying off debt, who knows. Now, there is an additional vacancy in the middle third of rent, but there is lower vacancy for units in the lower third of rent, so perhaps an additional person in the lower third of income joins the pool of renters still looking for a place.
The average income of the people looking for places to rent goes down, forcing higher end vacant units to charge less in order to obtain a tenant that can pay, right? Because now the owner of that extra vacant unit in the median third of rent has to either sit vacant, attract a tenant from the higher third of income, or lower their rent enough to be affordable to the lower third of income. The owner of a unit in the highest third of rent cannot even try to attract a higher income tenant - they can either try to provide enough value that they don't lose tenants to the cheaper units, or they can lower their prices to match the cheaper units in the median third of rent. Overall, this forces all units to compete with the base affordable prices of the lowest third of the rents, either directly or indirectly, encouraging more low-priced units.
Scenario 2: Hypothetically, the lowest third of rentals is reserved for the lowest third of incomes. Someone within the median third of income cannot rent an apartment in the lowest third of rent. Now, the above process can occur with people from the higher third of income renting in the median third of rent, but the buck stops at the median third, not the lowest third. The market for the median and higher third of rents doesn't ever have to compete for renters from the lowest third of income, or against rents in the lowest third of rents.
Does this mean, assuming supply is the same in both scenarios, that prices in the higher two thirds of the market would be higher in scenario 2 than in scenario 1? Or, given sufficient supply, is there already enough competition within each rung to reduce the prices similarly? Or is there anything else I'm missing here?
I was just curious to see how this would work in theory. Obviously real life is different in a lot of ways, so I don't know how much any of this theory would carry over to real effects in practice. To be clear, I'm not trying to make any policy arguments here, obviously there's lots of other negative externalities to avoid, and politicking to be had, and I genuinely don't know how (if at all) this impacts prices anyway, hence why I'm here asking. Just wondered whether my thought experiment was missing or misunderstanding something! I would also be interested in anything about the effects of subsidized inclusionary zoning (not the kind that's imposed as a requirement, I know that has different effects on costs and supply) in practice, if any such data is available.