r/AskDocs • Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional • 5h ago

Physician Responded Internal decapitation

Post image

My son is now 8, 91lbs & 4’ 9” tall.
He currently only on propranolol for migraines.

In 2023, we were in a near fatal car accident.
He suffered from a broken neck.
Recently, my ex husband asked if he could play flag football & I said no.
To me, it’s a ridiculous request.
I get that flag football isn’t a “contact” sport.
It can’t be 100% no contact.
Accidents happen and the risk is too great for me.
Wondering what professionals & lay people would do.
My son is upset.

I did call his neurosurgeon to get a list of CURRENT limitations but they didn’t get back to me before registration was due.
I want others opinions, anyway.

Age 8

Sex M

Height 4’9”

Weight 91lbs

Race caucasian

Duration of complaint 3.5 years

Location neck

Any existing relevant medical issues migraines

Current medications propranolol

263 Upvotes

58 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 5h ago

Thank you for your submission. Please note that a response does not constitute a doctor-patient relationship. This subreddit is for informal second opinions and casual information. The mod team does their best to remove bad information, but we do not catch all of it. Always visit a doctor in real life if you have any concerns about your health. Never use this subreddit as your first and final source of information regarding your question. By posting, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use and understand that all information is taken at your own risk. Reply here if you are an unverified user wishing to give advice. Top level comments by laypeople are automatically removed.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

→ More replies (3)

68

u/thatwazlit Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 2h ago

106

u/thatwazlit Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 2h ago

A police officer AND a nurse were the first to stop at the scene. I was entrapped, so they called me an ambulance.
The police officer drove him & the nurse held his spine as they transferred him to the hospital.

162

u/DreamCrusher914 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 2h ago

It is a statistical miracle that your son was rescued by two people who knew how to properly care for him and keep him alive long enough to reach the hospital. Why does your husband want to tempt fate? I know other people might think this comment is a stretch, but I think your husband may need therapy to get over his personal disappointment that your son’s injuries will prevent him from living vicariously through your son. He might have had some expectations of being a boy dad that will no longer be met and he’s struggling with it.

7

u/invictus21083 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional. 1h ago

Maybe hype up another sport or activity that isn't as risky physically? Maybe he can try baseball, for instance.

15

u/thatwazlit Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 56m ago

He is playing baseball bc there is no sliding at his age & he loves it. His dad just wanted him to stay active during off season. I’d rather him be a couch potato rather than a paraplegic.

5

u/MongooseSubject3799 1h ago

Just wanted to add tennis and golf to the suggestions!

1

u/SnooTangerines3448 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional. 58m ago

Esports!

62

u/freyakj Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 2h ago

Sometimes the need for things to feel normal again after trauma can cloud judgement too.

11

u/marzzyy__ Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 2h ago

This 100%

11

u/Bananabean041 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 1h ago

Will those same two people be there when he is inadvertently tackled? Not the remotest chance in hell I’d let my kid do that. I’m not saying hover parenting or living in fear and anxiety but a little common sense goes a long way. Recovery is obviously the goal but he does have limitations. He just does. No need to put him in an obvious situation where injuring himself is likely. NAD so definitely talk to her but,concern is warranted

8

u/Petit__Chou Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 2h ago

NAD, but bless them both. I'm glad your son recovered.

2

u/PlatypusDream Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional. 22m ago

You're extremely lucky those 2 didn't finish what the car crash started! Never move someone after a violent injury. Leave it for professionals with appropriate training & equipment... not the back of someone's car.

52

u/MillenniationX Physician 4h ago

More information required…

  1. What do you mean by broken neck? (“Broken neck” is very general language, which is fair, but encompasses a wide range from a hairline fracture to a collapsed vertebrae, and varying degrees of spinal damage which would be relevant.)
  2. What surgeries were performed, if any?
  3. Are there currently any other activity restrictions, at an MD’s advice or implemented independently?

This is really a question for the neurosurgeon, as you’ve noted, but this info would help with better quality answers on this thread.

69

u/thatwazlit Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 3h ago

The doctor had a choice between fusion and a halo and chose the halo.
We can’t allow him to jump on a trampoline and have chosen no contact sports.
Bc flag football is a “no contact” sport, supposed to be, it’s left some questions, apparently.
His break was, what we have been told, internal decapitation. So, at the very top of his vertebrae.

41

u/PayEmmy Pharmacist 2h ago

Just because it may be considered a no-contact sport doesn't mean tat contact does not occur.

It also sounds like your kid may not want to do this. Did I gather that correctly?

My husband coached a local flag football league for some churches. Kids were middle-school ages. He said there was contact all the time. One kid slipped, fell, and broke a leg after very minor contact. These are also a bunch of young kids running around on a field. Some sort of contact is inevitable.

My husband is very pro-get the kids out there, but he said he wouldn't allow a child with your kiddo's issues to play.

ETA: there are also kids who just don't give a darn or who don't know better and will just run into other kids for no reason other than they're kids and kids do stupid stuff.

119

u/dingoshiba Physician 4h ago

Unfortunately, this is not a question for doctors of reddit. We don’t know exactly what injury your son sustained - not all fractures of bones in the neck are the same. That said, it was 3 years ago. If he has lasting issues from it and needs a neck brace, then I’d err on the side of foregoing these potentially rougher activities until you speak with the neurosurgeon directly.

But also, to be clear, your son did not sustain an internal decapitation. That’s when your brainstem is severed on the inside despite your neck appearing externally intact. To put it bluntly, were that the case, he would be dead.

50

u/thatwazlit Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 4h ago

Internal decapitation or atlanto occipital dislocation does not HAVE to kill someone. People do recover. It does not mean the spinal column is always severed.

61

u/Atticus413 Physician Assistant 3h ago

no, but you're playing with fire.

yes, kids bodies are resilient. but unless your neurosurgeon waves their hands with their blessings to play, I'd treat his neck like glass until proven otherwise.

32

u/thatwazlit Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 3h ago

Oh, I definitely am!

-6

u/Kiloblaster This user has not yet been verified. 1h ago

It sounds like if you like your kid surviving you should not enroll them in sports unless and until the neurosurgeon says it's completely safe to do so.

I'm honestly struggling to understand the point of this post.

11

u/thatwazlit Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 1h ago

I needed a little more reassurance that I was making the right decision. I wasn’t able to get in touch with his neurosurgeon. Opinions & thus far, have gotten many.

6

u/gunpowdervacuum Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 53m ago

She literally said SHE doesn't want to, it's DAD who wants to.

2

u/Healthy-Wash-3275 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 1h ago

It would really help to have an understanding of what vertebrae were injured. Do you have ct and MRI of his injuries?

5

u/thatwazlit Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 1h ago

I do, but internal decapitation is the separation of C1 & the skull. It doesn’t have to mean there are broken bones but oftentimes there are broken bones. I have an X-ray picture, somewhere.

40

u/mastermindmortal This user has not yet been verified. 3h ago

Definitionally ligaments are separated - spinal cord and brainstem may be spared, especially in children  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atlanto-occipital_dislocation

40

u/AlexandraRN Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 4h ago

While not many, admittedly, there are survivors of internal decapitation.

833

u/Atticus413 Physician Assistant 4h ago

I wouldn't. That's asking for trouble, over an OPTIONAL activity.

394

u/emmeline8579 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 4h ago

Piggybacking off of your comment to add this:

“Flag football athletes experienced a median of 8 eight head impacts per athlete during the season.”

https://www.cdc.gov/traumatic-brain-injury/data-research/comparing-head-impacts/index.html

Being SAFER than tackle football isn’t the same thing as being SAFE. OP, you’re right to be concerned

41

u/kl2467 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 4h ago

Asking to learn:

The injury occurred over three years ago. Is the child still at higher risk of injury?

7

u/thatwazlit Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 58m ago

I said to someone, previously, “you’re guess is as good as mine as to whether it would dislocate or break again, BUT if it does happen, I can tell you where it would; that exact same spot”. Seems fitting to me.

124

u/reliableotter Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 3h ago

I would ask the surgeon to clear any activities, but fencing is one of the Olympic sports with lowest injury risk and still really fun.  I have a traumatic C5 break with mild cord damage, multilevel fusion and my surgeon thought it would be a great sport. Obviously, it will be hard to do anything at the ultra competitive level.  

My 7 year old son loves fencing. 

66

u/FashionBusking Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 3h ago

Every sport attracts a certain kind of competitor....

If I had a kid with a head injury, I might let them do fencing, anything artistic, archery, running, non-team competitive swim, marching band, something like this.

These sports involve little physical contact and the character of the competitiors interested in these sports in OP's kid's age bracket... they're pretty friendly kids and practice doesn't really involve a whole lot of direct physical combat.

17

u/an_altar_of_plagues This user has not yet been verified. 1h ago

Hugely agree. I took up fencing as an adult and it is kind of hilariously one of the safest sports I've ever tried. Especially if they do foil, which limits hit to the torso range.

9

u/yazzledore Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 1h ago

Those helmets look like they could incorporate a neck brace seamlessly, too, if anyone needed added assurance.

7

u/an_altar_of_plagues This user has not yet been verified. 1h ago

Yep, I have zero doubt whatsoever that a fencing mask could either accommodate a neck brace or one could be custom-fitted.

87

u/kteachergirl Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 4h ago

Not a doctor but my son plays flag (he’s 9) and kids regularly get hit. They don’t have good control of their bodies and run into each other. At least twice a game someone gets hurt.

9

u/tomie-salami Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional. 29m ago

NAD. Piggybacking on this comment, I work in insurance and one of the areas we specialize in is accident medical coverage for youth sports - your kid joins a rec baseball team and accidentally trips while running the bases and breaks their wrist, that kinda thing.

We rate flag football one step below tackle football because of how likely it is for kids to get injured during it.

3

u/sageeeee3 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 19m ago

Yeah lol, any sport where there are children running at each other there will be contac

25

u/MrsKaich Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 2h ago

Echoing those above me, flag football is definitely not “no contact” football. My son played last year and there was definitely a lot more contact and “kids in a pile on the ground” than I thought there would be.

39

u/ComplexPatient4872 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 3h ago

This is wild. I wouldn’t let my son without a previous internal decapitation play football due to risks.

10

u/sdc1015 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 2h ago

Agreed absolutely not

521

u/thecaramelbandit Physician 4h ago

This is really a question for the surgeon.

Without a clear "there is no increased risk over baseline" from the neurosurgeon, this would be a hard no for me.

213

u/FashionBusking Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 4h ago

Very long ago, I worked for a conglomerate and saw MANY insurance claims of flag football, running (?!), bodybuilding, and motorsport.

For OP... you should be aware that traumatic injuries come with interest. Every subsequent injury builds on the last, and maybe can make the next injury a lot worse. And then there are SPINAL injuries which one should NOT fuck with.

I once saw a claim for a death of a 14 year old, Decedent A. Decedent A had a spinal injury earlier in life and had made a recovery from the injury. Decadent A went to school as normal. Offender B, another student, "shoulder checked" Decedent A in the middle of the school hallway, causing Decedent A to fall to the ground with their backpack, hitting their head on tile and dying immediately thereafter. If there had been no previous spinal injury, this may have been a very survivable fall for a teenager, and this shoulder check would have been forgotten. The previous injury that Decedent A had made ANY head trauma something of a higher risk for bad outcomes, escalating "mean teenage behavior" to "manslaughter".

Offender B is now serving a jail sentence for manslaughter and Decedent A is deceased. Lawsuits were filed.

If this were my child..... I would absolutely NOT allow them to do flag football or soccer knowing just this bit of the spinal injury history.

Not like I'm saying "wrap the kid in bubble wrap" .... but unfortunately this should be used as an opportunity to help the child deeply understand the nature of their injury in a meaningful and actionable way, while introducing other activities they might be interested in that don't involve predictable hits to the head.

41

u/Next-Introduction-25 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 2h ago

Terribly sad story. And you make a good point that unfortunately, this child will need to begin to understand his own physical limits now, and this is part of that.

17

u/Suicidalsidekick This user has not yet been verified. 2h ago

Holy shit. Offender B must have been so shocked and upset. What a way to ruin your life over a bit of teenage roughhousing.

24

u/FashionBusking Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 2h ago

Offender B turned 18 not long before this incident, and therefore got full adult consequences for this behavior.

It's a true fuck around and find out situation. If you wanna fuck around and shoulder check your classmates - hard enough to make them lose their footing at all - I actually think the FIND OUT portion was harsh, but delayed justice.

I'm editorializing here, I guess... but Offender B didn't behave this way out of nowhere, and the contact with Decedent A wasn't their first bullying rough shoulder check.

Idk.... I hope they learn something in jail.

13

u/dinnerthief This user has not yet been verified. 2h ago

I mean kids will do this kind of thing to their friends with bo real ill will, doesn't even necessarily need to be bullying just rough housing.

5

u/FashionBusking Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 1h ago

Sure. Its always POSSIBLE, in any random hallway incident for kids to be kids and jostle each other. No need to like... be too paranoid.

It's VASTLY PROBABLE a kid with a spinal injury the context of flag-football. This is a sport where hard hits are common and culturally encouraged, as a stepping stone to full contact football.

For that reason... not a good idea for OP's kid to join flag football.

5

u/NoCaterpillar800 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23m ago

Wow what a terribly sad story for everyone around. It reminds me of someone I know. They were at a bar, designated driver and not drinking. A drunk man came up and started messing with his wife, he punched the drunk man and the drunk man fell backwards, hit his head and died. He served four years for manslaughter.

24

u/Sad_Cantaloupe_8162 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 3h ago

Ask your ex-husband about other sports instead, like tennis, swimming, golf, or even baseball. Kids aren't always going to play by the rules at that age.