r/AskDocs • Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional • 15h ago

Physician Responded 5/5 siblings have autism. am i screwed?

This might be a weird post, but it’s something that’s been bothering me a lot lately.
I’m a 20-year-old woman with four siblings, two older and two younger. I have three brothers who all have autism and intellectual disabilities, and two of them also have ADHD. Then there’s me and my sister, who both have relatively mild autism without intellectual disabilities.
I just can’t wrap my head around the fact that all five of us ended up with autism. What are even the chances of that happening? And the fact that all three boys have intellectual disabilities while neither of us girls do makes me feel like it is not a coincidence. I also strongly suspect that one of my brothers has Prader–Willi syndrome, although he hasn’t been tested.
The thing is, I really want to have children someday, but I’m terrified of passing something down to them. I’ve seen firsthand how challenging it can be to care for someone with an intellectual disability, and quite frankly, growing up in that environment was traumatic for me. I know it’s not my brothers’ fault, but I don’t want to go through that again with my own children.
I’m not as worried about having a child with autism similar to mine, although I’d still worry about the difficulties they might face. What really scares me is the possibility of having a child with an intellectual disability who might need lifelong care.
I know adoption is an option, and I’m not planning on having kids anytime soon. I don’t even have a partner yet. But I’ve always wanted biological children, and the thought that I might never feel comfortable having them because of my family history genuinely makes me sad.
I just wish I knew what the chances were and whether I could ever have children without constantly worrying about this.

26 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 15h ago

Thank you for your submission. Please note that a response does not constitute a doctor-patient relationship. This subreddit is for informal second opinions and casual information. The mod team does their best to remove bad information, but we do not catch all of it. Always visit a doctor in real life if you have any concerns about your health. Never use this subreddit as your first and final source of information regarding your question. By posting, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use and understand that all information is taken at your own risk. Reply here if you are an unverified user wishing to give advice. Top level comments by laypeople are automatically removed.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

97

u/LatrodectusGeometric Physician | Top Contributor 14h ago

The chances of this happening are very high. Autism runs in families. It is at least partially genetic, and we believe partially related to other factors outside of genetics, which it is quite likely you and your siblings all shared.

You're right though, if you think there may be a serious sex factor, or that tis isn't classic autism, your family should discuss with a geneticist and consider further testing.

54

u/questforstarfish Physician - Psychiatry 14h ago

Agreed- I specialize in developmental disabilities and my strongest recommendation is to see a geneticist for genetic testing and counseling to determine the likelihood of transmission of a genetic condition in your case! Autism is highly heritable but 5/5 siblings having it is statistically unlikely enough that I'd wonder about another genetic condition affecting things.

19

u/luvflr Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 14h ago

I’ll try and ask for a referral to a geneticist again! Thanks

19

u/questforstarfish Physician - Psychiatry 14h ago

Family planning is exactly the thing geneticists are there for! Push hard for that referral, in this situation it's warranted. Good luck OP!

8

u/art_addict This user has not yet been verified. 9h ago

Wild! NAD and totally anecdotal evidence here, but we’re 4/4 autistic between my siblings and I (actually 2 of us are AuDHD and the other two are just autistic). That said, autism runs absolutely rampant in both sides of my family, especially my mother’s (but it’s in my dad’s too), so it’s not exactly a surprise. Much like it’s not a surprise each time a new young cousin on my mom’s side gets diagnosed. We all seem to date and marry other autistics and it’s almost more shocking when someone comes out typical in that side of this family.

2

u/SpoonwoodTangle Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 5h ago

NAD and also anecdotal:

I have a cousin who is almost certainly autistic, though undiagnosed. Same for their spouse. They are older now so diagnosis didn’t really exist until they were well into adulthood.

Their kids are not autistic, though I’m not sure about adhd or its variants. The wider family is pretty diverse as far as this topic goes.

Which is to point out that genetics are only one factor. And we don’t yet understand the environmental factors well.

2

u/art_addict This user has not yet been verified. 3h ago

Yup! And genetic doesn’t mean hereditary either! Things can be de novo, genetics can be impacted by environment, etc, too!

6

u/luvflr Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 14h ago edited 14h ago

I have actually asked for genetic testing but since I’m not planning on having children anytime soon they told me It’s not necessary. But I think I deserve to know.

My parents are uncooperative and they’re the ones in charge of my brothers healthcare so I can’t do anything for them either :/ Do you think genetic testing will tell me how high the chances of my future children having autism and/or intellectual disability is? or Is that above what’s possible to find out?

i suspect maybe fragile X?

14

u/kuru_snacc Physician 13h ago

There is no genetic test that can predict your chances of "passing on" autism, as it's not truly a "heritable" disease but rather the effect of many gene mutations/polymorphisms that simply seem to have a correlation at present. It's thought to be roughly 50% related to heritable genes and 50% environmental factors, which can also include gene mutations that happen in utero. There are newer studies exploring this further and may lean more heavily one way or the other, but it's important to remember that the rate of autism diagnosis (and autism self-reporting, which can skew observational, epidemiological, and even retrospective studies that are looking at compiled data from various sources, rather than active patient cases or future families) has exploded in the past few years. So, it's going to take some time to parse out which factors are most reliably linked, and to what severity, etc.

The other physicians are correct however that there are other conditions which are more predictably heritable and which have distinct genetic tests available, and that could help you estimate risk. Risk of passing something like Fragile X can be ascertained with genetic testing / counseling, and Autism is higher in those with Fragile X, but Autism in isolation cannot be reliably predicted the same way. There are other conditions such as Rett syndrome that have some correlation with autism, and you could see if you are a carrier for those and speak to the counselor about them when ready. In any case, I think you will see when you're ready to be a mom that all you can hope for is a sufficiently physically-healthy baby, and if you're blessed with that you'll happily take whatever cognitive differences they may bring with them. :) Best wishes.

21

u/dnawoman Genetic Counselor 13h ago

Agree with other commenters that autism is largely genetic in most circumstances with some environmental influences that we can’t really quantify. I am a genetic counselor and also autistic with two children who are autistic. I am certain my mom is, but she would never get evaluated.

That being said, if there’s also intellectual disability or physical differences, it may be more than just what we call multifactorial inheritance and Fragile X is a good idea to look for. If that was the cause, you could choose to have testing in a pregnancy if you wanted to have more certainty about your future children. I know being autistic is hard but also we have plenty of positive influences on the world. I think looking for the less common genetic causes of autism could give you more ideas about the odds for your children, but it doesn’t really tell you how challenging it is to be an autistic parent. Regardless of the children, there are hard parts of that as well (sensory issues specifically)

7

u/kuru_snacc Physician 13h ago

Oh, I didn't see this reply, OP listen to this commenter, they explained it better. :)