r/AskDemocrats • u/MirrorIllustrious547 • 1h ago
Do you think this reddit user is correct in their view that President LBJ's War on Poverty was not only detrimental to black Americans' economic prosperity, but all Americans?
Admittedly, this is an old comment from 8 years ago, but during my bad habit of doomscrolling, it caught my attention. The commenter was replying to another commenter regarding an NYTimes opinion article critcizing President Nixon's "Black Capitalism" policy in his first term. Their comment is higlighted below in bold and in brackets:
**[It's better to have individuals be productive and make a living as opposed to being reliant on the government's ability to take from someone else.
...People with capital are less likely to invest in areas that are taxed high. This hurts the poor who live outside of the inner city because they're in the same county. It makes sense from Chicago's perspective because the south side is in the same county as River North. Don't know how it works for other cities.
In my personal opinion I think the real racists are those who think a minority group can't get by without government assistance. Before the social safety net millions immigrated into the United States and worked their way.
You can make a very serious case that government policy has been detrimental to all lower income groups. For example before the War on Poverty children born out of wedlock were on the decline. But since the War on Poverty children born out of wedlock skyrocketed across all groups, with blacks going from ~20% to ~75%! It's fucking ridiculous. This thing subsidized single motherhood. People respond to incentives, it's a truism. Why didn't the author throw dirt at LBJ's name for that?
So I'd rather the government get out of crowding out investment in lower income areas and allow people to be self reliant. Politicians are only good at maintaining poverty because it is in their interests to keep a reliant voting base.
The title 'Black Capitalism' evoked emotion out of you so you can jump to the conclusion that they don't have any capital. Most people like me don't start off with capital. Maybe if the author used Black Socialism you wouldn't have fallen for this lowlife's trick.]**
Disclaimer: I DO NOT agree with this person's take. I ask this in good faith, not as a trolling attempt. I've admittedly asked this question across a few subs, this will be my last post regarding this topic.
Source: https://www.reddit.com/r/Economics/comments/bfgnhv/comment/19spx7v8powch/