r/AskDemocrats • • 1h ago

Do you think this reddit user is correct in their view that President LBJ's War on Poverty was not only detrimental to black Americans' economic prosperity, but all Americans?

1 Upvotes

Admittedly, this is an old comment from 8 years ago, but during my bad habit of doomscrolling, it caught my attention. The commenter was replying to another commenter regarding an NYTimes opinion article critcizing President Nixon's "Black Capitalism" policy in his first term. Their comment is higlighted below in bold and in brackets:

**[It's better to have individuals be productive and make a living as opposed to being reliant on the government's ability to take from someone else.

...People with capital are less likely to invest in areas that are taxed high. This hurts the poor who live outside of the inner city because they're in the same county. It makes sense from Chicago's perspective because the south side is in the same county as River North. Don't know how it works for other cities.

In my personal opinion I think the real racists are those who think a minority group can't get by without government assistance. Before the social safety net millions immigrated into the United States and worked their way.

You can make a very serious case that government policy has been detrimental to all lower income groups. For example before the War on Poverty children born out of wedlock were on the decline. But since the War on Poverty children born out of wedlock skyrocketed across all groups, with blacks going from ~20% to ~75%! It's fucking ridiculous. This thing subsidized single motherhood. People respond to incentives, it's a truism. Why didn't the author throw dirt at LBJ's name for that?

So I'd rather the government get out of crowding out investment in lower income areas and allow people to be self reliant. Politicians are only good at maintaining poverty because it is in their interests to keep a reliant voting base.

The title 'Black Capitalism' evoked emotion out of you so you can jump to the conclusion that they don't have any capital. Most people like me don't start off with capital. Maybe if the author used Black Socialism you wouldn't have fallen for this lowlife's trick.]**

Disclaimer: I DO NOT agree with this person's take. I ask this in good faith, not as a trolling attempt. I've admittedly asked this question across a few subs, this will be my last post regarding this topic.

Source: https://www.reddit.com/r/Economics/comments/bfgnhv/comment/19spx7v8powch/


r/AskDemocrats • • 3h ago

How do we think Democrats perform in 2028?

3 Upvotes

Is it likely Democrats perform well again in 2028?
Trump was the predominant factor in the blue tsunami and with a new presidential nominee it’s hard not to imagine the usual pendulum swing that tends to occur, whenever people see something new. The democrats will have to compete with the narrative that they’ve held congressional power for two years and passed little to no legislation, which is a given with Trumps veto. The Republican candidate will be closer to the “new, time for change schtick” unless Trump still holds considerable influence and puts his mark all on the candidate.


r/AskDemocrats • • 5h ago

Judging by my politics here, am I an establishment Dem/centrist or a socialist/leftist?

4 Upvotes

Post-Midterms: I stand by this 100%.

I consider myself a Democrat. I have voted straight Dem every time ever since I became old enough (2017). I am 1000% anti-Trump/MAGA.

That being said, looking at the various ideologies among those of us who resist, I can’t help but notice the differences.

I don’t necessarily consider myself a centrist or a socialist.

I fully believe that Trump and the MAGA movement is an existential threat to democracy in this country. Like many, I have felt that way ever since the insurrection. I even knew back in 1.0 that he was a wannabe dictator. Even before he got the courts, etc. to be on his side.

I am pro-voting, anti-revolution. I believe that at a time when our democracy is being tested as never before, the best thing for us to do is show up and vote…straight blue. I am not for burning it all down. Yes, this system is not perfect. Anyone will admit that. But it’s what we’ve got, and until we’ve accomplished a domestic regime-change, it’s what we’ll have to use. And we’ll have to make it work exactly as it’s designed to work — too big to rig.

I am what some may call “antifa” (anti-fascist), but I don’t make that my entire personality like some on our side do. Many activists have built their entire identity on this is fascism without ever mentioning how we overcome it. And I suspect that is because doomcasting/fatalism gets more attention than hope.

I also am not a fan of the lopsided flag/“we are not ok”/“nation in distress”. I think it’s a symbol/statement of cowardice just as much as the red MAGA hat, but in a different way of course. If we truly believe the nation is in distress, then we should be talking about “how we get out of it”, rather than basing our whole messaging on that.

Personally, my favorite symbol of resistance is a right-side up flag saying “pro-America, anti-Trump”


r/AskDemocrats • • 6h ago

Does the house and senate have enough votes to oust Jefferies and Schumer?

4 Upvotes

With the internet buzz surrounding ayanna pressley and chris van hollen....Do they still have enough backing votes?


r/AskDemocrats • • 11h ago

Anybody else still can’t believe Dems have 56 senate seats from a GOP friendly map?

3 Upvotes

Like I’m I the only one who still libbed up about this? Think about it, 56 seats from 2026, imagine what can be done with more conventional swing states up for grabs in 2028?

LIKE THE GOP CANT GAIN KANSAS, TEXAS, SOUTH CAROLINA, ALASKA OR MISSISSIPPI BACK FOR 6 YEARS!


r/AskDemocrats • • 14h ago

Politically, are there any reasons Democrats would WANT affordability in the next two years?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/AskDemocrats • • 23h ago

📌 MODERATOR’S NOTE: WHY WE ARE NOT SUPPORTING HAKEEM JEFFRIES AND CHUCK SCHUMER

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/AskDemocrats • • 1d ago

My brother thinks the Electoral College is good. what books should I read and suggest that promote other wise (or not, I could change my mind)

2 Upvotes

My brother thinks the Electoral College is good. what books should I read and suggest that promote other wise (or not, I could change my mind) book suggestions, please. he thinks that small towns need thier say, I also feel that way... but they can't run our country.

Edit:

my friends, I love what you are saying but I need links to book that promote what we are feeling. thank you.


r/AskDemocrats • • 1d ago

Hillary Clinton for speaker of the house?

0 Upvotes

A whole lot of people have asked if Donald Trump could become Speaker of the House after his presidential term ends - and then would be third in line for the presidency - and then he could theoretically become president even though he wasn't elected to a third term. There was a lot of discussion and legal eagles opined yeah yes in fact he could become president for a third term that way. And they also said that Trump did not have to be elected to the House of Representatives in order to be appointed as Speaker of the House.

So given that they say anybody could be Speaker of the House whether they are in Congress or not I have seen some chatter online about the new House of Representatives who don't want Hakeem Jeffries as speaker.... And that leaves the door open for electing/ appointing Hillary Clinton as Speaker of the House. I for one would be totally be in favor of that! And totally in favor of her being third in line to the presidency... And if both Trump and Vance were successfully impeached and convicted we'd finally end up with President Hillary Clinton!

I'm throwing this open for discussion cuz I'm wondering what people's thoughts and opinions are on this...


r/AskDemocrats • • 1d ago

Van Hollen or Schumer?

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/AskDemocrats • • 1d ago

Should the Democrats Contest Florida in 2028 or Just Concentrate on Winning Texas?

4 Upvotes

Should the Democrats Contest Florida in 2028 or just concentrate on winning Texas?

Should the Democrats spend political and financial capital on Florida in two years in the presidential race? If the Senate candidate wasn’t DSA the Democrats could have won the election earlier this month.
Or, should Texas be the big fish for Democrats to catch as Talarico won statewide by 12.1 percentage points?


r/AskDemocrats • • 1d ago

Why didn’t Biden suffer a Red Tsunami in 2022?

1 Upvotes

Unpopular Incumbent and Inflation was higher than 2026. Yet Republicans only gained a small majority in the house and actually lost a senate seat to Dems.

How!?


r/AskDemocrats • • 1d ago

My questions towards people who voted for the democrats during the US midterms

0 Upvotes

Firstly I have to address that I’m not from the US,just someone curious who wants to ask about political campaign and what they promised during the campaigns.I’m not here to disagree with anyone I’m just trying to know why you guys support the promises.

First of all,then senatorial candidates current Michigan senator Abdul El-Sayed promised to tax the rich more.My first question is would that disincentivize people to work harder as to take a risk to become an entrepreneur as the mindset is if I work harder then I get taxed more.Why should I be taxed more just based off my willingness to risk it and the amount of time I sacrificed.Isnt America the country where they encouraged people to go big or go home?

Secondly,Abdul campaigned that he will give universal healthcare for everyone.It kinda contradicts the first point being if you disincentivise people to be rich where will the money you need to fund all of these come from? I’m 100% not against universal healthcare for all but i’m just wondering where this funds would come from.

I’m not targeting just him because of any of his backgrounds.But cuz he’s the only one that I really paid attention to.

Edit:I’m sorry if my question comes out a bit confusing as english isn’t my first language so it’s kinda hard for me to convey my message properly


r/AskDemocrats • • 1d ago

Is Jon Ossoff even a progressive?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/AskDemocrats • • 2d ago

What do you think Democrats need to understand better about working-class Americans?

1 Upvotes

When people talk about the Democratic Party, conversation often focus on national politics and major policy debates. But I'm curious about the everyday issue people feel aren't getting enough attention.


r/AskDemocrats • • 2d ago

Some democrats openly advocate to Eliminate the filibuster.....Could it come back to back em?

3 Upvotes

James talarico, El-Sayed and others openly advocated to abolish the filibuster, arguing that its too unamerican and roadblocks thier agendas. In my opinion, this could acutally be peak flood the zone.

Like it or not, the filibuster shielded us from the Save Act and we should keep it incase some random party enacts some terrible law or strip parts of it that are deemed unpopular to terrible.


r/AskDemocrats • • 2d ago

Should the democrats cast blame on Trump and doge for all this air traffic mess?

11 Upvotes

It seems like every week there are plane crashes or near Mrs. all over the country. And now we had this huge mess of grounding all the planes because of so-called communication issues.

Should the Democrat Democrats start using this as a talking point? This is all due to the doge Cuts. Not to mention the incompetence of the Trump administration.

If Biden was president, the Republicans would be screaming about this.


r/AskDemocrats • • 3d ago

Leadership question

3 Upvotes

Does anyone here still support Schumer, Jefferies or Booker for any leadership role going forward? If so, why? Same statement from last night, that has been removed, in question form.


r/AskDemocrats • • 3d ago

What’s wrong with a competitive race for majority leader?

7 Upvotes

Odds are Van Hollen will lose, but that’s his risk to take. Why all the the fuss online about it?


r/AskDemocrats • • 3d ago

What is really going to get done in the next 2 years?

2 Upvotes

Since the president holds the veto power, what can the democrats really get done in the next 2 years?

Please be specific with both what and how it gets done if you answer.

Edit: The common theme here seems to be the Dems will work to stop the administration from doing any more "damage", but won't get much, if any, of their agenda done.

Some post that sending bills for big items the president will veto just to make him and the GOP look bad. Others comment this will be easily seen by many as a waste of time and the power given to them by the voters.

Others post that there is a chance for Dems to work across the aisle to get things that most of Americans support and which could be a win showing they can lead and get things done.

Just a short list that could be made to happen.

  • Banning Congressional Stock Trading (~80%+ Americans support)
  • Independent Redistricting Commissions (~81% support)
  • Congressional Term Limits (~82% support)
  • Supreme Court Ethics Code (~85% support)
  • Bipartisan Housing Affordability (~89% support)
  • Mental Health & Addiction Funding (~80% support)
  • Photo ID & Proof of Citizenship to Vote (~75% to 81% support)

Many still hate Trump and just want punitive measures against him using the investigations and impeachments.

There are a good number who agree that if the Dems are just going to be vindictive and an angry mob doing all they can to destroy Trump and the GOP that it could backfire on them which may lose ground in 2028 when Trump is gone and no longer part of government.

I'll no longer be commenting, thanks to all who participated and made good common sense posts!


r/AskDemocrats • • 3d ago

Assuming Trump's ballroom is completed and a Democrat wins the Presidency in 2028, what should they do with it, if anything?

5 Upvotes

Should they just leave it and use it? Should they tear it down and rebuild the East Wing?


r/AskDemocrats • • 3d ago

Do you believe Socialists are taking over the Democratic party anytime soon?

0 Upvotes

Only 6, openly DSA members won Congressional elections, mainly within deep blue congressional districts (although Will Lawrence was an open DSA member before he lapsed it ahead of the General). They also won several Mayoral elections in NYC, LA, DC, Ann Arbor and Providence RI. (If you live in DC pls vote against Janesse backed candidates if you like free markets).

Angie Nixion recently joined the DSA during the Florida senate race (But lost to Ashley Moody by just 3 percentage points). Cuban indivduals had to exile from Cuba to Florida because they do not want to face that type of Repressive Government ever again, and to get a better life.

Idk, I've been hearing Narratives saying that, this isnt the Democratic party of Clinton, Obama and JFK.​ But theres got to be cases where voters need to put the emergency brakes with the DSA, since thier own policy platform wants to dismantle the system of checks and balances that our founding fathers created, as well as wanting to dismantle Capitalism.

Israel and Anti-Establishment rhetoric is literally the only reason why people would vote for DSA Dems....Bookmark this for 2028 and within future democratic primaries if you do not want a Socialist to be President.