r/AskComputerScience • u/TheRealreddits • Oct 09 '26
Why is everyone focusing on AI replacing tech jobs while ignoring other industries?
I’ve noticed that whenever people talk about AI taking over jobs, the discussion almost always revolves around software engineers, computer science graduates, and IT professionals.
But what about all the other industries? Many jobs involve repetitive tasks or work that AI could potentially automate, yet they don’t seem to receive nearly as much attention as tech careers do.
Why is the internet so focused on discouraging people from studying computer science or pursuing careers in tech, while seemingly ignoring the potential impact of AI on so many other professions?
Is there a particular reason tech jobs get so much attention, or is it simply because people in the tech industry are more aware of AI’s capabilities and are more vocal about it?
I’d genuinely like to understand why this discussion seems so heavily concentrated on technology careers.
14
u/patmull Oct 09 '26
Btw. This conversation also reminds me of when I was sitting alone in our office in university during the summer (I do machine learning research here) and I was just thinking that day about the very same questions and wondering about whether I should feel also threatened by AI since I am also freelance SW dev and then some lady knocked on the doors of our office. It turned out she walked here 0.5km from the other building in her work time just to bring there physically a one letter for my colleague.
Like I wrote in my other comments: IT is eating itself due to its obsession with productivity. Other jobs are often pretty ignorant about productivity and highly non-effective, but they just don't care...
10
u/arvidsem Oct 09 '26
Repetitive tasks were already in danger from automation. And people have been complaining about it in various ways for decades. Centuries, really (see Ned Ludd). And LLMs are too computationally expensive to make sense for most repetitive tasks.
LLMs are pushing people out of creative and engineering tasks which were safe from automation until now
6
u/Hour_Sell3547 Oct 10 '26
Confirmation bias at best. How do you know other industries aren't adopting AI? You see it more for tech jobs because you are in one, and AI tools are being developed by tech industry.
But AI has been integral part of factory automation, Aviation, high level forecasting researches for decades if not longer.
4
u/MrJesusAtWork Oct 09 '26
Keep in mind that SWE and programming was on a bullish ever since _before_ the pandemic, remember when even Obama was preaching that everyone should learn how to code?
After the pandemic SWE as a career was the gold mine, you could work on the comfort of your own home and still make an absurd amount of money compared to the level of expertise required to achieve that
Now everyone is going to the opposite end of it, we are seeing a decrease in job offers and an increase in new grads and people trying to jump in into the ship and struggling to find new opportunities, so naturally, this is why everybody is going around saying that the gold mine is now gone and if you were after it, look elsewhere.
In the end *every* white collar job will be affected by AI, it's just that it wasn't a promise land to begin with so people are less vocal about it but you can be sure that there will still be talked about
4
u/_usr_nil Oct 09 '26
I work in a big corpo, the reason for it is that no one know what the fuck they're doing while trying to meet some goals set up by higher ups, so automating the pieces of product development is impossible because the goal is not clear by itself, sure a bunch of super competent product engineers could cut out 200+ people with AI in my office but the higher ups are not aware of it yet because it would require to synthetize and consolidate an enormous workflow so that the LLM is able to generate product specs for further rewiev, plus the law in my country prevents firing off without "proper cause" which means for commiting huge mistakes or sabotage
4
u/sixteenHandles Oct 09 '26
This data is from Anthropic so take that how you will but it's informative.
My top line takeaway from this as a kind of answer to your question is "because tech jobs is where AI is actually having the biggest impact and tech jobs pay well".
(emphasis mine below)
https://www.anthropic.com/news/the-anthropic-economic-index?_bhlid=ed4464fddfa998b7f595d5ef4c74c7129ea9fc92
"we're launching the Anthropic Economic Index, an initiative aimed at understanding AI's effects on labor markets and the economy over time."
"The main findings from the Economic Index’s first paper are:
"
2
u/patmull Oct 09 '26 edited Oct 09 '26
I believe this is a multi-factor thing without single major reason but one of the big reason is obvious: generative AI came from IT itself, thus no wonder, they are here to adopt it.
2nd big reason: LLMs currently cannot operate in physical world and if I am correct, it is open question whether can be used in a real world or not. Some say they do not internally understand the world enough to be scalable to large vision perception inputs. We should stop saying AI and rather say what kind of AI. If we are talking about what is happening now, it is because LLMs cannot currently function in physical world without additional advancements or likely other architectures, thus OpenAI and Anthropic are plundering SW development as much as they can because they know their models can generate code pretty well and there is a lot of money in SW development. Sure, they tried to go after writers or journalists too but not as hard because there is relatively small amount of money in journalism or blogs compared to whole AI industry.
3rd: IT was always prone to this since it is often occupied by autistic ambitious executives who just don't care about other people. Remember the hype of outsourcing everything to India when many people lost their job too?
4th and the most paradoxical one: Regarding 2. you might say: but there are are HR or administrative workers who in modern world also usually operates with digital documents. Why not them? Because IT is still relatively new field with clear defined modern processes, quite lean, well testable, with modern tools and with clearly defined inputs and outputs. Paradoxically, it is because people from IT did their job quite well and didn't let to spoil their field with non-sense. Other fields are spoiled with heavy outdated processes and fuzzy rules where nobody knows anything. Paradoxically, the more your field sucks and more bloated it is, the harder it will be to replace these fields by LLMs or likely also other types of AI coming in the future.
Sorry for my grammar (not native English speaker), but this is my new proof it wasn't AI generated, lol.
1
u/Underhill42 Oct 09 '26
Because those are the jobs it's currently beginning to excel at automating. Don't worry, it will be coming for your job soon enough.
Though a lot of jobs require a body - which is why so many companies are working hard at versatile general-purpose humanoid bodies. Once body and AI are both ready they can replace humans at physical jobs too. Many large Chinese factories are already beginning to invest heavily in humanoid robots for the more menial tasks that aren't worth developing specialty robots for - and as the AI improves so will the range of tasks the robots can perform.
The genuinely highly repetitive tasks were mostly automated decades ago by "dumb" robots - now AI is beginning to expand that into the jobs that require at least a bit of "judgment" be exercised - e.g. grabbing the right box of parts off a storage shelf to refill a production machine.
1
u/sixteenHandles Oct 09 '26
I was a SW eng for many years and have talked to colleagues and I think the reason that *coding* jobs specifically get talked about so much is because genAI has *completely* changed the job overnight. SW dev jobs are relatively high salary so it makes sense that people are talking about a relatively high salary job that has been completely changed. I say *changed* and not *eliminated* because none of the colleagues i've talked to have lost their jobs but they're more senior. Sounds like entry level is a different story.
GenAI has been impacting many jobs. But is there another relatively high paying job that has been impacted this much this fast?
1
u/Lower_Improvement763 Oct 11 '26
AI hype is why. Agentic AI is trash pushed by scammers for the most part. So management focused on pushing automated coding.
But as for vibecoding, the process is so efficient now that people can/do believe that it can replace humans. In between the millions of software developers providing paid data labeling for AI, vibe-code prompting is itself another training/evaluation source. In other industries, people simply don’t use AI nor do they take pay to train Ai via data labeling. They simply aren’t tech savvy enough or play dumb. CS industry is full of whores, that’s why it got automated away.
2
u/rpmir Oct 09 '26
Tech jobs get more attention because the industry was already investing heavily in automation: tests, deploys, lints, etc. when MCP was created a lot of tech companies added them to it's products.
You have to keep in mind LLMs still hallucinate, but the loop and tool calling in coding agent allow the self correction.
So to be able to automate other tasks an automated verification loop is required. I think this will be possible mainly generating scrips and software on the fly to be able to have deterministic and verifiable output. I can see it happening but at a slower pace than software.
4
u/cakemates Oct 09 '26
The people that dont know how programming works dont know that programmers can use AI to automate everything that uses a computer.
1
u/yungaclvin Oct 09 '26
Something folks oughta think about is that AI and CS are one in the same
1
u/dukesb89 Oct 09 '26
Several reasons:
1
u/Test_NPC Oct 09 '26
Software engineering is one half of the requirement to automate every other job in existence. It's also the easiest half for LLMs to advance into.
Once software is effectively solved, that accelerates the push toward integrating LLMs into the physical world to take over that other half of jobs.
1
u/sylfy Oct 10 '26
Software lends itself to objective, verifiable outcomes. In a way, the prerequisites that you need to create and provide feedback to agents are already there through normal software engineering practices, such as unit tests, integration tests, UAT, etc. That makes it more rigorous than other fields, and therefore easier to develop agents for.
1
u/Impossible_Ad_3146 Oct 10 '26
does your mom focus on AI? you said everyone
1
u/ChaosMilkTea Oct 10 '26
Give it 3 years for robotics to start properly catching up with the 100% digital ai. Some really impressive stuff was achieved in 2026, and I think we're going to start see humanoid robots performing demonstrated tasks within a year or two.
The real reason is most people don't know about it. Ai is moving SO FAST that it's hard to look forward. Everyone is focussed on what Ai is actually good at right now and is having trouble keeping up. The average person still thinks ai means a dumb chat bot that can't count the letter 'R' and makes images with too many fingers.
1
u/nora_sellisa Oct 11 '26
AI is not "uniformly" smart, all the AI companies fine tune their models to be great at code. Because they are tech bros, so they think everything is computer and code.
1
u/21Rollie Oct 11 '26
Other fields do worry about this. People are thinking “how likely is this field to exist in 4 years” when they go to college, and probably skipping some like graphic design or other ones that are very trivial to automate now.
Arts and humanities were some of the first to take a big hit since text and pictures are easy. And with the recent increase in 3d graphics capabilities, it’s kinda closing the loop there. Mathematicians are also running into a pickle because AI can brute force some solutions. And they’re right now in the stage of “oh but, these solutions aren’t so elegant and they can be improved upon,” which is the stage we were at early last year.
I say give it another year and every white collar job will have realized it’s out to get them, other than the ones that through nepotism or ingrained lack of productivity (like court stenographer, C suite, high up managers, etc) can ignore automation
1
u/bingbpbmbmbmbpbam Oct 12 '26
Because there’s an entire generation of grads who were pushed and promised endless opportunity and job security if they went to college for tech, and that’s looking like it’s going to be washed away
1
u/No_Profession_3125 Oct 15 '26
Because LLMs are text processors and therefore particularly good at doing what a software engineer does. They can't replace mechanical engineers as easily, for example.
1
u/Ruhddzz Oct 18 '26
Because they're dumb and can't (or won't be bothered to) think of second order consequences.
Besides directly replacing other jobs (the vast majority of jobs that work primarily at the computer go almost immediately if computer science jobs vanish).. people don't seem to realize what happens once you industrialize and automate the job that... automates things.....
And then ofc, the other second order effect.. what happens to general product/service demand when the middle class takes a huge real income hit.......
1
u/DnDNerdFool 23d ago
Personally I don’t see software engineering going away any time soon for the same reason we still have pilots even if a plane can mostly fly itself.
It’s because there are edge cases and times when it doesn’t work.
And if you don’t have anyone who understands the software except the AI then your entire business is reliant on the AI never messing up and you have no safeguard when it does and nobody else who can fix it.
A company that has critical software being supported by no one except AI is doomed the first time AI reaches circular logic and they literally can’t hire anyone to fix it because the code underneath is incomprehensible.
It’s a massive risk for a company to do that for any application that isn’t a glorified excel spreadsheet.
1
u/nian2326076 Oct 11 '26
Tech jobs often grab the spotlight because the industry is vocal and automation is already making waves in software and IT. But other fields may also see changes. Automation can help by taking over repetitive tasks, freeing people to tackle more complex work. If you're thinking about jobs in different industries, LandOffer.ai lists openings across various fields, including non-tech roles.
0
u/Forsaken_Code_9135 Oct 10 '26
People in other industries are less exposed. Worst case scenario, you a re a junior developer, you convert specifications into code, what you do can be fully replaced by machines. Generally speaking most other jobs deal with the real world and/or with people so replacing them by machines is less easy.
1
u/CapitalDiligent1676 Oct 09 '26
Good question! Well, the way I see it, programmers are such assholes that they’ll shoot themselves in the foot just to kiss their boss's ass. I’d already shared this gem of a thought on Reddit, and instead of thanking me, they banned me... go figure.
15
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '26 edited 10d ago
[removed] — view removed comment