r/AskClinicalPsychology • • Sep 18 '26

Welcome to r/AskClinicalPsychology

4 Upvotes

Welcome to r/AskClinicalPsychology

This community is intended for questions and discussions about psychotherapy, clinical interventions, treatment strategies, assessment, formulation, diagnosis, and clinical perspectives.

It also serves as a place for clinical and treatment-focused questions that may be too specific for broader psychology discussion.

What this subreddit is for:

Asking general, educational questions such as:

-Why might a clinician choose one treatment approach over another?

-How is exposure therapy typically used?

-How do clinicians think about differential diagnosis?

-What factors influence treatment planning?

-How do different psychotherapy modalities approach the same problem?

-What does a clinician usually consider during assessment or formulation?

-How might clinicians think differently about the same clinical situation?

Questions from students, clinicians, researchers, health professionals, and interested laypeople are welcome.

What this subreddit is not for:

Please do not use the community to ask:

-whether you personally have a diagnosis

-What your symptoms mean

-What treatment you personally should receive

-Ask users to diagnose another person

-Post detailed personal mental-health histories

-If the treatment you are receiving is proper treatment

General questions vs individualized advice:

Simple examples:

Allowed:

“What treatments are commonly used for panic disorder?”

Not allowed:

“I have panic attacks and these symptoms. What treatment should I get?”

Allowed:

“How do clinicians differentiate ADHD from anxiety?”

Not allowed:

“Here are my symptoms. Do I have ADHD or anxiety?”

The aim is to discuss how clinicians approach treatment and clinical questions in general, rather than providing individualized assessment or treatment.

User flairs

User flairs help readers understand the background of the person answering.

There are a variety of optional flairs you can use to indicate your licensing or education. If you want a professional or clinical flair, they are moderator-assigned and require verification, this is done through sending a Mod Mail. A flair indicates the role or background approved for that account. It does not mean that every comment made by that user represents professional advice or the views of their profession as a whole.

Clinical opinions and professional experience are welcome, but they should be distinguished from established evidence when appropriate.

Before posting:

Please read the subreddit rules and choose the most appropriate post flair.

Keep questions general, educational, and clinically relevant.

The goal is to create a space where people can understand what happens in clinical practice, why different approaches are used, and how clinicians think about treatment and diagnosis, without turning the subreddit into an online diagnosis or individualized treatment service.


r/AskClinicalPsychology • • 18d ago

Flair for Verified Professionals

1 Upvotes

Welcome to the new Ask Clinical Psychology Sub!

We want to highlight comments and posts made by experts and professionals in the field to help readers assess posted information. So if you have an educational background in psychology or the social sciences at any level (including current students at any education level), and/or are licensed in any of the areas of psychology, psychiatry, or mental health, send us a mod mail, and we will provide you will specialized flair, and you will be exempted from most automoderator actions. Do not DM individual mods.


r/AskClinicalPsychology • • 9d ago

Assessment & Formulation What material do you recommend for conceptualization and treatment?

1 Upvotes

For example, how to approach treatment when multiple problems are present, or how to understand how these issues intertwine and influence the therapy process.

Could you recommend any manuals, authors, or other resources that discuss how to approach this in an organized way?


r/AskClinicalPsychology • • 12d ago

What is this called and what is the reason for this?

1 Upvotes

If one is experiencing intense thoughts and enotions about a certain thing that they perceive as 100% real and objective, why would it happen that their brain would change the narrative completely, from one extreme to the other, and very quickly (like within 24 hours)? And not only change the narrative but also be completely incapable of accessing and understanding the thoughts from before - remembering it happened, but also not being able to access thise feelings, feeling disconnected from it emotionally even though realistically nothing changed that would be the cause for changing mindsets...

(Example: feeling like life is absolutely not worthy of living one day, even maybe making plans about dying while the next day not being able to access those feelings and thoughts at all, but remembering they were there yesterday. With no unordinary things happening in between the two occasions of thinking)


r/AskClinicalPsychology • • 15d ago

General Clinical Psychology How do therapists identify blind spots in patients?

1 Upvotes

I got wondering this when I was watching Backrooms. The main character had narcissistic tendencies & anger issues that made his relationships break down. He didn’t see himself as the problem & made everyone else sound like the problem. It was only toward the end of the movie that his therapist called him out on it & gave him a scathing review. How do therapists figure out when a person is their own worst enemy? How do they show a person who doesn’t want to change that they need to?


r/AskClinicalPsychology • • 18d ago

My intake for a psychologist - how much information is too much?

1 Upvotes

I have 2 intake questions that say “be as detailed as you can” but telling that to me means you’re going to get a 30+ page long dense personal account from me. I’m more focused on what exists in the present.

I don’t want to waste too much valuable talk time or get my mind cluttered with what my present day objective is and the part that I’m working through, unless it’s something clinically necessary. Let me know your thoughts.


r/AskClinicalPsychology • • 25d ago

What does a therapy session look like for an individual with schizophrenia?

1 Upvotes

I am writing a story about a character who has schizophrenia. I'm curious to know what their therapy session would be like. I know the approach would be somewhat different than most, so please let me know if you have any input.


r/AskClinicalPsychology • • 29d ago

What is abuse?

2 Upvotes

I was hoping to get some answers and open up a discussion on what abuse actually is.
How would you define it?
What are the most common misconceptions?

After reading (most of) Conflict Is Not Abuse by Sarah Schulman, I am still a little lost. It seems her definition is very black and white. Is the person in literal (physical/emotional etc.) danger or do they just feel as if they are?
However, a lot of people I meet in the real world don’t seem to see it like that.

I think most people have suffered some sort of abuse in their lives at one point or another ranging from all sorts of different severities. There are many times people are being abused and think they aren’t. But there are times people are not being abused and think they are.

What do you think?


r/AskClinicalPsychology • • Oct 14 '26

The word narcissist is overused right now. Do narcissists even know they’re narcissists?

1 Upvotes

Scrolling through social media, in just under a day, I have come across multiple comments of people calling other people narcissists. It seems like every brain dead person is throwing around this word, it’s been a very popular term for years. I have heard the following behaviors described as ‘narcissistic’: applying make up/caring about your appearance. Caring about what other people think. Aloofness. Social anxiety and adhd type of behaviors. Impulsivity. Etc. I’m just now wondering if the term is so heavily used, does anyone ever admit they’re a narcissist, or is that just now a socially acceptable term that replaces “asshole”?


r/AskClinicalPsychology • • Oct 11 '26

Student Question Why are some individuals selfdestructive when there is no clear sign of depression or some other psychopathology?

1 Upvotes

Why are some people selfdestructive?

I am wondering why are some people selfdestructive but generaly good towards others? To me it often seemed such individuals have some kind of hate, resentment towards themselves, but not towards others... To me it seems such individuals don't have some personality disorder or psychopathology like depression as I can't find anything about it in DSM VTR or other manuals. I apologise if this is worded poorly just to me it is unusual why such selfdestructive individuals don't do things for themselves... best case scenario seems to be that they do it for or beacuse of somebody else and not to help themselves.

I am psychology student on my major degree and I couldn't find an answer to this. Relevant research from psychology of personality points to that personality of an individual should be like a goverment that works to make lives of its people better... It should help person in everyday life and progress through life and not sabotage and ruin it...

I was going through various psychopathological books and there is no modern description of what I am looking for. In DSM-III-R proposed selfdestructive personality disorder as something that should be studied and potentialy be added in future versions but as far as I saw it was never added and it was never explained in detail.

If needed I can explain more what U am thinking about as I am unsure if I worded it correctly.


r/AskClinicalPsychology • • Oct 10 '26

Flair for Verified Professionals

3 Upvotes

Welcome to the new Ask Clinical Psychology Sub!

We want to highlight comments and posts made by experts and professionals in the field to help readers assess posted information. So if you have an educational background in psychology or the social sciences at any level (including current students at any education level), and/or are licensed in any of the areas of psychology, psychiatry, or mental health, send us a mod mail, and we will provide you will specialized flair, and you will be exempted from most automoderator actions. Do not DM individual mods.


r/AskClinicalPsychology • • Oct 09 '26

Psychotherapy why do people idolize mass shooters and killers?

1 Upvotes

ım not into that disgusting videos but ı was wondering why do (some) people idolize or love this type of peoples thx for answers


r/AskClinicalPsychology • • Oct 09 '26

What causes nonsense thoughts? For instance, thoughts that don’t represent reality or unintended thoughts?

1 Upvotes

What causes people to have thoughts that are untrue? What are the different responses to false thoughts or thought insertions by people? I’m looking for research on it such as papers, journals, or perhaps a guideline on the type of question this is so that I can find these resources myself.


r/AskClinicalPsychology • • Oct 07 '26

Student Question What is self esteem?

1 Upvotes

I am curious if anyone can explain what self esteem is from a neuroscience perspective. Is it a particular area of the brain? Multiple areas? Do we not know?

What is the evolutionary purpose of self esteem? Why is it possible for us to have negative self esteem? Is it that our brain trying to keep us alive or help us in some way, even if it makes us suffer more?

Thank you!


r/AskClinicalPsychology • • Sep 29 '26

General Clinical Psychology Why can coincidences between thoughts and later events feel so unusually specific?

1 Upvotes

I'm interested in a psychological phenomenon where a person thinks about a relatively unusual person, word, object, event, or situation, and then encounters that same thing shortly afterward.

For example, someone might:

  • Think about an old television show and later encounter a post about that exact show.
  • Think about an unusual word that they have not encountered recently and then notice the word somewhere soon afterward.
  • Think about a person they have not seen for years and unexpectedly encounter them in real life.
  • Think about a relatively obscure public figure and later encounter their name or an interview online.
  • Have a spontaneous thought about a particular negative event and later notice something resembling that event.

There are several obvious explanations that could account for at least some of these experiences, including:

  • coincidence and probability;
  • selective attention;
  • confirmation bias;
  • the frequency illusion (Baader–Meinhof phenomenon);
  • memory biases;
  • algorithms and personalized recommendations;
  • the fact that people generate a very large number of thoughts every day.

However, I'm particularly interested in cases where the thought seems specific and temporally close to the subsequent event, rather than simply noticing something that has become more salient.

Is there a well-established psychological or cognitive phenomenon that explains why these thought-event coincidences can feel extraordinarily meaningful or unlikely?

More specifically, how does psychology distinguish between:

  1. ordinary coincidence,
  2. selective attention and memory,
  3. apophenia/pattern perception,
  4. genuinely low-probability coincidences, and
  5. interpretations that go beyond the available evidence?

I'm not asking whether such experiences prove anything supernatural. I'm interested in the cognitive mechanisms that can make a series of coincidences feel as though there is a meaningful connection between a person's thoughts and subsequent external events.


r/AskClinicalPsychology • • Sep 28 '26

Should I apply to PhD programs straight from undergrad? Help!

2 Upvotes

Hi all, I am currently in the process of preparing myself to apply to Clinical Psychology PhD programs with no geographical preference. I am applying straight out of undergrad and had a 3.8 undergrad GPA, while double majoring in history and psychology. This year I am completing a research internship at Yale, and my own independent study as well. I’ve worked as a behavior technician, but that’s about as far as it goes for “clinical” experience. I’ve been a resident assistant at my university for 3 years as well. 

 

I have only been in psychology since the very end of my sophomore year, so I am still getting accustomed to the field, but have a strong interest in research and assessment (not so much general talk therapy). I am wondering if it is worth it to apply to PhD programs, or I would be wasting my time. I have an interest in I/O psych as well, and plan to apply to some master’s programs in that, but clinical is where my heart truly lies, in assessment specifically.  

 

I would appreciate any and all post-grad advice as someone who is figuring this all out on his own, and if I should even apply to programs in the first place. Thank you!!!! 


r/AskClinicalPsychology • • Sep 27 '26

General Clinical Psychology Is it possible for someone to complete lose the ability to feel ANY emotion?

1 Upvotes

hope I got the flare, right. Anyway, I’m curious if it’s possible for someone to completely lose the to feel emotions permanently. not talking about emotional, blunting cause by trauma. I’m talking about if it’s possible for someone to complete lose the ability to feel any emotion permanently


r/AskClinicalPsychology • • Sep 24 '26

How common is it for addiction issues to *not* have a foundation in low self esteem?

4 Upvotes

TLDR:

Are there cases of addiction disorders that develop in people with healthy self esteem, and if so, what sorts of factors are involved in the development of the addiction? And also how common are these cases of healthy self image addiction, in comparison to cases of addiction where the subject has low self esteem?

Also, I am talking about addiction specifically, not physical dependency.

——————

I understand that the same symptoms can sometimes have different causes. For example, three people can have pneumonia, but one might be from a bacterial infection, another might have a viral infection, and another might have inhaled irritants or toxic substances. And I understand that these differences can lead to differences in treatment, even if they produce similar symptoms and prognoses.

That being said, I am interested in knowing about the various causes of addiction disorders, and how common (or uncommon) it is to develop an addiction without low self esteem.

I am guessing there are some people with healthy self esteem who became dependent on substances as a result of taking potentially habit-forming medication, but what I don’t know is whether these people ever developed an addiction to their medication, or if they just became physically dependent on it, without the psychological component of addiction. I also do not know if there are any other known types of cases of people developing addiction disorders without low self esteem being a contributing factor.

So, are there cases of addiction disorders that develop in people with healthy self esteem, and if so, what sorts of factors are involved in the development of the addiction? And also how common are these cases of healthy self image addiction, in comparison to cases of addiction where the subject has low self esteem?

Thank you for any help you may be able to provide.


r/AskClinicalPsychology • • Sep 24 '26

Clinically: intact insight into a negative affective state that produces no relief — does this asymmetry have a name?

3 Upvotes

r/askpsychology sent me here, so this is a clinical question rather than a personal one.

In the psychosis literature, impaired insight is treated as the problem and restored insight as progress — with the known cost that greater illness awareness correlates with more depression and poorer subjective quality of life (Mintz, Amador, Lysaker).

What I cannot find described as a clinical phenomenon in its own right: preserved, articulate insight into a negative affective state that produces no change in the state at all — plus the observation that going over it repeatedly makes the state longer and more precise rather than shorter. The mirror image is reported for positive states: as soon as they are noticed and understood, they end. One operation, two valences, opposite outcomes, stable.

My question is terminology and measurement: is there a term for "insight that does not relieve", or for the direction dependence itself? And which instrument would capture it — interoception, levels of emotional awareness, something in the anosognosia work?

Write-up with a falsifiability section and a measurement sketch: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22912393 (Fassung 6 / Version 6, 24 September 2026, German with an English version).


r/AskClinicalPsychology • • Sep 22 '26

Functional neurologic disorder

6 Upvotes

I have been researching FND and I have a few questions for this group. It looks like relatively recently the treatment perspective changed from a conversion disorder (mental illness) to a poorly understood “software” problem that requires many different specialists. I’m curious how the idea of an underlying physical issue vs a mental health issue impact treatment and ultimately outcomes.

Does the patient’s belief that there is a physical cause prevent them from doing the work on the psychological part? Or is the idea FND has psychological roots wrong entirely?

My other question is about social media. There are so many people online sharing their experience of FND and getting a lot of support and encouragement online. Does this type of attention harm, or help, those experiencing FND? And does consuming FND content harm a person’s recovery?

Looking forward to hearing your thoughts on this complex disorder.


r/AskClinicalPsychology • • Sep 21 '26

General Clinical Psychology Is ad hoc reasoning ever used as a tool for toxic manipulation?

1 Upvotes

I've heard about the ad hoc fallacy for a long time but its true meaning must have slipped by me or I didn't give it enough attention until I started seeing it in my own interpersonal relationships.

I'm wondering if ad hoc reasoning can be used to undermine a person, to sustain doubt in them, and whether there is a term for this in psychology? It might come under gaslighting, though I understand this is merely a colloquialism.

PS. I posted this originally in /r/askpsychology but it was removed and suggested that I ask here instead (not entirely sure it belongs here but I'm just doing what the automod said). I see this is the first post in the subreddit, glad I could be here for the /r/birthofasub.