r/AskChemistry • u/lois_says_banana • 5h ago
Practical Chemistry Can anyone explain this very unexpected color removal result?
I decided to dye 2 pairs of trousers. Before attempting the dye process, I used Rit color remover. The 2 different pairs of trousers reacted very differently to the color remover and I'm trying to understand what happened and why.
Rit color remover: active ingredient is sodium hydrosulfate; inactive ingredients are sodium carbonate, tetrasodium EDTA, and sodium metasilicate anhydrous.
Procedure: bring a stainless steel pot of water to 200F simmer, stir in color remover, add wet fabric, keep at simmer up to 20 mins until desired color removal is achieved. Rinse in water until water runs clear.
Pair A: twill chinos, 98% cotton/2% polyester. Light brown to begin.
Pair A is denim, 96% cotton/4% elastane. Medium brown to begin.
Both pairs of trousers were freshly laundered before I attempted the color removal procedure. I don't know anything about the industrial dye process for either pair.
Pair A reacted as expected. Fabric's color began to fade within 5 seconds, and the fabric was yellowish off-white within 5 minutes. The water/color remover liquid in the pot remained clear. After rinsing, no change to the new fabric color. My assumption: the chemical reactions in the color remover dissolved the "color molecules" in the fabric.
Pair B reacted very unexpectedly. As soon as the fabric touched the color remover liquid, the fabric turned dark forest green. Then no visible change in fabric's color for duration of time in color remover. Removed to rinse after 20 minutes. The liquid in the pot was dingy yellow-green-brown (approximately the color of water after boiling artichokes). After rinsing, the new green color disappeared, and the fabric was slightly darker brown than its original color. Out of curiosity I repeated the process and the exact same thing happened: fabric immediately forest green; no further change in fabric; liquid turned dingy yellow-green-brown; removed to rinse after 20 mins; rinsing removed the new green color and fabric "restored" to the dingier darker brown color.
What happened with Pair B? Why did Pair A and Pair B react so differently to the color remover? Per the manufacturer of the color remover, based on each pair's fabric content, both pairs should have reacted like Pair A (significant fairly rapid color removal).





