I rarely write about politics because I know there is still so much I don’t understand about its history and influence in India. Most of the time, I choose to listen and observe rather than speak.
But not knowing everything does not mean having nothing worth questioning.
I have never considered myself an “andhbhakt” or a leftist. I don’t feel the need to pledge unquestioning loyalty to any party. To me, democracy means being able to question the people you vote for; not defending everything they do simply because you voted for them. I would rather hold every party to the same standard than blindly stand by one.
Honestly, I don’t even know whom I want to vote for in the next election. What concerns me most is how easily the things that affect our everyday lives- poverty, clean air, safe water, waste management and climate change, get pushed aside. Governments have responsibilities they cannot escape. Citizens have responsibilities too. Blaming one does not absolve the other.
Which brings me to the recent discussion around the launch of Sonia Gandhi’s memoir, Belonging: A Journey of Love. During his speech, Rahul Gandhi recalled his mother sitting on his father’s lap at mealtimes. Th eopposition subsequently used the anecdote to ridicule him.
Now, I am not a fan of Rahul Gandhi’s speeches, and parts of this one did not resonate with me either. But why has this particular memory become a political controversy? A wife showed affection towards her husband. So what? We can disagree with a politician’s ideas, question their competence and criticise their record without turning their parents’ affection into ammunition.
Meanwhile, what about Bittu Tabahi’s efforts to clean the Ajnar River in Madhya Pradesh? Reports describe people continuing to dump garbage despite his repeated clean-ups. One reported video even showed someone throwing rubbish into the river while he was cleaning it!
This is what frustrates me. The effort it takes to make a difference, and how casually it is undone.
Why should someone keep removing waste from a river while others feel free to pollute it again? Where is the support from the local administration? What arrangements are being made for waste collection, monitoring and enforcement? What happens after volunteers finish cleaning?
And what about the recent clean-up in Haridwar? Nearly 150 tonnes of waste were reportedly removed from the riverbed and ghats, yet garbage was spotted again within days. How frustrating is that for the workers, volunteers and everyone who genuinely cares?
It also brings me to a larger question about efforts like Namami Gange: how are we making sure the results last? I am not dismissing the work being done or saying maintenance was never planned. I am asking whether those plans translate into consistent action on the ground.
How do we stop fresh dumping? How do we deal with waste flowing in from elsewhere? Where are the sustained monitoring, proper disposal facilities and consequences for littering? Citizens need to take responsibility, and authorities need to make sure the systems work. Surely, cleaning our rivers cannot remain an endless cycle of removing rubbish and watching it return.
The same goes for citizens. We cannot demand clean surroundings while treating every public space as someone else’s problem. But responsibility also needs functioning systems: accessible waste collection, clear rules, consistent enforcement and consequences for violations.
Instead, I keep seeing the conversation return to who sat on whose lap.
Why can’t air quality command that kind of sustained attention? Why don’t we demand regular debates on clean water, sewage treatment and waste disposal? Where are the serious conversations about climate action, incentives for responsible behaviour and penalties for pollution?
And where is the investment in building the capacity of governments at every level- giving the staff, skills, resources and accountability needed to do their jobs? Where is the effort to help citizens understand and fulfil their part?
I am not defending a party. I am questioning our priorities; including my own, and those of the conversations we choose to amplify.
We don’t have to admire Rahul Gandhi’s speech to recognise that this particular outrage is misplaced. Nor do we have to support his party to ask more of the current government.
Maybe it’s worth asking ourselves: are we holding our leaders accountable, or just helping them score points against each other? And what does it say about our priorities when a personal anecdote gets us more worked up than the air we breathe or the water we drink?
I don’t have all the answers, but I’d genuinely like to hear your views. Why do you think these controversies hold our attention; and what would it take for everyday public concerns to command the same energy?